Syllogism with Statements Containing a Negative or ‘No’ Relation
Reasoning › Syllogism · Topic 9.7
Syllogism with a negative or No relation uses at least one statement of the form No A is B or Some A are not B. A negative statement paired with a universal affirmative gives a negative conclusion: the main results are No A is C, Some C are not A and Some A are not C. Two negative statements together give no conclusion.
7 min read · Reasoning · Syllogism
Quick Answer
Syllogism with a negative or No relation uses at least one statement of the form No A is B or Some A are not B. A negative statement paired with a universal affirmative gives a negative conclusion: the main results are No A is C, Some C are not A and Some A are not C. Two negative statements together give no conclusion.
At a Glance
- All + No No (and Some not)
- No + All Some not
- Some + No Some not
- No + Some Some not
- No + No No conclusion
- Negative reversal No A is B equals No B is A
Where Does It Fit?
This topic collects the negative rows of the pair table of Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions and checks them with the diagrams of Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method. The next topic, Reverse Syllogism (Framing Statements from Given Conclusions), runs the process backward from a given conclusion.
Which Negative Pairs Give a Conclusion?
In short: a negative statement gives a conclusion only when it is paired with a statement that links a group to the same middle term in a positive way.
| Statement 1 | Statement 2 | Conclusion that follows |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | No B is C | No A is C; No C is A; Some C are not A |
| No A is B | All B are C | Some C are not A |
| Some A are B | No B is C | Some A are not C |
| No A is B | Some C are B | Some C are not A |
| No A is B | No B is C | None |
Rules
- The conclusion of a negative pair is always negative: No or Some not.
- A negative pair never gives a Some conclusion.
- Two negative statements give no conclusion.
How Do You Read a Negative Conclusion?
In short: a No conclusion is stronger than a Some not conclusion. Check which one the pair supports.
- No A is C needs the first group to lie wholly inside the middle term, with the middle term separate from the third group.
- Some A are not C needs only some members of A to sit in the middle term, with the middle term separate from C.
- Some C are not A holds when members of C lie inside a group that is separate from A.
- Reversing: No A is C can be read as No C is A, but Some A are not C cannot be reversed, as in Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions.
Why Do Two Negative Statements Fail?
In short: No A is B and No B is C leave A and C free to overlap or to stay apart, so no relation is fixed.
- Possibility: A and C may overlap, so Some A are C is only possible, as in Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’).
- Another option: A and C may also be separate, so No A is C is only possible.
- Result: neither Some A are C nor No A is C follows, and neither does Some A are not C.
- Either-or: the pair Some A are C and No A is C is a complementary pair, as in Syllogism Involving Complementary Pairs (Either-Or Conclusions).
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Statements: No stone is wood. All wood is fuel. Conclusions: I. Some fuel is not stone. II. No stone is fuel.
- Wood is fuel and is not stone, so some fuel (the wood) is not stone: I follows.
- Other fuel could include stone, so II does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Example 2
Question: Statements: Some tigers are cats. No cat is a bird. Conclusions: I. Some tigers are not birds. II. No tiger is a bird.
- The tigers that are cats are not birds: I follows.
- Other tigers may be birds, so II does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Example 3
Question: Statements: All kings are men. No man is a stone. Conclusions: I. No stone is a king. II. Some stones are not kings.
- Kings lie inside men, and men are separate from stones, so No king is a stone, and No stone is a king: I follows.
- Stones exist and none is a king, so Some stones are not kings: II follows.
Answer: Both I and II follow.
Example 4
Question: Statements: No pen is a book. No book is a cup. Conclusions: I. No pen is a cup. II. Some pens are cups.
- Two negative statements leave pens and cups free to overlap or stay apart.
- Neither conclusion is certain.
Answer: Neither I nor II follows.
Example 5
Question: Statements: No fish is a bird. Some animals are birds. Conclusions: I. Some animals are not fish. II. Some animals are fish.
- The animals that are birds are not fish: I follows.
- Other animals may or may not be fish, so II does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- A negative pair gives only a negative conclusion.
- Remember the four positive-negative rows, then the No+No row gives nothing.
- Convert No A is B to No B is A freely.
- Never reverse a Some not statement.
- If a conclusion has a Some, check whether the pair is all negative.
Common Mistakes
- Choosing No A is C when the pair gives only Some not.
- Concluding anything from two negative statements.
- Reversing Some A are not B.
- Treating No A is B as meaning Some A are B.
- Giving a Some conclusion from a negative pair.
Practice Questions
- No A is B. All B are C. Does Some C are not A follow?
- Some A are B. No B is C. Does No A is C follow?
- All A are B. No B is C. Does No C is A follow?
- No A is B. No B is C. Does Some A are C follow?
- No A is B. Some C are B. Does Some C are not A follow?
- Some A are B. No B is C. Does Some A are not C follow?
Answers: 1) yes; 2) no; 3) yes; 4) no; 5) yes; 6) yes.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Confusion point Negative statements cause most syllogism errors.
- Exam use Most sets contain at least one negative statement.
- Skill You learn to separate No from Some not.
- Link Negative rows connect to either-or pairs.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Reverse Syllogism (Framing Statements from Given Conclusions). It starts from a conclusion and asks which statements produce it.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Universal negative No A is B
- Particular negative Some A are not B
- Negative conclusion A conclusion of the form No or Some not
- Separate No shared members
- Reversal Reading a statement the other way round
- Middle term The common term in the statements
Related Topics
- Coded Syllogism (Statements Given in Coded Form)
- Reverse Syllogism (Framing Statements from Given Conclusions)
- Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions
- Syllogism with Multiple Statements and Multiple Conclusions
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Negative pairs give negative conclusions.
- No + No gives nothing.
- No A is B can be reversed.
- Some A are not B cannot be reversed.
- All + No gives No; the others give Some not.
Do Not Confuse With
- No vs Some not No is about every member; Some not is about at least one.
- No A is C vs No C is A They are equivalent.
- Some not vs Some A negative pair never gives a Some conclusion.
- Two negatives They give no conclusion.
Memory Hook
Negative in, negative out; two negatives, nothing out.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What conclusions follow from a negative statement in syllogism?
A negative statement paired with a positive one gives a negative conclusion. All A are B with No B is C gives No A is C. No A is B with All B are C gives Some C are not A. Some A are B with No B is C gives Some A are not C.
Why do two negative statements give no conclusion?
No A is B and No B is C leave A and C free to overlap or to stay apart, so neither No A is C nor Some A are C is certain. Both are only possible, which is why two negative statements never give a definite conclusion.
Can No A is B be reversed?
Yes, No A is B means the same as No B is A, because the two groups have no common member. The statement Some A are not B, however, cannot be reversed, since the members of A outside B say nothing about the members of B outside A.
What is the difference between No and Some not in conclusions?
No A is C says every member of A is outside C, while Some A are not C says at least one member of A is outside C. A pair may support the weaker Some not conclusion without supporting the stronger No conclusion.
Can a negative pair give a Some conclusion?
No, a pair that includes a negative statement can give only a negative conclusion, which is either No or Some not. A Some conclusion needs two affirmative statements, with at least one universal, so it can never come from a negative pair.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 From No A is B and All B are C, it follows that Some C are not A.
The B members are C but not A.
2 From No A is B and No B is C, it follows that No A is C.
Two negative statements give no conclusion.
3 From Some A are B and No B is C, it follows that No A is C.
Only Some A are not C follows.
4 No A is B means the same as No B is A.
The two groups share no member in either direction.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index