Syllogism with Multiple Statements and Multiple Conclusions
Reasoning › Syllogism · Topic 9.2
Syllogism with multiple statements and multiple conclusions chains three or four statements through common terms. Combine the statements two at a time using the pair table, carry the new result forward, and then test each conclusion. A conclusion follows only when it is certain after all statements are combined.
8 min read · Reasoning · Syllogism
Quick Answer
Syllogism with multiple statements and multiple conclusions chains three or four statements through common terms. Combine the statements two at a time using the pair table, carry the new result forward, and then test each conclusion. A conclusion follows only when it is certain after all statements are combined.
At a Glance
- Method Combine two statements at a time
- Order Start where a universal statement links two terms
- Carry forward Use the new result with the next statement
- Conclusion types Between any two of the four terms
- Valid chains At most one particular statement works
- Convention Some includes all; terms are non-empty
Where Does It Fit?
This topic extends the pair table of Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions to longer chains. The Venn method of Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method can verify any result, and Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’) deals with conclusions that are only possible.
How Do You Combine Three Statements?
In short: combine the first two statements to get a new statement, then combine that result with the third. Repeat if there are more statements.
| Statements | Step 1 | Step 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| All A are B; All B are C; Some C are D | All A are C | All A are C and Some C are D | Some C are B (reverse of All B are C); Some A are C |
| Some A are B; All B are C; All C are D | Some A are C | Some A are D | Some D are A |
| All A are B; Some B are C; No C is D | none between first two | Some B are not D | Some B are A |
Rules for chains
- A universal statement can carry its result forward.
- If a step produces a particular statement, the next step needs a universal statement next to it.
- Two particular statements in a row stop the chain.
The table of pairs is the same as in Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions.
How Do You Test Conclusions in a Four-Term Question?
In short: after combining, every conclusion is a statement about two of the terms. It follows only if the combined result implies it.
- Start with the given statements: each given statement can also be reversed as allowed, such as Some A are B to Some B are A.
- Look for a link: a conclusion between two terms that are not in a common statement needs a chain through the others.
- Test with a counter-case: if you can draw an arrangement where the conclusion is false while the statements stay true, the conclusion does not follow. The drawing method is in Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method.
What Are Common Patterns in Multi-Statement Questions?
In short: most questions use a universal chain with one particular statement at the end or the start.
- Chain of All: All A are B, All B are C, All C are D give All A are D.
- Particular at the start: Some A are B, then All statements, gives Some A at the end.
- Negative in the middle: a No statement turns the chain into a negative, which gives a Some not conclusion for the other side.
- Possible vs certain: extra conclusions that merely could be true are not accepted, as in Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Statements: All apples are fruits. All fruits are foods. Some foods are snacks. Conclusions: I. Some apples are foods. II. Some snacks are apples. III. Some foods are fruits. IV. Some snacks are fruits.
- All apples are fruits and all fruits are foods, so all apples are foods, and Some apples are foods follows: I follows.
- All fruits are foods, so Some foods are fruits: III follows.
- The snacks that are foods may lie outside fruits: II and IV do not follow.
Answer: Only I and III follow.
Example 2
Question: Statements: Some students are readers. All readers are thinkers. All thinkers are scholars. Conclusions: I. Some students are scholars. II. Some scholars are students. III. All students are scholars. IV. Some thinkers are students.
- Some students are readers, readers are thinkers and scholars: I follows.
- The reverse of I gives Some scholars are students: II follows.
- The students who are readers are thinkers, so Some thinkers are students: IV follows.
- Only some students are readers, so III does not follow.
Answer: I, II and IV follow.
Example 3
Question: Statements: All lions are cats. No cat is a bird. Some birds are pets. Conclusions: I. Some pets are not lions. II. Some pets are not cats. III. No pet is a lion. IV. Some pets are birds.
- Lions are cats and cats are not birds, so no lion is a bird.
- The pets that are birds are not lions, so I follows, and not cats, so II follows.
- Some birds are pets, so the reverse, IV, follows.
- Other pets may be lions, so III does not follow.
Answer: I, II and IV follow.
Example 4
Question: Statements: All books are papers. Some papers are pens. No pen is a cup. Conclusions: I. Some papers are books. II. Some papers are not cups. III. Some books are not cups. IV. No book is a cup.
- All books are papers, so Some papers are books: I follows.
- Some papers are pens, and no pen is a cup, so Some papers are not cups: II follows.
- Books may or may not be pens, so III and IV are uncertain.
Answer: Only I and II follow.
Example 5
Question: Statements: Some boys are girls. All girls are children. No child is a robot. Conclusions: I. Some boys are not robots. II. No boy is a robot. III. Some children are boys.
- Some boys are girls, girls are children, and no child is a robot, so those boys are not robots: I follows.
- Only some boys are girls, so II does not follow.
- Some boys are children, so Some children are boys: III follows.
Answer: I and III follow.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Combine the pair with a universal statement first.
- Carry the new result forward before reading the next statement.
- If a chain breaks at two particular statements, no conclusion across the break follows.
- Reverse Some and No statements to open up more links.
- Use a quick counter-case to reject a doubtful conclusion.
Common Mistakes
- Combining two particular statements.
- Forgetting to use a reversed statement.
- Accepting a conclusion that holds only in one arrangement.
- Losing a statement while combining.
- Treating a negative link as a positive one.
Practice Questions
- All A are B. All B are C. All C are D. Does All A are D follow?
- Some A are B. All B are C. All C are D. Does Some D are A follow?
- All A are B. Some B are C. No C is D. Does Some B are not D follow?
- Some A are B. All B are C. No C is D. Does Some A are not D follow?
- All A are B. Some B are C. No C is D. Does No A is D follow?
- All A are B. No B is C. Some C are D. Does Some D are not A follow?
Answers: 1) yes; 2) yes; 3) yes; 4) yes; 5) no; 6) yes.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Realistic format Most exam sets give three statements and four conclusions.
- Chain skill It builds on the pair table.
- Error control Combining step by step prevents lost statements.
- Link The same chaining is useful in the Venn method.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method. It shows how to draw the Venn diagrams that prove each result.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Chain A series of statements linked by common terms
- Carry forward Using a derived result with the next statement
- Counter-case An arrangement that shows a conclusion can fail
- Universal All or No
- Particular Some or Some not
- Four terms Four different groups named in the statements
Related Topics
- Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions
- Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method
- Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’)
- Syllogism Involving Complementary Pairs (Either-Or Conclusions)
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Combine two statements at a time.
- Carry the result forward.
- A chain with two particular statements in a row breaks.
- Reverse Some and No statements where useful.
- A conclusion follows only if it is certain.
Do Not Confuse With
- Chain vs pair A chain uses several pairs one after another.
- Certain vs possible A possible conclusion does not follow; see Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’).
- Start vs end term The particular statement can sit at either end of a chain.
- All vs Some A single Some in the chain makes the result particular.
Memory Hook
Pair, carry, pair again; break the chain at two particulars.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you solve syllogism with three statements?
Combine the first two statements into a single result using the pair table, then combine that result with the third statement. Repeat for each further statement. Test each conclusion against the final result and accept it only if it is certain.
How many conclusions follow in a multi-statement question?
Any number from none to all of them may follow, so test each conclusion on its own. In a typical set with four conclusions, two or three often follow. Do not assume that a fixed number follows, and check each with the chain.
When does a chain of statements break?
A chain breaks when a step would need to combine two particular statements, or two negative statements, because these pairs give no conclusion. After the break, conclusions linking the terms on the two sides do not follow.
How do I check a doubtful conclusion?
Try to draw an arrangement in which all the statements stay true but the conclusion is false. If such an arrangement exists, the conclusion does not follow. If no such arrangement exists, the conclusion follows. This is the Venn counter-case test.
Can I reverse statements in a long chain?
Yes, you may reverse a No statement and a Some statement, which gives extra links in a chain. All A are B can only be reversed to Some B are A, and Some not statements cannot be reversed at all.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 From All A are B, All B are C and All C are D, it follows that All A are D.
The universal chain carries through.
2 From All A are B, Some B are C and No C is D, it follows that No A is D.
A may overlap C inside B, so the link is uncertain.
3 From Some A are B, All B are C and All C are D, it follows that Some D are A.
Some A are D, and it can be reversed.
4 In a chain, two particular statements in a row give a conclusion.
Two particular statements give no conclusion.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index