An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 9.9

Syllogism Involving Quantifiers ‘Some’, ‘All’, ‘No’ and ‘Only’ in Combination

Reasoning › Syllogism · Topic 9.9

Syllogism with the quantifiers Some, All, No and Only combines the standard statement types with the word Only. The statement Only A are B means All B are A, and Only a few A are B means Some A are B together with Some A are not B. After converting, solve with the usual pair table.

Share:
Syllogism Involving Quantifiers ‘Some’, ‘All’, ‘No’ and ‘Only’ in Combination - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Syllogism with the quantifiers Some, All, No and Only combines the standard statement types with the word Only. The statement Only A are B means All B are A, and Only a few A are B means Some A are B together with Some A are not B. After converting, solve with the usual pair table.

At a Glance

  • Only A are B All B are A
  • Only a few A are B Some A are B and Some A are not B
  • Only some A are B Same as Only a few, by the convention here
  • Some At least one, may include all
  • After conversion Use the standard pair table
  • Check Direction of the converted All

Where Does It Fit?

This topic is the last of the Syllogism macro and builds on the pair table of Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions, the chains of Syllogism with Multiple Statements and Multiple Conclusions and the negative rows of Syllogism with Statements Containing a Negative or ‘No’ Relation. The macro that follows, Statement-Assumption, Statement-Argument and Statement-Conclusion, starts with Statement and Assumption – Identifying Implicit Assumptions in a Statement.

How Do You Convert Statements With Only?

In short: Only A are B means that every B is an A, so the group named after Only is the larger group. It converts to All B are A.

Given Convert to Example
Only A are B All B are A Only artists are painters: All painters are artists
Only a few A are B Some A are B and Some A are not B Only a few teachers are doctors: some teachers are doctors and some are not
Only some A are B Some A are B and Some A are not B Same reading as Only a few
Only A are B and Only B are A A and B are the same group Both All A are B and All B are A

Direction check

  • Only A are B does not mean All A are B.
  • The word after Only becomes the bigger group in the All statement.
  • Only a few gives both a Some and a Some not statement.

How Do You Solve Combined Statements?

In short: convert every Only statement first, then treat the question as an ordinary syllogism with All, Some, No and Some not.

  1. Convert each Only statement.
  2. Split Only a few into its Some and Some not parts.
  3. Combine the statements using Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions and Syllogism with Multiple Statements and Multiple Conclusions.
  4. Judge each conclusion.

When a statement is split, each part is a separate statement, and the part that matches the pair table gives the conclusion. The Some not part is usually extra and does not produce a conclusion unless it is paired with a universal statement.

What Are the Common Combinations?

In short: Only statements most often appear in front of an All or a No statement.

  • Only A are B, All B are C: All B are A and All B are C give Some A are C and Some C are A, but not All C are A.
  • Only A are B, No B is C: All B are A and No B is C give Some A are not C.
  • Only a few A are B, All B are C: Some A are B and All B are C give Some A are C.
  • Negative results: see the rows of Syllogism with Statements Containing a Negative or ‘No’ Relation for the logic behind them.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Statements: Only artists are painters. All painters are men. Conclusions: I. Some men are artists. II. All men are artists.

  1. Only artists are painters means All painters are artists.
  2. Painters are artists and men, so some men are artists: I follows.
  3. Other men need not be artists, so II does not follow.

Answer: Only I follows.

Example 2

Question: Statements: Only engineers are poets. All poets are singers. Conclusions: I. Some singers are engineers. II. All engineers are singers.

  1. Only engineers are poets means All poets are engineers.
  2. The poets are engineers and singers, so some singers are engineers: I follows.
  3. Engineers outside poets need not be singers, so II does not follow.

Answer: Only I follows.

Example 3

Question: Statements: Only a few teachers are doctors. All doctors are singers. Conclusions: I. Some teachers are singers. II. All teachers are singers. III. Some teachers are not singers.

  1. Convert: Some teachers are doctors and some teachers are not doctors.
  2. The teachers who are doctors are singers: I follows.
  3. The teachers who are not doctors may or may not be singers: II and III are only possible.

Answer: Only I follows.

Example 4

Question: Statements: Only men are soldiers. No soldier is a coward. Conclusions: I. Some men are not cowards. II. No coward is a man.

  1. Only men are soldiers means All soldiers are men.
  2. Soldiers are men and not cowards, so some men are not cowards: I follows.
  3. Other men may be cowards, so II does not follow.

Answer: Only I follows.

Example 5

Question: Statements: Only citizens are voters. Some voters are students. No student is a minor. Conclusions: I. Some citizens are students. II. Some students are not minors. III. Some citizens are not minors. IV. No citizen is a minor.

  1. Convert: All voters are citizens.
  2. The voters who are students are citizens: I follows.
  3. No student is a minor, and students exist, so II follows.
  4. The citizens who are students are not minors: III follows.
  5. Other citizens may be minors, so IV does not follow.

Answer: I, II and III follow.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Convert Only first, before reading anything else.
  • The word after Only becomes the subject of All: Only A are B gives All B are A.
  • Split Only a few into Some and Some not.
  • The Some not part rarely gives a conclusion alone.
  • After conversion, use the standard pair table.

Common Mistakes

  • Reading Only A are B as All A are B.
  • Forgetting the Some not part of Only a few.
  • Using the Some not part as if it were a Some statement.
  • Skipping conversion and judging the raw statement.
  • Concluding All C are A from All B are A and All B are C.

Practice Questions

  1. Convert: Only doctors are surgeons.
  2. Convert: Only a few pens are red.
  3. Only A are B. All B are C. Does Some C are A follow?
  4. Only A are B. No B is C. Does Some A are not C follow?
  5. Only a few A are B. All B are C. Does All A are C follow?
  6. Only A are B. All B are C. Does All C are A follow?

Answers: 1) All surgeons are doctors; 2) Some pens are red and some pens are not red; 3) yes; 4) yes; 5) no; 6) no.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Exam language Banks often use Only and Only a few.
  • Precision Conversion removes ambiguity.
  • Method Convert first, then use known rules.
  • Wrap-up It combines every rule of the macro.

What Comes Next?

The next macro begins with Statement and Assumption – Identifying Implicit Assumptions in a Statement. It moves from group statements to identifying the assumptions behind a statement.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Only Names the larger group in the converted All
  • Only a few Some, and also Some not
  • Quantifier A word such as All, Some, No or Only
  • Conversion Rewriting a statement in standard form
  • Split Dividing one statement into two
  • Standard form All, No, Some or Some not

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Only A are B means All B are A.
  • Only a few A are B means Some A are B and Some A are not B.
  • Some includes all possible.
  • Convert first, then solve.
  • Do not read Only A are B as All A are B.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Only vs All Only A are B reverses the direction of the All.
  • Only a few vs Some Only a few adds a Some not part.
  • Only some vs Only a few They are read the same here.
  • Conversion vs conclusion Conversion rewrites a statement; a conclusion is derived from it.

Memory Hook

Only flips the All; Only a few splits into Some and Some not.

GS Relevance

Statements with Only and Only a few appear in SSC, banking and CAPF syllogism sets, where converting them correctly decides the answer.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Only A are B mean in syllogism?

Only A are B means that every B is an A, so it converts to All B are A. It does not mean All A are B. For example, Only artists are painters means All painters are artists, and not all artists need be painters.

How do you convert Only a few in syllogism?

Only a few A are B is read as two statements together: Some A are B and Some A are not B. Use the Some part with an All statement to get a conclusion, and treat the Some not part separately, since it rarely gives a conclusion by itself.

How do you solve a syllogism that uses Only, Some, All and No?

Convert every Only statement into standard form first. Split Only a few into a Some and a Some not statement. Then combine the statements with the pair table, test each conclusion for certainty, and choose the options that follow.

Is Only A are B the same as All A are B?

No, they have opposite directions. All A are B puts A inside B, while Only A are B puts B inside A. Reading Only A are B as All A are B is the most common error in questions that use the word Only.

What follows from Only A are B and All B are C?

Converted, these are All B are A and All B are C. So Some A are C and Some C are A follow, because the B members are in both. All C are A does not follow, as C may contain members outside B.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 Only A are B means the same as All A are B.
False

It means All B are A.

2 Only a few A are B includes the statement Some A are not B.
True

It is read as Some A are B and Some A are not B.

3 From Only A are B and All B are C, Some C are A follows.
True

All B are A and All B are C make the B members both.

4 From Only A are B and All B are C, All C are A follows.
False

C may contain members outside B.

Share: