Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions
Reasoning › Syllogism · Topic 9.1
A syllogism with two statements and two conclusions asks which conclusions must be true if both statements are accepted as true. A conclusion follows only if it is true in every possible Venn arrangement of the statements. The four statement types are All, No, Some and Some not, and the middle term must link the two statements.
7 min read · Reasoning · Syllogism
Quick Answer
A syllogism with two statements and two conclusions asks which conclusions must be true if both statements are accepted as true. A conclusion follows only if it is true in every possible Venn arrangement of the statements. The four statement types are All, No, Some and Some not, and the middle term must link the two statements.
At a Glance
- Statement types All, No, Some, Some not
- Middle term The term common to both statements
- All + All All (and Some)
- Some + All Some
- All + No No
- Some + Some No definite conclusion
Where Does It Fit?
This is the first topic of the Syllogism macro and fixes the conventions used in the whole macro. The next topic, Syllogism with Multiple Statements and Multiple Conclusions, handles more statements, and Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method shows the Venn method that proves every result stated here.
What Are the Four Statement Types and the Conventions?
In short: every syllogism statement is All, No, Some or Some not. A conclusion follows only when it is true in every case that fits the statements.
| Type | Form | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Universal affirmative | All A are B | Every A is a B |
| Universal negative | No A is B | No A is in B; also No B is A |
| Particular affirmative | Some A are B | At least one A is a B; this may include all A |
| Particular negative | Some A are not B | At least one A is outside B |
- Convention used here: every term names a non-empty group, “Some” means at least one and may mean all, and the statements are taken as true even if they differ from real life.
- Conversion: No A is B can be read as No B is A, and Some A are B as Some B are A. All A are B gives Some B are A, but not All B are A.
- Some not: Some A are not B cannot be reversed.
Which Conclusions Follow From a Pair of Statements?
In short: two statements give a definite conclusion only when they share a middle term and at least one statement is universal.
| Statement 1 | Statement 2 | Conclusion that follows |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | All B are C | All A are C; Some C are A |
| Some A are B | All B are C | Some A are C; Some C are A |
| All A are B | No B is C | No A is C; No C is A; Some C are not A |
| No A is B | All B are C | Some C are not A |
| Some A are B | No B is C | Some A are not C |
| Some A are B | Some B are C | None |
Quick tests
- Two particular statements (Some, Some) give no conclusion.
- Two negative statements (No, No) give no conclusion.
- If the middle term is not common, no conclusion follows.
The reason each row works is shown by the Venn diagrams in Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method.
How Do You Solve a Two-Conclusion Question Step by Step?
In short: combine the statements through the middle term using the table, then test each conclusion against the result.
- Write the statements with letters for the terms.
- Identify the middle term.
- Use the table to find what definitely follows.
- Check each conclusion: follows, or does not follow.
- Choose from the options: only I, only II, both, or neither.
A conclusion that could be true but is not certain does not follow. Questions about what could be true are handled separately in Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’).
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Statements: All pens are books. All books are papers. Conclusions: I. All pens are papers. II. Some papers are pens.
- All pens are books and all books are papers, so all pens are papers: I follows.
- All pens are papers, and pens exist, so Some papers are pens: II follows.
Answer: Both I and II follow.
Example 2
Question: Statements: Some doctors are teachers. All teachers are engineers. Conclusions: I. Some doctors are engineers. II. All doctors are engineers.
- Some doctors are teachers, and all teachers are engineers, so those doctors are engineers: I follows.
- Only some doctors are known to be teachers, so all doctors need not be engineers: II does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Example 3
Question: Statements: No cat is a dog. All dogs are animals. Conclusions: I. No cat is an animal. II. Some animals are not cats.
- Dogs are animals and no dog is a cat, so some animals (the dogs) are not cats: II follows.
- Cats may or may not be animals, so I does not follow.
Answer: Only II follows.
Example 4
Question: Statements: All roses are flowers. Some trees are flowers. Conclusions: I. Some trees are roses. II. Some roses are trees.
- The middle term flowers is the predicate in both statements, and the second statement is only particular.
- The trees that are flowers may be outside roses, so neither I nor II is certain.
Answer: Neither I nor II follows.
Example 5
Question: Statements: All cars are vehicles. No vehicle is a flower. Conclusions: I. No flower is a car. II. Some cars are flowers.
- Cars lie inside vehicles, and vehicles are outside flowers, so no car is a flower and No flower is a car: I follows.
- II says the opposite of a certain fact, so it does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Write the statements with letters and mark the middle term first.
- Remember the pair table: All+All, Some+All, All+No, No+All, Some+No give conclusions.
- Some+Some and No+No never give a definite conclusion.
- Convert No and Some statements freely, but not All or Some not.
- If a conclusion is “could be”, it does not follow.
Common Mistakes
- Treating Some A are B as All A are B.
- Reversing All A are B to All B are A.
- Accepting a conclusion because it is true in real life.
- Concluding from two particular statements.
- Forgetting that Some not statements cannot be reversed.
Practice Questions
- All A are B. All B are C. Does Some C are A follow?
- Some A are B. Some B are C. Does Some A are C follow?
- No A is B. All B are C. Does Some C are not A follow?
- All A are B. No B is C. Does No C is A follow?
- Some A are B. All B are C. Does All A are C follow?
- All A are B. Some C are B. Does Some C are A follow?
Answers: 1) yes; 2) no; 3) yes; 4) yes; 5) no; 6) no.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- High weight Syllogism questions appear in most reasoning papers.
- Foundation Every longer syllogism builds on the pair table.
- Logic skill It trains you to separate certain from merely possible.
- Speed Once the table is memorised, each question takes under a minute.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Syllogism with Multiple Statements and Multiple Conclusions. It extends the pair table to three or four statements and several conclusions.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Statement A given fact to be treated as true
- Conclusion A claim that may or may not follow
- Middle term The term common to both statements
- Follows True in every case that fits the statements
- Universal A statement about all or none
- Particular A statement about some
Related Topics
- Syllogism with Multiple Statements and Multiple Conclusions
- Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method
- Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’)
- Syllogism Involving Complementary Pairs (Either-Or Conclusions)
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- A conclusion follows only if it is certain.
- The middle term must be common to both statements.
- Two particular statements give no conclusion.
- Two negative statements give no conclusion.
- Some includes all possible.
Do Not Confuse With
- Follows vs possible A possible conclusion does not follow; see Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’).
- All vs Some All gives certainty about every member; Some does not.
- No A is B vs Some A are not B No excludes all; Some not excludes at least one.
- Real life vs statement Treat statements as true even if false in life.
Memory Hook
Common middle, one universal, and only the certain conclusion follows.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you solve a syllogism with two statements and two conclusions?
Write the statements with letters, identify the middle term, and use the pair table to find what definitely follows. Then check each conclusion: it follows only if it is certain in every case that fits both statements. Choose from only I, only II, both or neither.
What are the four types of syllogism statements?
The four types are All A are B, No A is B, Some A are B and Some A are not B. All and No are universal statements, while Some and Some not are particular. Some means at least one and may include all, and its meaning is fixed by convention.
When does no conclusion follow in a syllogism?
No conclusion follows when both statements are particular, such as Some A are B and Some B are C, or when both are negative, such as No A is B and No B is C. It also fails when the statements share no middle term.
What does follows mean in syllogism?
A conclusion follows only if it is true in every possible case that fits the statements. If it could be true in one arrangement but false in another, it does not follow, and the answer for that conclusion is not follows.
Can I use real-life knowledge in syllogism questions?
No, treat the statements as true even if they differ from real life, and judge conclusions only by logic. For example, All cars are vehicles and No vehicle is a flower give No flower is a car, whatever real-world facts you know.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 From All A are B and All B are C, it follows that All A are C.
A lies inside B, which lies inside C.
2 From Some A are B and Some B are C, it follows that Some A are C.
Two particular statements give no conclusion.
3 From No A is B and All B are C, it follows that Some C are not A.
The B members are C but not A.
4 From All A are B, it follows that All B are A.
B may be a larger group than A.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index