An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 9.4

Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’)

Reasoning › Syllogism · Topic 9.4

Possibility-based syllogism asks which conclusions could possibly be true. A possibility conclusion is accepted if at least one Venn diagram that fits the statements makes it true, and rejected only when every fitting diagram makes it false. Anything that follows definitely is also possible.

Share:
Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’) - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Possibility-based syllogism asks which conclusions could possibly be true. A possibility conclusion is accepted if at least one Venn diagram that fits the statements makes it true, and rejected only when every fitting diagram makes it false. Anything that follows definitely is also possible.

At a Glance

  • Possibility true if At least one fitting diagram supports it
  • Possibility false if Every fitting diagram contradicts it
  • Certain conclusion Always counts as possible
  • Contradiction Opposite of a certain fact is false
  • Wording Can be, could be, is possible
  • Tool The loosest Venn diagrams

Where Does It Fit?

This topic uses the diagrams of Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method for a different question: could the conclusion be true, instead of must it be true. It also leads to the either-or pairs of Syllogism Involving Complementary Pairs (Either-Or Conclusions).

What Is the Possibility Rule?

In short: a possibility conclusion is true unless the statements make it impossible. To check, look for one diagram where the statements hold and the conclusion is true.

Statements Possibility conclusion Verdict Reason
All A are B; Some B are C Some A are C True C can overlap the A part of B
All A are B; Some B are C No A is C True C can stay in B outside A
Some A are B; All B are C All A are C True A can sit inside B
Some A are B; All B are C No A is C False The A members in B are in C
All A are B; No B is C Some A are C False A is inside B and B is separate from C

Two-step test

  • Step 1: does the conclusion contradict a certain fact from the statements? If yes, it is false.
  • Step 2: if not, draw a diagram in which it is true. If one exists, the possibility is true.

How Do Certain, Possible and Impossible Differ?

In short: every conclusion falls into one of three groups: certain, possible but not certain, or impossible. Possibility questions accept the first two.

  • Certain: true in all diagrams, as in Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions. It is also a true possibility.
  • Possible only: true in some diagrams and false in others.
  • Impossible: false in all diagrams, so the possibility is false.
  • Example: from No A is B and Some B are C, Some C are not A is certain, while Some A are C is possible only.

How Do You Answer Possibility Questions Quickly?

In short: remember that most conclusions are possible unless they directly oppose something certain.

  • Find the certain facts: use the pair table to list what must be true.
  • Reject opposites: a conclusion that is the opposite of a certain fact is false.
  • Accept the rest: if nothing contradicts it, the possibility is true.
  • Look for wording: words such as can be or is possible signal a possibility question, not a follows question.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Statements: All students are players. Some players are singers. Conclusions: I. Some singers can be students. II. No singer can be a student.

  1. Draw singers overlapping players so that they also overlap students: I is possible.
  2. Draw singers overlapping players outside students: II is also possible.
  3. Both are true in some diagram.

Answer: Both I and II are possible.

Example 2

Question: Statements: Some bats are balls. All balls are toys. Conclusions: I. All bats can be toys. II. No bat can be a toy.

  1. Some bats are balls, and balls are toys, so some bats are toys for certain.
  2. All bats can be toys is possible, with bats inside balls.
  3. No bat is a toy contradicts the certain fact.

Answer: Only I is possible.

Example 3

Question: Statements: No fish is a bird. Some birds are pets. Conclusions: I. Some pets can be fish. II. Some pets are not fish.

  1. Some pets are birds, birds are not fish, so Some pets are not fish is certain: II.
  2. Other pets may be fish, so I is possible.

Answer: Both I and II hold: I is possible and II is certain.

Example 4

Question: Statements: All cars are vehicles. No vehicle is a flower. Conclusion: Some cars can be flowers.

  1. Cars are inside vehicles, and vehicles are separate from flowers.
  2. So no car is a flower in any diagram.

Answer: The possibility is false.

Example 5

Question: Statements: All rivers are lakes. Some lakes are ponds. Conclusions: I. Some ponds can be rivers. II. All ponds can be lakes.

  1. Ponds may overlap the river part of lakes: I is possible.
  2. Ponds may sit entirely inside lakes: II is possible.

Answer: Both are possible.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • First list the certain facts, then judge the possibility.
  • A conclusion that contradicts a certain fact is false.
  • If it does not contradict anything, it is almost always possible.
  • Check the wording: can be and follows are different questions.
  • A certain conclusion is also a true possibility.

Common Mistakes

  • Treating possible as certain.
  • Rejecting a conclusion because it does not follow.
  • Not checking for a contradiction with a certain fact.
  • Accepting a conclusion that opposes a certain statement.
  • Using only one diagram to reject a possibility.

Practice Questions

  1. All A are B; Some B are C. Is Some A are C possible?
  2. Some A are B; All B are C. Is No A is C possible?
  3. All A are B; No B is C. Is Some A are C possible?
  4. Some A are B; All B are C. Is All A are C possible?
  5. No A is B; Some B are C. Is Some C are A possible?
  6. No A is B; Some B are C. Is No C is A possible?

Answers: 1) yes; 2) no; 3) no; 4) yes; 5) yes; 6) yes.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Extra marks Possibility conclusions appear in many bank-exam sets.
  • Understanding They separate certain, possible and impossible.
  • Link They prepare you for the either-or questions of Syllogism Involving Complementary Pairs (Either-Or Conclusions).
  • Speed Look for contradictions, not proofs.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Syllogism Involving Complementary Pairs (Either-Or Conclusions). It covers pairs of conclusions where one or the other must be true.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Possibility A conclusion that can be true
  • Certain True in all diagrams
  • Impossible False in all diagrams
  • Contradiction A conflict with a certain fact
  • Loosest diagram The diagram with the least overlap
  • Supporting diagram A diagram where the conclusion is true

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Possible if one diagram supports it.
  • False only if every diagram opposes it.
  • Certain implies possible.
  • Contradicting a certain fact makes it false.
  • Read the question wording carefully.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Follows vs possible Follows means certain; possible means at least one diagram.
  • Possible vs impossible Impossible conclusions are false in all diagrams.
  • Doubtful vs false A doubtful conclusion may still be a true possibility.
  • All vs some possible Either may be possible if no diagram forbids it.

Memory Hook

Find one diagram that works; if none exists, it is false.

GS Relevance

Possibility questions appear in banking, SSC and CAPF syllogism sets, and decide marks when conclusions are doubtful rather than certain.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is possibility-based syllogism?

Possibility-based syllogism asks whether a conclusion could possibly be true given the statements. A possibility conclusion is accepted if at least one Venn diagram that fits the statements makes it true, and rejected only if every fitting diagram makes it false.

How do you check a possibility conclusion?

First list the facts that are certain from the statements. If the conclusion opposes a certain fact, it is false. Otherwise, draw a diagram in which both the statements and the conclusion are true. If such a diagram exists, the possibility is true.

Is a certain conclusion also a possibility?

Yes, a conclusion that follows definitely is true in every diagram, so it is true in at least one and counts as a possibility. This is why a possibility question usually accepts every conclusion that is not opposed to the statements.

What is the difference between follows and could be true?

A conclusion follows only if it is true in every diagram that fits the statements. A conclusion could be true if it is true in at least one diagram. So follows is much stricter, and every conclusion that follows could also be true.

When is a possibility conclusion false?

A possibility conclusion is false when it contradicts something certain from the statements. For All A are B and No B is C, Some A are C is false, because A lies inside B and B is wholly separate from C.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 A conclusion that follows definitely is also a true possibility.
True

It holds in all diagrams, hence in at least one.

2 From All A are B and No B is C, Some A can be C.
False

A lies inside B, which is separate from C.

3 From All A are B and Some B are C, No A can be C is possible.
True

C can lie in B outside A.

4 A possibility conclusion is true only if it holds in every diagram.
False

One supporting diagram is enough.

Share: