An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 9.5

Syllogism Involving Complementary Pairs (Either-Or Conclusions)

Reasoning › Syllogism · Topic 9.5

An either-or conclusion pair in syllogism arises when two conclusions have the same subject and predicate, form a complementary pair, and neither follows on its own. The complementary pairs are Some and No, and All and Some not. In that case the answer is either I or II follows.

Share:
Syllogism Involving Complementary Pairs (Either-Or Conclusions) - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

An either-or conclusion pair in syllogism arises when two conclusions have the same subject and predicate, form a complementary pair, and neither follows on its own. The complementary pairs are Some and No, and All and Some not. In that case the answer is either I or II follows.

At a Glance

  • Condition 1 Same subject and same predicate
  • Condition 2 Complementary pair
  • Condition 3 Neither conclusion follows alone
  • Pair 1 Some A are B with No A is B
  • Pair 2 All A are B with Some A are not B
  • Not complementary All and No; Some and Some not

Where Does It Fit?

This topic builds on the possibility idea of Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’): each conclusion of an either-or pair is possible, and exactly one of them is true. The Venn diagrams of Syllogism Using Venn Diagram Method show why, and the next topic, Coded Syllogism (Statements Given in Coded Form), applies the same logic to coded statements.

When Does Either I or II Follow?

In short: either I or II follows when the two conclusions are about the same two terms in the same order, one is the exact denial of the other, and neither follows by itself.

Conclusion pair Complementary? Why
Some A are B and No A is B Yes One of them must be true, and both cannot be true together
All A are B and Some A are not B Yes Each is the denial of the other
All A are B and No A is B No Both can be false
Some A are B and Some A are not B No Both can be true

Three checks

  • 1. Same subject and predicate in both conclusions.
  • 2. They form a complementary pair.
  • 3. Neither conclusion follows on its own from the statements.
  • If all three hold, the answer is either I or II.

How Do You Use the Rule in a Question?

In short: first check each conclusion alone. If either follows, the answer does not involve either-or. If neither follows, test the pair.

  1. Combine the statements and decide whether I or II follows alone, using Syllogism with Two Statements and Two Conclusions.
  2. If neither follows, check that the terms match.
  3. Check that the pair is Some and No, or All and Some not.
  4. If both pass, choose either I or II follows.

The pair works because the statements leave the relation open, and that relation is either true or false. Both conclusions are possible in the sense of Possibility-Based Syllogism (Conclusions That ‘Could Possibly Be True’), but only one can be true.

What Cases Look Like Either-Or but Are Not?

In short: a pair is not either-or if one conclusion already follows, if the terms differ, or if the pair is not complementary.

  • One follows: from Some A are B and No B is C, Some A are not C follows, so the pair with No A is C is not either-or.
  • Different order of terms: Some A are B and No B is A can be paired once the order is made the same by conversion.
  • Not complementary: Some C are A and Some C are not A can both be true together, so neither follows and the answer is neither.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Statements: All students are players. Some players are singers. Conclusions: I. Some singers are students. II. No singer is a student.

  1. Neither follows alone: singers may or may not overlap students.
  2. Same subject and predicate, and the pair is Some and No.
  3. Exactly one of them must be true.

Answer: Either I or II follows.

Example 2

Question: Statements: Some artists are poets. All poets are writers. Conclusions: I. All artists are writers. II. Some artists are not writers.

  1. Some artists are writers for certain, but all of them being writers is not certain.
  2. Neither follows alone, and the pair is All and Some not.

Answer: Either I or II follows.

Example 3

Question: Statements: Some men are doctors. Some doctors are pilots. Conclusions: I. Some men are pilots. II. No man is a pilot.

  1. Two particular statements give no certain conclusion.
  2. The pair is Some and No with the same terms.

Answer: Either I or II follows.

Example 4

Question: Statements: All dogs are mammals. All cats are mammals. Conclusions: I. Some dogs are cats. II. No dog is a cat.

  1. Dogs and cats may overlap or be separate, so neither follows.
  2. The pair is Some and No.

Answer: Either I or II follows.

Example 5

Question: Statements: All roads are paths. Some paths are tracks. Conclusions: I. Some tracks are roads. II. Some tracks are not roads.

  1. Neither follows alone.
  2. Some and Some not are not complementary, because both can be true together.

Answer: Neither I nor II follows.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Check each conclusion alone before thinking of either-or.
  • Look for the pairs Some with No, and All with Some not.
  • Make the order of the terms the same before comparing.
  • Do not choose either-or for All with No.
  • If one of the pair follows, choose it alone.

Common Mistakes

  • Choosing either-or when one conclusion already follows.
  • Choosing either-or for All and No.
  • Choosing either-or for Some and Some not.
  • Ignoring a difference in the terms.
  • Forgetting to test each conclusion alone first.

Practice Questions

  1. All A are B. Some B are C. I. Some C are A. II. No C is A. What is the answer?
  2. Some A are B. All B are C. I. All A are C. II. Some A are not C. What is the answer?
  3. Some A are B. Some B are C. I. Some A are C. II. No A is C. What is the answer?
  4. All A are B. No B is C. I. No A is C. II. Some A are C. What is the answer?
  5. All A are B. Some B are C. I. Some C are A. II. Some C are not A. What is the answer?
  6. All A are B. All C are B. I. Some C are A. II. No C is A. What is the answer?

Answers: 1) either I or II; 2) either I or II; 3) either I or II; 4) only I follows; 5) neither; 6) either I or II.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Frequent twist Many sets include an either-or pair.
  • Precision It teaches the exact denial of a statement.
  • Link It combines the Venn and possibility ideas.
  • Accuracy Three checks prevent wrong choices.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Coded Syllogism (Statements Given in Coded Form). It presents syllogism statements in coded or symbolic form.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Either-or A pair where exactly one conclusion is true
  • Complementary pair Two conclusions that deny each other
  • Denial The statement that is true when the other is false
  • Subject The first term of a conclusion
  • Predicate The second term of a conclusion
  • Contrary Two statements that cannot both be true but can both be false

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Same subject and predicate.
  • Some with No, or All with Some not.
  • Neither follows alone.
  • All with No is not a complementary pair.
  • Some with Some not is not a complementary pair.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Either-or vs neither Either-or needs a complementary pair; neither needs no such pair.
  • Contrary vs complementary All and No can both be false; Some and No cannot.
  • Alone vs pair If one follows alone, the pair does not apply.
  • Order of terms Convert so the subject and predicate match.

Memory Hook

Same terms, exact denials, nothing follows alone: either I or II.

GS Relevance

Either-or conclusions are a regular twist in UPSC CSAT, SSC CGL, banking and CAPF syllogism sets and are decided by three quick checks.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the answer either I or II in syllogism?

The answer is either I or II when both conclusions have the same subject and predicate, form a complementary pair, and neither follows on its own. The complementary pairs are Some with No, and All with Some not. Then exactly one of the two conclusions must be true.

Which conclusion pairs are complementary?

Some A are B with No A is B, and All A are B with Some A are not B are complementary, because each is the exact denial of the other. All with No, and Some with Some not are not complementary, since both members can be false or both true.

Can either-or apply if one conclusion follows?

No, if one conclusion already follows from the statements, the answer is that conclusion alone. Either-or applies only when neither conclusion follows by itself and the statements leave the relation open for the same two terms.

Why does exactly one conclusion of an either-or pair hold?

The statements leave the relation between two terms open, and the relation is either that some members overlap or that none do. These two possibilities cover all cases and cannot both be true, so exactly one of the two conclusions holds.

How do I avoid mistakes in either-or questions?

Test each conclusion alone first. Then check that the terms are the same, that the pair is Some with No or All with Some not, and that neither follows. If any check fails, the answer is not either-or, and may be only one or neither.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 From All A are B and Some B are C, either Some C are A or No C is A follows.
True

Neither follows alone and the pair is Some and No.

2 Some A are B and Some A are not B form an either-or pair.
False

Both can be true together.

3 All A are B and No A is B form an either-or pair.
False

Both can be false, so the pair is not complementary.

4 If one conclusion of a Some and No pair follows alone, the answer is either-or.
False

Either-or applies only when neither follows alone.

Share: