Statement and Argument – Evaluating Strong and Weak Arguments
Reasoning › Statement-Assumption, Statement-Argument and Statement-Conclusion · Topic 10.2
In a statement and argument question, a policy question such as "Should X be done?" is followed by arguments for and against it, and you decide which are strong and which are weak. A strong argument is important, directly related to the question and based on a general fact or principle. A weak argument is trivial, irrelevant, vague, based on one example or personal opinion, or too broad to prove the point.
8 min read · Reasoning · Statement-Assumption, Statement-Argument and Statement-Conclusion
Quick Answer
In a statement and argument question, a policy question such as “Should X be done?” is followed by arguments for and against it, and you decide which are strong and which are weak. A strong argument is important, directly related to the question and based on a general fact or principle. A weak argument is trivial, irrelevant, vague, based on one example or personal opinion, or too broad to prove the point.
At a Glance
- Question form Should X be done? Arguments I, II
- Strong argument Relevant, important, general and fact-based
- Weak argument Trivial, vague, personal, irrelevant or extreme
- Judge The argument, not whether you agree with it
- Standard options Only I, only II, both, neither, either
- Special case If two arguments are on opposite sides and both are strong, check the either-or rule
Where Does It Fit?
This is the second topic of the Statement-Assumption, Statement-Argument and Statement-Conclusion macro. It comes after Statement and Assumption – Identifying Implicit Assumptions in a Statement, which finds hidden premises, and before Statement and Conclusion – Determining Logically Valid Conclusions, which checks conclusions. A broader treatment of how strength is graded appears in Argument Evaluation Based on Relevance and Strength Criteria.
What Makes an Argument Strong or Weak?
In short: an argument is strong if it is a general, relevant and important reason that bears directly on the question. It is weak if it is a small, personal, vague or unrelated point.
| Test | Strong argument | Weak argument |
|---|---|---|
| Relevance | Directly about the proposal | About a side issue |
| Importance | Affects many people or a major aim | Minor or one-off convenience |
| Basis | Fact, principle or widely true effect | One example, opinion, emotion or rumour |
| Scope | Reasonable and modest | Absolute, with words like all and never |
| Form | Explains why | Merely repeats the question or only says yes or no |
- Important: the point must matter for the goal in the statement, such as safety, cost, health or national interest.
- Universal: a reason that holds in general beats one that holds for one case.
- Factual: a claim based on a known effect is better than a feeling or a guess.
How Do You Solve Statement and Argument Questions?
In short: read the proposal, then judge each argument separately against the strength tests, ignoring your own view on the proposal.
- State the proposal in your own words, for example “ban plastic bags”.
- Take each argument alone and ask whether it is relevant to the proposal.
- Ask whether it is important and general, or trivial and special.
- Mark it strong or weak, then choose the option that matches.
Standard decision table
- Both strong: choose both.
- Only one strong: choose that one.
- Neither strong: choose neither.
- Both arguments strong but on opposite sides of the same issue: many papers still choose both, but if the question says either-or, choose either. Follow the option set given.
Whether the statement is a good idea or not has no bearing on the answer. A strong argument against a policy you support is still strong. The related skill of weighing relevance is described again in Argument Evaluation Based on Relevance and Strength Criteria.
Which Kinds of Argument Are Always Weak?
In short: arguments that rest on a single example, on emotion, on tradition, or on an unrelated fact are weak, whatever they say.
| Type | Example | Why weak |
|---|---|---|
| Single example | A friend of mine did it and failed | One case proves nothing general |
| Appeal to emotion | It will make children very sad | Feeling is not a reason |
| Appeal to tradition | We have always done it this way | Age is not merit |
| Mere repetition | Yes, because it should be done | Restates the question |
| Irrelevant fact | Other countries have a different flag | No link to the proposal |
| Absolute claim | It will solve all problems | Too strong to be believable |
A strong argument can still be short. “Yes, because it will reduce road accidents” is strong for a helmet law, since safety is a central aim and the claim is a known general effect.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Statement: Should helmets be made compulsory for all two-wheeler riders? Arguments I. Yes, helmets reduce head injuries in accidents. II. No, helmets are uncomfortable in hot weather.
- I is a general, important, fact-based effect directly linked to safety. Strong.
- II points to a minor discomfort that does not outweigh life safety. Weak.
Answer: Only I is strong.
Example 2
Question: Statement: Should the government ban the sale of tobacco? Arguments I. Yes, tobacco causes serious diseases. II. No, many people like smoking.
- I names a major health effect and is directly relevant. Strong.
- II is a matter of personal liking and does not address public harm. Weak.
Answer: Only I is strong.
Example 3
Question: Statement: Should students be given homework every day? Arguments I. Yes, it builds a habit of regular study. II. Yes, my cousin did homework daily and became a doctor.
- I gives a general benefit tied to learning. Strong.
- II is one example, so it proves nothing general. Weak.
Answer: Only I is strong.
Example 4
Question: Statement: Should the retirement age be raised to 65? Arguments I. Yes, many people remain fit and productive at 60. II. Yes, because it should be done.
- I gives a relevant, general reason. Strong.
- II only repeats the proposal. Weak.
Answer: Only I is strong.
Example 5
Question: Statement: Should cash prizes be given to students for high marks? Arguments I. Yes, rewards motivate students to work harder. II. No, it may make students study only for money.
- I states a widely accepted motivational effect. Strong.
- II states a real risk to the purpose of learning, relevant and general enough. Strong.
- Both are strong and on opposite sides. Under the standard rule, both are judged on strength alone.
Answer: Both I and II are strong.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Always judge the argument and never the statement. Do not let your own opinion pick the answer.
- Reject any argument that begins with “because my friend”, “in my opinion” or “everyone says”.
- Reject arguments that only say “yes, it should be done” or “no, it should not”.
- Prefer arguments about safety, health, cost, law, national interest and fairness, as they are central values.
- Mark an argument weak if it uses all, never or always without support.
Common Mistakes
- Calling an argument strong because it agrees with your view. Strength is about reasoning, not agreement.
- Treating a true but unrelated fact as strong. It must connect to the proposal.
- Choosing “both” without testing each argument alone.
- Accepting emotional language as a reason. Feelings do not prove a point.
- Forgetting that two opposite arguments can both be strong in a given question.
Practice Questions
- Should plastic carry bags be banned? Argument: Yes, plastic bags clog drains and harm animals. Strong or weak?
- Should the school start an hour later? Argument: No, because my brother prefers the old time. Strong or weak?
- Should smoking be banned in public places? Argument: Yes, it harms people who do not smoke. Strong or weak?
- Should the metro fare be reduced? Argument: Yes, because the fare should be low. Strong or weak?
- Should a country give up nuclear power? Argument: No, it will solve all energy problems. Strong or weak?
- Should voting be compulsory? Argument: Yes, it will increase participation in elections. Strong or weak?
Answers: 1) Strong; 2) Weak; 3) Strong; 4) Weak; 5) Weak; 6) Strong.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Frequency Argument questions appear in CSAT, SSC, banking and defence reasoning papers.
- Skill They train you to judge reasons objectively, which helps in GS answers and interviews.
- Link The same strength test supports Argument Evaluation Based on Relevance and Strength Criteria and Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems.
- Speed A fixed checklist of relevance, importance and generality gives fast answers.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Statement and Conclusion – Determining Logically Valid Conclusions. It switches from judging arguments about a proposal to checking which conclusions follow from a given statement.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Proposal The policy or action in the question
- Strong argument Relevant, important, general and fact-based
- Weak argument Trivial, vague, personal or irrelevant
- Direct relevance A close link between the argument and the proposal
- Universal validity Holds for most cases, not one case
- Appeal to emotion A reason that rests on feeling and not on fact
Related Topics
- Statement and Assumption – Identifying Implicit Assumptions in a Statement
- Statement and Conclusion – Determining Logically Valid Conclusions
- Statement and Inference – Distinguishing Inferences from Given Information
- Passage-Based Conclusion and Inference Problems
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Judge the argument on its own merit, not on your view of the statement.
- A strong argument is relevant, important and general.
- Single examples, emotion, tradition and repetition are weak.
- Both strong or neither strong are valid outcomes.
- Absolute words weaken an argument.
Do Not Confuse With
- Argument vs assumption An argument gives a reason for or against; an assumption is a hidden premise.
- Strong vs true A strong argument is a good reason; a true statement may still be irrelevant.
- Weak vs wrong A weak argument may be true yet fail to support the point.
- Agreement vs strength You can agree with a weak argument and disagree with a strong one.
Memory Hook
Relevant, important, general: three ticks make an argument strong.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a strong argument in logical reasoning?
A strong argument is a reason that is directly relevant to the proposal, important for its aim, and based on a general fact or principle. It affects many cases rather than one, and it is neither extreme nor emotional, so it genuinely supports or opposes the proposal.
How do you solve statement and argument questions?
State the proposal, then test each argument alone for relevance, importance and generality. Mark it strong if it passes and weak if it is trivial, vague, personal or based on one example. Then pick the option that matches, ignoring your own opinion of the proposal.
What makes an argument weak?
An argument is weak when it is irrelevant, trivial, too general to be credible, based on a single example, an emotion or tradition, or merely repeats the question. Arguments that use absolute words such as all or never without support are also treated as weak.
Can both arguments be strong in a statement and argument question?
Yes. Two arguments on opposite sides of an issue can both be strong if each is relevant, important and general. Judge each by its own merit. Some papers provide an either-or option for such cases, so follow the option set in the question.
Should I use my own opinion to judge arguments?
No. Evaluate the reasoning only. A strong argument against a policy you support is still strong, and a weak argument for it is still weak. Personal agreement does not change the strength, so set your own view aside before deciding.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 An argument based on a single personal example is a strong argument.
One example cannot prove a general point, so the argument is weak.
2 An argument that only repeats the proposal is weak.
It gives no reason, so it adds nothing.
3 Your personal agreement with the proposal makes an argument strong.
Strength depends on relevance and importance, not on agreement.
4 Two opposite arguments can both be strong.
Each is judged on its own merit.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index