An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 10.3

Statement and Conclusion – Determining Logically Valid Conclusions

Reasoning › Statement-Assumption, Statement-Argument and Statement-Conclusion · Topic 10.3

A conclusion follows from a statement only if it is a direct, necessary result of the given facts, with nothing added from outside knowledge. To test a conclusion, ask whether it must be true if the statement is true. If it must be true, it follows. If it could be false, adds new facts, goes beyond the data, or only repeats part of the statement in a stronger form, it does not follow.

Share:
Statement and Conclusion – Determining Logically Valid Conclusions - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

A conclusion follows from a statement only if it is a direct, necessary result of the given facts, with nothing added from outside knowledge. To test a conclusion, ask whether it must be true if the statement is true. If it must be true, it follows. If it could be false, adds new facts, goes beyond the data, or only repeats part of the statement in a stronger form, it does not follow.

At a Glance

  • Task Choose conclusions that follow from the statement
  • Key test Must it be true if the statement is true?
  • Allowed Direct, necessary results of the given facts
  • Not allowed Outside facts, extremes, guesses, advice
  • Typical options Only I, only II, both, neither
  • Common frame Statement or passage, then Conclusions I and II

Where Does It Fit?

This is the third topic of the Statement-Assumption, Statement-Argument and Statement-Conclusion macro. It follows Statement and Assumption – Identifying Implicit Assumptions in a Statement and Statement and Argument – Evaluating Strong and Weak Arguments. The next topic, Statement and Inference – Distinguishing Inferences from Given Information, uses a graded scale (definitely true to definitely false) for the same kind of reasoning, and longer passages are handled in Passage-Based Conclusion and Inference Problems.

What Does It Mean for a Conclusion to Follow?

In short: a conclusion follows when the statement alone forces it to be true. Probable, likely or desirable results do not count.

Take the statement “All the flights to the city are delayed because of fog.” The conclusion “No flight reached the city on time” follows if the statement means every flight is late. The conclusion “Fog will continue tomorrow” does not follow, since the statement says nothing about tomorrow.

Conclusion type Does it follow? Reason
Direct result of the statement Yes Forced by the given facts
Restates the statement in other words Yes Same meaning
Needs a new fact No Adds outside information
Predicts the future No Statement does not cover it
Gives advice or a moral No A suggestion is not a deduction
Stronger than the statement (all for some) No Goes beyond the data

How Do You Apply the Must-Be-True Test?

In short: treat the statement as the only truth, then ask for each conclusion whether it must be true. If any doubt remains, it does not follow.

  1. Read the statement and note every fact and quantity in it, including words such as some, most and all.
  2. Read the conclusion and underline its claim.
  3. Check whether the claim is stated or logically forced by the statement.
  4. If it needs another fact, or could be false while the statement is true, reject it.

Words that need extra care

  • Some: a part, possibly all, but not a guarantee of all.
  • Most: more than half, not every one.
  • All, every: no exception allowed.
  • Only, none, never: exclusion that the statement must support.

Quantity words decide many questions. If the statement says “most employees attend the training”, the conclusion “all employees attend” does not follow, and “some employees attend” does follow, because most includes some. The difference between this approach and the assumption approach is explained in Distinguishing Between an Assumption and an Inference.

When Do Two Conclusions Compete?

In short: when two conclusions are complementary and neither follows alone, some exams include an either-or option. Check whether exactly one must be true.

Suppose the statement is “Some of the students passed.” Conclusion I: “Some students did not pass.” Conclusion II: “All students passed.” Neither follows. “Some passed” is compatible with all passing and with only a few passing, so I is not guaranteed and II is not guaranteed.

  • Complementary pair: two conclusions that cannot both be false and cannot both be true, such as “the policy was effective” and “the policy was not effective”. If the statement settles the issue neither way, an either-or option may be right.
  • Same-subject test: the either-or rule needs both conclusions to talk about the same subject and the same time.
  • Exam rule: use either-or only if the options offer it. Otherwise choose neither.

For graded judgments on the same information, move to Statement and Inference – Distinguishing Inferences from Given Information, where each statement is rated definitely true, probably true, data inadequate, probably false or definitely false.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Statement: “The school has made yoga compulsory for all students from next month.” Conclusions I. All students will learn yoga from next month. II. Yoga is the best form of exercise.

  1. If yoga is compulsory for all from next month, then all students will learn it. I follows.
  2. The statement does not compare yoga with other exercise. II adds an opinion. It does not follow.

Answer: Only I follows.

Example 2

Question: Statement: “Most of the candidates who appeared for the interview were graduates.” Conclusions I. Some candidates who appeared were graduates. II. All the candidates were graduates.

  1. Most means more than half, so some candidates were certainly graduates. I follows.
  2. Most does not cover all. II does not follow.

Answer: Only I follows.

Example 3

Question: Statement: “The price of petrol has been increased by 10 per cent.” Conclusions I. The price of diesel will also go up. II. The price of petrol was lower before the increase.

  1. The statement says nothing about diesel, so I does not follow.
  2. A 10 per cent increase means the earlier price was lower than the new price. II follows.

Answer: Only II follows.

Example 4

Question: Statement: “Every employee who completes the course gets a certificate. Ravi completed the course.” Conclusions I. Ravi gets a certificate. II. Ravi will be promoted.

  1. Completing the course leads to a certificate, and Ravi completed it. I follows.
  2. Promotion is not mentioned. II does not follow.

Answer: Only I follows.

Example 5

Question: Statement: “Only the first 100 applicants will be called for the test. Meera was the 140th applicant.” Conclusions I. Meera will not be called for the test. II. The test will be difficult.

  1. Only the first 100 are called, and 140 is outside that group. I follows.
  2. Difficulty is not mentioned. II does not follow.

Answer: Only I follows.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Underline quantity words (some, most, all) in the statement and the conclusion and compare them first.
  • Reject conclusions that predict the future, give advice, or use words like should and best.
  • A conclusion that only paraphrases the statement is safe and follows.
  • Do not use real-world knowledge. Treat the statement as the only available information.
  • Use the either-or option only when both conclusions are complementary and the options include it.

Common Mistakes

  • Accepting a conclusion because it is sensible in real life. It must be forced by the statement.
  • Reading “some” as “not all” or “most” as “all”.
  • Marking a conclusion that is a suggestion (should, must) as following.
  • Using future predictions that the statement does not support.
  • Ignoring a small condition in the statement such as only, unless or until.

Practice Questions

  1. Statement: “All the roads in the town are flooded.” Conclusion: Some roads in the town are flooded. Follows?
  2. Statement: “Some members of the club are doctors.” Conclusion: All members of the club are doctors. Follows?
  3. Statement: “The bank is open on all weekdays.” Conclusion: The bank is open on Tuesday. Follows?
  4. Statement: “Ananya scored more than 90 in maths.” Conclusion: Ananya scored more than 90 in science. Follows?
  5. Statement: “Only graduates are eligible for the post. Kiran is eligible.” Conclusion: Kiran is a graduate. Follows?
  6. Statement: “The company will recruit 50 people.” Conclusion: The company will recruit 60 people. Follows?

Answers: 1) Yes; 2) No; 3) Yes; 4) No; 5) Yes; 6) No.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Frequency Conclusion questions are a regular part of CSAT, SSC and banking reasoning.
  • Skill They train you to separate what is given from what is imagined.
  • Link The same discipline is needed for Statement and Inference – Distinguishing Inferences from Given Information and Passage-Based Conclusion and Inference Problems.
  • Accuracy Watching quantity words removes most careless errors.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Statement and Inference – Distinguishing Inferences from Given Information. It uses the same facts but asks for a graded judgment on each statement, from definitely true to definitely false.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Conclusion A result that follows from the given facts
  • Follows Must be true if the statement is true
  • Paraphrase The same idea in different words
  • Quantifier A word such as some, most or all that sets the quantity
  • Complementary pair Two conclusions of which exactly one must be true
  • Either-or option Choice used when exactly one of two conclusions must hold
  • Statement and Argument – Evaluating Strong and Weak Arguments
  • Statement and Inference – Distinguishing Inferences from Given Information
  • Statement and Assumption – Identifying Implicit Assumptions in a Statement
  • Passage-Based Conclusion and Inference Problems

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • A conclusion follows only if the statement forces it.
  • Do not bring in outside facts.
  • Check quantity words: some, most, all.
  • Advice and predictions do not follow.
  • Use either-or only for complementary conclusions.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Conclusion vs assumption A conclusion comes out of the statement; an assumption stands behind it.
  • Follows vs possible A possible result may be true, but only a necessary result follows.
  • Some vs most Some can be any part; most is more than half.
  • Paraphrase vs extension A paraphrase follows; an extension adds a new claim and does not.

Memory Hook

If the statement is true and the conclusion could still be false, it does not follow.

GS Relevance

Common in UPSC CSAT, SSC CGL, bank PO, CDS and CAPF reasoning as 'Statements and Conclusions', where you choose which conclusions logically follow from one or more given statements.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you decide which conclusion follows from a statement?

Treat the statement as the only truth and ask whether the conclusion must be true if the statement is true. If it is forced by the given facts or is a paraphrase, it follows. If it adds outside facts, predicts the future or goes beyond the data, it does not follow.

What is a logically valid conclusion?

A logically valid conclusion is a result that must be true whenever the given statement is true. It uses only the information supplied, respects quantity words such as some and all, and adds no new facts, opinions or predictions that the statement did not support.

Can outside knowledge be used in statement and conclusion questions?

No. The statement is treated as the only source of truth. A conclusion that is sensible in real life but is not forced by the given words does not follow. Use common meaning of words only, and never extra facts from your own knowledge.

When is the either-or option correct in conclusions?

The either-or option is correct when two conclusions are complementary, so that exactly one of them must be true, and neither follows on its own. Both must refer to the same subject. If the options do not offer either-or, choose neither.

Does most imply some in conclusion questions?

Yes. If most of a group has a quality, then more than half has it, so at least some of the group has it. However, most does not imply all, so a conclusion saying all of the group has that quality does not follow.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 A conclusion follows if it is sensible in real life.
False

It must be forced by the given statement.

2 If most of the people attend, then some of the people attend.
True

Most is more than half, so some must attend.

3 A conclusion that gives advice follows from a factual statement.
False

A suggestion is not a deduction.

4 A paraphrase of the statement is a valid conclusion.
True

It carries the same meaning.

Share: