An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 9.10

Pipe-Filling Problems with a Simultaneous Leak

Quantitative Aptitude › Time and Work, Pipes and Cisterns · Topic 9.10

A leak in a tank is an outlet that works against the inlet pipe. If a pipe alone fills a tank in a hours and takes b hours with the leak, the leak's rate is 1/a minus 1/b, and the leak alone empties a full tank in ab/(b minus a) hours.

Share:
Pipe-Filling Problems with a Simultaneous Leak - Quantitative Aptitude - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

A leak in a tank is an outlet that works against the inlet pipe. If a pipe alone fills a tank in a hours and takes b hours with the leak, the leak’s rate is 1/a minus 1/b, and the leak alone empties a full tank in ab/(b minus a) hours.

At a Glance

  • Leak rate 1/a – 1/b
  • Leak alone empties ab / (b – a) hours
  • Pipe alone a hours
  • Pipe with leak b hours (b is more than a)
  • Net rate with leak Pipe rate – leak rate
  • Capacity known Leak in litres per hour = capacity × (1/a – 1/b)

Where Does It Fit?

A leak is the simplest outlet, so this topic follows Pipes and Cisterns – Filling and Emptying Problems and Pipes Working Together, Alternately or with One Acting as an Outlet. It is the last topic in the pipes group before Work Problems Involving Men, Women and Children Working Together at Different Rates returns to workers.

How Do You Find the Leak Rate From the Two Filling Times?

In short: the leak is whatever slows the filling, so its rate is the difference between the rate without the leak and the rate with the leak.

Leak formulas

  • Leak rate = 1/a – 1/b
  • Time for the leak to empty a full tank = 1 / (1/a – 1/b) = ab / (b – a)
  • Leak in litres per hour = capacity × (1/a – 1/b)

If a pipe fills a tank in 6 hours but takes 8 hours with a leak, the leak rate is 1/6 – 1/8 = 1/24, so the leak alone empties the full tank in 24 hours.

How Do You Find the Filling Time When the Leak Is Known?

Pipe alone Leak alone Net rate Time with leak
4 h 12 h 1/4 – 1/12 = 1/6 6 hours
3 h 12 h 1/3 – 1/12 = 1/4 4 hours
6 h 24 h 1/6 – 1/24 = 1/8 8 hours

The net rate is the pipe rate minus the leak rate, and the filling time is its reciprocal, exactly as in Pipes and Cisterns – Filling and Emptying Problems. The tank fills only if the pipe rate is larger than the leak rate.

What Other Forms Do Leak Questions Take?

  • Two pipes and a leak: two pipes that together fill a tank in 6 hours take 7.5 hours with a leak, so the leak rate is 1/6 – 2/15 = 1/30 and it empties a full tank in 30 hours.
  • Capacity given: if the tank holds 1,500 litres and the leak empties it in 30 hours, the leak loses 1,500 / 30 = 50 litres per hour.
  • Extra time given: if filling takes 2 hours longer because of a leak, use the two times to get the leak rate, as above.
  • Related topics: the idea of subtracting rates also appears in Pipes Working Together, Alternately or with One Acting as an Outlet.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: A pipe fills a tank in 6 hours. Because of a leak, it takes 8 hours. In how many hours will the leak alone empty the full tank?

  1. Leak rate = 1/6 – 1/8 = 4/24 – 3/24 = 1/24.
  2. Time to empty = 1 / (1/24) = 24 hours.
  3. Check with the formula ab/(b – a) = 6 × 8 / 2 = 24.

Answer: 24 hours

Example 2

Question: A pipe normally fills a tank in 5 hours but takes 6 hours with a leak. How long does the leak alone take to empty the full tank?

  1. Leak rate = 1/5 – 1/6 = 6/30 – 5/30 = 1/30.
  2. Time = 30 hours.

Answer: 30 hours

Example 3

Question: A tank holds 1,500 litres. A pipe fills it in 6 hours normally and in 7.5 hours with a leak. How many litres per hour does the leak lose?

  1. Leak rate = 1/6 – 1/7.5 = 1/6 – 2/15 = 5/30 – 4/30 = 1/30 of the tank per hour.
  2. Litres lost per hour = 1,500 × 1/30 = 50.

Answer: 50 litres per hour

Example 4

Question: Two pipes fill a tank in 10 and 15 hours. With a leak, the tank is filled in 7.5 hours. How long would the leak alone take to empty a full tank?

  1. Without the leak, rate = 1/10 + 1/15 = 1/6.
  2. With the leak, rate = 1/7.5 = 2/15.
  3. Leak rate = 1/6 – 2/15 = 1/30, so 30 hours.

Answer: 30 hours

Example 5

Question: A pipe fills a tank in 4 hours and a leak empties the full tank in 12 hours. How long does the tank take to fill with the leak?

  1. Net rate = 1/4 – 1/12 = 3/12 – 1/12 = 1/6.
  2. Time = 6 hours.

Answer: 6 hours

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Use ab/(b – a) for the time the leak takes to empty the tank.
  • Check that the time with the leak is longer than the time without it.
  • Use the LCM of the times as the tank capacity in units to avoid fractions.
  • When capacity is given, multiply it by the leak rate to get litres lost per hour.
  • Treat a leak like an outlet with its own emptying time.

Common Mistakes

  • Subtracting the times (b – a) instead of the rates.
  • Adding the leak rate to the pipe rate.
  • Forgetting that the leak empties a full tank, not a part.
  • Mixing minutes and hours.
  • Taking the reciprocal of the wrong rate.

Practice Questions

  1. A pipe fills a tank in 9 hours, and in 12 hours with a leak. How long does the leak alone take to empty the tank?
  2. A pipe fills a tank in 15 hours, and in 18 hours with a leak. How long does the leak alone take to empty the tank?
  3. A pipe fills a tank in 3 hours. A leak empties the full tank in 12 hours. How long to fill with the leak?
  4. A pipe fills a tank in 8 hours and in 10 hours with a leak. How long does the leak alone take?
  5. A 600-litre tank fills in 5 hours normally and 6 hours with a leak. How many litres per hour does the leak lose?

Answers: 1) 36 hours; 2) 90 hours; 3) 4 hours; 4) 40 hours; 5) 20 litres per hour.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Exam favourite Leak questions are the most common pipe problem.
  • Real life It models a tank with a hole or a loss.
  • Same method It reinforces net rates from earlier topics.
  • Next step It leads to Work Problems Involving Men, Women and Children Working Together at Different Rates.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Work Problems Involving Men, Women and Children Working Together at Different Rates, which brings men, women and children with different rates into one work problem.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Leak An unintended outlet that empties the tank
  • Net rate Pipe rate minus leak rate
  • Inlet A pipe that fills the tank
  • Capacity Volume the tank holds
  • Filling time Reciprocal of the net rate
  • Leak time Time for the leak alone to empty a full tank

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Leak rate = 1/a – 1/b.
  • Leak alone empties the tank in ab/(b – a) hours.
  • Net rate with a leak = pipe rate – leak rate.
  • The tank fills only if the pipe rate is larger than the leak rate.
  • Litres per hour = capacity × leak rate.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Leak time vs extra time The extra time (b – a) is not the leak’s emptying time.
  • Pipe rate vs leak rate The pipe adds, the leak subtracts.
  • Full tank vs part tank The leak time is for a full tank.
  • Net rate vs single rate Use the net rate when both act together.

Memory Hook

Pipe rate minus leak rate gives the net rate; flip it for the time.

GS Relevance

Leak problems are the most common form of pipes and cisterns in SSC CGL and CAT.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you find the time a leak takes to empty a tank?

The time a leak takes to empty a full tank is found from the difference of the two filling rates. If a pipe fills a tank in a hours and takes b hours with the leak, the leak empties the full tank in a times b divided by b minus a hours.

What is the leak rate when a pipe takes 6 hours but 8 hours with a leak?

The leak rate is the pipe rate minus the net rate, which is one sixth minus one eighth, giving one twenty-fourth of the tank per hour. The leak alone therefore empties the full tank in 24 hours, as the formula 6 times 8 divided by 2 also shows.

How are litres lost per hour calculated for a leak?

Litres lost per hour equal the tank capacity multiplied by the leak rate. For a 1,500-litre tank where the pipe takes 6 hours normally and 7.5 hours with a leak, the leak rate is one thirtieth, so the leak loses 50 litres every hour.

When does a tank fill despite a leak?

A tank fills despite a leak only when the inlet pipe rate is larger than the leak rate. If the leak rate equals or exceeds the pipe rate, the net rate is zero or negative, and the tank never fills, and it empties instead if it was full.

How is a leak problem related to pipes and cisterns?

A leak problem is a pipes and cisterns problem in which one outlet is hidden inside the extra filling time. The solution uses the same method as other pipe problems: add the inlet rates, subtract the outlet rate to get the net rate, and take the reciprocal.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 A pipe fills a tank in 6 hours and in 8 hours with a leak, so the leak alone empties the full tank in 2 hours.
False

The leak rate is 1/6 - 1/8 = 1/24, so 24 hours.

2 The leak rate equals the pipe's rate minus the rate with the leak.
True

For example 1/6 - 1/8 = 1/24.

3 A pipe filling in 4 hours with a leak emptying in 12 hours fills the tank in 6 hours.
True

1/4 - 1/12 = 1/6.

4 A leak can only make the tank fill faster.
False

A leak is an outlet and always slows filling.

Share: