An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 9.6

Pipes Working Together, Alternately or with One Acting as an Outlet

Quantitative Aptitude › Time and Work, Pipes and Cisterns · Topic 9.6

Pipes can work together, take turns alternately, or work with an outlet that drains the tank. In every case the work of each pipe is added, with outlets counted as negative, and alternate working is solved cycle by cycle.

Share:
Pipes Working Together, Alternately or with One Acting as an Outlet - Quantitative Aptitude - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Pipes can work together, take turns alternately, or work with an outlet that drains the tank. In every case the work of each pipe is added, with outlets counted as negative, and alternate working is solved cycle by cycle.

At a Glance

  • Together Add all rates
  • Alternate Work cycle by cycle
  • With outlet Subtract the outlet rate
  • Cycle work Sum of rates in one cycle
  • Last fraction Finish in part of an hour
  • Check Net rate must be positive

Where Does It Fit?

This topic builds on Pipes and Cisterns – Filling and Emptying Problems and uses the stage idea of Work Left/Completed When People Join or Leave Midway. It leads to Work Completed in a Fractional/Part Day Problems on part-day work.

How Do Pipes Working Together With an Outlet Behave?

In short: add the inlet rates, subtract the outlet rate, and take the reciprocal.

Together with an outlet

  • Net rate = sum of inlet rates – outlet rate
  • Time = 1 / net rate

Pipes A and B fill a tank in 6 hours and 12 hours, and pipe C empties it in 9 hours. The net rate is 1/6 + 1/12 – 1/9 = 6/36 + 3/36 – 4/36 = 5/36, so the tank fills in 36/5 = 7.2 hours. If C empties in 12 hours with A filling in 4 hours and B in 6 hours, the net rate is 1/4 + 1/6 – 1/12 = 1/3, so it fills in 3 hours.

How Do You Solve Alternate Working?

In short: find the work done in one full cycle of both pipes, count full cycles, and then handle the remaining part.

Case Cycle Work in a cycle Result
A 10 h, B 15 h, A first 2 hours 1/10 + 1/15 = 1/6 6 cycles, so 12 hours
A 8 h, B 12 h, A first 2 hours 1/8 + 1/12 = 5/24 4 cycles = 8 hours, then 1.5 hours more

For A taking 8 hours and B taking 12 hours, four cycles take 8 hours and fill 20/24 = 5/6. In the ninth hour A adds 1/8, bringing the total to 23/24. The remaining 1/24 is filled by B at 1/12 per hour in half an hour, so the tank is full in 9.5 hours.

What Points Need Care?

  • Who starts: the order affects the total time when the job does not end on a full cycle.
  • Last partial hour: the pipe operating when the tank fills may work for only part of the hour.
  • Net rate sign: if inlets do not outpace the outlet, the tank never fills.
  • Link: the part-hour handling is explored further in Work Completed in a Fractional/Part Day Problems.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: A takes 10 hours and B takes 15 hours to fill a tank. They work alternately for one hour each, starting with A. When is the tank full?

  1. Work in a 2-hour cycle = 1/10 + 1/15 = 1/6.
  2. Six cycles fill the tank exactly.
  3. Time = 6 × 2 = 12 hours.

Answer: 12 hours

Example 2

Question: A takes 8 hours and B takes 12 hours. They work alternately for one hour each, starting with A. When is the tank full?

  1. Work in a cycle = 1/8 + 1/12 = 5/24.
  2. Four cycles (8 hours) fill 20/24 = 5/6.
  3. Ninth hour (A) adds 1/8, total 23/24.
  4. Remaining 1/24 at B’s rate 1/12 takes half an hour.
  5. Total = 8 + 1 + 0.5 = 9.5 hours.

Answer: 9.5 hours

Example 3

Question: Pipes A and B fill a tank in 6 hours and 12 hours, and pipe C empties it in 9 hours. All three are open. How long to fill the tank?

  1. Net rate = 1/6 + 1/12 – 1/9.
  2. = 6/36 + 3/36 – 4/36 = 5/36.
  3. Time = 36/5 = 7.2 hours.

Answer: 7.2 hours

Example 4

Question: Pipes fill a tank in 4 hours and 6 hours, and a pipe empties it in 12 hours. How long with all open?

  1. Net rate = 1/4 + 1/6 – 1/12 = 3/12 + 2/12 – 1/12 = 4/12.
  2. 4/12 = 1/3.
  3. Time = 3 hours.

Answer: 3 hours

Example 5

Question: Two pipes fill a tank in 6 hours and 12 hours working together. How much is filled in 2 hours?

  1. Rate = 1/6 + 1/12 = 1/4 per hour.
  2. In 2 hours = 2 × 1/4 = 1/2.

Answer: Half the tank

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Compute the work in one full cycle before counting cycles.
  • Stop the cycle count one cycle early if the tank fills during the last cycle, then treat the remainder.
  • Use the LCM of times as the tank capacity for whole-number rates.
  • Check which pipe works when the tank fills.
  • Confirm that the total work in all stages equals 1.

Common Mistakes

  • Using the 2-hour cycle count without handling the leftover.
  • Forgetting that the order of starting matters.
  • Giving a full hour to the last pipe when only part is needed.
  • Adding the outlet rate.
  • Treating alternate working as working together.

Practice Questions

  1. Pipes fill a tank in 10 and 15 hours, working alternately starting with A. When full?
  2. A fills in 6 hours, B in 12 hours, C empties in 9 hours. With all open, when full?
  3. A fills in 4 hours, B in 6 hours, C empties in 12 hours. With all open, when full?
  4. A fills in 8 hours, B in 12 hours, alternate hours starting with A. When full?
  5. Two pipes fill in 6 and 12 hours together. What fraction in 2 hours?

Answers: 1) 12 hours; 2) 7.2 hours; 3) 3 hours; 4) 9.5 hours; 5) 1/2.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Harder pattern Alternate working is a common trap.
  • Reasoning It builds cycle-based thinking.
  • Link Prepares for Work Completed in a Fractional/Part Day Problems.
  • Frequency Together-with-outlet questions are very common.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Man-Days-Hours Work Equivalence Problems, which links men, days and hours in one equation.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Alternate working Pipes take turns
  • Cycle One round of all the pipes
  • Net rate Sum of inlet and outlet rates
  • Remainder Work left after full cycles
  • Starting pipe The pipe that opens first
  • Outlet Draining pipe

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Together: add rates; outlets are negative.
  • Alternate: work cycle by cycle.
  • The last partial hour may be a fraction.
  • Order of starting matters.
  • Net rate must be positive to fill.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Together vs alternate Alternate pipes work one at a time.
  • Cycle vs total A cycle is one round.
  • Inlet vs outlet Outlets subtract.
  • Full hour vs part hour The last pipe may work a fraction.

Memory Hook

Do the cycle, then finish the leftover at the right pipe’s rate.

GS Relevance

Alternate-pipe and outlet questions form the harder end of pipes and cisterns in SSC CGL and CAT.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you solve alternate pipe problems?

Alternate pipe problems are solved cycle by cycle. Find the work done in one full cycle of all pipes, count how many full cycles are needed, and then use the rate of the next pipe to finish the remaining fraction. The time is the cycle count multiplied by cycle length plus the partial time.

How do you find the filling time with an outlet?

The filling time with an outlet is the reciprocal of the net rate, found by adding the inlet rates and subtracting the outlet rate. For inlets of 6 and 12 hours with an outlet of 9 hours, the net rate is 5/36, so the tank fills in 7.2 hours.

Does the starting pipe matter in alternate working?

The starting pipe matters in alternate working when the tank does not fill at the end of a complete cycle. A faster pipe working in the final partial hour can complete the tank sooner, so the same pair of pipes can give different filling times depending on which opens first.

How do you handle the last partial hour?

The last partial hour is handled by finding the remaining fraction and dividing it by the rate of the pipe that is working. For a remaining 1/24 and a pipe with rate 1/12 per hour, the pipe needs half an hour, so the total time includes that fraction.

What if the net rate is zero or negative?

If the net rate is zero or negative, the tank never fills. The outlet drains water as fast as the inlets supply it or faster, so the water level stays constant or falls. A filling time exists only when the sum of inlet rates exceeds the outlet rate.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 In alternate working, the same two pipes always take the same time whichever opens first.
False

The last partial hour can change the total.

2 Pipes filling in 6, 12 and with an outlet emptying in 9 hours fill a tank in 7.2 hours.
True

1/6 + 1/12 - 1/9 = 5/36.

3 A and B filling in 10 and 15 hours, working alternately from A, fill the tank in 12 hours.
True

Six 2-hour cycles each add 1/6.

4 When the outlet rate exceeds the inlet rate, the tank fills at the net rate.
False

The net rate is negative, so it empties.

Share: