Puzzles Requiring Elimination Method with Partial/Conditional Clues
Reasoning › Puzzles – Floor-Based, Box-Based and Scheduling · Topic 16.5
Puzzles requiring the elimination method use partial and conditional clues, such as if A visits on Monday then B visits on Tuesday, or either B or D visits on Tuesday. A conditional clue "if X then Y" is false only when X is true and Y is false. Use it forwards (X true gives Y) and backwards (Y false gives X false), and test each possible case against all clues.
8 min read · Reasoning · Puzzles – Floor-Based, Box-Based and Scheduling
Quick Answer
Puzzles requiring the elimination method use partial and conditional clues, such as if A visits on Monday then B visits on Tuesday, or either B or D visits on Tuesday. A conditional clue “if X then Y” is false only when X is true and Y is false. Use it forwards (X true gives Y) and backwards (Y false gives X false), and test each possible case against all clues.
At a Glance
- If X then Y X true forces Y true
- Contrapositive Y false forces X false
- Either P or Q At least one is true; exclusive only if stated
- Method Test each possible case against all clues
- Stopping rule One case left means the answer
- Danger Treating if X then Y as if Y then X
Where Does It Fit?
This topic continues Puzzles Involving Multiple Variables (Person, Place, Profession, Preference) Simultaneously with clues that do not place a person directly. It uses the case testing of Seating Arrangement with Incomplete/Partial Information Requiring Deduction and prepares the mixed puzzles in Puzzles Combining Circular Seating with Floor-Based Assignment and Puzzles Combining Blood Relations with Scheduling Constraints.
How Do Conditional Clues Work?
In short: a clue of the form “if X then Y” forces Y when X is true and rules out X when Y is false, but says nothing when X is false.
| Clue form | If you know | You can conclude |
|---|---|---|
| If X then Y | X is true | Y is true |
| If X then Y | Y is false | X is false (the contrapositive) |
| If X then Y | X is false | Nothing about Y |
| If X then Y | Y is true | Nothing about X |
| Either X or Y | X is false | Y is true |
| Not both X and Y | X is true | Y is false |
Partial clues give only part of a placement, and the two main kinds are the if then form and the either or form. The common mistake is to read “if X then Y” as “if Y then X”. If a match is cancelled whenever it rains, a cancelled match does not prove rain, but a match played proves no rain. The same reasoning applies to days, floors and cities.
- Either-or: unless the clue says “but not both”, the usual convention is that at least one is true.
- Exclusive either-or: if the puzzle says exactly one, then exactly one is true.
- Unless: “X unless Y” means if Y is false then X is true.
How Do You Eliminate Cases Step by Step?
In short: list the possible placements for the most restricted person, test each against the clues, and keep only the case that survives.
- Place direct clues and write the open slots for everyone else.
- Choose the most restricted person, the one with the fewest options.
- Test each option against the unconditional clues first.
- Apply conditional clues, forwards and backwards.
- Discard any option that breaks a clue.
- If more than one case survives, use the remaining clues to choose.
Case testing rules
- A case is dead as soon as one clue fails.
- If one case is left, it is the answer.
- If two cases remain, the question has an answer only if both agree.
The “answer only if all cases agree” rule was met in Seating Arrangement with Incomplete/Partial Information Requiring Deduction.
How Do You Handle Either-Or Clues?
In short: an either-or clue splits the puzzle into two cases, and you follow each case until one of them breaks a clue.
- Split: “either B or D visits on Tuesday” gives case one with B on Tuesday and case two with D on Tuesday.
- Follow: apply every other clue in each case.
- Prune: a case with a contradiction is removed.
- Merge: if both cases survive, check if the answer agrees.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Five persons A to E visit a clinic on five days, Monday to Friday, one each. A visits before B. If C visits on Wednesday, then D visits on Friday. E does not visit on Monday or Friday. Either B or D visits on Tuesday. C visits after A. If A does not visit on Monday, then B does not visit on Tuesday. D visits after E. C visits after D. Who visits on Wednesday?
- C visits after D and D visits after E, so the order contains E, D, C. A visits before B and before C.
- Suppose C visits on Wednesday. Then D visits on Friday, but C visits after D, which is impossible. So C is not on Wednesday.
- C is after A, E and D, so C is on Thursday or Friday. If C were on Thursday, B would be on Friday, and then D would have to be on Tuesday, which puts E on Monday and breaks a clue. So C is on Friday.
- Either B or D is on Tuesday. If D were on Tuesday, E would be on Monday, which is not allowed. So B is on Tuesday.
- B on Tuesday and A before B means A is on Monday. The remaining days Wednesday and Thursday go to E and D, with E before D.
Answer: E visits on Wednesday. The days are A, B, E, D, C.
Example 2
Question: Four persons P, Q, R and S visit on Monday to Thursday, one each. P visits before Q. R visits before Q. If R does not visit on Monday, then S visits on Monday. S visits after R. S does not visit on Thursday. P does not visit on Tuesday. Q visits on Thursday. Who visits on Wednesday?
- Suppose R is not on Monday. Then S is on Monday, but S visits after R, which is impossible. So R is on Monday.
- Q is on Thursday. P and S take Tuesday and Wednesday. P is not on Tuesday, so P is on Wednesday and S is on Tuesday.
Answer: P visits on Wednesday. The days are R, S, P, Q.
Example 3
Question: If C visits on Wednesday then D visits on Friday. D visits on Thursday. Does C visit on Wednesday?
- D is not on Friday, so the conclusion of the condition is false.
- By the contrapositive, C is not on Wednesday.
Answer: No, C does not visit on Wednesday.
Example 4
Question: If P is in March, then Q is in May. Q is in April. Can P be in March?
- Q is not in May, so the conclusion is false.
- So the condition cannot hold: P is not in March.
Answer: No, P cannot be in March.
Example 5
Question: Either X or Y visits on Friday, and X visits on Thursday. Who visits on Friday?
- X is on Thursday, so X is not on Friday.
- The either-or clue then forces Y.
Answer: Y visits on Friday.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Use the contrapositive: when the result is false, the condition is false.
- Never convert if X then Y into if Y then X.
- Start from the most restricted person and test cases.
- An either-or clue splits the puzzle into two cases to follow.
- Stop as soon as one case survives and verify it.
Common Mistakes
- Reading if X then Y as if Y then X.
- Concluding something when the condition is false.
- Forgetting to check the case against unconditional clues first.
- Treating either-or as exactly one when the clue does not say so.
- Stopping at the first case that seems to fit without testing the rest.
Practice Questions
- If it rains, the match is cancelled. The match was played. Did it rain?
- If A visits on Monday, then B visits on Tuesday. B visits on Wednesday. On which day does A not visit?
- Either X or Y visits on Friday, and X visits on Thursday. Who visits on Friday?
- If P is before Q, then R is before S. S is before R. Is P before Q?
- Three persons A, B and C visit on Monday to Wednesday. A visits before B. If A visits on Tuesday, then C visits on Wednesday. C does not visit on Tuesday. Who visits on Monday?
Answers: 1) No; 2) Monday; 3) Y; 4) No; 5) A.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Logical rigour It trains correct use of if-then statements, the core of reasoning.
- Exam frequency Conditional clues appear in almost every difficult puzzle.
- Link The same logic is used in Statement and Conclusion – Determining Logically Valid Conclusions.
- Speed Contrapositive thinking removes cases in one step.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Puzzles Combining Circular Seating with Floor-Based Assignment. It joins a circular seating arrangement with a floor assignment for the same persons.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Conditional An if-then statement
- Contrapositive If not Y then not X
- Either-or At least one of two holds
- Case One possible placement
- Pruning Removing cases that fail
- Converse If Y then X, which is not implied
Related Topics
- Puzzles Involving Multiple Variables (Person, Place, Profession, Preference) Simultaneously
- Puzzles Combining Circular Seating with Floor-Based Assignment
- Floor-Based Puzzles (People/Items Assigned to Different Floors of a Building)
- Box-Based Puzzles (Boxes Arranged in Stacks with Given Attributes)
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- If X then Y: X true gives Y true; Y false gives X false.
- A false condition gives no information.
- Either-or means at least one, unless stated otherwise.
- Test cases from the most restricted person.
- One surviving case is the answer.
Do Not Confuse With
- If X then Y vs if Y then X They are different statements.
- Contrapositive vs converse The contrapositive is valid; the converse is not.
- Either-or vs exactly one Exactly one excludes both.
- Unconditional vs conditional clue Unconditional clues hold in every case.
Memory Hook
Y false means X false; split either-or into cases and kill the cases that break a clue.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you solve puzzles using the elimination method?
List the possible placements for the most restricted person, then test each against the unconditional clues first and the conditional clues next, using both the forward and the contrapositive reading. Discard any case that breaks a clue. When one case survives it is the answer, so verify it against every clue.
What does a conditional clue if X then Y tell you?
It tells you that when X is true, Y must be true, and when Y is false, X must be false. It tells you nothing when X is false or when Y is true. Confusing it with its converse, if Y then X, is the most common error with such clues.
What is the contrapositive in reasoning puzzles?
The contrapositive of if X then Y is if not Y then not X, and it is always valid when the original is. If the clue says that C on Wednesday forces D on Friday, then D not on Friday means C is not on Wednesday. It lets you eliminate cases quickly.
How do you handle either-or clues in puzzles?
Treat an either-or clue as splitting the puzzle into two cases, one for each alternative. Follow each case through the other clues, and discard the case that breaks a clue. Unless the clue says exactly one or not both, assume that at least one alternative is true.
Why is the converse of a conditional clue not valid?
Because the condition may be only one of several ways to reach the result. If a match is cancelled whenever it rains, the match may also be cancelled for other reasons, so a cancelled match does not prove that it rained. Only the contrapositive can be used.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 If X then Y, and Y is false, then X is false.
This is the contrapositive of the conditional.
2 If X then Y, and Y is true, then X must be true.
Y may be true for other reasons; this is the converse.
3 An either-or clue always means exactly one of the two.
It normally means at least one unless stated as exactly one.
4 When one case survives all clues, it is the answer.
All other cases have failed.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index