An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 16.2

Box-Based Puzzles (Boxes Arranged in Stacks with Given Attributes)

Reasoning › Puzzles – Floor-Based, Box-Based and Scheduling · Topic 16.2

In a box-based puzzle, boxes are stacked one above another and each box has attributes such as a letter, colour or content. Number the positions from the bottom, place boxes with clues such as immediately above, top, bottom and number of boxes between, and link colours or contents through shared boxes. Position from top plus position from bottom equals total boxes plus one.

Share:
Box-Based Puzzles (Boxes Arranged in Stacks with Given Attributes) - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

In a box-based puzzle, boxes are stacked one above another and each box has attributes such as a letter, colour or content. Number the positions from the bottom, place boxes with clues such as immediately above, top, bottom and number of boxes between, and link colours or contents through shared boxes. Position from top plus position from bottom equals total boxes plus one.

At a Glance

  • Setup Boxes stacked vertically
  • Numbering Position 1 is the bottom box
  • Total From top + from bottom = total + 1
  • Boxes between Position difference minus 1
  • Attributes Colour, content, label
  • Method Stack diagram plus a small grid

Where Does It Fit?

A stack is a floor puzzle in which the floors are boxes, as in Floor-Based Puzzles (People/Items Assigned to Different Floors of a Building). This topic adds colours and contents to the boxes, and Box-Based Puzzles Involving Comparison of Weight or Size adds weight and size comparisons.

How Do You Read a Stack of Boxes?

In short: a stack is a vertical list read from the bottom, so number the boxes upward and treat “above” as a higher number.

Phrase Meaning Example, stack of 7, box K at position 3
Immediately above K Position + 1 Position 4
Immediately below K Position – 1 Position 2
Topmost box Position n Position 7
Bottom box Position 1 Position 1
Boxes above K n – position 4
Boxes below K position – 1 2

If a box is 4th from the bottom and 5th from the top, the stack holds 4 + 5 – 1 = 8 boxes. The same formula applies to rows and ranks, as in Finding Total Number of People Given Relative Ranks.

How Do You Solve a Box Puzzle With Colours Step by Step?

In short: build the stack of box labels first, then attach colours or contents by following the shared boxes.

  1. Draw a column with the bottom at the foot.
  2. Place top and bottom clues for labels, then colours.
  3. Join blocks from immediately above and below clues.
  4. Link colours through clues that name both a colour and a position or label.
  5. Eliminate for the last colour.
  6. Verify every clue.

Working rules

  • Position from the top = total + 1 – position from the bottom.
  • Boxes between = |difference of positions| – 1.
  • A colour used once goes to exactly one box.

What Do Box Puzzles Test That Floor Puzzles Do Not?

In short: they test attribute linking: the same box is described by a label in one clue and by a colour in another.

  • Two descriptions: “the green box is at the bottom” and “R is at the bottom” together give R green.
  • Chains: a colour clue about a box above another box moves colour information into the label stack.
  • Removal clues: some questions remove boxes from the top, which changes positions from the top but not from the bottom.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Five boxes P, Q, R, S and T are stacked one above another. The colours are red, blue, green, yellow and white, each used once. R is at the bottom. Q is at the top. S is immediately above P. T is immediately below P. The green box is at the bottom. The white box is immediately above the green box. Box P is red. The yellow box is 4th from the bottom. What colour is the top box?

  1. R is at position 1 and Q is at position 5.
  2. T, P, S form a block T below P below S. It must fit in positions 2 to 4, so T is at 2, P at 3 and S at 4.
  3. The green box is at the bottom, so R is green. The white box is immediately above, so T is white.
  4. P is red. The yellow box is at position 4, so S is yellow. The remaining colour, blue, belongs to Q.

Answer: The top box Q is blue. From the bottom the stack is R, T, P, S, Q.

Example 2

Question: A box is 4th from the bottom and 5th from the top in a stack. How many boxes are in the stack?

  1. Total = position from bottom + position from top – 1.
  2. 4 + 5 – 1 = 8.

Answer: The stack has 8 boxes.

Example 3

Question: X is 2nd from the top in a stack. Three boxes lie between X and Y, and Y is below X. What is Y’s position from the top?

  1. The positions from the top are 2 for X, then 3 boxes between at 3, 4 and 5.
  2. Y is next, at position 6.

Answer: Y is 6th from the top.

Example 4

Question: In a stack of 7 boxes, box K is 3rd from the bottom. How many boxes are above K?

  1. Boxes above = total – position.
  2. 7 – 3 = 4.

Answer: 4 boxes are above K.

Example 5

Question: In the first example, which box is directly below the red box and what is its colour?

  1. The red box is P at position 3.
  2. The box immediately below is T at position 2, which is white.

Answer: T, a white box, is directly below the red box.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Number positions from the bottom and write it beside the column.
  • Use top + bottom = total + 1 to convert counts.
  • Join colour clues to labels through the box they share.
  • The last colour is usually fixed by elimination.
  • Redraw the column after each removal clue.

Common Mistakes

  • Counting from the top when a clue says from the bottom.
  • Forgetting the minus 1 in boxes between.
  • Treating above as immediately above.
  • Assigning one colour to two boxes.
  • Not redrawing the stack after boxes are removed.

Practice Questions

  1. A box is 4th from the bottom and 5th from the top in a stack. How many boxes are there?
  2. In a stack of 9, a box is 6th from the top. What is its position from the bottom?
  3. Boxes A, B and C are stacked. A is not at the top, B is above A and C is at the bottom. Which box is at the top?
  4. In a stack of 10 boxes, how many boxes are above the box in 7th position from the bottom?
  5. Three boxes are stacked. The green box is at the bottom, the blue box is immediately below the red box and the red box is not at the bottom. What colour is on top?

Answers: 1) 8; 2) 4th; 3) B; 4) 3; 5) red.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Attribute linking It trains you to join two descriptions of the same object.
  • Exam frequency Stacks of 5 to 8 boxes appear regularly in bank mains.
  • Reuse The method extends to weight comparisons in Box-Based Puzzles Involving Comparison of Weight or Size.
  • Accuracy A column diagram prevents direction errors.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Scheduling Puzzles (Days of the Week/Months Assigned to People or Events). It assigns days or months to people instead of floors to persons.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Stack Boxes placed one above another
  • Topmost box The highest box
  • Bottom box Position 1
  • Boxes between Difference of positions minus 1
  • Attribute A colour, label or content
  • Block Boxes in a fixed order

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Position 1 is the bottom.
  • From top + from bottom = total + 1.
  • Boxes between = difference – 1.
  • Link colours through shared boxes.
  • Each colour is used once.

Do Not Confuse With

  • From top vs from bottom They add up to total plus one.
  • Above vs immediately above Above is any higher box.
  • Label vs colour They describe the same box in different clues.
  • Between vs adjacent Between needs at least one box in the middle.

Memory Hook

Count from the bottom, join colours to labels, and use total plus one.

GS Relevance

Box and stack puzzles appear in IBPS PO, SBI PO and SSC reasoning papers as a vertical arrangement with colour or content attributes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you solve box-based puzzles in reasoning?

Draw a column with the bottom box at the foot and number positions upward. Place top and bottom clues, join immediately above and below clues into blocks, fit the blocks into the remaining positions, then link colours or contents through the boxes they share. Use elimination for the last attribute and check all clues.

How do you find the total number of boxes in a stack?

Add the position of a box from the bottom to its position from the top and subtract one. A box that is 4th from the bottom and 5th from the top gives 4 plus 5 minus 1, so the stack holds 8 boxes. This works for any box in the stack.

How do you count boxes between two boxes?

Find each box's position counted from the same end, subtract the smaller from the larger, and subtract one more. If one box is 3rd from the top and another is 8th from the top, then 8 minus 3 minus 1 gives 4 boxes between them.

How do you link colour clues to labelled boxes?

Find a box that appears in both kinds of clue. If a clue says the green box is at the bottom and another says box R is at the bottom, then R is green. Chains of such links assign every colour, and the last colour goes to the remaining box.

What changes when boxes are removed from a stack?

Positions counted from the bottom stay the same for the boxes that remain, unless boxes below are removed, while positions from the top change. Redraw the stack after each removal and recount from the end that the question uses.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 A box that is 4th from the bottom and 5th from the top is in a stack of 8.
True

4 + 5 - 1 = 8.

2 In a stack of 9, the box 6th from the top is 4th from the bottom.
True

9 + 1 - 6 = 4.

3 Above and immediately above mean the same in stack puzzles.
False

Above allows boxes in between.

4 Two boxes can have the same colour in a puzzle that says each colour is used once.
False

Each colour belongs to one box.

Share: