Box-Based Puzzles Involving Comparison of Weight or Size
Reasoning › Puzzles – Floor-Based, Box-Based and Scheduling · Topic 16.7
Box puzzles involving comparison of weight or size give clues such as P is heavier than Q or R is lighter than only one box. Convert each clue into an inequality, chain the inequalities into one order from lightest to heaviest, and use counting clues: heavier than exactly k boxes means rank k + 1 from the lightest. Numeric clues are solved by adding and subtracting weights.
7 min read · Reasoning · Puzzles – Floor-Based, Box-Based and Scheduling
Quick Answer
Box puzzles involving comparison of weight or size give clues such as P is heavier than Q or R is lighter than only one box. Convert each clue into an inequality, chain the inequalities into one order from lightest to heaviest, and use counting clues: heavier than exactly k boxes means rank k + 1 from the lightest. Numeric clues are solved by adding and subtracting weights.
At a Glance
- Clue form X heavier than Y, X lighter than Y
- Method Chain inequalities into one order
- Counting clue Heavier than exactly k boxes gives rank k + 1 from the lightest
- Rank sum From heaviest + from lightest = total + 1
- Numeric clues Use addition and subtraction
- Check Every clue holds in the final order
Where Does It Fit?
This topic is the comparison form of the stacks in Box-Based Puzzles (Boxes Arranged in Stacks with Given Attributes), and it uses ordering ideas from Ranking Based on Height, Weight, Age, Marks or Performance. The next topic, Puzzles Combining Blood Relations with Scheduling Constraints, mixes relations with scheduling.
How Do You Chain Weight Comparisons?
In short: write each clue as an inequality using greater-than signs, join inequalities that share a box, and read off the order.
| Clue | Inequality |
|---|---|
| R is heavier than P | R > P |
| Q is lighter than P but heavier than S | P > Q > S |
| T is not the heaviest | Some box > T |
| X is heavier than only Y | X > Y and every other box > X |
| W is the second lightest | Exactly one box < W |
Joining R > P with P > Q > S gives R > P > Q > S, which is the start of the order of weights. A box that has not been compared yet, such as T, is placed using its counting clue. When a clue says “T is heavier than exactly one box”, exactly one box is lighter than T, so T is second from the lightest end.
- Transitivity: if A > B and B > C then A > C.
- No information: A > B and A > C do not order B and C.
- Size clues: bigger and smaller work exactly like heavier and lighter.
How Do Counting Clues and Ranks Work?
In short: a clue saying a box is heavier than exactly k boxes puts it at rank k + 1 from the lightest, and ranks from both ends add up to the total plus one.
Rank rules
- Heavier than exactly k boxes: rank k + 1 from the lightest.
- Lighter than exactly k boxes: rank k + 1 from the heaviest.
- Rank from heaviest + rank from lightest = total + 1.
- Boxes heavier than a box of rank r from the heaviest = r – 1.
The rank arithmetic is the same as in Ranking from the Top and Bottom in a List/Row. For 5 boxes, a box of rank 2 from the lightest is rank 4 from the heaviest.
How Do You Solve Numeric Weight Clues?
In short: fix one weight, then express every other weight by adding or subtracting the stated difference.
- Pick a known weight and write it down.
- Add or subtract for clues like “2 kg more than” or “4 kg less than”.
- Use ratio clues such as “twice as heavy” as multiplication.
- Sort the final weights to read the order.
Numeric clues remove all doubt about order, so the order check is a simple sort.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Five boxes P, Q, R, S and T have different weights. R is heavier than P. Q is lighter than P but heavier than S. T is heavier than exactly one box. Which box is the heaviest, and which is the middle one?
- R > P and P > Q > S give R > P > Q > S.
- T is heavier than exactly one box, so exactly one box is lighter than T. That box must be S, the lightest of the chain.
- So T is second from the lightest, giving S < T < Q < P < R.
Answer: R is the heaviest and Q is the middle box. The order from lightest is S, T, Q, P, R.
Example 2
Question: Box B weighs 10 kg. Box A is 2 kg heavier than B. Box C is 3 kg heavier than B. Box D is 4 kg lighter than A. Box E is 1 kg heavier than D. Which is the second heaviest box, and what is the weight difference between the heaviest and the lightest?
- A = 10 + 2 = 12 kg and C = 10 + 3 = 13 kg.
- D = 12 – 4 = 8 kg and E = 8 + 1 = 9 kg.
- The order from lightest is D 8, E 9, B 10, A 12, C 13.
- The difference between the heaviest and the lightest is 13 – 8.
Answer: A is the second heaviest, and the difference is 5 kg.
Example 3
Question: In the first example, how many boxes are heavier than T?
- The order from lightest is S, T, Q, P, R.
- Boxes after T are Q, P and R.
Answer: Three boxes are heavier than T.
Example 4
Question: A box is heavier than 3 of 6 boxes. What is its rank from the heaviest?
- Heavier than 3 boxes means rank 4 from the lightest.
- Rank from the heaviest = 6 + 1 – 4.
Answer: It is 3rd from the heaviest.
Example 5
Question: P weighs twice Q, Q weighs 6 kg, and R is 4 kg lighter than P. What does R weigh?
- P = 2 x 6 = 12 kg.
- R = 12 – 4.
Answer: R weighs 8 kg.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Write each clue as an inequality with the heavier box on the left.
- Chain inequalities that share a box before using counting clues.
- Use counting clues to place the box that has not been compared.
- Convert ranks with total + 1 minus the rank.
- For numeric clues, fix one weight and move outward.
Common Mistakes
- Assuming A > B and A > C order B and C.
- Mixing up lighter and heavier when writing the inequality.
- Reading heavier than exactly k boxes as rank k from the lightest instead of k + 1.
- Forgetting to sort numeric weights before answering.
- Not checking every clue on the final order.
Practice Questions
- P is heavier than Q and Q is heavier than R. Which box is the lightest?
- A box is heavier than 3 of 5 boxes. What is its rank from the heaviest?
- A weighs twice B, B weighs 6 kg and C is 4 kg lighter than A. What does C weigh?
- W is the third heaviest of 7 boxes. How many boxes are lighter than W?
- A is heavier than B, B is heavier than C, D is lighter than C and E is heavier than A. Which box is the heaviest?
Answers: 1) R; 2) 2nd; 3) 8 kg; 4) 4; 5) E.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Exam frequency Comparison puzzles appear in reasoning papers as a quick set of 5 to 7 items.
- Skill They train chaining of inequalities.
- Link The chaining skill is used in inequality reasoning in Direct Inequality Problems (Combining Given Relations to Draw a Conclusion).
- Speed A clean order line solves the set in a few minutes.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Puzzles Combining Blood Relations with Scheduling Constraints. It combines family relations with scheduling constraints.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Inequality chain A line such as R > P > Q > S
- Transitivity If A > B and B > C then A > C
- Rank Position in the order
- Counting clue Heavier than exactly k boxes
- Numeric clue A weight stated in units
- Heaviest The top of the order
Related Topics
- Puzzles Combining Circular Seating with Floor-Based Assignment
- Puzzles Combining Blood Relations with Scheduling Constraints
- Floor-Based Puzzles (People/Items Assigned to Different Floors of a Building)
- Box-Based Puzzles (Boxes Arranged in Stacks with Given Attributes)
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Chain inequalities through shared boxes.
- Heavier than exactly k boxes gives rank k + 1 from the lightest.
- From heaviest + from lightest = total + 1.
- Two comparisons with a common larger box do not order the smaller ones.
- Sort numeric weights.
Do Not Confuse With
- Heavier than vs heavier than only The word only gives a counting clue.
- Rank from heaviest vs lightest They add up to total plus one.
- Chain vs tie A chain orders boxes; equal weights need an explicit statement.
- Heavier vs larger Size and weight are separate attributes unless stated.
Memory Hook
Chain the greater-thans, place the box with the counting clue, then check.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you solve weight comparison box puzzles?
Write each clue as an inequality with the heavier box on the left, chain inequalities that share a box into one order, place any box without a direct comparison using its counting clue, such as heavier than exactly one box, and check every clue against the final order from lightest to heaviest.
What does heavier than exactly one box mean?
It means exactly one box is lighter than this box, so the box is second from the lightest end. In general, heavier than exactly k boxes puts it at rank k plus 1 counted from the lightest, and the number of boxes heavier than it is the total minus k minus 1.
How do you convert rank from the heaviest to rank from the lightest?
Add one to the total number of boxes and subtract the rank. In a set of seven boxes, the third heaviest is the fifth from the lightest, because 7 plus 1 minus 3 equals 5. The same rule works for height, age and marks.
Can two comparisons with the same heavier box order the lighter boxes?
No. If A is heavier than B and A is heavier than C, nothing is known about B and C. Another clue is needed to compare them, either a direct one or a chain through other boxes. Assuming an order here is a common mistake.
How are numeric weight clues solved?
Fix one stated weight and compute the others by adding or subtracting the stated differences, using multiplication for twice-as-heavy clues. Once every box has a weight, sort the numbers to find the heaviest, lightest and any ranks. No inequality chain is needed.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 If A is heavier than B and A is heavier than C, then B is heavier than C.
Nothing is known about B and C.
2 A box heavier than exactly 2 of 6 boxes is third from the lightest.
Rank = 2 + 1 = 3 from the lightest.
3 In 7 boxes, the third heaviest is fifth from the lightest.
7 + 1 - 3 = 5.
4 If A > B and B > C, then A > C.
Weight comparison is transitive.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index