An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 16.4

Puzzles Involving Multiple Variables (Person, Place, Profession, Preference) Simultaneously

Reasoning › Puzzles – Floor-Based, Box-Based and Scheduling · Topic 16.4

Puzzles with multiple variables assign several attributes to each person at once, such as city, profession and preference. Build a matching grid with one row per person and one column per variable, fill direct clues, rule out impossible cells with negative clues, and use one-to-one elimination: each value belongs to exactly one person, so when one cell is fixed the rest of its row and column close.

Share:
Puzzles Involving Multiple Variables (Person, Place, Profession, Preference) Simultaneously - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Puzzles with multiple variables assign several attributes to each person at once, such as city, profession and preference. Build a matching grid with one row per person and one column per variable, fill direct clues, rule out impossible cells with negative clues, and use one-to-one elimination: each value belongs to exactly one person, so when one cell is fixed the rest of its row and column close.

At a Glance

  • Setup Several attributes for each of n persons
  • Tool A matching grid
  • One-to-one rule Each value belongs to exactly one person
  • Direct clue Fills a cell and closes its row and column
  • Negative clue Crosses out a cell
  • Finish The last cell in a row or column is forced

Where Does It Fit?

This topic generalises the attribute work of Double Row Arrangement Combined with Additional Attributes (Profession, Colour, etc.) and Seating Arrangement Combined with Additional Puzzle Variables (Age, Profession, City) by removing seats entirely. It leads into Puzzles Requiring Elimination Method with Partial/Conditional Clues, where clues are partial or conditional.

How Do You Build a Matching Grid?

In short: draw a table with the persons as rows and each variable’s values as columns, mark a tick for a confirmed match and a cross for an impossible one.

Person City Profession Drink
P Jaipur Doctor Tea
Q Delhi Pilot Milk
R Pune Banker Juice
S Mumbai Teacher Coffee

This finished grid is the answer to the first example below. During solving, keep a separate small grid for each pair of variables if needed, for example person against city, and city against profession. Whenever a match is confirmed, cross out the rest of its row and column.

  • Direct clue: “Q is the pilot” ticks one cell. A place variable such as city is treated like any other column.
  • Negative clue: “R does not live in Mumbai” crosses one cell.
  • Link clue: “The doctor lives in Jaipur” ties two variables together without naming a person.

How Does One-to-One Elimination Work?

In short: because each value belongs to exactly one person, confirming a match closes the rest of that row and column, and a row left with one open cell is forced.

  1. Fill direct clues that name a person and a value.
  2. Cross out the rest of that person’s row and that value’s column.
  3. Use link clues: if the doctor lives in Jaipur, any person who cannot live in Jaipur cannot be the doctor.
  4. Chain: move information between variables through shared values.
  5. Force: any row or column with one open cell is complete.
  6. Verify against every clue.

Counting check

  • n persons, v variables: the grid holds n x v matches.
  • Without clues there are n! assignments per variable, so the clues must remove all but one.
  • Every forced cell is also a ticked cell in the opposite grid.

The same idea of removing options with conditions is extended in Puzzles Requiring Elimination Method with Partial/Conditional Clues.

Which Clues Should You Use First?

In short: use clues that name a person directly, then clues that tie two values together, and use negative clues last.

  • Direct clues give certain cells.
  • Link clues let you move between variables, so use them after one side is fixed.
  • Negative clues are the best finishers.
  • Counting clues such as “only one person drinks tea” confirm uniqueness.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Four persons P, Q, R and S live in four cities (Delhi, Mumbai, Pune, Jaipur), have four professions (doctor, teacher, pilot, banker) and prefer four drinks (tea, coffee, juice, milk), each used once. The doctor lives in Jaipur. The teacher lives in Mumbai. Q is the pilot and lives in Delhi. R does not live in Mumbai. The pilot drinks milk. The banker drinks juice. P drinks tea. The doctor drinks tea. What does S drink, and where does S live?

  1. Q is the pilot in Delhi and drinks milk.
  2. The doctor drinks tea and P drinks tea, so P is the doctor and lives in Jaipur.
  3. R and S remain, with the cities Mumbai and Pune. R does not live in Mumbai, so R lives in Pune and S lives in Mumbai.
  4. The teacher lives in Mumbai, so S is the teacher. R is then the banker, who drinks juice.
  5. The remaining drink, coffee, belongs to S.

Answer: S drinks coffee and lives in Mumbai.

Example 2

Question: Three persons A, B and C live in Delhi, Pune and Goa, and are a doctor, a teacher and a pilot, in some order. A does not live in Goa. The teacher lives in Pune. B is the pilot. C does not live in Delhi. The doctor lives in Delhi. Where does B live?

  1. B is the pilot, so the doctor and teacher are A and C.
  2. The doctor lives in Delhi and C does not live in Delhi, so A is the doctor in Delhi.
  3. C is the teacher and lives in Pune. B lives in the remaining city.

Answer: B lives in Goa.

Example 3

Question: In the first example, who is the banker and what does that person drink?

  1. P is the doctor, Q is the pilot and S is the teacher.
  2. R is the banker and drinks juice.

Answer: R is the banker and drinks juice.

Example 4

Question: If four persons are to be matched with four cities with no clues, how many assignments are possible, and how many remain after one person is fixed to one city?

  1. Without clues: 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 = 24.
  2. After one person is fixed: 3 x 2 x 1 = 6.

Answer: 24 assignments without clues, and 6 after one is fixed.

Example 5

Question: In a puzzle with 5 persons and 3 variables, how many matches must be found to complete the grid?

  1. Each variable has one match per person.
  2. 5 x 3 = 15.

Answer: 15 matches.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Draw the grid first. Do not hold more than two facts in your head.
  • Cross out the whole row and column after each confirmed match.
  • Use link clues to move a fact from one variable to another.
  • A person with one open cell left is forced.
  • Finish with the negative clues to settle the last pair.

Common Mistakes

  • Not crossing out the rest of the row after a match.
  • Using a link clue on a value that has not yet been assigned.
  • Assuming two persons can share a city or profession.
  • Reading “does not” as “is”.
  • Skipping the final check of all clues.

Practice Questions

  1. A, B and C live in Delhi, Pune and Goa. A lives in Delhi and B does not live in Goa. Where does C live?
  2. How many ways can 5 persons be matched with 5 cities if there are no clues?
  3. Four persons P, Q, R and S have four different professions. The pilot is not P, Q or R. Who is the pilot?
  4. A, B and C wear red, green and blue, one each. A is not red, B is not green, C is not blue and C is not red. What colour does A wear?
  5. A puzzle has 4 persons and 3 variables with 4 values each. How many cells are in the person-by-value grid for all three variables?

Answers: 1) Goa; 2) 120; 3) S; 4) blue; 5) 48.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Exam frequency Long matching puzzles carry the most marks in bank mains reasoning sets.
  • Skill It trains disciplined elimination, which supports Puzzles Requiring Elimination Method with Partial/Conditional Clues.
  • Reuse The grid is the same tool used in Seating Arrangement Combined with Additional Puzzle Variables (Age, Profession, City).
  • Accuracy A written grid removes most contradictions.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Puzzles Requiring Elimination Method with Partial/Conditional Clues. It handles puzzles whose clues are partial or conditional, so elimination must be done with care.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Matching grid A table of persons against values
  • One-to-one Each value belongs to one person
  • Link clue Ties two values without naming a person
  • Direct clue Names a person and a value
  • Negative clue Rules out a match
  • Forced cell The only open cell in a row or column

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Persons are rows; values are columns.
  • A confirmed match closes its row and column.
  • Use link clues after one side is fixed.
  • Negative clues finish the puzzle.
  • Always check every clue at the end.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Direct vs link clue Direct names a person; link ties two values.
  • Cross vs tick A cross rules out; a tick confirms.
  • Row vs column A row is a person; a column is a value.
  • Possible vs forced Forced means only one option remains.

Memory Hook

Grid it, tick it, cross out the rest, and the last cell is forced.

GS Relevance

Multi-variable matching puzzles are the longest puzzles in IBPS PO, SBI PO, SSC and CSAT reasoning, and they reward a clean grid more than speed of thought.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you solve puzzles with multiple variables?

Draw a grid with persons as rows and each variable's values as columns. Fill direct clues, cross out the rest of each row and column after a match, use link clues to move facts between variables, apply negative clues, and fill any row or column left with a single open cell. Then verify every clue.

What is one-to-one elimination in a puzzle?

Each value, such as a city, belongs to exactly one person. So once a person is matched with a value, no other person can have it and the person cannot have another value of that variable. Crossing out the rest of that row and column narrows the remaining options.

What is a link clue in a matching puzzle?

A link clue ties two values together without naming a person, such as the doctor lives in Jaipur. It is used after one of the values is fixed to a person, since then the other value goes to the same person. Without a fixed value it only narrows the options.

Which clue should be used first in a multi-variable puzzle?

Use direct clues that name a person and a value first, because they fill cells with certainty. Then use link clues, which carry facts between variables, and finish with negative clues to settle the last pair. Starting with a negative clue rarely fixes anything alone.

How can I avoid contradictions in long puzzles?

Write every confirmed match and every ruled-out cell in a grid rather than keeping them in your head, cross out rows and columns at once, and check each new match against the earlier clues. A contradiction usually means a clue was misread or a cell was crossed by mistake.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 In a one-to-one puzzle, once a person is matched to a city, no other person can have that city.
True

Each value belongs to exactly one person.

2 A negative clue always fixes a cell.
False

It only rules out a cell; fixing needs the other options to be closed too.

3 With 4 persons and 4 cities and no clues, there are 24 possible assignments.
True

4! = 24.

4 A row with only one open cell is forced.
True

The one remaining value must be the match.

Share: