Data Sufficiency Problems Requiring Combination of Both Statements
Quantitative Aptitude › Data Sufficiency · Topic 26.5
In data sufficiency, some questions can be answered only by combining both statements, because each statement supplies a different missing piece. The answer is option C when the combination fixes a unique value, and option E when even the combination leaves more than one possibility.
7 min read · Quantitative Aptitude · Data Sufficiency
Quick Answer
In data sufficiency, some questions can be answered only by combining both statements, because each statement supplies a different missing piece. The answer is option C when the combination fixes a unique value, and option E when even the combination leaves more than one possibility.
At a Glance
- When to combine Neither statement is sufficient alone
- Result C if unique, E if not
- Method Merge the information into one problem
- Check Do the statements agree
- Trap Two statements giving the same fact
- Format Two statements, five options
Where Does It Fit?
This topic follows Data Sufficiency Problems Based on Number System, Ratios and Algebra and extends the testing order of Data Sufficiency – Two-Statement Format (Statement I and Statement II). The next topic, Data Sufficiency Where Both Statements Together Are Required but Neither Alone Suffices, studies the typical patterns that need both statements, and Data Sufficiency Problems with Apparently Sufficient but Actually Insufficient Information looks at cases that only appear to work.
When Do You Combine the Statements?
In short: combine the statements only after Statement I alone and Statement II alone have both failed. Then treat the two statements as one problem and see whether a unique answer appears.
- Split inputs: one statement gives one quantity and the other gives another, as when a distance and a time are needed to find a speed.
- Merged equations: two equations with the same unknowns become a system that can be solved.
- Condition plus rule: one statement gives a condition, such as a ratio, and the other gives a total, such as the class size.
- No new information: if the second statement repeats the first, the combination is no better, and the answer is E.
Steps for combining
- Write down what each statement gives in symbols.
- Join them into one set of equations or facts.
- Check whether a unique value now exists, and that the statements do not contradict each other.
- If a unique value exists, choose C. If not, choose E.
How Do You Check That the Combination Works?
In short: count unknowns against independent facts after combining. Then verify that the facts are consistent.
- Count: two unknowns need two independent equations, as discussed in Data Sufficiency Problems Based on Number System, Ratios and Algebra.
- Independence: the equations x + 2y = 8 and 2x + 4y = 16 look different but are the same line, so they do not fix x and y.
- Consistency: in a proper question the statements never contradict each other, so you do not need to test for that.
- Conditions: check whether conditions in the question, such as integers or positive numbers, narrow the possibilities.
| Case | Statements | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Split inputs | Distance 240 km; time 4 hours | Speed = 60 km/h. Option C. |
| Merged equations | x + y = 7 and x – y = 1 | x = 4. Option C. |
| Repeated facts | x + 2y = 8 and 2x + 4y = 16 | x not fixed. Option E. |
| Condition plus total | Class of 40; girls 35% | Boys = 26. Option C. |
What Typical Questions Need Both Statements?
In short: speed, age, percentage and geometry questions often split their inputs between the two statements.
- Speed, distance, time: each statement gives one of the three quantities, as in Speed, Distance and Time Basic Relationship and Unit Conversion (km/h to m/s).
- Ages: one statement gives a difference, and the other gives an age in the future or past.
- Percentage of a total: one gives the total, and the other gives the percentage.
- Geometry: one gives a ratio of sides, and the other gives a perimeter, which together fix the sides.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: What is the speed of the car? I: The distance is 240 km. II: The time taken is 4 hours.
- Statement I alone gives distance only. Not sufficient.
- Statement II alone gives time only. Not sufficient.
- Together, speed = 240 / 4 = 60 km/h.
Answer: C.
Example 2
Question: What is Ravi’s present age? I: Ravi is 4 years older than Sita. II: Sita will be 20 years old in 5 years.
- Statement I alone gives a difference only. Not sufficient.
- Statement II alone: Sita is 15 now, but Ravi’s age is unknown. Not sufficient.
- Together, Ravi = 15 + 4 = 19.
Answer: C.
Example 3
Question: How many boys are in the class? I: The class has 40 students. II: Girls are 35% of the class.
- Each alone is not sufficient.
- Together, boys are 65% of 40 = 26.
Answer: C.
Example 4
Question: What is the length of a rectangle? I: Its perimeter is 36 cm. II: Its length is twice its breadth.
- Statement I: l + b = 18. Many pairs. Not sufficient.
- Statement II: l = 2b. Many sizes. Not sufficient.
- Together, 3b = 18, so b = 6 and l = 12.
Answer: C.
Example 5
Question: What is the price of a pen? I: 3 pens and 2 notebooks cost Rs 70. II: 6 pens and 4 notebooks cost Rs 140.
- Statement I has two unknowns and one equation. Not sufficient.
- Statement II is Statement I multiplied by 2, so it gives no new information.
- Together, there is still one independent equation.
Answer: E.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- After combining, count unknowns and independent equations once more.
- Check whether Statement II is a multiple or a restatement of Statement I.
- For split inputs, think of the formula and see which pieces are missing.
- Use conditions in the question stem to narrow the combined possibilities.
- Do not solve fully once uniqueness is clear.
Common Mistakes
- Choosing C when the two statements are the same equation.
- Using Statement II while testing Statement I alone.
- Forgetting conditions such as positive integers given in the stem.
- Solving for the final number and running out of time.
- Assuming a unique answer without counting independent facts.
Practice Questions
- What is the total cost of 3 pens and 2 books? I: One pen costs Rs 10. II: One book costs Rs 25.
- What is the cost price? I: The selling price is Rs 600. II: The profit is 20%.
- How many girls are in a class? I: The class has 50 students. II: 60% are boys.
- Is the product ab positive? I: a is greater than 0. II: b is greater than 0.
- What is the length of a train? I: It crosses a pole in 15 seconds. II: Its speed is 72 km/h.
- What is x? I: x + 2y = 8. II: 2x + 4y = 16.
Answers: 1) C (Rs 80); 2) C (Rs 500); 3) C (20); 4) C; 5) C (300 m); 6) E.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Frequency Combination questions are the most common type of sufficiency question.
- Skill They test whether you can merge information.
- Equations They use the ideas of Simultaneous Linear Equations and Their Solution Methods.
- Link Patterns are developed in Data Sufficiency Where Both Statements Together Are Required but Neither Alone Suffices.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Data Sufficiency Where Both Statements Together Are Required but Neither Alone Suffices. It describes the classic patterns where both statements are required but neither alone suffices.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Combine Use both statements as one set of facts
- Split inputs Different statements giving different inputs
- Independent equation An equation not made from another
- Redundant statement A statement that adds no new information
- Unique value Exactly one possible answer
- Consistent Not contradicting each other
Related Topics
- Data Sufficiency Problems Based on Number System, Ratios and Algebra
- Data Sufficiency Where Both Statements Together Are Required but Neither Alone Suffices
- Data Sufficiency – Two-Statement Format (Statement I and Statement II)
- Data Sufficiency Problems Based on Arithmetic Topics (Percentage, Profit-Loss, Interest)
Related Topics in Maarg Manthan
Study this topic together with these linked topics from other subjects.
- Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice (Reasoning)
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Combine only after each alone has failed.
- Count independent equations after combining.
- A repeated statement adds nothing.
- Use the conditions in the stem.
- Stop once uniqueness is clear.
Do Not Confuse With
- C vs E C means the combination suffices, and E means it does not.
- C vs D D means each statement alone is sufficient, and C means neither is.
- Independent vs repeated A multiple of an equation is not new information.
- Combine vs substitute Combining is about information, and substitution is a method of solving.
Memory Hook
Fail alone, then merge, then count.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
When do you combine the two statements in data sufficiency?
The two statements are combined only after Statement I alone and Statement II alone have each been shown not to be sufficient. Together they are treated as one problem, and if they fix a unique value the answer is option C, and if not, the answer is option E.
How do you know that the combination is sufficient?
The combination is sufficient when the number of independent facts equals the number of unknowns and the facts lead to one value. Two unknowns need two independent equations, and a repeated or multiplied equation does not count as a second one.
What happens if the second statement repeats the first?
If the second statement repeats the first in a different form, the combination adds no new information, and the answer is that even together they are not sufficient. For example, 3 pens and 2 notebooks costing Rs 70 and double that for twice the number do not fix the price.
Which questions often need both statements?
Questions that often need both statements include speed, distance and time, where each statement gives one quantity, age questions with a difference and a future age, percentage questions with a total and a share, and geometry questions with a ratio and a perimeter.
Should you solve the combined problem fully?
The combined problem should not be solved fully, because the task is only to decide whether a unique value exists. Once the independent facts equal the unknowns, the answer is sufficient, and the remaining time is better spent on other questions.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 If the second statement is a multiple of the first equation, the two together are sufficient for two unknowns.
They give the same information.
2 A distance of 240 km and a time of 4 hours together give a speed of 60 km/h.
240 / 4 = 60.
3 Combining is done before testing each statement alone.
Each statement is tested alone first.
4 When the combination fixes a unique value and neither alone does, the answer is option C.
That is the meaning of C.
Related Topics
Browse the full Quantitative Aptitude index