An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 26.6

Data Sufficiency Where Both Statements Together Are Required but Neither Alone Suffices

Quantitative Aptitude › Data Sufficiency · Topic 26.6

Some data sufficiency questions have a fixed pattern in which neither statement helps alone, but both together give one answer. The pattern is usually a split of inputs, a sum with a product, or a definition with a value, and recognising it makes the answer option C quick to confirm.

Share:
Data Sufficiency Where Both Statements Together Are Required but Neither Alone Suffices - Quantitative Aptitude - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Some data sufficiency questions have a fixed pattern in which neither statement helps alone, but both together give one answer. The pattern is usually a split of inputs, a sum with a product, or a definition with a value, and recognising it makes the answer option C quick to confirm.

At a Glance

  • Answer option C
  • Pattern 1 Split inputs
  • Pattern 2 Sum and product or difference
  • Pattern 3 Definition plus value
  • Check Each alone must fail
  • Format Two statements, five options

Where Does It Fit?

This topic follows Data Sufficiency Problems Requiring Combination of Both Statements and focuses on recognising the classic templates. It is followed by Data Sufficiency Problems with Apparently Sufficient but Actually Insufficient Information, which shows look-alike cases that fail, and Data Sufficiency Involving Geometric Figures with Unstated or Missing Measurements, which applies the ideas to figures.

What Are the Classic Patterns?

In short: option C questions repeat a small number of templates. Learning them lets you confirm the answer quickly.

Pattern Statement I Statement II Result
Split inputs Speed is 54 km/h Train crosses a pole in 12 s Length = 15 × 12 = 180 m
Sum and product x + y = 12 x × y = 35 |x – y| = 2
Sum and difference a + b = 9 a – b = 4 a squared – b squared = 36
Total and fraction Bag has 30 balls Probability of red is 2/5 Red balls = 12
Equation and value 3 apples and 2 oranges cost Rs 90 1 orange costs Rs 15 Apple = Rs 20
  • Split inputs: each statement supplies one variable of a formula.
  • Identity patterns: a + b and a – b together give a squared minus b squared, and x + y and xy together give (x – y) squared.
  • Definition plus value: a probability or percentage needs a total.

How Do You Confirm That Neither Alone Works?

In short: always test each statement alone first, even when a pattern is obvious, because a statement may be sufficient by itself.

  • Speed example: the speed alone does not give a length, and the crossing time alone does not either, so neither alone works.
  • Sum and product example: x + y = 12 alone gives many pairs, and xy = 35 alone also gives many pairs. Together, (x – y) squared = 144 – 140 = 4, so |x – y| = 2.
  • Apple example: 3A + 2O = 90 has two unknowns. O = 15 alone does not give A. Together, 3A = 90 – 30 = 60 and A = 20.

Identities used in these patterns

  • (x – y) squared = (x + y) squared – 4xy.
  • a squared – b squared = (a + b)(a – b).
  • Distance = Speed × Time. Length of a train crossing a pole = speed × time.
  • Number of favourable outcomes = Probability × Total outcomes.

The speed and time ideas come from Speed, Distance and Time Basic Relationship and Unit Conversion (km/h to m/s), and the probability idea from Probability – Classical Definition and Basic Addition/Multiplication Rules.

How Is This Different From Combined Questions in General?

In short: the earlier topic Data Sufficiency Problems Requiring Combination of Both Statements teaches the method. This topic teaches the templates, so you recognise them at once.

  • Recognition: if the two statements give different formula inputs, expect C.
  • Verification: still confirm that each alone fails, since a statement may give everything.
  • Danger: a template that looks complete may still fail if the question has an extra condition. See Data Sufficiency Problems with Apparently Sufficient but Actually Insufficient Information.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: What is |x – y|? I: x + y = 12. II: xy = 35.

  1. Statement I alone gives many pairs, so |x – y| is not fixed.
  2. Statement II alone gives many pairs, so it is not fixed.
  3. Together, (x – y) squared = 12 squared – 4 × 35 = 144 – 140 = 4.
  4. So |x – y| = 2.

Answer: C.

Example 2

Question: What is the length of a train? I: Its speed is 54 km/h. II: It crosses a pole in 12 seconds.

  1. Statement I alone gives speed only. Not sufficient.
  2. Statement II alone gives time only. Not sufficient.
  3. Together, speed = 54 × 5/18 = 15 m/s, and length = 15 × 12 = 180 m.

Answer: C.

Example 3

Question: How many red balls are in the bag? I: The bag has 30 balls. II: The probability of a red ball is 2/5.

  1. Statement I alone gives the total only.
  2. Statement II alone gives a probability only.
  3. Together, red balls = 2/5 × 30 = 12.

Answer: C.

Example 4

Question: What is the value of a squared minus b squared? I: a + b = 9. II: a – b = 4.

  1. Neither alone fixes it.
  2. Together, a squared – b squared = (a + b)(a – b) = 9 × 4 = 36.

Answer: C.

Example 5

Question: What is the price of an apple? I: 3 apples and 2 oranges cost Rs 90. II: One orange costs Rs 15.

  1. Statement I has two unknowns. Statement II gives only the orange.
  2. Together, 3 apples = 90 – 2 × 15 = 60.
  3. Apple = 60 / 3 = Rs 20.

Answer: C.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Match the question to a template: formula inputs, identity, or total and fraction.
  • For x and y, remember that sum and product fix the difference up to sign.
  • Convert km/h to m/s by multiplying by 5/18.
  • For probability questions, ask whether the total number of outcomes is given.
  • Still test each statement alone before choosing C.
  • A question needs a unique answer; if two values fit, the data are not sufficient together.

Common Mistakes

  • Choosing C without checking that each alone fails.
  • Forgetting that x + y and xy fix x – y only up to sign.
  • Using km/h with metres without converting.
  • Assuming a probability gives a count without a total.
  • Solving the full numerical answer.

Practice Questions

  1. What is the volume of a cuboid? I: Its length is 5 and breadth is 4. II: Its height is 3.
  2. What is the time taken? I: The distance is 150 km. II: The speed is 50 km/h.
  3. What is ab? I: a + b = 7. II: a squared + b squared = 25.
  4. What is m? I: m + n = 10. II: n = 4.
  5. How many girls are in the class? I: The class has 40 students. II: Girls : boys = 3 : 5.
  6. What is the simple interest earned? I: The rate is 5% per annum. II: The principal is Rs 4,000 and the time is 2 years.

Answers: 1) C (60); 2) C (3 hours); 3) C (12); 4) C (6); 5) C (15); 6) C (Rs 400).

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Speed Recognising templates saves time in the exam.
  • Reliability Templates reduce the risk of missing a split input.
  • Link They use identities from Basic Algebraic Identities (a+b, a-b, a²-b² and Related Expansions).
  • Next step Data Sufficiency Problems with Apparently Sufficient but Actually Insufficient Information shows when templates mislead.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Data Sufficiency Problems with Apparently Sufficient but Actually Insufficient Information. It shows questions that look sufficient at first but are not, which are the main source of mistakes.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Template A repeated pattern in questions
  • Split inputs Inputs divided between the statements
  • Identity An equation true for all values
  • Probability Favourable outcomes divided by total outcomes
  • Unit conversion km/h to m/s by multiplying by 5/18
  • Up to sign Fixed except for a plus or minus

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • C often means split inputs.
  • Sum and product give the difference up to sign.
  • A probability needs a total for a count.
  • Convert units before using speed.
  • Test each alone first.

Do Not Confuse With

  • C vs D D needs each alone to work.
  • Sum and product vs sum alone Sum alone gives many pairs.
  • Probability vs count A probability is a fraction, and a count is a number.
  • Speed vs length Length needs time too.

Memory Hook

Different inputs, one formula, option C.

GS Relevance

Data sufficiency pattern recognition for CAT, SSC CGL and CSAT: the classic cases in which both statements are needed and neither alone is enough.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does option C mean in data sufficiency?

Option C means that both statements together are sufficient to answer the question, but neither statement alone is sufficient. It applies when each statement supplies a different missing input, so that only the combination fixes a unique value for the quantity asked.

What are the classic patterns for option C?

The classic patterns for option C are split inputs, such as distance and time for speed, sum together with product, sum together with difference, a total with a fraction or probability, and one equation in two unknowns together with a single value of one unknown.

How do the sum and product of two numbers help?

The sum and product of two numbers together fix their difference up to sign, because the square of the difference equals the square of the sum minus four times the product. For a sum of 12 and a product of 35, the difference is 2 in absolute value.

Why should each statement be tested alone even for C patterns?

Each statement should be tested alone because a statement that looks incomplete may still give the full answer, or two statements may each be sufficient alone, which would make the answer D instead of C. Only after both fail alone should the combination be tested.

How do you find the length of a train from two statements?

The length of a train crossing a pole is its speed multiplied by the time taken, so one statement must give the speed and the other the time. A speed of 54 km per hour, which is 15 metres per second, and a crossing time of 12 seconds give 180 metres.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The sum and product of two numbers together fix their difference up to sign.
True

(x - y) squared equals (x + y) squared minus 4xy.

2 A probability of 2/5 alone gives the number of red balls.
False

The total number of balls is also needed.

3 A speed of 54 km/h equals 15 m/s.
True

54 × 5/18 = 15.

4 In option C patterns, each statement alone is sufficient.
False

Neither alone is sufficient.

Share: