An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 13.5

Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice

Reasoning › Data Sufficiency (Reasoning-Based) · Topic 13.5

To decide which statement or statements suffice in a data sufficiency question, test Statement I alone, then Statement II alone, and combine them only if neither works. The answer is one of five outcomes: I alone, II alone, either alone, both together, or neither even together. A statement suffices when it gives exactly one answer to the question; you never need to find the final value of a quantity unless the question demands it.

Share:
Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

To decide which statement or statements suffice in a data sufficiency question, test Statement I alone, then Statement II alone, and combine them only if neither works. The answer is one of five outcomes: I alone, II alone, either alone, both together, or neither even together. A statement suffices when it gives exactly one answer to the question; you never need to find the final value of a quantity unless the question demands it.

At a Glance

  • Step 1 Test Statement I alone
  • Step 2 Test Statement II alone
  • Step 3 Combine only if both failed
  • Sufficient Exactly one answer
  • Insufficient Zero, or more than one answer
  • Five outcomes A, B, C, D, E in the common key

Where Does It Fit?

This is the fifth topic of the Data Sufficiency (Reasoning-Based) macro. It states the decision method that Data Sufficiency Based on Blood Relations, Data Sufficiency Based on Ranking, Ordering or Seating Arrangement, Data Sufficiency Based on Directions and Distance and Data Sufficiency Based on Coding-Decoding apply to specific data types. The case where neither statement helps is treated in Data Sufficiency Cases Where Data in Neither Statement Is Sufficient, and the combination with arithmetic symbols appears in Data Sufficiency Combined with Mathematical Operations/Symbol-Based Coding.

What Are the Five Outcomes?

In short: every question ends in one of five outcomes, decided by how many answers each statement leaves open. The key below is the common order. Always check the key printed in your own paper.

Option Outcome What it means
A I alone suffices Statement I gives one answer; II does not
B II alone suffices Statement II gives one answer; I does not
C Either alone suffices Each statement gives the same single answer
D Both together are needed Neither alone, but together one answer
E Neither suffices Even together there is more than one possible answer

The distinction between C and D is the most common source of error. In C each statement stands alone. In D the statements need each other. Sufficient always means one definite answer, never just a probable one.

How Do You Decide Quickly and Reliably?

In short: separate the two statements mentally, solve for the answer set of each, and only then merge the information.

  1. Understand what the question asks, whether a value, a yes or no, or a relation.
  2. Take Statement I alone. Ignore Statement II completely. Does it fix one answer?
  3. Take Statement II alone. Ignore Statement I. Does it fix one answer?
  4. If both do, check they agree: choose C. If only one does, choose A or B.
  5. If neither does, combine them and test again: D if one answer results, E if not.

Decision table

  • I yes, II no: A.
  • I no, II yes: B.
  • I yes, II yes: C.
  • I no, II no, together yes: D.
  • I no, II no, together no: E.

For yes-or-no questions, a statement suffices if it gives a definite yes or a definite no. A statement that gives yes in some cases and no in others is insufficient. For value questions, it must fix a single value. The blood-relation, ranking and direction forms of the same method are in Data Sufficiency Based on Blood Relations, Data Sufficiency Based on Ranking, Ordering or Seating Arrangement and Data Sufficiency Based on Directions and Distance.

What Habits Prevent Mistakes?

In short: do not carry information from one statement into the other, do not guess, and do not over-solve.

  • Do not mix early: reading both statements together before testing each alone makes you choose D when C or A was right.
  • Do not use outside facts: use only common knowledge such as days in a week, or what the question itself gives.
  • Do not stop at a range: a statement that gives values between 5 and 9 does not fix one value.
  • Do not over-solve: you only need to know whether one answer is fixed, not to compute it in detail.
Situation Verdict
Statement gives a range, but the question asks for a value Insufficient
Statement gives two possible values Insufficient
Statement contradicts the other Check the question; data are normally consistent
Statement repeats the question Insufficient

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: What is x? I. x + 3 = 8. II. x is an integer less than 10.

  1. I alone: x = 5. One answer.
  2. II alone: x could be any integer below 10. Not one answer.

Answer: A (I alone is sufficient, II alone is not); x = 5.

Example 2

Question: What is the age of P? I. P is older than Q. II. P’s age is twice Q’s age, and Q is 10 years old.

  1. I alone: no value.
  2. II alone: Q is 10, so P is 20. One answer.

Answer: B (II alone is sufficient, I alone is not); P is 20.

Example 3

Question: What is x? I. 2x = 10. II. x + 1 = 6.

  1. I alone: x = 5.
  2. II alone: x = 5.
  3. Each gives the same single value.

Answer: C (either alone is sufficient); x = 5.

Example 4

Question: What is the age of Ram? I. Ram is 5 years older than Shyam. II. Shyam is 20 years old.

  1. I alone: Shyam’s age is not known.
  2. II alone: Ram’s age is not related to Shyam’s.
  3. Together: Ram is 20 + 5 = 25.

Answer: D (both together are needed); Ram is 25.

Example 5

Question: What is the weight of box A? I. A is heavier than B. II. B weighs 50 kg.

  1. I alone: no value.
  2. II alone: nothing about A.
  3. Together: A is heavier than 50 kg, which is a range, not one weight.

Answer: E (neither suffices, even together).

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Cover Statement II while testing I, and the reverse.
  • Use the decision table: yes, no, yes, then together.
  • A range, or two possible values, is insufficient.
  • Do not compute fully; confirm only that one answer is fixed.
  • If both alone suffice, check that they agree before choosing C.

Common Mistakes

  • Combining the statements before testing each alone.
  • Choosing D when each statement alone is enough.
  • Calling a range sufficient.
  • Using outside facts to fill gaps.
  • Confusing the key letters of the paper with a remembered key.

Practice Questions

  1. Is x positive? I. x squared is 9. II. x + 3 = 6. Key?
  2. How old is A? I. A is 3 years older than B. II. B is 12 years old. Key?
  3. What is y? I. 3y = 12. II. y squared is 16. Key?
  4. What is the price of a pen? I. The pen costs Rs 5 more than a pencil. II. The pencil costs Rs 7. Key?
  5. What is a? I. a + a = 12. II. a = 6. Key?
  6. What is the weight of the box? I. It is heavier than 5 kg. II. It is lighter than 9 kg. Key?

Answers: 1) B; 2) D; 3) A; 4) D, the pen costs Rs 12; 5) C; 6) E.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Core method Every sufficiency type uses the same alone-then-together test.
  • Key accuracy Mistakes in C and D decide many marks.
  • Exam speed Not solving fully saves time.
  • Link It underpins Data Sufficiency Cases Where Data in Neither Statement Is Sufficient and Data Sufficiency Combined with Mathematical Operations/Symbol-Based Coding.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Data Sufficiency Cases Where Data in Neither Statement Is Sufficient. It looks at questions where the data in neither statement is sufficient, even when combined.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Sufficient Gives one definite answer
  • Alone One statement used by itself
  • Together Both statements combined
  • Either Each statement alone gives the answer
  • Neither No statement or combination gives the answer
  • Range A set of values, not a single value
  • Data Sufficiency Based on Coding-Decoding
  • Data Sufficiency Cases Where Data in Neither Statement Is Sufficient
  • Data Sufficiency Based on Blood Relations
  • Data Sufficiency Based on Ranking, Ordering or Seating Arrangement

Study this topic together with these linked topics from other subjects.

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Test I alone, II alone, then together.
  • Sufficient means exactly one answer.
  • A range or two values is insufficient.
  • C means each alone; D means both needed.
  • Read the key printed in your paper.

Do Not Confuse With

  • C vs D C: each works alone. D: they work only together.
  • A vs C A needs only I. C needs both to work alone.
  • D vs E D gives one answer together; E does not.
  • Solving vs deciding You decide sufficiency; you need not compute fully.

Memory Hook

Alone, alone, together; one answer or none.

GS Relevance

The core method behind every data sufficiency question in SSC CGL, bank PO and clerk mains, CDS, CAPF and CSAT-style reasoning: reading the answer key correctly and applying alone-then-together logic.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you decide which statement is sufficient in data sufficiency?

Test Statement I alone and check whether it fixes exactly one answer. Test Statement II alone in the same way. If one works, choose that statement. If both work, choose either. If neither works, combine them and check again. If together they still leave several answers, neither suffices.

What is the difference between either alone and both together?

Either alone means each statement by itself gives the same single answer. Both together means each statement alone fails, but combined they give one answer. Test each statement alone before combining, or you may choose both together when either alone was correct.

What does sufficient mean in data sufficiency?

Sufficient means the statement or statements fix exactly one definite answer to the question. If the information allows no answer, two answers, or only a range of values, it is insufficient. For yes or no questions, it must give a definite yes or a definite no.

Should I compute the full answer in data sufficiency?

No. You only need to decide whether one answer is fixed. Computing the exact value wastes time. Check that the information leads to a single value, a single relation or a definite yes or no, and then choose the key letter.

Why does the answer key letter vary between papers?

Different exams print the five options in different orders, for example with both together listed before either alone. The meanings are the same, so always read the key printed in your paper before marking the answer, instead of relying on a remembered letter.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 A statement that gives a range of values is sufficient for a value question.
False

It does not fix one value.

2 Each statement should be tested alone before they are combined.
True

That is how alone and together are separated.

3 If each statement alone gives the same single answer, the outcome is either alone.
True

That is option C in the common key.

4 If the statements together give two possible answers, they are sufficient.
False

They must give one definite answer.

Share: