An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 26.7

Data Sufficiency Problems with Apparently Sufficient but Actually Insufficient Information

Quantitative Aptitude › Data Sufficiency · Topic 26.7

Some data sufficiency questions look as if the information is enough but actually leave more than one possible answer. These apparently sufficient cases hide a second solution, a missing weight or a freedom in the figure, and the correct option is usually E.

Share:
Data Sufficiency Problems with Apparently Sufficient but Actually Insufficient Information - Quantitative Aptitude - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Some data sufficiency questions look as if the information is enough but actually leave more than one possible answer. These apparently sufficient cases hide a second solution, a missing weight or a freedom in the figure, and the correct option is usually E.

At a Glance

  • Typical answer E
  • Method Find a counter-example
  • Trap 1 Squares and two roots
  • Trap 2 Averages without weights
  • Trap 3 Repeated facts
  • Format Two statements, five options

Where Does It Fit?

This topic follows Data Sufficiency Where Both Statements Together Are Required but Neither Alone Suffices and is the mirror image of it: the patterns there work, and the cases here only appear to. It leads into Data Sufficiency Involving Geometric Figures with Unstated or Missing Measurements, where figures with missing measurements create similar traps.

Why Do Some Statements Only Look Sufficient?

In short: a statement looks sufficient when it contains a number or a relation, but it may leave a hidden freedom. The test is to find two different cases that both satisfy the statements but give different answers.

Trap Looks like Hidden freedom
Square equation x squared = 49 x can be 7 or -7
Same side twice Side 10 and perimeter 40 for a rhombus The angle or diagonal is still free
Averages Boys average 60 and girls average 70 The number of each is unknown
Divides b divides 24 b can be 6 or 8, giving different answers
  • Counter-example method: if you can find two valid cases with different answers, the data is not sufficient.
  • Hidden second root: equations with even powers or absolute values often have two solutions.
  • Missing weight: a combined average needs the number of items in each group. See Change in Average on Addition, Removal or Replacement of a Value.

How Do You Find a Counter-Example Quickly?

In short: try the smallest and the most extreme values that satisfy the statements, and see whether the answer changes.

  • Average of a class: if boys average 60 and girls average 70, a class with 29 boys and 1 girl has an average near 60.3, while a class with 1 boy and 29 girls has an average near 69.7. The average can be anything between 60 and 70.
  • Integer division: to test if 12 divided by b is an integer, with b dividing 24 and b even, try b = 6 (gives 2) and b = 8 (gives 1.5). The answer varies.
  • Sign: to test whether x is positive when x squared is 49, try 7 and -7.
  • Contrast case: some statements that look weak are in fact sufficient together. One apple and orange question is solved in Data Sufficiency Where Both Statements Together Are Required but Neither Alone Suffices.

Warning signs

  • Even powers, absolute values and square roots hide a sign.
  • Averages and percentages without group sizes are incomplete.
  • Two statements describing the same fact leave the answer open.
  • Divisibility with a list of divisors may include values that break the rule.

How Do You Avoid Choosing the Wrong Option?

In short: slow down on a question that seems to need no calculation. Look for what has not been stated.

  • List the unknowns: if the unknowns exceed the independent facts, choose E.
  • Check the stem: a condition such as positive integers in the stem may rescue a statement.
  • Weights: for averages and percentages, ask whether group sizes are given.
  • Linked idea: more on combining information is in Data Sufficiency Problems Requiring Combination of Both Statements.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Is x positive? I: x squared = 49. II: x is an integer.

  1. Statement I: x = 7 or x = -7. The answer is sometimes yes and sometimes no.
  2. Statement II alone gives no sign.
  3. Together, x is still 7 or -7, since both are integers.

Answer: E.

Example 2

Question: What is the area of a rhombus? I: Its side is 10 cm. II: Its perimeter is 40 cm.

  1. Statement I: side 10, but the angle or a diagonal is free.
  2. Statement II: perimeter 40 gives side 10 again, which is the same fact.
  3. Together, the angle is still not given, so the area varies.

Answer: E.

Example 3

Question: What is the average marks of the whole class? I: Boys average 60 and girls average 70. II: There are 30 students.

  1. Statement I alone: the numbers of boys and girls are missing.
  2. Statement II alone: the averages are missing.
  3. Together, the split of the 30 students is still unknown, so the average can be anywhere between 60 and 70.

Answer: E.

Example 4

Question: Is 12 divided by b an integer? I: b divides 24. II: b is even.

  1. Take b = 6, which divides 24 and is even. 12 / 6 = 2, an integer.
  2. Take b = 8, which divides 24 and is even. 12 / 8 = 1.5, not an integer.
  3. The answer varies even with both statements.

Answer: E.

Example 5

Question: Contrast: What is the price of an apple? I: 3 apples and 2 oranges cost Rs 90. II: One orange costs Rs 15.

  1. At first the two unknowns look free, but Statement II gives the orange.
  2. Together, 3 apples = 90 – 30 = 60, so an apple costs Rs 20.

Answer: C. This one only looks insufficient.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Always ask whether a hidden second solution exists before declaring the data sufficient.
  • Search for two valid cases with different answers. That proves the data is not sufficient.
  • Be suspicious of squares, absolute values and square roots.
  • For averages and percentages, always ask whether the group sizes are given.
  • If two statements say the same thing, the combination is no stronger than one.
  • Do not calculate far. A counter-example is enough.

Common Mistakes

  • Choosing C because two numbers are given, when the numbers are really one fact.
  • Ignoring that a square gives two roots.
  • Computing an average without the number of items in each group.
  • Ignoring a condition in the stem that would narrow the cases.
  • Assuming that the figure is fixed when only one measure is given.

Practice Questions

  1. Is x positive? I: x squared = 49. II: x is an integer.
  2. What is the area of a rhombus? I: Its side is 10. II: Its perimeter is 40.
  3. What is the class average? I: Boys average 60 and girls average 70. II: There are 30 students.
  4. Is 12 / b an integer? I: b divides 24. II: b is even.
  5. What is the price of an apple? I: 3 apples and 2 oranges cost Rs 90. II: One orange costs Rs 15.
  6. What is n? I: n squared = n. II: n is not 0.

Answers: 1) E; 2) E; 3) E; 4) E; 5) C; 6) C (n = 1).

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Error prevention Most wrong answers in sufficiency come from these traps.
  • Logic The counter-example method is a general reasoning tool.
  • Averages It reinforces the weights idea of Change in Average on Addition, Removal or Replacement of a Value.
  • Link It prepares for the figure traps in Data Sufficiency Involving Geometric Figures with Unstated or Missing Measurements.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Data Sufficiency Involving Geometric Figures with Unstated or Missing Measurements. It applies the same alertness to geometric figures where some measurements are missing.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Counter-example A valid case that gives a different answer
  • Hidden freedom An unstated quantity that can change the answer
  • Weight The number of items behind an average
  • Redundant fact A fact repeated in another form
  • Even power A power such as squared, which loses the sign
  • Not determinable The data allows more than one answer

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Find a counter-example to prove insufficiency.
  • Squares give two roots.
  • Averages need group sizes.
  • Repeated facts add nothing.
  • Read the stem for conditions.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Looks sufficient vs is sufficient Only a unique answer is sufficient.
  • E vs C E means even together there is no unique answer.
  • Average of averages vs weighted average They are equal only when group sizes are equal.
  • Same fact vs new fact A restatement is not new.

Memory Hook

Two valid cases, two answers: not sufficient.

GS Relevance

Data sufficiency traps for CAT, SSC CGL and CSAT: statements that look sufficient but are not, with counter-examples, hidden solutions and missing weights.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an apparently sufficient statement?

An apparently sufficient statement is one that seems to give enough information, because it contains numbers or a relation, but still allows more than one answer. Examples include a squared equation that has two roots and averages of two groups given without the number of items in each group.

How do you prove that a statement is not sufficient?

A statement is proved not sufficient by finding two cases that both satisfy it but give different answers. For example, x squared equal to 49 is satisfied by 7 and by minus 7, so a question about the sign of x cannot be answered from it.

Why are averages without group sizes insufficient?

Averages without group sizes are insufficient because the combined average depends on how many items each group contains. If boys average 60 and girls average 70, the class average can lie anywhere between 60 and 70 depending on how the 30 students are split.

Can two statements that look different give the same information?

Two statements can look different and still give the same information. A rhombus with a side of 10 and a perimeter of 40 states one fact twice, so the angle or a diagonal is still missing, and the area remains undetermined.

What is the correct option for traps that look sufficient?

The correct option for such traps is usually option E, that the statements are not sufficient even together. Occasionally a case that only looks insufficient is solved by the combination, so each question should be tested with counter-examples before an option is chosen.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 If two valid cases give different answers, the data is not sufficient.
True

A sufficient statement gives one definite answer.

2 The class average is fixed by the boys' average and the girls' average alone.
False

The number in each group is also needed.

3 If x squared = 49, then x is positive.
False

x can be 7 or -7.

4 A rhombus with side 10 has a fixed area.
False

The angle or a diagonal is still free.

Share: