An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 8.13

Simon Commission (1927)

Modern History › Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929) · Topic 8.13

The all-white, seven-member Indian Statutory Commission, known as the Simon Commission after its chairman Sir John Simon, was set up on 8 November 1927 to study the working of the Government of India Act, 1919. Indians were excluded, which united them in boycott. It landed in Bombay on 3 February 1928 to hartals and black flags, and Lala Lajpat Rai died after a lathi-charge.

Share:
Simon Commission (1927) - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Set up 8 November 1927, under Baldwin’s government
  • Chairman Sir John Simon; all-white, seven members
  • Landed in Bombay 3 February 1928; hartal and black flags
  • Response Near-unanimous boycott: Simon Go Back
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929)

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 8.13 of the category “Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929)”. Previous topic: dyarchy Result Majority and minority reports Exam link…">Muddiman Committee (1924).

What Was the Simon Commission?

The Government of India Act, 1919 provided that a commission would be appointed ten years after it to study the progress of the governance scheme and suggest new steps. The all-white, seven-member Indian Statutory Commission, popularly known as the Simon Commission after its chairman Sir John Simon, was set up by the British government under Prime Minister Stanley Baldwin on 8 November 1927. It was to recommend whether India was ready for further constitutional reforms and along what lines. The 1919 Act is described in Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms and the Government of India Act, 1919.

Why Was It Appointed Early?

Constitutional reforms were due only in 1929. The Conservative government then in power feared defeat by the Labour Party and did not want to leave the future of Britain’s most prized colony in what it called irresponsible Labour hands. Also, by the mid-1920s the failure of the 1919 Act to create a stable imperial arrangement had led to several parliamentary reports and inquiries.

Inquiry Subject
Lee Commission The Raj’s failure to recruit enough British officers
Mudiman Commission The deadlock within the dyarchic arrangement
Linlithgow Commission The crisis of Indian agriculture

The Conservative Secretary of State for India, Lord Birkenhead, had often said that Indians could not formulate a concrete scheme of constitutional reform that had the support of wide sections of Indian opinion, and he was responsible for appointing the commission.

How Did India Respond?

The Indian response was immediate and nearly unanimous. What angered Indians most was the exclusion of Indians from the commission, and the notion behind it that foreigners would discuss and decide India’s fitness for self-government. This was seen as a violation of the principle of self-determination and a deliberate insult to Indian self-respect.

Group Response
Congress The Madras session of December 1927, under M.A. Ansari, decided to boycott the commission at every stage and in every form; Nehru also got a snap resolution passed declaring complete independence the goal
Hindu Mahasabha liberals Supported the boycott
Muslim League majority faction Supported the boycott under Jinnah
Muslim League, Shafi faction The League held two sessions in 1927, one under Jinnah at Calcutta opposing the commission and one at Lahore under Muhammad Shafi supporting the government
Unionists in Punjab and the Justice Party in the south Decided not to boycott

What Happened When the Commission Arrived?

The commission landed in Bombay on 3 February 1928. A countrywide hartal was organised that day and mass rallies were held. Wherever the commission went there were black flag demonstrations, hartals and slogans of Simon Go Back. A significant feature was that a new generation of youth had its first taste of political action. They played the most active part and gave the protest a militant flavour, and youth leagues and conferences received a real boost. Nehru and Subhash Bose emerged as leaders of this new wave and travelled widely, addressing and presiding over conferences.

The upsurge also provided fertile ground for new radical ideas of socialism, seen in groups such as the Punjab Naujawan Bharat Sabha, the Workers’ and Peasants’ Parties and the Hindustani Sewa Dal in Karnataka. These currents are described in Spread of Socialist and Marxist Ideas, Youth Activism and Trade Unionism.

How Did the Police Respond?

The police came down heavily on demonstrators. There were lathi-charges that did not spare even senior leaders. Jawaharlal Nehru and G.B. Pant were beaten up in Lucknow. Lala Lajpat Rai received severe blows on the chest in October 1928, from which he died on 17 November 1928. He had said that the blows that fell on him were the last nails in the coffin of British imperialism. His death led to the Saunders murder, covered in Revolutionary Activity in Punjab, United Provinces and Bihar.

What Was the Impact on the National Movement?

The impact of the appointment was two-fold. First, it gave a stimulus to radical forces demanding complete independence and major socio-economic reform on socialist lines. The Congress, which had no active programme, got an issue around which it could again forge mass action. Second, Birkenhead’s challenge to Indian politicians to produce an agreed constitution was accepted by various political sections, and prospects for Indian unity seemed bright at that point.

As an analytical point, one decision, the exclusion of Indians, did two things at once: it united groups that had been divided since the end of non-cooperation, and it gave the Congress a mass issue. The Indian answer to the challenge is described in Nehru Report, 1928, and the commission’s report in Recommendations of the Simon Commission.

What Did the Report Propose for the Provinces?

The Simon Commission published a two-volume report in May 1930. It proposed the abolition of dyarchy and the establishment of representative government in the provinces, which were to be given autonomy. The governor was to have discretionary power in relation to internal security and administrative powers to protect the different communities. The number of members of provincial legislative councils was to be increased. Dyarchy is described in Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms and the Government of India Act, 1919.

What Did It Propose for the Centre?

The report rejected parliamentary responsibility at the Centre. The Governor-General would have complete power to appoint members of the cabinet, and the Government of India would have complete control over the high courts.

What Did It Say on Electorates, Federation and Regions?

The report proposed that separate communal electorates be retained, and extended to other communities, but only until tensions between Hindus and Muslims had died down. There was to be no universal franchise.

Subject Recommendation
Federalism Accepted in principle but not in the near future; a Consultative Council of Greater India including representatives of British provinces and princely states
North-West Frontier Province and Baluchistan Local legislatures, and the right to be represented at the Centre
Sindh To be separated from Bombay
Burma To be separated from India as it was not a natural part of the Indian subcontinent
Army Indianisation of the army, though British forces must be retained

What Was Done for the Depressed Classes?

The report did grant reserved seats to the depressed classes, but on the condition that candidates first had their competence endorsed by the Governor of the province. Dr Ambedkar was most displeased with this, and in any case the report remained a dead letter. His own evidence is in Dr Ambedkar and the Simon Commission.

How Did the Report Compare With What Indians Wanted?

Indian opinion had asked for responsible government. The report gave something in the provinces, where dyarchy was to go and representative government and autonomy were to follow, but it kept the Centre irresponsible to the legislature. It also kept the governor’s discretionary power over internal security, which meant that the most sensitive subject would remain outside popular control.

The report kept communal electorates, which Indian nationalists had been trying to move away from, and it made no provision for a universal franchise. It treated federation as a distant goal. As an analytical point, each proposal moved a little towards Indian demands, but none of them gave the Centre to Indians, which is why the Indian response to the report, coming after the boycott of the commission itself, was negative.

Why Did the Report Lose Relevance?

By the time the report came out, it was no longer relevant, because several events had overtaken its recommendations. The Congress had already declared complete independence as its goal and was on the eve of the Civil Disobedience Movement, as described in Lahore Congress and Purna Swaraj, and the constitutional questions were taken up afresh at the separate electorates Result No agreement Exam link…">Round Table Conferences, described in First and Second Round Table Conferences.

As an analytical point, the report offered more provincial autonomy while denying responsibility at the Centre, which meant that it moved in the opposite direction from the demand of Indian leaders for responsible government at the Centre, as expressed in Nehru Report, 1928. Its approach to communal electorates also set the terms for the debates that followed.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Boycott and responses Group-wise responses are a frequent Prelims and Mains point
  • Link to Lajpat Rai’s death Connects the commission to the revolutionaries’ actions
  • Revival of mass politics Shows how the Congress regained a mass issue

What Came Next?

Next topic: Bardoli Satyagraha (1928).

Key People and Terms

  • Indian Statutory Commission The official name of the Simon Commission
  • Sir John Simon Chairman of the commission
  • Lord Birkenhead Secretary of State who was responsible for its appointment
  • Simon Go Back Slogan raised wherever the commission went
  • Lee Commission Inquired into recruitment of British officers
  • Mudiman Commission Inquired into dyarchy

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Commission set up 8 November 1927; seven members, all white.
  • Landed in Bombay 3 February 1928; Simon Go Back.
  • Madras Congress December 1927, president M.A. Ansari: boycott; complete independence resolution.
  • Lajpat Rai died 17 November 1928.
  • Not boycotting: Unionists and Justice Party; Shafi League faction.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Jinnah’s and Shafi’s League factions Jinnah’s majority boycotted; Shafi’s supported the government
  • Lee, Mudiman and Linlithgow commissions Officers, dyarchy and agriculture respectively
  • Simon Commission and the Nehru Committee One was British and all-white; the other an Indian answer

Memory Hook

No Indian on the panel, so India answered with black flags and Birkenhead’s challenge with a constitution.

Mains Angle

Questions ask why the commission was boycotted and what followed. These points add depth.

  • Reasons Insult to self-respect and self-determination
  • Responses Congress and the groups that did not boycott
  • Impact Mass action and the challenge to draft a constitution

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Why was the Simon Commission boycotted in India, and what was the impact of its appointment on the national movement?”

How to Answer

  1. Background Appointment and the all-white membership.
  2. Responses Congress, Muslim League and others.
  3. Protest Hartals, repression and youth.
  4. Conclude Mass action and the constitutional challenge.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929). GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Simon Commission?

The Simon Commission, officially the Indian Statutory Commission, was an all-white seven-member body headed by Sir John Simon. It was set up on 8 November 1927 to review the working of the Government of India Act, 1919 and recommend whether India was ready for further reforms.

Why was the Simon Commission appointed before 1929?

Reforms were due only in 1929, but the Conservative government feared losing power to the Labour Party and did not want to leave India's future to it. Failures of the 1919 Act, shown by the Lee, Mudiman and Linlithgow inquiries, also pushed Lord Birkenhead to set it up.

Why did Indians boycott the Simon Commission?

Indians were angered by the exclusion of any Indian from the commission and by the notion that foreigners would decide India's fitness for self-government. This was seen as violating the principle of self-determination and as an insult to Indian self-respect.

How did different groups respond to the commission?

The Congress at Madras in December 1927 decided to boycott it at every stage. Hindu Mahasabha liberals and the Jinnah faction of the Muslim League joined the boycott, while the Shafi faction, the Unionists in Punjab and the Justice Party in the south did not.

What happened when the commission arrived in India?

It landed in Bombay on 3 February 1928, when a countrywide hartal was held. Wherever it went there were black flag demonstrations and Simon Go Back slogans. Police lathi-charges injured Nehru and Pant at Lucknow, and Lala Lajpat Rai died on 17 November 1928 after being hit.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Simon Commission was set up on 8 November 1927.
True

It had seven members, all white.

2 The Simon Commission included Indian members.
False

It was all-white, which led to the boycott.

3 The Congress session at Madras in December 1927 decided to boycott the Simon Commission.
True

M.A. Ansari presided.

4 The commission landed in Bombay on 3 February 1928.
True

A countrywide hartal marked the day.

5 Lala Lajpat Rai died on 17 November 1928 after being injured in a lathi-charge.
True

He was leading a demonstration against the commission.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929). UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: