An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 7.5

Indian Councils Act (Morley-Minto Reforms), 1909

Modern History › Indian National Movement – I (1905-1918) · Topic 7.5

The Indian Councils Act of 1909, known as the Morley-Minto Reforms after the Secretary of State John Morley and the Viceroy Lord Minto, enlarged the legislative councils, recognised the elective principle, gave separate electorates to Muslims for the first time and appointed the first Indian, Satyendra Sinha, to the Viceroy's Executive Council. It gave no responsible government.

Share:
Indian Councils Act (Morley-Minto Reforms), 1909 - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Act Indian Councils Act, 1909
  • Named after John Morley and Lord Minto
  • Key feature Separate electorates for Muslims
  • First Indian in Executive Council Satyendra Sinha
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Indian National Movement – I (1905-1918)

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 7.5 of the category “Indian National Movement – I (1905-1918)”. Previous topic: Surat Session of the Indian National Congress (1907).

What Were the Reforms of 1909?

The Viceroy, Lord Minto, and the Secretary of State, John Morley, agreed that some reforms were due, to placate both the Moderates and the Muslims. They worked out the set of measures known as the Morley-Minto Reforms, which became the Indian Councils Act of 1909.

Provision Detail
Elective principle Recognised for the non-official membership of the councils; Indians could take part in the election of various legislative councils, on the basis of class and community
Separate electorates For the first time established for Muslims for election to the central council, called a most detrimental step for India
Size The number of elected members in the Imperial and Provincial Legislative Councils increased; in the provincial councils a non-official majority was introduced, but because some non-officials were nominated, the overall non-elected majority remained
Imperial Council seats (Sumit Sarkar) 69 members: 37 officials and 32 non-officials, of whom 5 were nominated; of 27 elected non-officials, 8 seats reserved for Muslims under separate electorates, 4 for British capitalists, 2 for landlords and 13 under a general electorate
Indirect election Local bodies elected an electoral college, which elected members of provincial councils, who elected members of the central council
Muslim privileges Representation in excess of their population strength; lower income qualification for Muslim voters than for Hindus
Powers Legislatures could pass resolutions (which might not be accepted), ask questions and supplementaries and vote on separate items of the budget, though not on the budget as a whole
Executive council One Indian to be appointed to the Viceroy’s Executive Council; Satyendra Sinha was the first, in 1909

The earlier Raja Rammohan Roy and Metcalfe Jailed Surendranath Banerjea, 1883; Tilak, 1897 Laws Press Acts of 1908 and…">Indian Councils Act of 1892, with which these reforms are often compared, is in Constitutional Reforms, Administrative Reforms and Civil Rights Campaigns.

How Were the Reforms Evaluated?

The reforms of 1909 afforded no answer to the Indian political problem. Lord Morley made it clear that colonial self-government, as demanded by the Congress, was not suitable for India, and he was against introducing a parliamentary or responsible government. He said that if it could be said that this chapter of reforms led directly or indirectly to a parliamentary system in India, he would have nothing to do with it.

The constitutional reforms were aimed at dividing the nationalist ranks by confusing the Moderates and at checking the growth of unity among Indians through the instrument of separate electorates. The government aimed at rallying the Moderates and the Muslims against the rising tide of nationalism. Officials and Muslim leaders often spoke of the entire community when they spoke of separate electorates, but in reality it meant the appeasement of a small section of the Muslim elite. The election was too indirect, giving the impression of infiltration of legislators through a number of sieves. Parliamentary forms were introduced but no responsibility was conceded, which sometimes led to thoughtless and irresponsible criticism of the government. Only some members, like Gokhale, put the opportunity to debate to constructive use by demanding universal primary education, attacking repressive policies and drawing attention to the plight of indentured labour and Indian workers in South Africa. The reforms gave the people a shadow rather than substance: they had demanded self-government and were given benevolent despotism.

Lord Morley hoped the reforms might save the Raj, and the later Montford Report said they afforded no answer to Indian problems. Jawaharlal Nehru wrote that the political barrier created round Muslims isolated them from the rest of India and reversed the unifying process that had gone on for centuries, a barrier small at first that grew with every extension of the franchise and affected the whole structure of political and social life like a canker.

As an analytical point, the 1909 reforms combine the two aims of the government’s strategy in Government Repression and Strategy: they gave the Moderates a step in representation, and they gave separate electorates to a small Muslim elite, which put the principle of community representation into the constitution. The consequences of that principle belong to the later categories on communal politics and constitutional development.

Why Did the Government Offer Reforms in 1909?

By 1909 the government faced the Swadeshi agitation, revolutionary violence and the Extremists. It chose to follow a three-part plan of repression, reform and division. Repression meant arrests and new press laws, reform meant the Morley-Minto Reforms to win over the Moderates, and division meant separate electorates to win Muslim support. John Morley, the Secretary of State for India, and Lord Minto, the Viceroy, worked out the plan together.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Provisions Separate electorates is the key fact
  • Criticism Divide and rule is a Mains theme
  • Link It follows the Muslim League and precedes Montford

What Came Next?

Next topic: Formation of the Ghadar Party (1913).

Key People and Terms

  • Morley-Minto Reforms The 1909 reforms
  • Separate electorates Voting by community
  • Satyendra Sinha First Indian member of the Executive Council
  • Elective principle Election of non-official members
  • Indirect election Election through electoral colleges
  • Responsible government Government accountable to the legislature

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Act of 1909.
  • Separate electorates for Muslims.
  • First Indian member: Satyendra Sinha.
  • Elections were indirect.
  • No responsible government.

Do Not Confuse With

  • 1892 and 1909 Acts Both enlarged the councils; 1909 added separate electorates
  • Morley and Minto Secretary of State and Viceroy
  • Montford and Morley-Minto 1919 versus 1909

Memory Hook

Morley, Minto and a divided vote: 1909.

Mains Angle

Questions ask whether the reforms were a step forward. Use these points.

  • Gains More Indian members and a right to discuss
  • Division Separate electorates
  • Limits No responsibility

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Examine the Morley-Minto Reforms of 1909 and why they were criticised.”

How to Answer

  1. Introduce Context of 1909.
  2. Provisions Councils and electorates.
  3. Criticism Divide and rule.
  4. Conclude Legacy.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Indian National Movement – I (1905-1918). GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the main provisions of the Morley-Minto Reforms of 1909?

The Act recognised the elective principle, raised the number of elected members in the central and provincial councils, introduced separate electorates for Muslims at the centre, allowed resolutions, questions and voting on separate budget items, and appointed one Indian to the Viceroy's Executive Council.

Why are the Morley-Minto Reforms criticised?

They created separate electorates, a step which divided Indians, and gave Muslims representation above their population and lower income qualifications. Election was indirect, official influence remained, and no responsible government was conceded, so the people got a shadow rather than substance.

Who was the first Indian in the Viceroy's Executive Council?

Satyendra Sinha was the first Indian appointed to the Viceroy's Executive Council, in 1909, under the Morley-Minto Reforms. This was one of the Act's limited concessions to Indian participation in the executive government, though officials still kept the majority.

What did Lord Morley say about parliamentary government?

Morley made it clear that colonial self-government, as demanded by the Congress, was unsuitable for India. He said he would have nothing to do with the reforms if they led directly or indirectly to a parliamentary system in India.

What was the Simla Deputation of 1906?

The Simla Deputation was a group of Muslim leaders led by the Aga Khan who met Lord Minto in October 1906 and asked for separate electorates and representation beyond their numbers, to which Minto agreed.

How many seats were reserved for Muslims in the Imperial Council?

Of the 27 elected non-official seats in the Imperial Legislative Council, 8 were reserved for Muslims under separate electorates, along with seats for British capitalists, landlords and a general electorate. Satyendra Sinha, later Lord Sinha, joined the Executive Council as Law Member and became a peer in 1919.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Morley-Minto Reforms became the Indian Councils Act of 1909.
True

They introduced separate electorates for Muslims.

2 The Morley-Minto Reforms introduced responsible government in India.
False

Morley opposed parliamentary government.

3 Satyendra Sinha was the first Indian member of the Viceroy's Executive Council.
True

He was appointed in 1909.

4 Separate electorates for Muslims were established for the first time in the central council in 1909.
True

They were also given weightage.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Indian National Movement – I (1905-1918). UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: