An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 14.9

Education Under Dyarchy

Modern History › Development of Education · Topic 14.9

The Saddler Commission of 1917-19 reviewed schooling and universities and urged a 12-year school course, an intermediate stage and unitary teaching universities; seven new universities arose in 1916-21. Under dyarchy education passed to provincial ministers and grants fell. The Hartog Committee of 1929 stressed primary education, the Wardha Scheme of 1937 proposed basic education through handicraft, and the Sargent Plan of 1944 proposed universal elementary education.

Share:
Education Under Dyarchy - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Saddler 1917-19; 12-year school course; unitary universities
  • Hartog 1929; primary education emphasised
  • Wardha 1937; basic education through handicraft
  • Sargent 1944; universal elementary education
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Development of Education

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 14.9 of the category “Development of Education”. Previous topic: Saddler University Commission (1917–19).

What Happened Under Dyarchy and What Did the Hartog Committee Say?

Under the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms, education moved to provincial ministries and the government stopped taking a direct interest in educational matters, while the grants liberally sanctioned since 1902 were stopped. Financial difficulties prevented substantial expansion, but education still grew, especially through philanthropic efforts. The reforms are in Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms and the Government of India Act, 1919.

The increase in the number of schools and colleges had led to a fall in standards, and the Hartog Committee of 1929 was set up to report on education. It recommended emphasis on primary education without hasty expansion or compulsion, only deserving students going on to high school and intermediate stages while average students were diverted to vocational courses after class VIII, and restricted admission to universities to improve standards.

How Did Dyarchy Affect Education?

Under the Act of 1919 education became a transferred subject under Indian ministers, which gave Indians control of the policy for the first time. The provincial legislatures passed primary education acts for compulsory education in some areas, such as the Patel Act in Bombay in 1918 and similar acts in other provinces. But the ministers had little money, since finance was reserved, and the Government’s share in education spending fell, so that expansion was slow. The Hartog Committee later noted the poor quality and waste.

What Did the Saddler Commission Recommend?

The Saddler University Commission of 1917-19 was set up to study the problems of Calcutta University, but its recommendations applied more or less to other universities too. It reviewed the whole field from school to university education and held that improving secondary education was a precondition for improving universities.

Recommendation Detail
1 School course to cover 12 years; students to enter university after an intermediate stage instead of matric, for a three-year degree course; to prepare students, relieve universities of those below university standard and give collegiate education to those not planning to go to university; a separate board of secondary and intermediate education
2 Less rigidity in framing university regulations
3 A university to be a centralised, unitary, residential, teaching and autonomous body and not a group of scattered affiliated colleges
4 Extension of female education, applied scientific and technological education, and teachers’ training, including for professional and vocational colleges

From 1916 to 1921 seven new universities came up at Mysore, Patna, Benaras, Aligarh, Dacca, Lucknow and Osmania. In 1920 the government recommended the Saddler report to the provincial governments. The 1913 policy is in Education After 1858: Hunter Commission to the Universities Act, 1904.

What Was the Wardha Scheme of Basic Education, 1937?

The Congress held a National Conference on Education at Wardha in October 1937, and on its resolutions a committee under Zakir Hussain drew up a detailed national scheme of basic education. Its main principle was learning through activity. It was based on Gandhi’s ideas published in a series of articles in Harijan. Gandhi thought that Western education had created a gulf between the educated few and the masses and had made the educated elite ineffective.

Provision Detail
1 Inclusion of a basic handicraft in the syllabus
2 The first seven years of schooling to be part of a free and compulsory nationwide system, through the mother tongue
3 Teaching in Hindi from class II to VII and in English only after class VIII
4 Ways to contact the community around the schools through service
5 A technique to educate the child through the productive activity of a suitable handicraft

The scheme was an expression of an idea of a new life and a new society, and its premise was that only through such a scheme could India become an independent and non-violent society. It was child-centred and cooperative. Little development followed because of the outbreak of the Second World War and the resignation of the Congress ministries in October 1939. Gandhi’s educational ideas are also in Gandhi and Bose: Ideological Differences, and the ministries in Congress Ministries: Labour Policy, Social Welfare and Evaluation.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Commissions and committees A standard Prelims list with years and recommendations
  • Wardha Scheme Gandhi’s basic education
  • Evaluation A frequent Mains topic

What Came Next?

Next topic: Hartog Committee (1929).

Key People and Terms

  • Saddler Commission The 1917-19 university commission
  • Hartog Committee The 1929 committee on education
  • Wardha Scheme The 1937 scheme of basic education
  • Sargent Plan The 1944 post-war education plan
  • Basic education Education through productive handicraft
  • Intermediate stage A stage between school and degree courses

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Saddler 1917-19; seven universities 1916-21.
  • Hartog 1929; Wardha 1937; Sargent 1944.
  • Wardha: learning through activity; Zakir Hussain committee.
  • Sargent: 40 years to reach England’s level; adult illiteracy in 20 years.
  • Illiteracy 84 per cent (1911), 92 per cent (1921) by the source.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Saddler and Hartog Universities and schools versus primary education and standards
  • Wardha and Sargent Congress basic education versus the government’s post-war plan
  • 1916-21 universities Mysore, Patna, Benaras, Aligarh, Dacca, Lucknow, Osmania

Memory Hook

Saddler for the university, Hartog for the standard, Wardha for the hand, Sargent for the nation.

Mains Angle

Questions ask about education reforms and their limits. These points add depth.

  • Reforms Saddler to Sargent
  • Basic education Gandhian alternative
  • Verdict Neglect of the masses and women

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Evaluate British education policy in India, with reference to the main commissions and plans between 1917 and 1944.”

How to Answer

  1. Commissions Saddler and Hartog.
  2. Alternatives Wardha and Sargent.
  3. Evaluation Aims and neglect.
  4. Conclude Legacy.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Development of Education. GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the Saddler Commission recommend?

It recommended a 12-year school course, entry to university after an intermediate stage for a three-year degree, a separate secondary and intermediate board, unitary residential teaching universities, and expansion of women's, scientific and technical education and teachers' training. Seven new universities arose between 1916 and 1921.

What did the Hartog Committee of 1929 recommend?

It stressed primary education without hasty expansion or compulsion, suggested that only deserving students go on to high school and the intermediate stage while average students move to vocational courses after class VIII, and restricted university admissions to improve standards.

What was the Wardha Scheme of Basic Education?

The Wardha Scheme of 1937, drawn up by a Zakir Hussain committee after the Wardha conference, was based on Gandhi's ideas and meant to educate children through a productive handicraft, with free, compulsory education in the mother tongue for seven years and community service.

What was the Sargent Plan of 1944?

It was a plan by the government's educational adviser for pre-primary education, free and compulsory elementary schooling for ages 6 to 11, selective high schooling, a three-year university course, technical education and removal of adult illiteracy in 20 years, aiming to reach England's level in 40 years, without a method of implementation.

What were the weaknesses of British education policy?

It neglected mass education, leaving 84 per cent illiterate in 1911 and 92 per cent in 1921 by the source's figures, made education a monopoly of the upper classes and city dwellers, neglected women's education, and largely neglected scientific and technical education.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Saddler Commission recommended a 12-year school course.
True

It also proposed an intermediate stage before university.

2 The Wardha Scheme of 1937 was based on Gandhi's ideas of basic education.
True

It stressed learning through activity.

3 The Sargent Plan of 1944 proposed abolition of the intermediate course.
True

It also proposed compulsory elementary education.

4 The Hartog Committee recommended hasty expansion and compulsion in primary education.
False

It said there need be no hasty expansion or compulsion.

5 Education was shifted to provincial ministers under dyarchy.
True

Government grants were stopped.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Development of Education. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: