Muddiman Committee (1924)
Modern History › Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929) · Topic 8.12
The Muddiman Committee, or Reforms Enquiry Committee, was appointed in 1924 under Sir Alexander Muddiman to inquire into the working of dyarchy under the Government of India Act, 1919. The majority held that dyarchy could be worked with changes within the Act, while Indian members such as Tej Bahadur Sapru wrote a minority report that it had failed. The Government rejected any big change.
5 min read · UPSC Prelims · History · Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929)
At a Glance
- Year 1924
- Chairman Sir Alexander Muddiman
- Task Inquire into working of dyarchy
- Result Majority and minority reports
- Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929)
Where Does It Fit?
This is topic 8.12 of the category “Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929)”. The Muddiman Committee belongs to the middle of the 1920s, after the formation of the Swaraj Party and before the appointment of the Simon Commission. It is the Government’s first official response to the Swarajists’ demand for constitutional review. Previous topic: Formation and Evaluation of the Swaraj Party.
What Did the Swarajists Achieve in the Councils?
With coalition partners the Swarajists outvoted the government several times, even on budgetary grants, and passed adjournment motions. They spoke powerfully on self-government, civil liberties and industrialisation.
| Achievement | Detail |
|---|---|
| Outvoting the government | Several times, with coalition partners, including on budgetary grants |
| Speeches | On self-government, civil liberties and industrialisation |
| Speaker | Vithalbhai Patel was elected Speaker of the Central Legislative Assembly in 1925 |
| Public Safety Bill | Defeated in 1928; it aimed to deport undesirable and subversive foreigners, as the government was alarmed by socialist and communist ideas and Comintern-sent activists |
| Political vacuum | Filled it while the national movement recouped its strength |
| Montford scheme | Exposed its hollowness |
| Creative use | Showed that the councils could be used creatively |
What Were the Swarajists’ Drawbacks?
- They lacked a policy to coordinate their militancy inside the legislatures with the mass struggle outside and relied on newspaper reports to reach the public.
- An obstructionist strategy had its limits.
- They could not go far with coalition partners because of conflicting ideas.
- They failed to resist the perks and privileges of power and office.
- They did not support the peasants’ cause in Bengal and lost support among pro-peasant Muslim members.
What Was the Reforms Inquiry Committee?
In February 1924 Motilal Nehru, leading the Swarajists in the Central Legislative Assembly, moved a resolution asking the Government to call a separate electorates Result No agreement Exam link…">round table conference to frame a new constitution. The Assembly passed an amended resolution that asked the Government to examine the defects in the Act of 1919 and the possible remedies. In response the Government set up the Reforms Enquiry Committee in 1924 under Sir Alexander Muddiman, the Home Member, to inquire into the working of the dyarchy and to suggest remedies within the limits of the Act.
What Did the Majority and Minority Say?
| Group | View |
|---|---|
| Majority | Dyarchy had defects but could be made to work with changes in the rules and with better working; no change in the Act was needed |
| Minority (Sapru and other Indian members) | Dyarchy had failed; the Act should be revised and a full inquiry made into a new constitution |
| Government | Accepted only the first view and made some changes in the rules |
| Swarajists | Rejected the report as inadequate and went on with their work in the councils |
The Committee’s report was published in 1925, and the Government’s decision not to revise the Act was one reason for the later appointment of the Simon Commission in 1927.
How Did the Muddiman Committee Fit Into the Constitutional Story?
| Year | Step |
|---|---|
| 1919 | Government of India Act introduces dyarchy |
| 1923 | Swarajists enter the councils |
| 1924 | Muddiman Committee appointed after the Swarajist demand |
| 1925 | Report published; Government refuses major change |
| 1927 | Simon Commission appointed |
| 1930 | Simon report published |
The table shows that the Muddiman Committee is the link between the working of dyarchy and the larger review by the Simon Commission, and that the Swarajists’ pressure in the councils was a reason for both.
What Should a Student Remember?
The Muddiman Committee is a short topic but it is often asked in a one-line form: appointed in 1924, to examine the working of dyarchy, and with a minority report that dyarchy had failed. Remember also that Tej Bahadur Sapru was among the Indian members who signed the minority report, and that the Government, by refusing to make major changes, helped to bring on the demand for a fresh review.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Name and year Muddiman and 1924 are matched
- Dyarchy It links to the Act of 1919
- Link It leads to the Simon Commission
What Came Next?
The Simon Commission follows, which was the larger review of the Act of 1919. Next topic: Simon Commission (1927).
Key People and Terms
- Muddiman Committee Reforms Enquiry Committee of 1924
- Dyarchy Rule by two authorities in the provinces
- Minority report A dissenting report by some members
- Swarajists Congress members in the councils
- Motilal Nehru Leader of the Swarajists in the Assembly
- Home Member Member of the Viceroy’s Council for home affairs
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Appointed in 1924.
- Head: Alexander Muddiman.
- Inquired into dyarchy.
- Minority said dyarchy had failed.
- Followed by the Simon Commission.
Do Not Confuse With
- Muddiman and Simon 1924 versus 1927
- Majority and minority views Make it work versus revise the Act
- Muddiman and Montagu Different people
Memory Hook
Muddiman checks the dyarchy in 1924 and Simon follows in 1927.
Mains Angle
Questions ask how the Government dealt with the demand for constitutional change. Use these points.
- Pressure Swarajist resolutions in the Assembly
- Response A limited inquiry
- Result No change in the Act
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Describe the work of the Muddiman Committee and its importance.”
How to Answer
- Introduce The demand of 1924.
- Committee Task and members.
- Reports Majority and minority.
- Conclude Simon follows.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Swarajists achieve in the councils?
With coalition partners they outvoted the government several times, even on budgets, and passed adjournment motions. Vithalbhai Patel was elected Speaker of the Central Legislative Assembly in 1925, and the Public Safety Bill was defeated in 1928. They also exposed the hollowness of the Montford scheme.
Why was the Muddiman Committee appointed?
It was appointed in 1924 after the Swarajists in the Central Legislative Assembly, led by Motilal Nehru, demanded a review of the Act of 1919 and a round table conference to frame a new constitution.
What did the Muddiman Committee examine?
The Reforms Enquiry Committee examined the working of the dyarchy in the provinces under the Government of India Act, 1919, and the possible remedies within the limits of the Act. The Committee was appointed by the Government in 1924, and its report was published in 1925.
What were the findings of the Muddiman Committee?
The majority of the Committee held that dyarchy had defects but could be worked with changes in the rules, while a minority of Indian members, including Tej Bahadur Sapru, held that dyarchy had failed and should be revised.
How is the Muddiman Committee linked to the Simon Commission?
The Government's refusal to revise the Act after the Muddiman Committee, together with the demand of the Indians for reform, was one reason for the appointment of the Simon Commission in 1927. The Simon Commission was appointed in 1927 earlier than the date of review laid down in the Act, which was ten years after 1919.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 Vithalbhai Patel was elected Speaker of the Central Legislative Assembly in 1925.
The Swarajists supported his election.
2 The Muddiman Committee was appointed in 1924.
It reviewed dyarchy.
3 The Muddiman Committee recommended an end to dyarchy by the majority.
The majority wanted changes in working.
4 Motilal Nehru's resolution led to its appointment.
He led the Swarajists.
Past Mains Questions on This Topic
This topic comes under Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929). UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:
Related Topics
Browse the full Modern History index