An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 8.11

Formation and Evaluation of the Swaraj Party

Modern History › Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929) · Topic 8.11

After Gandhi's arrest in March 1922, the Congress split on how to use the passive phase. The Swarajists under C.R. Das, Motilal Nehru and Ajmal Khan wanted to enter the legislative councils to end or mend them, while the No-Changers under Rajagopalachari, Patel, Rajendra Prasad and M.A. Ansari wanted constructive work. The Swarajist Party was formed after the Gaya session of December 1922.

Share:
Formation and Evaluation of the Swaraj Party - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Cause Passive phase after Gandhi’s arrest in March 1922
  • Swarajists C.R. Das, Motilal Nehru, Ajmal Khan: enter councils
  • No-Changers C. Rajagopalachari, Vallabhbhai Patel, Rajendra Prasad, M.A. Ansari: constructive work
  • Party formed Congress-Khilafat Swarajya Party after the Gaya session, December 1922
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929)

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 8.11 of the category “Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929)”. The Swaraj Party was the political response of Congress leaders to the withdrawal of Non-Cooperation in 1922. It was formed by C.R. Das and Motilal Nehru, and it won seats in the councils in the elections of November 1923. Its record is covered with the No-Changers’ alternative of constructive work. Previous topic: Nagpur Session of the Indian National Congress.

How Did the Debate Begin?

After Gandhi’s arrest in March 1922 there was disintegration, disorganisation and demoralisation in nationalist ranks. A debate started among Congressmen on what to do in the transition, the passive phase of the movement. The withdrawal that led to it is in Government Response and Withdrawal of the Movement.

School Leaders View
Swarajists C.R. Das, Motilal Nehru, Ajmal Khan End the boycott of legislative councils, enter them to expose their weaknesses and use them as an arena of political struggle to arouse popular enthusiasm; end or mend them, and obstruct their working if the government did not respond
No-Changers C. Rajagopalachari, Vallabhbhai Patel, Rajendra Prasad, M.A. Ansari Oppose council entry, concentrate on constructive work, continue boycott and non-cooperation, and prepare quietly for resuming civil disobedience

How Was the Swarajist Party Formed?

The differences over council entry led to the defeat of the Swarajists’ proposal of end or mend at the Gaya session of the Congress in December 1922. C.R. Das and Motilal Nehru resigned as president and secretary of the Congress and announced the formation of the Congress-Khilafat Swarajya Party, or Swarajist Party, with C.R. Das as president and Motilal Nehru as one of the secretaries.

What Were the Arguments of Each Side?

The Swarajists argued that entering the councils would not negate non-cooperation but would carry on the movement by other means, opening a new front. In a time of political vacuum, council work would keep up the morale of the masses, and the entry of nationalists would stop the government stuffing the councils with undesirable elements who could give legitimacy to its measures. The councils were to be an arena of struggle and not organs for gradual transformation of colonial rule.

The No-Changers argued that parliamentary work would lead to neglect of constructive work, loss of revolutionary zeal and political corruption, and that constructive work would prepare people for the next phase of civil disobedience.

How Was the Split Avoided?

Both sides wanted to avoid a split like that of 1907, and kept in touch with Gandhi in jail. Both realised the importance of a united front to force the government to introduce reforms, and both accepted that Gandhi should lead a united nationalist front. A compromise was reached at a meeting in Delhi in September 1923.

Term Detail
Swarajists Allowed to contest elections as a group within the Congress
Programme They accepted the Congress programme, with the one difference that they would join legislative councils
Elections To the new Central Legislative Assembly and provincial councils in November 1923

The earlier split is described in Surat Split, 1907. As an analytical point, the compromise worked because both sides accepted a shared leader and a shared goal and differed only on a method, which is why they could reunite later whenever a new struggle was due.

What Did the Swarajist Manifesto Say?

Released in October 1923, the Swarajist manifesto took a strongly anti-imperialist line.

Point Content
British motive The guiding motive of the British in governing India lay in selfish interests of their own country
Reforms The so-called reforms were a blind to further those interests while pretending to grant responsible government, the real objective being to continue exploiting India’s resources and keep Indians subservient
Demand The Swarajists would present the nationalist demand for self-government in the councils
Obstruction If rejected, a policy of uniform, continuous and consistent obstruction within the councils to make governance through them impossible
Method Wreck the councils from within by creating deadlocks on every measure

How Did Gandhi’s Attitude Change?

Gandhi was at first opposed to council entry. After his release from prison on health grounds in February 1924, he moved gradually towards reconciliation. He felt that public opposition to council entry would be counter-productive. In the November 1923 elections the Swarajists had won 42 of 141 elected seats and a clear majority in the provincial assembly of the Central Provinces; in the legislatures, in cooperation with the Liberals and independents like Jinnah and Malaviya, they won a majority. Their courageous and uncompromising conduct convinced him that they would not become another limb of colonial administration.

A government crackdown on revolutionary terrorists and the Swarajists towards the end of 1924 angered Gandhi, and he expressed solidarity by surrendering to their wishes. The two sides reached an agreement in 1924, endorsed at the Belgaum session in December 1924, which Gandhi presided over, the only time he did so, that the Swarajists would work in the councils as an integral part of the Congress. What the Swarajists did in the councils is in Swarajist Activity in the Councils and the No-Changers’ Constructive Work.

What Did the Swarajists Achieve in the Councils?

With coalition partners the Swarajists outvoted the government several times, even on budgetary grants, and passed adjournment motions. They spoke powerfully on self-government, civil liberties and industrialisation.

Achievement Detail
Outvoting the government Several times, with coalition partners, including on budgetary grants
Speeches On self-government, civil liberties and industrialisation
Speaker Vithalbhai Patel was elected Speaker of the Central Legislative Assembly in 1925
Public Safety Bill Defeated in 1928; it aimed to deport undesirable and subversive foreigners, as the government was alarmed by socialist and communist ideas and Comintern-sent activists
Political vacuum Filled it while the national movement recouped its strength
Montford scheme Exposed its hollowness
Creative use Showed that the councils could be used creatively

What Were the Swarajists’ Drawbacks?

  • They lacked a policy to coordinate their militancy inside the legislatures with the mass struggle outside and relied on newspaper reports to reach the public.
  • An obstructionist strategy had its limits.
  • They could not go far with coalition partners because of conflicting ideas.
  • They failed to resist the perks and privileges of power and office.
  • They did not support the peasants’ cause in Bengal and lost support among pro-peasant Muslim members.

Why Did the Swarajist Position Weaken?

The Swarajist position weakened because of widespread communal riots and a split among the Swarajists on communal and Responsivist versus Non-responsivist lines. The government strategy of dividing the more militant from the moderate and Hindus from Muslims was successful. The Swarajists lost many Muslim supporters when the party did not back the tenants against zamindars in Bengal, where most tenants were Muslims. Communal interests also entered the party, and the death of C.R. Das in 1925 weakened it further.

The Responsivists among the Swarajists, Lala Lajpat Rai, Madan Mohan Malaviya and N.C. Kelkar, advocated cooperation with the government and holding office wherever possible, and also wanted to protect so-called Hindu interests. Communal elements accused leaders such as Motilal Nehru, who did not favour joining the council, of being anti-Hindu, while Muslim communalists called the Swarajists anti-Muslim.

Date Event
March 1926 The main Swarajist leadership reiterated faith in mass civil disobedience and withdrew from the legislatures
1926 elections Another section contested as a party in disarray; won 40 seats at the Centre and some in Madras, but was routed in the United Provinces, Central Provinces and Punjab
1930 The Swarajists walked out after the Lahore Congress resolution on purna swaraj and the start of Civil Disobedience

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Method debate Council entry versus constructive work is a favourite Mains theme
  • Party details Names, dates and leaders are stock Prelims facts
  • Constitutional route Links to the use of councils by nationalists

What Came Next?

Next topic: Muddiman Committee (1924).

Key People and Terms

  • Swarajists Those who advocated council entry
  • No-Changers Those who opposed council entry and favoured constructive work
  • End or mend The Swarajist plan to reform or wreck the councils
  • Gaya session Congress session of December 1922 where the Swarajist proposal was defeated
  • Swarajist Party Congress-Khilafat Swarajya Party, with C.R. Das as president

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Gaya session: December 1922; Swarajist Party formed; Das president, Motilal Nehru secretary.
  • Delhi compromise: September 1923; manifesto: October 1923.
  • Elections of November 1923: 42 of 141 elected seats.
  • Gandhi released February 1924; Belgaum December 1924.
  • No-Changers: Rajagopalachari, Patel, Prasad, Ansari.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Swarajists and No-Changers Council entry versus constructive work
  • End or mend and obstruction Mend if the government responded; obstruct if not
  • Gaya and Belgaum Gaya: proposal defeated, party formed; Belgaum: agreement endorsed

Memory Hook

Das and Nehru wanted in, Rajaji and Patel wanted out, Gandhi finally blessed both.

Mains Angle

Questions ask about the arguments of the two groups and the compromise. These points add depth.

  • Swarajist case Another front of the movement
  • No-Changer case Danger of corruption and neglect of mass work
  • Unity Delhi compromise and Belgaum

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Compare the views of the Swarajists and the No-Changers and explain how the differences between them were resolved.”

How to Answer

  1. Context Passive phase after 1922.
  2. Compare Arguments of each school.
  3. Resolution Delhi compromise, manifesto and Belgaum.
  4. Conclude Unity on goal despite differences of method.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929). GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who were the Swarajists and the No-Changers?

After the withdrawal of non-cooperation, the Swarajists, led by C.R. Das, Motilal Nehru and Ajmal Khan, wanted to enter the legislative councils. The No-Changers, led by C. Rajagopalachari, Vallabhbhai Patel, Rajendra Prasad and M.A. Ansari, opposed council entry and favoured constructive work.

How was the Swarajist Party formed?

At the Gaya session in December 1922 the Swarajist proposal to end or mend the councils was defeated. C.R. Das and Motilal Nehru resigned as Congress president and secretary and formed the Congress-Khilafat Swarajya Party, with Das as president and Motilal Nehru as a secretary.

What was the Delhi compromise of 1923?

In September 1923 a meeting in Delhi allowed the Swarajists to contest elections as a group within the Congress. They accepted the Congress programme with one difference, that they would join the legislative councils, in the elections of November 1923.

What did the Swarajist manifesto of 1923 promise?

Released in October 1923, it said the British governed India for selfish reasons and the reforms were a blind. It promised to present the demand for self-government in the councils and, if rejected, to obstruct them continuously and consistently to make governance impossible.

How did Gandhi's attitude to the Swarajists change?

Gandhi first opposed council entry. After release in February 1924, he saw that opposition would be counter-productive and that the Swarajists were not becoming part of colonial administration. A crackdown at the end of 1924 angered him, and the Belgaum session in December 1924 agreed they would work in councils as part of the Congress.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Swarajist Party was formed after the Gaya session of December 1922.
True

C.R. Das was president and Motilal Nehru a secretary.

2 The No-Changers favoured entry into the legislative councils.
False

They opposed council entry and favoured constructive work.

3 The Swarajists won 42 of 141 elected seats in the November 1923 elections.
True

They also won a majority in the Central Provinces assembly.

4 Gandhi presided over the Belgaum session of the Congress in December 1924.
True

It was the only time he presided.

5 The Swarajist plan was to end or mend the councils.
True

They would obstruct the councils if the government did not respond.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Indian National Movement – II (1918-1929). UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: