An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 12.10

Government of India Act, 1935 – Provincial Autonomy

Modern History › Administrative Changes After 1857 · Topic 12.10

The Government of India Act, passed by the British Parliament in August 1935, proposed an all-India federation that never came into being, a bicameral Centre with reserved and transferred subjects, and provincial autonomy in place of dyarchy. Nearly all sections condemned it and the Congress rejected it unanimously, demanding a Constituent Assembly elected on adult franchise.

Share:
Government of India Act, 1935 – Provincial Autonomy - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Passed August 1935 by the British Parliament
  • Federation Proposed but never formed; the conditions were not met
  • Provinces Autonomy replaced dyarchy
  • Congress response Rejected; demanded a Constituent Assembly on adult franchise
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Administrative Changes After 1857

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 12.10 of the category “Administrative Changes After 1857”. Previous topic: Lee Commission (1924).

What Did the Act Provide in the Provinces?

Provincial autonomy replaced dyarchy. Provinces gained autonomy and a separate legal identity, were freed from the superintendence and direction of the Secretary of State and the Governor-General, derived their legal authority directly from the Crown, and were given independent financial powers, including the power to borrow on their own security. Dyarchy is in Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms and the Government of India Act, 1919.

Feature Detail
Governor The Crown’s nominee, with special powers on minorities, civil servants’ rights, law and order, British business interests, partially excluded areas and princely states; could take over and run the administration indefinitely
Electorates Separate electorates based on the Communal Award to be made operational
Legislature All members directly elected; franchise extended, with women voting on the same basis as men
Ministers Administered all provincial subjects in a council of ministers under a premier, answerable to the legislature
Budget 40 per cent still not votable
Governor’s powers Refuse assent to bills, promulgate ordinances and enact governor’s Acts

The Communal Award is in Communal Award, 1932.

How Was the Act Evaluated?

The numerous safeguards and special responsibilities of the Governor-General worked as brakes on the Act. The governor in the provinces still held extensive powers. The Act enfranchised 14 per cent of the British Indian population. The extension of communal electorates and the representation of different interests encouraged separatist tendencies, which are said to have culminated in the partition of India. The Act gave a rigid constitution with no scope for internal growth, since the right of amendment stayed with the British Parliament.

Three comments are recorded. Lord Linlithgow, Viceroy from 1936 to 1943, said that the Act was framed as the best way to maintain British influence in India. Nehru said that the country had been provided with a car with all brakes and no engine. The scholar B.R. Tomlinson said that constitutional advance in India was determined by the need to attract Indian collaborators to the Raj.

How Did Nationalists Respond?

The Act was condemned by nearly all sections and unanimously rejected by the Congress. The Hindu Mahasabha and the National Liberal Federation, however, declared themselves in favour of working the Act at the Centre and in the provinces. The Congress instead demanded a Constituent Assembly elected on adult franchise to frame a constitution for independent India. As an analytical point, the Act met a demand for provincial autonomy while denying the demand for a responsible Centre, so the Congress could reject its form while still contesting its provincial elections, as shown in Congress in the 1937 Elections. The Nehru Report that had earlier asked for a responsible Centre is in Nehru Report, 1928.

How Did Provincial Autonomy Work?

Under the Act of 1935, elections were held in 1936 and 1937 and the Congress formed ministries in seven provinces. The ministers controlled all provincial subjects, and the Governor kept special responsibilities for law and order, minorities and the services. Provincial autonomy worked from April 1937 until the resignation of the Congress ministries in 1939, and it gave Indians their first real experience of government at the provincial level.

How Did the Act Come About?

The Third Round Table Conference was held in November 1932, again without the Congress, in the midst of the struggle, and its discussions led to the formulation of the Act of 1935. The Act was passed by the British Parliament in August 1935. The conferences are in Third Round Table Conference and the Resumption of Civil Disobedience.

What Was the Proposed All-India Federation?

The federation was to comprise all British Indian provinces, all chief commissioners’ provinces and the Indian states. It was conditional on two requirements: states with an allotment of 52 seats in the proposed Council of States should agree to join, and the aggregate population of such states should be 50 per cent of the total population of all Indian states. These conditions were not fulfilled, so the federation never came into being, and the central government carried on until 1946 under the provisions of the 1919 Act.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Features The Act is a major Prelims topic with many numbers and provisions
  • Link to the Constitution Many provisions were carried into later constitutional structures
  • Evaluation Nehru’s and Linlithgow’s views are Mains quotations

What Came Next?

Next topic: Evolution of the Indian Civil Service – Role of Cornwallis and Wellesley.

Key People and Terms

  • All-India Federation The proposed union of provinces and princely states
  • Provincial autonomy Self-government in the provinces replacing dyarchy
  • Concurrent list Subjects on which both Centre and provinces could legislate
  • Governor’s Acts Laws enacted by the governor in his special powers
  • Residuary powers Powers not listed, held by the Governor-General
  • Constituent Assembly The elected body the Congress demanded

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Passed August 1935; federation never formed.
  • Council of States 260; Federal Assembly 375.
  • 80 per cent of the central budget non-votable; 40 per cent of the provincial budget.
  • Enfranchised 14 per cent of the population.
  • Nehru: a car with all brakes and no engine.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Dyarchy and provincial autonomy 1919: dyarchy in provinces; 1935: autonomy in provinces
  • Centre and provinces Centre: reserved and transferred subjects; provinces: ministers for all subjects
  • Mahasabha and Congress responses The Mahasabha and Liberals would work the Act; the Congress rejected it

Memory Hook

Autonomy below, brakes above, and a federation that never came.

Mains Angle

Questions ask about the features and the criticism of the Act. These points add depth.

  • Provinces Autonomy with governor’s powers
  • Centre Federation that never formed; reserved subjects
  • British aim Integrating the national movement

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Examine the main features of the Government of India Act, 1935 and explain why the nationalists rejected it.”

How to Answer

  1. Features Federation, Centre and provinces.
  2. Limits Safeguards and special powers.
  3. Aim British strategy.
  4. Conclude Congress demand for a Constituent Assembly.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Administrative Changes After 1857. GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Government of India Act, 1935?

The Government of India Act was passed by the British Parliament in August 1935 after the Round Table discussions. It proposed an all-India federation, a bicameral Centre with reserved and transferred subjects, and provincial autonomy replacing dyarchy, but it kept many safeguards in the hands of the Governor-General.

Why was the all-India federation never formed?

The federation depended on states with 52 seats in the proposed Council of States agreeing to join and on their population being half of the total population of Indian states. These conditions were not met, so the Centre ran under the 1919 Act until 1946.

What did the Act of 1935 provide for the provinces?

It replaced dyarchy with provincial autonomy. Provinces were given a separate legal identity, financial powers and the right to borrow, with elected legislatures and ministers answerable to them, though governors kept special powers and 40 per cent of the budget was non-votable.

How did nationalists view the Act of 1935?

The Congress unanimously rejected it and nearly all sections condemned it. Nehru said it was a car with all brakes and no engine. The Hindu Mahasabha and National Liberal Federation were willing to work it, and the Congress demanded a Constituent Assembly on adult franchise.

What was the long-term British strategy behind the Act?

The British hoped to weaken the national movement and absorb large parts of it into the colonial constitutional structure. Reforms would revive liberals, convince Congressmen that extra-legal struggle failed, divide the Congress, and create strong provincial leaders to provincialise the Congress.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Government of India Act of 1935 introduced provincial autonomy.
True

It replaced dyarchy in the provinces.

2 The federation proposed by the Act of 1935 came into being.
False

The conditions for the princely states to join were not met.

3 The Act of 1935 enfranchised about 14 per cent of the British Indian population.
True

Women got the vote on the same basis as men.

4 The Congress accepted the Act of 1935.
False

It unanimously rejected it.

5 Under the Act, defence and foreign affairs were reserved subjects at the Centre.
True

The Governor-General administered them.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Administrative Changes After 1857. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: