Statutory Civil Service (1878)
Modern History › Administrative Changes After 1857 · Topic 12.12
The Indian Civil Service Act of 1861 reserved certain offices for covenanted civil servants, with an examination held in England, in English, on Greek and Latin learning, and a maximum age cut from 23 in 1859 to 19 in 1878. Satyendra Nath Tagore qualified in 1863. Lytton's Statutory Civil Service of 1878-79 failed, and the Aitchison Committee of 1886 recommended a three-tier service but the demand for simultaneous examinations was never implemented.
5 min read · UPSC Prelims · History · Administrative Changes After 1857
At a Glance
- ICS Act 1861; examination in London, in English
- First Indian Satyendra Nath Tagore, 1863
- Statutory Civil Service Lytton, 1878-79; one-sixth of covenanted posts; failed
- Aitchison Committee 1886; Imperial, Provincial and Subordinate services
- Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Administrative Changes After 1857
Where Does It Fit?
This is topic 12.12 of the category “Administrative Changes After 1857”. Previous topic: Evolution of the Indian Civil Service – Role of Cornwallis and Wellesley.
What Was the Statutory Civil Service?
In 1878-79 Lytton introduced the Statutory Civil Service, in which one-sixth of the covenanted posts were to be filled by Indians of high families, nominated by local governments subject to the approval of the Secretary of State and the Viceroy. The system failed and was abolished.
What Was the Statutory Civil Service?
The Statutory Civil Service was created in 1878-79 under Lytton, who wished to give some posts in the covenanted service to Indians of good family by nomination, in the face of their exclusion by the lowered age limit of 1876. One-sixth of the covenanted posts were to be filled by Indians of high birth nominated by the local governments. The scheme failed to satisfy Indians, since it was by patronage, and it was wound up in 1891 after the Aitchison Commission.
Why Did the Scheme Fail?
The statutory civilians were paid less than the covenanted men and were generally held inferior. The nominations favoured the families of landlords and officials, not the educated middle class, and the scheme was criticised as a means of buying loyalty. The Indian Association and the Congress asked instead for simultaneous examinations in India and England.
What Did the Indian Civil Service Act of 1861 Provide?
The Act reserved certain offices for covenanted civil servants. The examination was held in England, in the English language, and was based on classical learning in Greek and Latin. The maximum permissible age was gradually reduced.
| Year | Maximum age |
|---|---|
| 1859 | 23 |
| 1860 | 22 |
| 1866 | 21 |
| 1878 | 19 |
In 1863 Satyendra Nath Tagore became the first Indian to qualify for the Indian Civil Service. The earlier exclusion of Indians is in Evolution of the Civil Services: Cornwallis to the Charter Act of 1853.
What Did the Congress Demand and What Did the Aitchison Committee Recommend?
After its foundation in 1885, the Indian National Congress demanded a lower age limit for recruitment and the holding of the examination simultaneously in India and Britain. The Aitchison Committee on Public Services, set up in 1886 by Dufferin, made recommendations.
| Recommendation | Detail |
|---|---|
| Terms | Drop the terms covenanted and uncovenanted |
| Classification | Imperial Indian Civil Service (examination in England), Provincial Civil Service (examination in India) and Subordinate Civil Service (examination in India) |
| Age | Raise the age limit to 23 |
In 1893 the House of Commons passed a resolution in support of holding the examination simultaneously in India and England, but it was never implemented. The Secretary of State, Kimberley, said that it was indispensable that an adequate number of civil service members should always be Europeans. The Congress’s early demands are in Evaluation of the Early Nationalists.
As an analytical point, the pattern of the 1860s to the 1890s is that every reform addressed the form of entry but kept its main condition: the cost and place of the examination, the Greek and Latin syllabus and the falling age limit meant that very few Indians could compete, while the nominated Statutory Service was dropped when it did not suit British interests. The later reforms are in Dyarchy: reserved and transferred subjects Centre Bicameral…">Montford Reforms, Lee Commission and Evaluation of the Civil Services.
Why Did the Age Limit Matter?
Lowering the maximum age from 23 to 19 made it hard for Indian candidates, who had to learn the English language and classical subjects and then travel to London for the examination, to compete with British candidates who had trained for it at school. A young Indian candidate had also to bear the cost of travel and stay abroad. The age was thus a barrier even though the examination was in principle open to all British subjects, which is why the Congress made its reduction one of its first demands.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Barriers to Indians The age limit and place of the exam are Prelims facts
- Statutory Civil Service A frequently asked failed experiment
- Aitchison Committee Its three-tier classification is a stock Mains point
What Came Next?
Next topic: Evolution of the Police System Under British Rule.
Key People and Terms
- ICS The Indian Civil Service
- Statutory Civil Service Lytton’s nominated service of 1878-79
- Aitchison Committee The 1886 committee on public services
- Simultaneous examination Holding the examination in India and England at the same time
- Covenanted The higher service reserved for the Company’s covenanted servants
- Kimberley Secretary of State who said Europeans must always be adequate
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- ICS Act 1861: exam in London, in English, with Greek and Latin.
- Age limit 23 (1859) to 19 (1878).
- Satyendra Nath Tagore qualified in 1863.
- Aitchison Committee 1886: Imperial, Provincial, Subordinate.
- Commons resolution of 1893 on simultaneous examination never implemented.
Do Not Confuse With
- Statutory Civil Service and the ICS Statutory was nominated; ICS was by examination
- Aitchison Committee and Lee Commission 1886 versus 1924
- Imperial and Provincial service Imperial examination in England; provincial examination in India
Memory Hook
Age down, exam in London, Greek and Latin: the gate was open in law and closed in practice.
Mains Angle
Questions ask about the Indianisation of the civil service. These points add depth.
- Barriers Examination place, syllabus and age
- Experiments Statutory Civil Service
- Reform proposals Aitchison and the Commons resolution
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Examine the obstacles faced by Indians in entering the Indian Civil Service in the second half of the nineteenth century.”
How to Answer
- ICS Act Examination conditions.
- Age limit Falling maximum age.
- Reforms Statutory Civil Service and Aitchison.
- Conclude Resistance to simultaneous exams.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Indian Civil Service Act of 1861 provide?
The Act reserved certain offices for covenanted civil servants, with the examination held in England, in English and based on Greek and Latin learning. The maximum age was reduced from 23 in 1859 to 22 in 1860, 21 in 1866 and 19 in 1878.
Who was the first Indian to qualify for the ICS?
Satyendra Nath Tagore became the first Indian to qualify for the Indian Civil Service in 1863, though entry remained very difficult for Indians because of the examination place, language, classical syllabus and falling age limit.
What was the Statutory Civil Service?
Lytton introduced it in 1878-79, reserving one-sixth of covenanted posts for Indians of high families nominated by local governments, subject to approval by the Secretary of State and the Viceroy. The system failed and was abolished.
What did the Aitchison Committee recommend?
The Aitchison Committee of 1886 recommended dropping the terms covenanted and uncovenanted, dividing the service into Imperial, Provincial and Subordinate services, with the Imperial examination in England and the others in India, and raising the age limit to 23.
What happened to the demand for simultaneous examinations?
The Congress demanded examinations simultaneously in India and Britain. In 1893 the House of Commons passed a resolution supporting it, but it was never implemented, and Secretary of State Kimberley said an adequate number of civil servants must always be Europeans.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The ICS examination under the Act of 1861 was held in England.
It was in English and tested Greek and Latin.
2 Satyendra Nath Tagore qualified for the ICS in 1863.
He was the first Indian to do so.
3 Lytton's Statutory Civil Service was a lasting success.
It failed and was abolished.
4 The Aitchison Committee was set up in 1886 by Dufferin.
It recommended three classes of service.
5 The 1893 Commons resolution on simultaneous examinations was implemented.
It was never implemented.
Past Mains Questions on This Topic
This topic comes under Administrative Changes After 1857. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:
Related Topics
Browse the full Modern History index