Government of India Act, 1935: Constitutional Provisions
Modern History › Constitutional Development · Topic 11.12
The Government of India Act of 1935 provided for an all-India federation of provinces and princely states, which was never set up, provincial autonomy with responsible ministers, which came into force in April 1937, dyarchy at the Centre, three legislative lists, a Federal Court and public service commissions. It formed the base of the Constitution of independent India.
5 min read · UPSC Prelims · History · Constitutional Development
At a Glance
- Year 1935
- Provinces Autonomy from 1 April 1937
- Federation Never established
- Court Federal Court, 1937
- Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Constitutional Development
Where Does It Fit?
This is topic 11.12 of the category “Constitutional Development”. The Government of India Act of 1935 is the longest and last big constitutional Act before independence. Its constitutional provisions are covered here, while its political reception is described under the national movement. Previous topic: Government of India Act, 1919 (Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms).
How Did the Simon Commission and the Act of 1935 Follow?
The 1919 Act provided for a Royal Commission after ten years, and in November 1927, two years early, the Indian Statutory Commission was announced. It reported in 1930, recommending abolition of dyarchy, extension of responsible government in the provinces, a federation of British India and the princely states, and continued communal electorates. Three Round Table Conferences were held, a White Paper was published in March 1933, a Joint Committee under Lord Linlithgow reported in 1934 that a federation would be formed if at least 50 per cent of the princely states were ready to join, and the bill became the Government of India Act of 1935. The Commission is in Recommendations of the Simon Commission.
| Feature of the Act of 1935 | Detail |
|---|---|
| Size | 451 clauses and 15 schedules |
| Federation | An All-India Federation of governors’ provinces, chief commissioners’ provinces and acceding states, each ruler signing an instrument of accession |
| Centre | Dyarchy in the federal executive; bicameral federal legislature of a permanent Council of States and a Federal Legislative Assembly; joint sitting for deadlock; three lists; residuary powers at the Governor-General’s discretion; veto by the Governor-General and disallowance by the King-in-Council |
| Provinces | Dyarchy abolished and autonomy given; reserved and transferred distinction ended; powers from the Crown directly; independent finances and borrowing; bicameral legislatures in six provinces, Madras, Bombay, Bengal, the United Provinces, Bihar and Assam, and unicameral in five |
| Electorates | Communal electorates and weightage extended to depressed classes, women and labour; about 10 per cent of the population got the vote |
| Courts | A Federal Court established in 1937, dominated by the Privy Council in London |
| Council of the Secretary of State | Abolished |
The All-India Federation never came into being because of opposition from different parties; provincial autonomy began on 1 April 1937, the Centre continued under the 1919 Act with minor amendments, and the operative part of the 1935 Act remained in force until 15 August 1947. The Act was an endeavour to give India a written constitution, though Indians were not involved in it, and a step towards complete responsible government. But it gave a rigid constitution, with the right of amendment reserved for the British Parliament, and the extension of communal electorates promoted separatist tendencies culminating in the partition of India. It was condemned by nearly all sections and unanimously rejected by the Congress. The Act and the nationalist response are in Nationalist Response to the Government of India Act, 1935.As an analytical point, each Act was a response to pressure, from the Congress in 1892, from the war and the nationalist movement in 1919 and from the Civil Disobedience Movement and the Round Table Conferences in 1935, and each gave less than was asked, which is why the sequence shows a steady widening of Indian participation without a transfer of power.
What Were the Main Features of the Act of 1935?
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Federation | An all-India federation of provinces and princely states, never established |
| Provinces | Provincial autonomy with responsible ministers; dyarchy ended |
| Centre | Dyarchy introduced at the Centre |
| Lists | Federal, provincial and concurrent lists |
| Federal Court | Set up in 1937 |
| Reserve Bank | Set up in 1935 |
| Services | Federal and provincial Public Service Commissions |
| Separation | Burma and Aden separated; Sind and Orissa made provinces |
What Did the Indian Councils Act of 1861 Do?
The 1861 Act marked an advance in that the principle of non-official representatives in legislative bodies was accepted. Laws were to be made after deliberation, and being legislation they could be changed only by the same deliberative process, so law-making was no longer the exclusive business of the executive. The portfolio system introduced by Lord Canning laid the foundations of cabinet government in India, with each branch having an official head and spokesman responsible for it. By vesting legislative powers in the governments of Bombay and Madras and providing for similar councils in other provinces, the Act laid the foundations of legislative devolution. But the councils had no real powers: they could not discuss important matters or any financial matters without prior approval, had no control over the budget, could not discuss executive action, the Viceroy’s approval was needed, and the Secretary of State could disallow a law. The Indians associated were from elite sections only. The council’s structure is in Major Administrative Changes After 1857: Central and Provincial Government.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Provisions of each Act A major Prelims topic
- Pattern of limited reform A standard Mains framework
- Link to partition Communal electorates are seen as contributing to separatism
What Came Next?
Next topic: Indian Independence Act, 1947: Constitutional Provisions.
Key People and Terms
- Provincial autonomy Responsible ministers in provinces
- Federation Union of provinces and states
- Federal Court Court of 1937
- Concurrent list Subjects shared by both
- Governor’s special powers Reserved powers
- Instrument of Accession Document for a state to join
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Passed in 1935.
- Provincial autonomy from 1937.
- Federation never formed.
- Three lists.
- Federal Court.
Do Not Confuse With
- 1892 and 1909 Acts 1892 added representation; 1909 added separate electorates
- 1919 and 1935 dyarchy 1919: dyarchy in provinces; 1935: dyarchy proposed in the federal executive
- Federation proposed and federation formed Never formed
Memory Hook
Non-officials in 1861, questions in 1892, electorates in 1909, dyarchy in 1919, autonomy in 1935.
Mains Angle
Questions ask about the stages of constitutional development. These points add depth.
- Councils Slow expansion
- Electorates Communal principle
- Limits Executive power retained
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Trace the constitutional development from 1861 to 1935 and assess its limits.”
How to Answer
- Early Acts 1861, 1892 and 1909.
- 1919 Dyarchy and its failure.
- 1935 Autonomy and federation.
- Conclude Reform without transfer of power.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the Government of India Act of 1935?
The Government of India Act of 1935 provided for provincial autonomy and an all-India federation, introduced dyarchy at the Centre and set up a Federal Court, and its provincial part came into force in April 1937.
Why was the federation never established?
The federation was never established because the princes would not agree to join in the numbers required, and then the Second World War began. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1935: Constitutional Provisions" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
What was provincial autonomy?
Provincial autonomy meant that the provinces were governed by ministers responsible to elected legislatures, with the Governor keeping some special powers, and it replaced dyarchy in the provinces. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1935: Constitutional Provisions" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
What were the three lists?
The Act divided legislative powers into a federal list, a provincial list and a concurrent list, which the Constitution of India later followed in its Seventh Schedule. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1935: Constitutional Provisions" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
How did the Act influence the Constitution of India?
Many provisions of the Constitution of India, such as the federal structure, the lists of powers, the Federal Court and public service commissions, were taken from the Act of 1935. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1935: Constitutional Provisions" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The Government of India Act was passed in 1935.
Provincial autonomy began in 1937.
2 The federation was set up soon after.
It was never set up.
3 It established a Federal Court.
In 1937.
4 It introduced dyarchy in the provinces.
It ended it there.
5 It created three legislative lists.
Federal, provincial and concurrent.
Past Mains Questions on This Topic
This topic comes under Constitutional Development. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:
Related Topics
Browse the full Modern History index