Government of India Act, 1919 (Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms)
Modern History › Constitutional Development · Topic 11.11
The Government of India Act of 1919, based on the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, introduced dyarchy in the provinces, with transferred subjects under Indian ministers and reserved subjects under the Governor. It set up a bicameral central legislature of a Council of State and a Legislative Assembly, extended communal electorates, separated the central and provincial budgets and created a High Commissioner for India in London.
5 min read · UPSC Prelims · History · Constitutional Development
At a Glance
- Year 1919
- System Dyarchy in the provinces
- Centre Council of State and Legislative Assembly
- Based on Montagu-Chelmsford Report
- Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Constitutional Development
Where Does It Fit?
This is topic 11.11 of the category “Constitutional Development”. The Government of India Act of 1919 follows the Montagu-Chelmsford Report and the August Declaration of 1917, and it is replaced by the Government of India Act of 1935. Previous topic: Indian Councils Act, 1909 (Morley-Minto Reforms).
What Did the Government of India Act of 1919 Do?
The Act of 1919 was based on the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms. In August 1917 the British government declared for the first time that its objective was the gradual introduction of responsible government in India as an integral part of the Empire. The Act made it clear that development of self-governing institutions would be gradual and that the British Parliament, and not the self-determination of the Indian people, would decide the time and manner of each step.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Centre | The Imperial Legislative Council was replaced by a bicameral legislature of a Council of State and a Legislative Assembly, each with a majority of directly elected members; the franchise was restricted by property, tax or education |
| Communal electorates | Extended to Sikhs, Christians and Anglo-Indians besides Muslims |
| Provinces | Dyarchy, a substantial step towards transfer of power; unicameral provincial legislatures |
| Budgets | Provincial and central budgets were separated for the first time |
| High Commissioner | Appointed in London for six years to look after Indian trade in Europe |
| Secretary of State | To be paid from the British Exchequer, undoing an injustice of the Charter Act of 1793 |
Indian leaders got some administrative experience, but the demand for responsible government was not met, and the structure stayed unitary and centralised; dyarchy in the provinces failed. The Central Legislature, for the first time with the power to vote supplies, could not replace the government and was limited by the Governor-General’s powers to veto bills, reserve them for the monarch and secure laws he thought essential. Subhash Kashyap observes that the legislature was a non-sovereign law-making body, powerless before the executive. The Act is in Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms and the Government of India Act, 1919.
How Did Dyarchy Work in the Provinces?
| Transferred subjects | Reserved subjects |
|---|---|
| Education, local self-government, health, public works, agriculture, excise | Law and order, police, finance, land revenue, irrigation, justice |
| Under Indian ministers responsible to the legislature | Under the Governor and his Executive Council, not responsible to the legislature |
The Governor could override the ministers and kept the control of finance, so that the ministers had little power. The system worked for about eighteen years and was ended by the Act of 1935.
What Did the Indian Councils Act of 1861 Do?
The 1861 Act marked an advance in that the principle of non-official representatives in legislative bodies was accepted. Laws were to be made after deliberation, and being legislation they could be changed only by the same deliberative process, so law-making was no longer the exclusive business of the executive. The portfolio system introduced by Lord Canning laid the foundations of cabinet government in India, with each branch having an official head and spokesman responsible for it. By vesting legislative powers in the governments of Bombay and Madras and providing for similar councils in other provinces, the Act laid the foundations of legislative devolution. But the councils had no real powers: they could not discuss important matters or any financial matters without prior approval, had no control over the budget, could not discuss executive action, the Viceroy’s approval was needed, and the Secretary of State could disallow a law. The Indians associated were from elite sections only. The council’s structure is in Major Administrative Changes After 1857: Central and Provincial Government.
What Did the Indian Councils Act of 1892 Do?
The Congress, founded in 1885, saw council reform as the root of all other reforms. In response to its demand for expansion, the Act of 1892 increased the number of non-official members in the central and provincial legislative councils.
- The Legislative Council of the Governor-General was enlarged.
- Universities, district boards, municipalities, zamindars, trade bodies and chambers of commerce were empowered to recommend members to the provincial councils, introducing the principle of representation.
- The word election was firmly avoided, but an element of indirect election was accepted in choosing some non-official members.
- Members could comment on financial statements, to be made on the floor of the legislatures.
- They could put questions within limits to the executive on matters of public interest after six days’ notice.
The 1892 Act is also in Indian Councils Act of 1892, discussed with the early nationalists.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Provisions of each Act A major Prelims topic
- Pattern of limited reform A standard Mains framework
- Link to partition Communal electorates are seen as contributing to separatism
What Came Next?
Next topic: Government of India Act, 1935: Constitutional Provisions.
Key People and Terms
- Dyarchy Rule by two authorities
- Transferred subjects Under Indian ministers
- Reserved subjects Under the Governor
- Council of State Upper house
- Legislative Assembly Lower house
- High Commissioner Indian representative in London
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Passed in 1919.
- Dyarchy in provinces.
- Bicameral Centre.
- High Commissioner in London.
- Statutory Commission after ten years.
Do Not Confuse With
- 1892 and 1909 Acts 1892 added representation; 1909 added separate electorates
- 1919 and 1935 dyarchy 1919: dyarchy in provinces; 1935: dyarchy proposed in the federal executive
- Federation proposed and federation formed Never formed
Memory Hook
Non-officials in 1861, questions in 1892, electorates in 1909, dyarchy in 1919, autonomy in 1935.
Mains Angle
Questions ask about the stages of constitutional development. These points add depth.
- Councils Slow expansion
- Electorates Communal principle
- Limits Executive power retained
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Trace the constitutional development from 1861 to 1935 and assess its limits.”
How to Answer
- Early Acts 1861, 1892 and 1909.
- 1919 Dyarchy and its failure.
- 1935 Autonomy and federation.
- Conclude Reform without transfer of power.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What was dyarchy?
Dyarchy was the system under the Act of 1919 by which provincial subjects were divided into transferred subjects, under Indian ministers, and reserved subjects, under the Governor and his Council. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1919 (Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms)" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
What did the Act of 1919 provide at the Centre?
The Act created a bicameral central legislature, with a Council of State and a Legislative Assembly, each with an elected majority, though the executive was not responsible to it. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1919 (Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms)" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
What was the office of High Commissioner?
The Act created the post of High Commissioner for India in London, appointed for six years, to look after Indian trade and some of the work formerly done by the Secretary of State. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1919 (Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms)" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
Why did dyarchy fail?
Dyarchy failed because the ministers had little control over finance, the Governor could override them and the division of subjects was artificial and unworkable. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1919 (Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms)" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
When was a review of the Act due?
The Act provided for a Statutory Commission to be appointed after ten years, and the Simon Commission was appointed in 1927, two years earlier than needed. This answer belongs to the topic "Government of India Act, 1919 (Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms)" in the macro "Constitutional Development".
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The Act of 1919 introduced dyarchy.
In the provinces.
2 Education was a reserved subject.
It was transferred.
3 The Act created a bicameral Centre.
Council of State and Assembly.
4 It introduced provincial autonomy.
That was in 1935.
5 It created a High Commissioner.
In London.
Past Mains Questions on This Topic
This topic comes under Constitutional Development. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:
Related Topics
Browse the full Modern History index