An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 13.6

Data Sufficiency Cases Where Data in Neither Statement Is Sufficient

Reasoning › Data Sufficiency (Reasoning-Based) · Topic 13.6

Data in neither statement is sufficient when, even after combining both, more than one answer is still possible or a needed fact is missing. The reliable way to prove this is the two-worlds test: build two different situations that both satisfy every given statement but give different answers to the question. If two such situations exist, the data are insufficient and the key is option E.

Share:
Data Sufficiency Cases Where Data in Neither Statement Is Sufficient - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Data in neither statement is sufficient when, even after combining both, more than one answer is still possible or a needed fact is missing. The reliable way to prove this is the two-worlds test: build two different situations that both satisfy every given statement but give different answers to the question. If two such situations exist, the data are insufficient and the key is option E.

At a Glance

  • Key Option E in the common key
  • Proof method Two situations, same statements, different answers
  • Common causes Missing link, range, two values, irrelevant facts
  • Not E If together they give one answer, it is D
  • Trap Assuming a convenient case
  • Habit Try to break the answer, not confirm it

Where Does It Fit?

This is the sixth topic of the Data Sufficiency (Reasoning-Based) macro. It completes the five-outcome method of Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice by studying the outcome where nothing suffices, and it applies to the data types in Data Sufficiency Based on Blood Relations, Data Sufficiency Based on Ranking, Ordering or Seating Arrangement, Data Sufficiency Based on Directions and Distance and Data Sufficiency Based on Coding-Decoding. The last topic, Data Sufficiency Combined with Mathematical Operations/Symbol-Based Coding, adds mathematical symbols.

What Does the Two-Worlds Test Say?

In short: data are insufficient if you can imagine two situations that obey every statement but give different answers.

  1. Write down everything the statements say, together.
  2. Build the first situation that fits all of it and answer the question.
  3. Build a second situation that also fits all of it and answers differently.
  4. If you can, the answer key is E (neither suffices). If you cannot, the data suffice together.

Illustration

  • Question: Who sits in the middle of five people in a row? Statements: A sits at the extreme left; E sits next to A.
  • World 1: A, E, B, C, D. The middle is B.
  • World 2: A, E, C, B, D. The middle is C.
  • Two answers, so the data are insufficient.

The test works because sufficiency demands one answer for all situations that obey the statements. A single counter-example is enough to break it.

What Are the Common Causes of Insufficiency?

In short: the usual causes are a missing link, a range instead of a value, two possible values, and statements that repeat or ignore the question.

Cause Example Why neither suffices
Missing link Who is the shortest of A, B, C? A is taller than B; A is taller than C B and C are not compared
Range Weight of box: more than 5 kg; less than 9 kg Many values fit
Two values x squared = 25; x is an integer x = 5 or x = -5
Irrelevant fact Age of father: father is older than the son; son is 12 Only a bound, not a value
Unlinked statements A is 4 km north of C; B is 3 km east of D No common point
Neutral relation Is R the maternal cousin of S? R is a cousin of S; S is a woman Side is not fixed

Whenever a question asks for one specific object, quantity or yes-or-no answer, check whether the statements actually reach it. A statement that is true and related can still be irrelevant to the exact thing asked.

How Is E Different From D?

In short: in D the two statements together give one answer. In E, they do not.

Situation Key Reason
Tallest of A, B, C: A taller than B; B taller than C D Together A > B > C
Shortest of A, B, C: B taller than A; C taller than A D Together A is below both
Tallest of A, B, C: A taller than B; C taller than B E A and C are not compared

The pair of statements “B is taller than A” and “C is taller than A” does fix the shortest person, but the same pair does not fix the tallest. The answer depends on what the question asks, so read it again before choosing the key. The decision order is described in Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Who sits in the middle of five people in a row? I. A sits at the extreme left. II. E sits next to A.

  1. World 1: A, E, B, C, D. The middle is B.
  2. World 2: A, E, C, B, D. The middle is C.
  3. Both worlds fit the statements, so the answer is not fixed.

Answer: E (neither suffices, even together).

Example 2

Question: What is x? I. x squared = 25. II. x is an integer.

  1. Integers 5 and -5 both satisfy both statements.
  2. Two answers remain.

Answer: E (neither suffices, even together).

Example 3

Question: Is R the maternal cousin of S? I. R is a cousin of S. II. S is a woman.

  1. A cousin may be on the mother’s side or the father’s side.
  2. S being a woman does not fix R’s side.

Answer: E (neither suffices, even together).

Example 4

Question: Who scored the highest among P, Q and R? I. P scored more than Q. II. R scored more than Q.

  1. World 1: P > R > Q. P is highest.
  2. World 2: R > P > Q. R is highest.

Answer: E (neither suffices, even together).

Example 5

Question: How old is the father? I. The father is older than his son. II. The son is 12 years old.

  1. The father could be 30, 35, or any age above 12 plus a reasonable gap.
  2. Many ages fit.

Answer: E (neither suffices, even together).

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Try to break the answer with a second situation, not to confirm it.
  • Look for ranges, signs (plus or minus), and unlinked statements.
  • Check that the statements mention the very thing the question asks about.
  • A single counter-example is enough to prove insufficiency.
  • Read the question again when two statements seem to fit; the exact ask often changes the key.

Common Mistakes

  • Assuming the convenient case, such as positive x or a particular seating.
  • Taking a bound or range as a value.
  • Choosing D without checking that together they give exactly one answer.
  • Treating related facts as relevant.
  • Not checking both signs of a squared value.

Practice Questions

  1. What is a? I. a squared = 4. II. a is an integer. Key?
  2. Is B older than C? I. A is older than B. II. A is older than C. Key?
  3. How many students are in the class? I. Rita is 5th from the top. II. Rita is taller than Sita. Key?
  4. What is n? I. n is a prime number. II. n is less than 10. Key?
  5. Who is the shortest of A, B, C? I. B is taller than A. II. C is taller than A. Key?
  6. Is X north of Y? I. Y is 3 km from Z. II. Z is 4 km from X. Key?

Answers: 1) E; 2) E; 3) E; 4) E; 5) D; 6) E.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Scoring Many wrong answers come from missing an E.
  • Logic Counter-examples are a core skill of reasoning.
  • Method The two-worlds test is quick and reliable.
  • Link It completes Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice and prepares Data Sufficiency Combined with Mathematical Operations/Symbol-Based Coding.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Data Sufficiency Combined with Mathematical Operations/Symbol-Based Coding. It combines data sufficiency with arithmetic symbols and symbol-based coding.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Counter-example A situation that fits the statements but breaks the claim
  • Two-worlds test Finding two valid situations with different answers
  • Missing link A fact needed to connect statements
  • Range More than one possible value
  • Insufficient Does not fix a single answer
  • Option E Neither suffices, even together
  • Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice
  • Data Sufficiency Combined with Mathematical Operations/Symbol-Based Coding
  • Data Sufficiency Based on Blood Relations
  • Data Sufficiency Based on Ranking, Ordering or Seating Arrangement

Study this topic together with these linked topics from other subjects.

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Find two valid situations with different answers.
  • A range is not a value.
  • Squared values give two signs.
  • Unlinked statements do not combine.
  • Reread the question before choosing E.

Do Not Confuse With

  • E vs D D: together give one answer. E: they do not.
  • Related vs relevant A related fact may not touch the exact question.
  • Possible vs certain Sufficiency needs certainty, not a likely answer.
  • Bound vs value Older than 12 is a bound; 25 is a value.

Memory Hook

Two worlds, one set of statements, two answers: insufficient.

GS Relevance

Tests whether you can show insufficiency, which decides many data sufficiency marks in SSC CGL, bank PO and clerk mains, CDS, CAPF and CSAT-style reasoning.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you prove that data are insufficient?

Use the two-worlds test. Build two situations that satisfy every statement but give different answers to the question. If you can, the data are insufficient even together and the key is E. If every valid situation gives the same answer, the data suffice.

What are the most common causes of option E?

The usual causes are a missing link between statements, a range instead of a value, a squared value that gives plus and minus answers, statements about unlinked people or points, and neutral relations such as cousin that do not fix side or gender.

What is the difference between D and E in data sufficiency?

In D, the statements fail alone but give exactly one answer when combined. In E, they still leave more than one answer, or a needed fact is missing, even when combined. Check the exact question, as the same statements can fix the shortest person but not the tallest.

Can a true statement still be insufficient?

Yes. A statement can be true and related to the question but still not fix one answer. For example, knowing that the father is older than his 12-year-old son gives a lower bound on his age, not his age.

Why should I look for a counter-example?

A single counter-example proves insufficiency, while confirming the answer in one situation does not prove sufficiency. Trying to break the answer is the faster and more reliable way to decide whether the data fix it uniquely.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 If two valid situations give different answers, the data are insufficient.
True

That is the two-worlds test.

2 The statements x squared = 25 and x is an integer fix x.
False

Both 5 and -5 fit.

3 A lower bound on age is a sufficient answer for the age.
False

It does not fix one value.

4 Unlinked statements about different people can be combined.
False

They need a common point.

Share: