Data Sufficiency Based on Ranking, Ordering or Seating Arrangement
Reasoning › Data Sufficiency (Reasoning-Based) · Topic 13.2
In ranking, ordering and seating data sufficiency, you decide whether the statements fix one definite position or order. Use the position formulas: total = rank from top + rank from bottom - 1, and people between two positions = difference of positions - 1. A statement is sufficient only if it leaves exactly one possible answer, and a comparison chain needs every link present before the end person is known.
8 min read · Reasoning · Data Sufficiency (Reasoning-Based)
Quick Answer
In ranking, ordering and seating data sufficiency, you decide whether the statements fix one definite position or order. Use the position formulas: total = rank from top + rank from bottom – 1, and people between two positions = difference of positions – 1. A statement is sufficient only if it leaves exactly one possible answer, and a comparison chain needs every link present before the end person is known.
At a Glance
- Total in a line Top rank + bottom rank – 1
- Between two positions Difference of positions – 1
- Comparison chain Needs a link between every adjacent pair
- Key (D) Both together needed
- Key (E) Even together insufficient
- Trap Two possible orders left open
Where Does It Fit?
This is the second topic of the Data Sufficiency (Reasoning-Based) macro. It uses the same five-option key described in Data Sufficiency Based on Blood Relations and explained in full in Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice. The next topic, Data Sufficiency Based on Directions and Distance, applies sufficiency to directions and distance, and Data Sufficiency Cases Where Data in Neither Statement Is Sufficient studies cases where the answer is E.
Which Formulas Fix a Position?
In short: a line of people has a total, a rank from each end, and a count between any two persons. Two of these facts usually fix the third.
| Fact wanted | Formula | Needs |
|---|---|---|
| Total number | Rank from top + rank from bottom – 1 | Both ranks of one person |
| Rank from bottom | Total – rank from top + 1 | Total and rank from top |
| Rank from top | Total – rank from bottom + 1 | Total and rank from bottom |
| People between A and B | Difference of their positions – 1 | Both positions counted from the same end |
| Position from the other end | Total – position + 1 | Total |
For example, if a person is 12th from the top and 20th from the bottom, the total is 12 + 20 – 1 = 31. Neither fact alone gives the total, so that question needs both statements.
How Do You Handle Comparison Chains?
In short: to find the tallest, oldest or highest scorer, you need a chain of comparisons that links every person. A missing link leaves the answer open.
- Write each statement as an inequality, such as A > B.
- Join the inequalities into one chain.
- If every person lies on the chain, the ends are fixed.
- If any person is outside the chain, the answer for the end person is not definite.
Chain check
- A > B and B > C give A > B > C: A is first, C is last.
- A > B and C < B: A > B > C also, so the same chain.
- A > B and A > C: B and C are not compared, so the order of B and C is open.
A statement of the form “A is taller than B” never decides the shortest person alone. The statements must jointly connect all names.
What About Seating and Row Positions?
In short: for seating, check that the statements fix who sits where. Leaving a gap such as “second to the right” without naming the seat in between leaves the answer open.
| Statement | What it fixes | What stays open |
|---|---|---|
| Q is second to the right of P | Q’s position relative to P | Who sits between P and Q |
| R is to the left of P | R is on P’s left side somewhere | How far left |
| A is at the extreme left | A’s exact position | Others |
| B is immediately between A and C | A, B, C in a block | Which end is A |
Words like immediate, adjacent and neighbour fix a gap of zero. Words such as to the left of, somewhere, or ahead of do not. Combined statements may fix a chain even if neither does alone, which is the pattern of key D in Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: How many students are in the class? I. Ravi ranks 12th from the top. II. Ravi ranks 20th from the bottom.
- Statement I alone gives no total. Statement II alone gives no total.
- Together: 12 + 20 – 1 = 31.
Answer: D (both together are needed); the class has 31 students.
Example 2
Question: What is Ravi’s rank from the top? I. Ravi is 15th from the bottom. II. There are 40 students in the class.
- I alone: no total, so no top rank.
- II alone: no information about Ravi.
- Together: 40 – 15 + 1 = 26.
Answer: D (both together are needed); the rank is 26th.
Example 3
Question: Who is the tallest among A, B and C? I. A is taller than B. II. C is shorter than B.
- I alone: A > B, but C is not compared. C could be taller than A.
- II alone: B > C, A is not compared.
- Together: A > B > C. A is the tallest.
Answer: D (both together are needed); A is the tallest.
Example 4
Question: Who sits immediately to the right of P in a row? I. Q sits second to the right of P. II. R sits to the left of P.
- I alone: someone sits between P and Q, but who is not stated.
- II alone: R is on the left, which says nothing about the right side.
- Together: still no name for the seat immediately right of P.
Answer: E (even both together are insufficient).
Example 5
Question: In a class of 30, what is Meena’s rank from the top? I. Meena is 10th from the bottom. II. There are 20 students above Meena.
- I alone: 30 – 10 + 1 = 21.
- II alone: 20 students above means her rank is 21.
- Each alone gives 21.
Answer: C (either statement alone is sufficient); the rank is 21st.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Remember total = top + bottom – 1 and use it to check whether a question can be fixed.
- Convert every comparison to an inequality and build a chain.
- If a name is missing from the chain, the end person is not fixed.
- Count positions from the same end before finding the number between.
- Do not assume a row or circle direction unless stated.
Common Mistakes
- Using top + bottom as the total without subtracting 1.
- Treating “taller than” as if it also gave the shortest.
- Counting between two persons from different ends.
- Assuming “to the left” means immediately left.
- Ignoring that a statement may give a tie.
Practice Questions
- In a class of 45, what is Anil’s rank from the bottom? I. Anil is 10th from the top. II. Anil’s class meets in the morning. Key?
- How many students are there? I. P is 7th from the top. II. P is 18th from the bottom. Key?
- Who is the oldest of A, B, C? I. A is older than B. II. B is older than C. Key?
- In a row, is X at the extreme left? I. X is to the left of Y. II. Y is to the left of Z. Key?
- A row has 20 people. How many are between A and B? I. A is 5th from the left. II. B is 12th from the right. Key?
- In a class of 25, what is Rita’s rank from the top? I. Rita is 8th from the bottom. II. There are 17 students above Rita. Key?
Answers: 1) A; 2) D; 3) D; 4) E; 5) D; 6) C.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Format Ranking sufficiency questions need little theory and reward careful reading.
- Formula check The position formulas give instant decisions.
- Chains They train logical linking of comparisons.
- Link It prepares for Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice and Data Sufficiency Cases Where Data in Neither Statement Is Sufficient.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Data Sufficiency Based on Directions and Distance. It decides whether statements about movement and bearings fix a direction or a distance.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Rank from top Position counted from the first place
- Rank from bottom Position counted from the last place
- Chain A linked set of comparisons
- Between Persons strictly inside two positions
- Adjacent Next to each other
- Extreme At either end of a row
Related Topics
- Data Sufficiency Based on Blood Relations
- Data Sufficiency Based on Directions and Distance
- Data Sufficiency Based on Coding-Decoding
- Data Sufficiency Requiring Determination of Which Statement(s) Alone or Together Suffice
Related Topics in Maarg Manthan
Study this topic together with these linked topics from other subjects.
- Data Sufficiency – Two-Statement Format (Statement I and Statement II) (Quantitative Aptitude)
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Total = top rank + bottom rank – 1.
- Between = position difference – 1.
- Comparisons need a complete chain.
- Gaps like second to the right leave names open.
- Test alone before together.
Do Not Confuse With
- Top rank vs bottom rank Counted from opposite ends.
- Between vs difference Between is difference minus 1.
- Taller than vs tallest A single comparison does not fix the tallest.
- Immediate vs somewhere Immediate fixes the seat; somewhere does not.
Memory Hook
Top plus bottom minus one gives the line; every name must sit on the chain.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you solve data sufficiency on ranking?
Use total = rank from top + rank from bottom - 1 and check whether the statements supply enough numbers to fix the asked value. Test each statement alone first, then together. If a single position or total is still open, the data are insufficient.
How do you decide the tallest person in sufficiency questions?
Write every statement as an inequality and join them into a chain. If all persons lie on one chain, the ends are fixed and the tallest is known. If any person is not compared, or two chains stay separate, the tallest cannot be decided.
What is the formula for the number of students in a row?
The total number is the rank of a person from the top plus the rank of the same person from the bottom minus 1. For example, 12th from the top and 20th from the bottom gives 12 + 20 - 1 = 31 students.
How many people are between two positions?
Count both positions from the same end and subtract the smaller from the larger, then subtract 1. For example, if A is 5th and B is 9th from the left, 9 - 5 - 1 = 3 people sit between them.
When are seating statements insufficient?
Seating statements are insufficient when they leave a gap unnamed, such as second to the right with no one named in between, or when the left or right placement is stated without an exact distance. In those cases, more than one arrangement remains possible.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The total number in a line equals the sum of a person's top and bottom ranks.
One must be subtracted, since the person is counted twice.
2 A statement that A is taller than B fixes the tallest of three people.
Other comparisons are needed.
3 People between two positions equal the difference of positions minus one.
Neither end is counted.
4 Second to the right names the person sitting in between.
It leaves that seat unnamed.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index