An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 3.3

Planning Strategies / Models: Harrod–Domar; Nehru–Mahalanobis; Gandhian; Wage-Good Model; LPG Strategy; Rao–Manmohan Model; Amartya Sen Model

Indian Economy › Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms · Topic 3.3

Planning models are the growth strategies that guided economic planning in India and in economic thought. The Harrod-Domar model, from Roy Harrod (1939) and Evsey Domar (1946), says growth rate g = s / v, the saving rate divided by the capital-output ratio, and shaped the First Plan (1951-56). The Nehru-Mahalanobis model of the Second Plan (1956-61) put heavy investment in capital goods industries under public sector lead. Other strategies are the Gandhian model of village-based decentralised growth, the wage-good model of C.N. Vakil and P.R. Brahmananda, the LPG strategy of 1991, the Rao-Manmohan model of liberal reform, and the Amartya Sen model of human capabilities. A Prelims 2019 question tested the Second Plan thrust.

Share:
Planning Strategies / Models: Harrod–Domar; Nehru–Mahalanobis; Gandhian; Wage-Good Model; LPG Strategy; Rao–Manmohan Model; Amartya Sen Model - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Harrod-Domar g = s / v, First Plan
  • Nehru-Mahalanobis Heavy industry, Second Plan
  • Wage-good model Vakil and Brahmananda, 1956
  • LPG strategy 1991 reforms
  • Sen model Capabilities and human development
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms

Where Does It Fit?

After the types of planning, this topic looks at the economic ideas behind the plans. The Five-Year Plans that follow in later topics rest on these models. Previous topic: Types: Regional and National, Imperative and Indicative, Centralised and Decentralised Planning. Next topic: Pre-Independence Plans: Visvesvaraya Plan, Gandhian Plan, FICCI Proposal, Congress Plan, People’s Plan, Sarvodaya Plan, Bombay Plan.

How Do the Main Planning Models Compare?

Model Author or source Core idea Link with Indian planning
Harrod-Domar Roy Harrod (1939) and Evsey Domar (1946) Growth depends on the saving rate and the capital-output ratio: g = s / v First Plan (1951-56), with stress on saving and investment
Nehru-Mahalanobis P.C. Mahalanobis, with Jawaharlal Nehru’s backing Raise the share of investment in capital goods, so that later output of consumer goods can rise faster Second Plan (1956-61) and the heavy industry drive
Gandhian model M.K. Gandhi, planned form by Shriman Narayan Agarwal (1944) Village self-reliance, cottage industry, decentralisation, trusteeship, agriculture first Influenced village industry, Panchayati Raj and the Sarvodaya idea
Wage-good model C.N. Vakil and P.R. Brahmananda, 1956 Growth is limited by the supply of wage goods such as food and cloth, so invest there Critique of the Mahalanobis strategy
LPG strategy Reform package of 1991 Liberalisation, privatisation, globalisation: less control, more market and trade Eighth Plan (1992-97) onward
Rao-Manmohan model P.V. Narasimha Rao (Prime Minister) and Manmohan Singh (Finance Minister) Dismantle licence-permit raj, open to trade and foreign investment, fiscal and financial reform The 1991 reform path
Amartya Sen model Amartya Sen, Nobel 1998 Development means expanding human capabilities and freedoms, with health and education as central Influenced the Human Development Index and later plan stress on social sectors

What Is the Harrod-Domar Formula and How Is It Used?

  • Formula: g = s / v, where g is the growth rate of output, s is the saving rate and v is the capital-output ratio, shown as ICOR (incremental capital-output ratio)
  • Worked example 1: If s = 20 per cent and ICOR = 4, then g = 20 / 4 = 5 per cent. The economy needs Rs 4 of investment for each Rs 1 of extra output
  • Worked example 2: To grow at 8 per cent with an ICOR of 4, the saving and investment rate must be 8 x 4 = 32 per cent of GDP
  • Natural meaning: A higher saving rate or a lower ICOR (better use of capital) raises growth
  • Warranted and natural growth: Harrod called the rate that keeps capital fully used the warranted rate, and the rate set by labour and technology the natural rate. When they differ, growth is unstable, called the knife-edge problem
  • Use in India: The First Plan stressed raising saving and investment, mostly in agriculture, irrigation and power
  • Limits: It ignores technology change, the sector mix and human capital, and treats the ICOR as fixed

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Mahalanobis in detail: P.C. Mahalanobis built a two-sector model in 1953, with a capital goods sector and a consumer goods sector, and later a four-sector model in 1955 with investment goods, factory consumer goods, household and small industry, and services. The model assumed a closed economy, so trade mattered mainly for importing capital goods
  • Second Plan result: The Second Plan started the steel plants at Bhilai, Rourkela and Durgapur and gave the public sector the commanding heights, as in Industrial Policy Resolutions 1948 and 1956; Industries (Development and Regulation) Act 1951; Schedules A and B; Public Sector Monopoly Industries
  • Asked in UPSC Prelims 2019: A Prelims 2019 question asked whether, from the Second Plan, there was a determined thrust towards substitution of basic and capital goods industries. That is true, and it is the Mahalanobis strategy. The same question carried statements on the Fourth and Fifth Plans, covered in The Five-Year Plans (1st to 12th); First Plan, Second Plan, Third Plan Priorities and Objectives; Plan Holiday; Rolling Plan
  • Gandhian model: Gandhi argued in Hind Swaraj (1909) for self-sufficient villages and small-scale industry. The Gandhian Plan of 1944 by Shriman Narayan Agarwal followed this line, as in Pre-Independence Plans: Visvesvaraya Plan, Gandhian Plan, FICCI Proposal, Congress Plan, People’s Plan, Sarvodaya Plan, Bombay Plan
  • Wage-good model, detail: Vakil and Brahmananda held that in a poor economy food and cloth are the real constraint on growth, because workers spend their wages on them. They preferred labour-intensive consumer goods and agriculture to heavy industry
  • LPG strategy: The 1991 strategy of liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation is covered in New Economic Policy (NEP): Liberalisation, Privatisation, Globalisation (LPG); Two Primary Strategies of NEP
  • Rao-Manmohan model, detail: In July 1991 the rupee was devalued, industrial licensing was largely abolished and import controls were eased. The change was driven by the balance of payments crisis, as in Late 1980s Deepening Crisis; 1991 BoP Crisis; Pre-1991 Regulatory Mechanisms and Post-1991 Reforms
  • Amartya Sen model, detail: In Development as Freedom (1999) Sen treats growth as a means and expanded capabilities as the end. With Jean Dreze he argued for public spending on health and education, as in Human Development: Meaning; Approaches: Income, Welfare, Basic Needs, Capability (Amartya Sen); Human Development Report; HDI Dimensions; Gender Development Index
  • Sen versus the growth-first view: Growth-first economists such as Jagdish Bhagwati and Arvind Panagariya argued that rapid growth pays for social spending. Sen argued that social development raises growth and cannot wait
  • Capital-output ratio: ICOR = investment / change in output. For example, if investment of Rs 400 raises output by Rs 100, ICOR = 4. A lower ICOR means capital is used efficiently
  • Common order: Harrod-Domar, then Mahalanobis, then wage-good critique, then LPG and Rao-Manmohan, then Sen. Match model to person and Plan

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Harrod-Domar: Formula g = s / v, First Plan
  2. Mahalanobis: Four-sector model, heavy industry, Second Plan, asked in UPSC Prelims 2019
  3. Wage-good model: Authors are C.N. Vakil and P.R. Brahmananda
  4. Sen model: Capability approach, Development as Freedom, Nobel 1998
  5. Common errors: Mixing the First Plan (Harrod-Domar) with the Second Plan (Mahalanobis), or crediting the wage-good model to Mahalanobis

As an analytical point, each model fitted its time. Harrod-Domar suited a saving-poor economy, Mahalanobis a closed economy short of capital goods, and LPG an economy in a balance of payments crisis. Sen’s view reminds planners that growth is judged by what it does for human lives.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Models Matched with authors
  • Formula g = s / v
  • PYQ Prelims 2019

What Came Next?

The next topic covers the plans prepared before independence. Next topic: Pre-Independence Plans: Visvesvaraya Plan, Gandhian Plan, FICCI Proposal, Congress Plan, People’s Plan, Sarvodaya Plan, Bombay Plan.

Key People and Terms

  • Harrod-Domar model Growth equals saving rate over capital-output ratio
  • ICOR Investment needed per unit extra output
  • Mahalanobis model Capital goods first
  • Wage goods Food and cloth for workers
  • Capability approach Development as freedom
  • LPG Liberalisation, privatisation, globalisation

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Harrod-Domar: g = s / v, First Plan.
  • Worked: s = 20 per cent, ICOR = 4 gives 5 per cent.
  • Mahalanobis: Second Plan, capital goods.
  • Wage-good model: Vakil and Brahmananda, 1956.
  • Sen: Nobel 1998, Development as Freedom 1999.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Harrod-Domar and Mahalanobis models Saving and ICOR versus capital goods sector share
  • Mahalanobis model and wage-good model Heavy industry versus consumer goods and food
  • Gandhian Plan and Gandhian model The 1944 plan document versus the broader philosophy

Memory Hook

Harrod-Domar saves, Mahalanobis builds machines, Vakil feeds workers, Sen frees people.

Mains Angle

Questions ask which strategy suited India and why. These points give a frame.

  • Models Matched to periods
  • Debate Heavy industry versus wage goods
  • Lesson Fit strategy to stage

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Compare the Harrod-Domar and Nehru-Mahalanobis models and discuss the alternatives to them in Indian planning.”

How to Answer

  1. First Harrod-Domar and First Plan.
  2. Second Mahalanobis and heavy industry.
  3. Critique Wage-good and Gandhian views.
  4. Later LPG, Rao-Manmohan, Sen.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Harrod-Domar, Mahalanobis, wage-good, Gandhian, LPG and Sen models, with their plans and authors. GS Paper 3: planning strategy and growth.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Harrod-Domar model?

The Harrod-Domar model, developed by Roy Harrod in 1939 and Evsey Domar in 1946, says the growth rate equals the saving rate divided by the capital-output ratio, g = s / v. With saving of 20 per cent and an ICOR of 4, growth is 5 per cent. India used it in the First Plan.

What is the Nehru-Mahalanobis model?

It is the strategy of the Second Plan (1956-61), prepared by P.C. Mahalanobis, which gave priority to capital goods and heavy industry under public sector lead. The idea was that building machines first would raise future output of consumer goods faster. It assumed a closed economy.

What is the wage-good model?

The wage-good model was put forward by C.N. Vakil and P.R. Brahmananda in 1956. It argues that the real limit on growth in a poor economy is the supply of wage goods such as food and cloth, so investment should go to agriculture and labour-intensive consumer goods rather than heavy industry.

What is the difference between the Harrod-Domar and Mahalanobis models?

Harrod-Domar links growth to the saving rate and ICOR, without stressing which sector gets investment. Mahalanobis shows that the sector split matters and puts a larger share of investment in the capital goods sector to raise long-run growth.

What is the Rao-Manmohan model?

It is the reform strategy begun in 1991 by Prime Minister P.V. Narasimha Rao and Finance Minister Manmohan Singh. It dismantled licence-permit raj, devalued the rupee, opened trade and foreign investment and reformed finance and tax, under the label of liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation.

What is the Amartya Sen model of development?

Amartya Sen treats development as the expansion of human capabilities and freedoms, with health, education and entitlements at the centre, and not only a rise in income. His capability approach, set out in Development as Freedom (1999), shaped the Human Development Index.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Harrod-Domar model links growth to the saving rate and the capital-output ratio.
True

g = s / v.

2 The Second Plan was based on the Harrod-Domar model.
False

It was based on the Mahalanobis model; the First Plan used Harrod-Domar.

3 From the Second Plan there was a thrust towards substitution of basic and capital goods industries.
True

Asked in UPSC Prelims 2019, and correct.

4 The wage-good model was proposed by P.C. Mahalanobis.
False

It was proposed by C.N. Vakil and P.R. Brahmananda.

Share: