Types: Regional and National, Imperative and Indicative, Centralised and Decentralised Planning
Indian Economy › Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms · Topic 3.2
Economic planning is classified in three main pairs. By area, it is national planning for the whole country or regional planning for one region or state. By compulsion, it is imperative planning, also called command planning, where the state orders targets and all units must obey, or indicative planning, where the state only gives direction and offers incentives. By decision-making, it is centralised planning, where one central authority decides, or decentralised planning, where lower levels such as states, districts and panchayats frame plans. India followed imperative planning for the public sector and indicative planning for the private sector, and the 73rd and 74th Amendments of 1992 gave decentralised planning a constitutional base.
6 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms
At a Glance
- By area National and regional
- By compulsion Imperative (command) and indicative
- By decision level Centralised and decentralised
- Imperative example Soviet Gosplan
- Indicative example France after 1945, India after 1991
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms
Where Does It Fit?
After the meaning and objectives of planning, this topic sorts planning into types. These types are used in the next topics on planning models, the Planning Commission and the Five-Year Plans. Previous topic: Meaning and Objectives of Economic Planning; Strategies of Planning. Next topic: Planning Strategies / Models: Harrod–Domar; Nehru–Mahalanobis; Gandhian; Wage-Good Model; LPG Strategy; Rao–Manmohan Model; Amartya Sen Model.
How Do Imperative and Indicative Planning Differ?
| Feature | Imperative planning | Indicative planning |
|---|---|---|
| Other names | Command planning, directive planning, planning by direction | Planning by inducement, planning by persuasion |
| Who decides | The state fixes targets for every sector | The state gives broad goals and forecasts |
| Private sector | Little or none, firms follow orders | Free to act, guided by incentives |
| Tools | Orders, quotas, controlled prices | Subsidies, tax breaks, credit, information |
| Compliance | Compulsory | Voluntary |
| Typical economy | Soviet Union under Gosplan, from 1928, and China before 1978 | France after 1945, Japan, India after 1991 |
| Indian use | Public sector targets in the early plans | Private sector throughout, and the whole plan from the Eighth Plan (1992-97) |
How Do Centralised and Decentralised Planning Differ?
| Feature | Centralised planning | Decentralised planning |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | One central body prepares the plan for the whole economy | Plans are made at state, district, block and village levels and added together |
| Direction of flow | Top-down | Bottom-up |
| Strength | National priorities, coordination, big projects | Local needs, participation, better use of local knowledge |
| Weakness | Ignores local conditions, slow, rigid | Weak capacity, risk of conflict among units, funds and staff gaps |
| Indian body | Planning Commission and National Development Council | State planning boards, District Planning Committees, Gram Panchayat Development Plans |
| Constitutional base | None for the Commission, set up by Cabinet resolution | Article 243G, 243W and 243ZD (District Planning Committee) after the 73rd and 74th Amendments, 1992 |
What Else Should You Remember?
- National planning: A plan for the whole country, with common goals, such as the Five-Year Plans prepared by the Planning Commission
- Regional planning: A plan for a region with common features, such as a backward area, a river valley or a hill region. Examples are the Damodar Valley project, the Northeastern Region plans and the Hill Area programme
- Link between the two: In India, regional plans are meant to fit within the national plan, and states get central assistance by a formula, the Gadgil formula from 1969, now replaced by the Finance Commission and Union scheme transfers
- Command planning in practice: The Soviet Union created Gosplan, the state planning committee, in 1921, and began the first Five-Year Plan in 1928. Firms received output quotas and input supplies from the state
- Indicative planning in practice: France set up its Commissariat general du Plan in 1946 to give targets that business was encouraged to follow. In India the Eighth Plan under P.V. Narasimha Rao was the first to be openly indicative
- India as a mixed case: India used imperative planning for the public sector, where the state set output and investment, and indicative planning for the private sector, which was guided by licences, credit and incentives
- Other classifications: Physical and financial planning, short-term, medium-term and long-term (perspective) planning, fixed and rolling planning, and sectoral and overall planning
- Rolling plan: A plan that is revised every year and moves forward, so that a fresh year is added as one is completed. India tried it in 1978-80, as in The Five-Year Plans (1st to 12th); First Plan, Second Plan, Third Plan Priorities and Objectives; Plan Holiday; Rolling Plan
- Constitutional basis for decentralisation: The 73rd Amendment (Panchayats, Part IX) and 74th Amendment (Municipalities, Part IXA) of 1992 made local bodies plan for economic development and social justice under the Eleventh and Twelfth Schedules. A District Planning Committee consolidates rural and urban plans under Article 243ZD
- Earlier steps: The Balwant Rai Mehta Committee (1957) proposed the three-tier Panchayati Raj, and the Ashok Mehta Committee (1978) stressed district-level planning
- Kerala example: The People’s Plan Campaign of 1996 gave panchayats 35 to 40 per cent of the state plan outlay, a model of bottom-up planning
- Present practice: Gram Panchayat Development Plans are prepared every year under the Sabki Yojana Sabka Vikas campaign of the Ministry of Panchayati Raj. States use district planning and NITI Aayog works as a think tank, as in Planning After the Planning Commission: NITI Aayog; Functions of NITI Aayog
- Next step: For the national and decentralised experience in detail, see Central Planning: Five-Year Plans, 20-Point Programme, MPLADS; Decentralised Planning
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Pairs: Know the three pairs: national and regional, imperative and indicative, centralised and decentralised
- Imperative planning: Another name is command planning, and it is linked with the Soviet Union and Gosplan
- Indicative planning: Persuasion and incentives, as in France and in India from the Eighth Plan
- Decentralised planning: Linked with the 73rd and 74th Amendments, District Planning Committee, Article 243ZD
- Common errors: Calling Indian planning purely imperative, or saying decentralised planning began with the Planning Commission
As an analytical point, no country uses one pure type. India shows how the mix shifts with the stage of development: strong state direction when capital was scarce, and indicative, decentralised planning as markets and local governments gained strength.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Types Asked as pairs
- Examples USSR, France, India
- Decentralisation 73rd and 74th Amendments
What Came Next?
The next topic explains the planning models used in India and elsewhere. Next topic: Planning Strategies / Models: Harrod–Domar; Nehru–Mahalanobis; Gandhian; Wage-Good Model; LPG Strategy; Rao–Manmohan Model; Amartya Sen Model.
Key People and Terms
- Imperative planning Compulsory state targets
- Indicative planning Direction with incentives
- Gosplan Soviet planning body
- Perspective plan Long-term frame
- Bottom-up planning Local plans added up
- District Planning Committee Consolidates local plans
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Imperative planning is also command planning.
- Soviet first Five-Year Plan: 1928, Gosplan.
- India’s first openly indicative plan: Eighth Plan.
- District Planning Committee: Article 243ZD.
- Constitutional amendments: 73rd and 74th, 1992.
Do Not Confuse With
- Imperative and indicative planning Compulsion versus guidance
- Centralised and decentralised planning Top-down versus bottom-up
- Regional planning and decentralised planning Area focus versus level of decision-making
Memory Hook
Imperative orders, indicative persuades; centre decides, local levels build up.
Mains Angle
Questions ask about the case for decentralised planning. These points give a frame.
- Types Three pairs
- India Mixed practice
- Decentralisation Constitutional base and gaps
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Distinguish between imperative and indicative planning. How far has India moved towards decentralised planning?”
How to Answer
- Types Three pairs.
- Compare Imperative and indicative.
- India Mixed and later indicative.
- Local 73rd and 74th Amendments.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the types of economic planning?
Planning is classified as national or regional by area, imperative or indicative by compulsion, and centralised or decentralised by the level of decision-making. Other types include physical and financial, short-term and perspective, and fixed and rolling plans.
What is the difference between imperative and indicative planning?
In imperative planning, also called command planning, the state fixes compulsory targets for all units, as the Soviet Union did. In indicative planning the state gives broad direction and uses incentives and information, leaving firms free to decide, as in France and in India after 1991.
What is the difference between centralised and decentralised planning?
Centralised planning is top-down, with one central body preparing the plan for the whole economy. Decentralised planning is bottom-up, with plans made by states, districts and panchayats and then combined. India's local planning rests on the 73rd and 74th Amendments of 1992.
Which type of planning did India follow?
India followed a mix. Public sector targets were imperative, while the private sector faced indicative planning through licences, credit and incentives. The Eighth Plan of 1992 was openly indicative, and the Planning Commission was replaced by NITI Aayog in 2015.
What is a District Planning Committee?
A District Planning Committee is a body under Article 243ZD, inserted by the 74th Amendment, which consolidates the plans of panchayats and municipalities in a district into a draft development plan for the whole district. Its chairperson is chosen as the state law provides.
What is regional planning?
Regional planning prepares development plans for a region that shares common features or problems, such as a backward area, river valley or hill region. It aims at balanced regional growth and must fit within the national plan, as the Damodar Valley and Northeast plans show.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 Imperative planning is also called command planning.
The state gives compulsory orders, as in the Soviet model.
2 Indicative planning forces private firms to meet state targets.
It only gives direction and offers incentives.
3 District Planning Committees are provided for under Article 243ZD.
Inserted by the 74th Amendment.
4 Decentralised planning is top-down planning from the Centre.
It is bottom-up, from local levels.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index