Pre-Independence Plans: Visvesvaraya Plan, Gandhian Plan, FICCI Proposal, Congress Plan, People’s Plan, Sarvodaya Plan, Bombay Plan
Indian Economy › Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms · Topic 3.4
The pre-independence plans were proposals for economic development drawn up in India between 1934 and 1950, before any official plan existed. They are the Visvesvaraya Plan (1934), the FICCI proposal (1934), the Congress Plan of the National Planning Committee (1938), the Bombay Plan (1944), the Gandhian Plan (1944) by Shriman Narayan Agarwal, the People's Plan (1945) by M.N. Roy, and the Sarvodaya Plan (1950) by Jayaprakash Narayan. They differed in ideology, from industrial capitalist to Gandhian and Marxist, but all agreed on the need for planning. Their ideas shaped the Planning Commission of 1950 and the First Five-Year Plan.
6 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms
At a Glance
- Earliest plan Visvesvaraya Plan, 1934
- Industrialists’ plan Bombay Plan, 1944
- Gandhian Plan Shriman Narayan Agarwal, 1944
- People’s Plan M.N. Roy, 1945
- Sarvodaya Plan Jayaprakash Narayan, 1950
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms
Where Does It Fit?
After the models of planning, this topic looks at the first Indian plans before 1947. They show the range of ideas that the Planning Commission and the Five-Year Plans later drew on. Previous topic: Planning Strategies / Models: Harrod–Domar; Nehru–Mahalanobis; Gandhian; Wage-Good Model; LPG Strategy; Rao–Manmohan Model; Amartya Sen Model. Next topic: History of Planning in India; Planning Commission and National Development Council (NDC).
Which Pre-Independence Plans Were Drawn Up and by Whom?
| Plan | Year | Author or body | Main features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Visvesvaraya Plan | 1934 | Sir M. Visvesvaraya, in Planned Economy for India | A ten-year plan to double national income, with industrialisation and a shift of workers from agriculture |
| FICCI proposal | 1934 | Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry, associated with N.R. Sarkar | Called for a national planning commission and planned industrial development |
| Congress Plan | 1938 | National Planning Committee of the Indian National Congress, chaired by Jawaharlal Nehru | Wide plan covering industry, agriculture and social services, with state control of key industries; its reports came out in 1948 |
| Bombay Plan | 1944 | Eight industrialists including J.R.D. Tata, G.D. Birla, Purshotamdas Thakurdas, Lala Shri Ram, Kasturbhai Lalbhai, A.D. Shroff, Ardeshir Dalal and John Matthai | A fifteen-year plan of about Rs 10,000 crore, to double per capita income and nearly triple national income, with state-led infrastructure and heavy industry |
| Gandhian Plan | 1944 | Shriman Narayan Agarwal | A ten-year plan of about Rs 3,500 crore on Gandhian lines, stressing agriculture, village and cottage industry and decentralisation |
| People’s Plan | 1945 | M.N. Roy and the Indian Federation of Labour | A ten-year plan of about Rs 15,000 crore, giving priority to agriculture and consumer goods, with land nationalisation and a socialist outlook |
| Sarvodaya Plan | 1950 | Jayaprakash Narayan | Based on the ideas of Gandhi and Vinoba Bhave, with stress on village self-rule, land reform and the Bhoodan movement |
How Do the Pre-Independence Plans Differ in Approach?
| Plan | Ideological leaning | Priority | Role of the state |
|---|---|---|---|
| Visvesvaraya Plan | Liberal, modernising | Industry | Active, to promote industrialisation |
| Congress Plan | Nehruvian, socialist-leaning | Heavy and basic industry with social goals | Strong, public control of key sectors |
| Bombay Plan | Industrialist, pro-state in infrastructure | Capital goods, power, transport | Large role in basic sectors, private firms elsewhere |
| Gandhian Plan | Gandhian | Agriculture, cottage and village industries | Limited, decentralised |
| People’s Plan | Marxist and radical humanist | Agriculture and consumer goods | Large, with land nationalisation |
| Sarvodaya Plan | Gandhian, Sarvodaya | Village development and land reform | Limited, community-led |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Visvesvaraya: Mokshagundam Visvesvaraya, an engineer, wrote Planned Economy for India in 1934. He proposed a ten-year plan to double national income and move people from farm to industry
- FICCI proposal: The FICCI proposal of 1934 asked for a planning commission and is commonly attributed to N.R. Sarkar. It is listed as a proposal and not a full plan
- Congress Plan: The National Planning Committee was set up in October 1938 under the Congress president Subhas Chandra Bose, with Nehru as chairman. It formed subcommittees on many subjects, and its work was interrupted by the war
- Bombay Plan: Written in 1944 and formally called A Plan of Economic Development for India, it supported state planning of basic industry and infrastructure, while keeping a place for private enterprise. It aimed at about Rs 10,000 crore of investment over 15 years
- Why the Bombay Plan matters: It showed that Indian business itself wanted state help in building power, steel and transport. It is seen as an influence on the mixed economy and the public sector role in the Second Plan
- Gandhian Plan: Shriman Narayan Agarwal wrote it in 1944. It aimed at an outlay of about Rs 3,500 crore over ten years and gave priority to agriculture and cottage industries
- People’s Plan: M.N. Roy released it in 1945. It envisaged Rs 15,000 crore over ten years, more spending on consumer goods and agriculture and state ownership of land
- Sarvodaya Plan: Jayaprakash Narayan prepared it in 1950, after Gandhi’s death, drawing on Gandhi’s and Vinoba Bhave’s thinking on Sarvodaya, meaning the welfare of all
- Government steps before 1947: The Viceroy’s government created a Department of Planning and Development in 1944 under Ardeshir Dalal and an Advisory Planning Board in 1946 under K.C. Neogy, which recommended a Planning Commission
- Link to later events: The Planning Commission was set up on 15 March 1950, as in History of Planning in India; Planning Commission and National Development Council (NDC)
- Link to models: The Gandhian Plan fits the Gandhian model in Planning Strategies / Models: Harrod–Domar; Nehru–Mahalanobis; Gandhian; Wage-Good Model; LPG Strategy; Rao–Manmohan Model; Amartya Sen Model
- Memory trick: Order by year: Visvesvaraya 1934, FICCI 1934, Congress 1938, Bombay 1944, Gandhian 1944, People’s 1945, Sarvodaya 1950
- Mains view: A fuller analysis is in Planning in India: issues related to planning; Bombay Plan, People’s Plan, Mahalanobis Plan, Wage-Good Model, Gandhian Plan; Mobilisation of Resources
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Author matching: Visvesvaraya, Shriman Narayan Agarwal, M.N. Roy, Jayaprakash Narayan, and the industrialists of the Bombay Plan
- Year matching: 1934, 1938, 1944, 1945 and 1950
- Features: Bombay Plan Rs 10,000 crore, Gandhian Plan Rs 3,500 crore, People’s Plan Rs 15,000 crore
- Ideology: Industrialist, Gandhian, Marxist and Sarvodaya approaches
- Common errors: Crediting the Bombay Plan to the Congress, or mixing the Gandhian Plan of 1944 with the Sarvodaya Plan of 1950
As an analytical point, these plans show that planning was an Indian idea before independence and came from business, nationalist, Gandhian and left thinkers alike. The mixed economy that India adopted drew from all of them.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Authors Match the plan and writer
- Years 1934 to 1950
- Ideas Four schools of thought
What Came Next?
The next topic traces the history of planning and the Planning Commission and the National Development Council. Next topic: History of Planning in India; Planning Commission and National Development Council (NDC).
Key People and Terms
- Bombay Plan 1944 industrialists’ plan
- Gandhian Plan 1944 village-based plan
- People’s Plan 1945 M.N. Roy plan
- Sarvodaya Plan 1950 JP plan
- National Planning Committee Congress body of 1938
- Visvesvaraya Plan 1934 ten-year plan
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Visvesvaraya Plan: 1934, double income in 10 years.
- Congress NPC: 1938, Nehru chairman.
- Bombay Plan: 1944, Rs 10,000 crore, 15 years.
- Gandhian Plan: Shriman Narayan Agarwal.
- People’s Plan: M.N. Roy, 1945.
Do Not Confuse With
- Gandhian Plan and Sarvodaya Plan Agarwal 1944 versus Jayaprakash Narayan 1950
- Bombay Plan and People’s Plan Industrialists versus M.N. Roy
- FICCI proposal and Bombay Plan Chamber proposal 1934 versus 1944 industrialists’ plan
Memory Hook
Visvesvaraya first in 1934, Bombay in 1944, Roy in 1945, JP in 1950.
Mains Angle
Questions ask what these plans contributed to later planning. These points give a frame.
- Range Four schools of thought
- Influence Mixed economy and public sector
- Gaps Not official plans
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Examine the main pre-independence plans for India and their influence on post-independence planning.”
How to Answer
- List Seven plans with authors.
- Compare Ideology and priority.
- Influence Mixed economy.
- Limit No official force.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the pre-independence plans of India?
The pre-independence plans are the Visvesvaraya Plan (1934), the FICCI proposal (1934), the Congress Plan (1938), the Bombay Plan (1944), the Gandhian Plan (1944), the People's Plan (1945) and the Sarvodaya Plan (1950). They were proposals and not official government plans.
Who made the Bombay Plan and when?
The Bombay Plan was made in 1944 by eight leading industrialists, including J.R.D. Tata, G.D. Birla and Purshotamdas Thakurdas. It proposed about Rs 10,000 crore of investment over 15 years, to double per capita income, with the state leading in basic industry and infrastructure.
Who wrote the Gandhian Plan?
The Gandhian Plan was written in 1944 by Shriman Narayan Agarwal. It proposed about Rs 3,500 crore over ten years and emphasised agriculture, cottage and village industries and decentralised economic life, following the economic thought of Mahatma Gandhi.
What was the People's Plan of 1945?
The People's Plan was drawn up in 1945 by M.N. Roy and the Indian Federation of Labour. It proposed about Rs 15,000 crore over ten years, stressed agriculture and consumer goods and called for nationalisation of land and key industries from a Marxist and radical humanist view.
Who prepared the Sarvodaya Plan?
Jayaprakash Narayan prepared the Sarvodaya Plan in 1950. It was based on the ideas of Mahatma Gandhi and Vinoba Bhave, with stress on village self-rule, land reform and voluntary action such as the Bhoodan movement.
Who wrote the Visvesvaraya Plan?
Sir M. Visvesvaraya, an engineer and statesman, wrote Planned Economy for India in 1934. It proposed a ten-year plan to double national income through industrialisation and a shift of workers from agriculture to industry, which became the base of later industrial planning.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The Bombay Plan was prepared by leading industrialists in 1944.
Including Tata and Birla.
2 The People's Plan was drawn up by Shriman Narayan Agarwal.
It was by M.N. Roy; Agarwal wrote the Gandhian Plan.
3 The Sarvodaya Plan was prepared by Jayaprakash Narayan.
It dates to 1950.
4 The Visvesvaraya Plan was published in 1944.
It was published in 1934.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index