An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 9.29

Fiscal federalism and Centre-state transfers

Indian Economy › Public Finance: Budget, Deficits and Fiscal Policy · Topic 9.29

Fiscal federalism is the division of taxing and spending powers between the Union and the states, and the transfers that correct the gap between them. In India the Centre holds the more elastic taxes while states carry large service duties, which creates a vertical fiscal imbalance. It is bridged through three channels: tax devolution and grants recommended by the Finance Commission under Article 280, Centrally Sponsored Schemes and other discretionary transfers under Article 282, and GST sharing through the GST Council. In 2026-27 the Union Budget estimates total resources to states at about Rs 25.44 lakh crore, as reported.

Share:
Fiscal federalism and Centre-state transfers - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Total resources to states, 2026-27 About Rs 25.44 lakh crore, as stated by the Finance Minister
  • Tax devolution, 2026-27 (budget) About Rs 15.26 lakh crore at 41%, as reported
  • Finance Commission grants About Rs 1.4 lakh crore, as reported
  • CSS revenue releases About Rs 5.2 lakh crore, as reported
  • Compensation cess Ended; tobacco cess closed on 1 February 2026, as reported
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Public Finance: Budget, Deficits and Fiscal Policy

Where Does It Fit?

This Mains topic joins the constitutional rules in Centre-State Fiscal Relations: Finance Commission (Article 280), Share of Central Taxes and Divisible Pool, Exclusions (Cess and Surcharge), Grants-in-Aid (Article 275) and the money flows in Funds Transfer from Union to State: Tax Devolution, Grants, Centrally Sponsored Schemes; Total Allocation, Utilisation, Fund Allocation, Centre-State Contribution Ratio with the new formula in 16th Finance Commission: redefined horizontal devolution (formula) and the state position in RBI Report on State Finances 2025-26: key highlights. It asks whether the system is fair and efficient. Previous topic: The role of the government in the economy; need of government budgeting. Next topic: Tax: Direct Tax and Indirect Tax; Classification of Taxes Based on Incidence; Tax Incidence; Taxation System in India.

Through Which Channels Does the Centre Transfer Money to States?

Channel How it works and the latest position
Tax devolution States receive a share of the divisible pool of central taxes, fixed by the Finance Commission under Article 280. The 16th Finance Commission kept it at 41 per cent for 2026-31, and the budget estimate for 2026-27 is about Rs 15.26 lakh crore, as reported. It is untied and formula based
Finance Commission grants Grants-in-aid under Article 275 for local bodies and disaster funds. For 2026-31 the 16th Finance Commission recommended Rs 9,47,409 crore, and about Rs 1.4 lakh crore is earmarked for 2026-27, as reported. Revenue deficit grants have been discontinued
Centrally Sponsored Schemes (CSS) Schemes designed by the Centre and run by states with a cost sharing ratio, such as 60:40 or 90:10 for special category states. They are discretionary and tied, and the budget shows revenue releases of about Rs 5.2 lakh crore for 2026-27, as reported
Special assistance for capital investment The Centre gives 50-year interest-free loans to states for capital projects, conditional on reform, and these sit above the normal borrowing ceiling
GST sharing The GST Council under Article 279A decides rates and rules. The state share of IGST and CGST is built into the revenue base, and states have lost the power to set most indirect tax rates independently
GST compensation States were promised compensation for five years from July 2017 for revenue loss, financed by a compensation cess. Back-to-back loans of about Rs 2.69 lakh crore were taken during the pandemic, as reported, and the cess was kept after June 2022 to repay them
Borrowing limits States borrow within a net borrowing ceiling set by the Centre under Article 293, normally 3 per cent of GSDP, with extra room for power sector reform and capital loans

Where Do Centre and States Disagree?

Issue The dispute and the evidence
Cess and surcharge They are outside the divisible pool. As reported, they have averaged over 20 per cent of gross tax revenue, so the effective share given to states is smaller than 41 per cent. States ask for a lower reliance on them
Rise of CSS Tied schemes in state subjects reduce flexibility. The 16th Finance Commission and other analysts suggest reviewing schemes that lack clear externalities, as reported
GST compensation ending The compensation cess has ended, with the tobacco levy closed on 1 February 2026, as reported, and replaced by excise duty and a new health and security cess whose collection the Centre said it would partly share. States lost an assured revenue floor
Horizontal equity Southern and western states feel that their growth subsidises others. The new GDP criterion partly meets this, while poorer states stress equalisation, as in 16th Finance Commission: redefined horizontal devolution (formula)
Borrowing control States object to conditions on borrowing room and the treatment of off-budget borrowing
Conditional grants Entry conditions on local body grants push reform but add compliance burdens
Discretionary transfers Article 282 transfers lack a formula, which invites charges of political bias

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Vertical fiscal imbalance: States handle health, education, police, agriculture and local services but collect a smaller share of revenue than they spend. This gap is the reason for transfers
  • Horizontal fiscal imbalance: States differ in their tax capacity, so transfers equalise. Income distance carries the largest weight at 42.5 per cent
  • Constitutional design: The Seventh Schedule lists Union, State and Concurrent subjects, and Articles 268 to 293 allocate taxes and transfers. The Finance Commission is the main balancing body
  • Evolution: The Planning Commission once gave plan transfers. After 2014 the Finance Commission’s role grew, tax devolution rose from 32 to 42 per cent under the 14th Finance Commission, and the 15th and 16th set it at 41 per cent
  • Cooperative federalism and competitive federalism: Cooperative federalism is seen in the GST Council and NITI Aayog, while rankings such as the Fiscal Health Index, as in Fiscal Health Index: role in assessing states’ fiscal performance; ways it encourages prudent fiscal policy, encourage competition
  • State fiscal position: The RBI reports states’ consolidated gross fiscal deficit at 3.3 per cent of GDP in 2024-25 and outstanding liabilities budgeted at 29.2 per cent of GDP at end-March 2026, as in RBI Report on State Finances 2025-26: key highlights
  • Local governments: Grants to panchayats and urban local bodies are the third tier of fiscal federalism. State Finance Commissions under Articles 243I and 243Y are meant to share state revenue with them
  • Reform direction: Simplify and merge CSS, give states more untied money, share cess revenue, bring a clear formula for discretionary grants, and strengthen the GST Council as a trust building forum
  • Fair verdict: The system is fairly rule based for devolution but less so for tied and discretionary transfers. Trust will grow if cess, CSS and borrowing rules are made transparent

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Typical question: critically examine fiscal federalism in India, with reference to Centre-state transfers and recent disputes
  2. Numbers to quote: 41 per cent devolution, Rs 9,47,409 crore grants, Rs 25.44 lakh crore total resources
  3. Constitutional anchors: Article 280, 275, 282, 279A and 293
  4. Common errors: saying CSS are Finance Commission transfers, or including cess in the divisible pool
  5. Pair it with: 16th Finance Commission formula and the GST regime

As an analytical point, India’s fiscal federalism is stable on the formula side and strained on the discretionary side. Cess, tied schemes and GST rate setting by consensus are where trust is tested.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Current 16th Commission award begins
  • Transfers Three channels
  • Disputes Cess, CSS, GST

What Came Next?

This is the last topic of the public finance macro; the next macro moves to the taxation system in India, where the taxes shared with states are studied in detail. Next topic: Tax: Direct Tax and Indirect Tax; Classification of Taxes Based on Incidence; Tax Incidence; Taxation System in India.

Key People and Terms

  • Vertical fiscal imbalance Centre has revenue, states have spending
  • Tax devolution Share of central taxes
  • Grants-in-aid Money under Article 275
  • CSS Centrally sponsored schemes
  • Divisible pool Taxes shared with states
  • GST Council Body under Article 279A

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Channels: devolution, grants, CSS, plus GST sharing and loans.
  • Devolution: 41 per cent, Article 280.
  • Grants: Article 275; discretionary: Article 282.
  • GST Council: Article 279A.
  • Cess and surcharge: outside the divisible pool.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Tax devolution and grants-in-aid Formula share of taxes versus assistance under Article 275
  • Finance Commission transfers and CSS Constitutional, mostly untied versus scheme based and tied
  • Vertical and horizontal imbalance Centre versus states, and among states

Memory Hook

Share the pool, fund the gaps, tie the schemes lightly, and talk in the Council.

Mains Angle

Questions want a balanced view. Map the channels first, then list disputes with data, then close with a reform package that builds trust.

  • Channels Devolution, grants, CSS, loans
  • Disputes Cess, tied schemes, GST
  • Equity Horizontal formula
  • Reforms Merge CSS, share cess

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Critically examine the state of fiscal federalism in India with reference to Centre-state transfers and the issues raised by states.”

How to Answer

  1. Intro Define fiscal federalism and vertical imbalance.
  2. Body 1 Transfer channels with 2026-27 numbers.
  3. Body 2 Disputes: cess, CSS, GST compensation, formula.
  4. Body 3 Reforms.
  5. Conclusion Federalism works when rules are predictable and tied money is the exception.

GS Relevance

GS Paper 2: Centre-state relations, federal structure, finance commissions; GS Paper 3: government budgeting, GST and resource mobilisation. This page maps the full set of transfers to states, the contested areas and the reform options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is fiscal federalism in India?

Fiscal federalism is the division of taxation and spending powers between the Union and states, with transfers to fill the gap. The Centre raises more revenue while states spend on health, education and local services, so tax devolution, grants and schemes channel money to states.

What is vertical fiscal imbalance?

Vertical fiscal imbalance is the gap between what states must spend and what they can raise from their own taxes. The Centre has the more elastic revenue sources while states carry large service duties, which is why the Finance Commission recommends a share of central taxes and grants.

What are the main Centre-state transfers?

The main transfers are tax devolution, which is 41 per cent of the divisible pool for 2026-31, Finance Commission grants under Article 275, Centrally Sponsored Schemes, special capital loans and GST related flows. The Finance Minister put total resources to states at about Rs 25.44 lakh crore for 2026-27.

Why are cess and surcharge a Centre-state issue?

Cess and surcharge are excluded from the divisible pool, so the Centre does not share them with states. As reported, they have averaged over 20 per cent of gross tax revenue, which means the real share states receive is lower than the 41 per cent headline.

What happened to GST compensation to states?

States were compensated for revenue loss for five years from July 2017, and the compensation cess continued after June 2022 to repay pandemic-era loans. As reported, the tobacco cess ended on 1 February 2026, which closed the compensation cess regime.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 Centrally Sponsored Schemes are transfers recommended by the Finance Commission.
False

They are discretionary Union schemes with cost sharing.

2 Cess and surcharge form part of the divisible pool of central taxes.
False

They are excluded from the pool.

3 The GST Council is established under Article 279A.
True

It decides GST rates and rules.

4 Under the 16th Finance Commission the states' share of the divisible pool is 41 per cent.
True

The same as under the 15th Finance Commission.

Share: