An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 10.1

Tax: Direct Tax and Indirect Tax; Classification of Taxes Based on Incidence; Tax Incidence; Taxation System in India

Indian Economy › Taxation System in India · Topic 10.1

A tax is a compulsory, unrequited payment made by a person or firm to the government, with no direct return of a service in proportion to the amount paid. Taxes are classified by incidence, that is, by who finally bears the burden. A direct tax, such as income tax, is paid to the government by the same person who bears it and cannot be shifted. An indirect tax, such as Goods and Services Tax (GST) or customs duty, is collected by a seller but borne by the consumer. In Budget 2026-27 direct taxes are about 61.2 per cent of India's estimated gross tax revenue of Rs 44.04 lakh crore.

Share:
Tax: Direct Tax and Indirect Tax; Classification of Taxes Based on Incidence; Tax Incidence; Taxation System in India - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Direct tax Burden cannot be shifted: income tax, corporation tax, capital gains
  • Indirect tax Burden is shifted to the buyer: GST, customs, excise
  • Legal basis Article 265: no tax without authority of law
  • Direct share About 61.2 per cent of gross tax revenue, Budget 2026-27
  • Income tax law Income-tax Act, 2025 from 1 April 2026
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Taxation System in India

Where Does It Fit?

This topic opens the macro on taxation. It sets up the vocabulary used by every later page: the progressive and regressive designs in Methods of Taxation: Progressive, Regressive, Proportional, the main direct taxes in Direct Taxes: Personal Income Tax, Corporate Tax, Securities Transaction Tax, Capital Gains; Direct Tax Code (DTC); Equalisation Levy and GAFA Tax and the indirect taxes in Indirect Taxes: Customs, Excise, VAT (VAT in India), Service Tax, Sales Tax; Anti-Dumping and Countervailing Duties. Previous topic: Fiscal federalism and Centre-state transfers. Next topic: Methods of Taxation: Progressive, Regressive, Proportional.

What Is the Difference Between a Direct Tax and an Indirect Tax?

Basis Direct tax Indirect tax
Meaning Levied on income or wealth and paid by the person on whom it is imposed Levied on goods, services or transactions and collected by an intermediary such as a seller
Incidence Impact and incidence fall on the same person Impact falls on the seller, incidence can fall on the buyer
Shifting Cannot be shifted Can be shifted forward to buyers or backward to suppliers
Fairness Usually progressive, linked to ability to pay Often regressive, because the same rate applies to rich and poor
Evasion Easier to evade through under-reporting of income Harder to avoid for the final buyer, but possible through under-billing
Effect on prices Little direct effect on prices Raises the price of the taxed item
Indian examples Personal income tax, corporation tax, capital gains tax, securities transaction tax GST, customs duty, Union excise duty, state excise on liquor
Budget 2026-27 estimate About Rs 26.97 lakh crore, 61.2 per cent of gross tax revenue About Rs 17.07 lakh crore, 38.8 per cent of gross tax revenue

What Do Impact, Shifting and Incidence of a Tax Mean?

Term Meaning Example
Impact of a tax The first point where the tax falls, that is, the person who is legally liable to pay it to the government A shopkeeper who deposits GST with the tax department
Shifting of a tax The process of passing the tax on to someone else through a higher price or lower payment to suppliers The shopkeeper adds the GST to the bill
Incidence of a tax The final resting place of the tax, that is, the person who bears the burden out of his or her own income The customer who pays the higher price
Statutory incidence Who the law says must pay The seller under GST
Economic incidence Who actually bears the burden after prices adjust Depends on elasticities of demand and supply
Effect of a tax The wider results such as lower output, changed spending and changes in welfare Fall in cars sold after a duty rise

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Also called: Direct taxes are also called taxes on income and property. Indirect taxes are also called taxes on commodities and services, or taxes on expenditure. A direct tax is a non-shiftable tax and an indirect tax is a shiftable tax
  • Classification by incidence: the logic: The study of tax incidence rests on one test. If impact and incidence are on the same person, the tax is direct. If they are on different persons, it is indirect. The test is the intended shifting, not the form of collection
  • Worked example: who bears an indirect tax: Suppose a tax of Rs 10 is imposed on each unit of a good. The share of the tax borne by buyers equals Es divided by the sum of Es and Ed, where Es is the elasticity of supply and Ed is the absolute value of the elasticity of demand. With Es = 1.5 and Ed = 0.5, the buyer share is 1.5 / (1.5 + 0.5) = 0.75, so buyers bear Rs 7.50 and sellers bear Rs 2.50 per unit. The less responsive side bears more. Salt or petrol, with low demand elasticity, push most of the tax onto the consumer
  • Worked example: GST on a bill: A shop sells a pair of shoes with a base price of Rs 1,000 and GST at 5 per cent. The buyer pays Rs 1,050. The seller is liable for Rs 50, but the buyer bears it. Both the legal impact and the final burden are in different hands, which is why GST is indirect
  • Worked example: share in revenue: The Budget 2026-27 estimates are gross tax revenue Rs 44,04,086 crore, corporation tax Rs 12.31 lakh crore and taxes on income Rs 14.66 lakh crore. Direct = 12.31 + 14.66 = Rs 26.97 lakh crore. Share = 26.97 / 44.04 = 0.612, which is 61.2 per cent. The balance of 38.8 per cent comes from GST, customs, Union excise duties and other taxes. These are Budget estimates, and actual collections can differ
  • Trap: securities transaction tax: Securities Transaction Tax (STT) is levied on each purchase or sale of listed securities, which looks like a transaction tax. It is still treated as a direct tax, because it is levied on the taxpayer as a part of taxes on income and cannot be passed on in a way that GST can
  • Taxation powers in the Constitution: Article 265 says no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law. The Seventh Schedule divides powers. Entry 82 of the Union List covers income tax other than on agricultural income, and Entry 46 of the State List covers taxes on agricultural income. Article 246A, added by the 101st Amendment, gives Parliament and the legislature of every state power to make laws on GST
  • Income tax law now: India is in its first tax year under the Income-tax Act, 2025, which came into force on 1 April 2026 and replaced the Income-tax Act, 1961. It replaces assessment year and previous year with a single term, tax year
  • Why India relies on both: Direct taxes bring equity and build on a formal income base, but only a small share of the population pays income tax. Indirect taxes reach everyone who consumes and are easy to collect but burden the poor more. The balance is a continuing policy choice, and the trend in collection is covered in Classification of taxes: recent trends in tax collection
  • Tax to GDP and buoyancy: How much tax India collects compared with the size of its economy, and how revenue responds to growth, are covered in Tax Buoyancy; Tax to GDP Ratio; Non-Tax Revenue (Dividends, Spectrum, Fees). Types of receipts are in Classification of Receipts: Revenue Receipts (Tax and Non-Tax) and Capital Receipts (Loans, Sale of Government Assets, Disinvestment)

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Classification: Questions ask which of a list of taxes is direct or indirect, usually mixing in STT, customs and GST
  2. Definition of incidence: Direct tax: impact and incidence on the same person. Indirect tax: impact and incidence on different persons
  3. Constitution: Article 265, Article 246A, Union List Entry 82 and State List Entry 46
  4. Data: Budget estimates of the direct and indirect share, usually in a Mains data point
  5. Common errors: Calling STT or capital gains tax indirect, or calling a tax direct because the government collects it directly

As an analytical point, a healthy tax system uses both kinds. Direct taxes make the system fairer, and indirect taxes make it broad and stable. The task of policy is to widen the direct tax base without raising the burden on the honest taxpayer who already pays.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Basics Direct and indirect, impact and incidence
  • Constitution Article 265 and the Seventh Schedule
  • Data Direct tax share near 61 per cent

What Came Next?

The next topic explains how tax rates change with income: progressive, regressive and proportional taxation. Next topic: Methods of Taxation: Progressive, Regressive, Proportional.

Key People and Terms

  • Direct tax Burden stays with the payer
  • Indirect tax Burden passed to the buyer
  • Impact Where the tax first falls
  • Incidence Where it finally rests
  • Shifting Passing the tax on
  • Article 265 No tax without law

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Direct: income, corporation, capital gains, STT.
  • Indirect: GST, customs, excise.
  • Buyer share of a tax = Es / (Es + Ed).
  • No tax without law: Article 265.
  • GST power: Article 246A.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Impact and incidence First payer versus final bearer
  • Direct tax and tax collected directly The test is shifting, not the collector
  • Tax and fee A tax has no direct quid pro quo, a fee does
  • Tax and cess A cess is a tax earmarked for a purpose

Memory Hook

If it sticks to you, it is direct, and if you can pass it along, it is indirect.

Mains Angle

A Mains question may ask about the balance between direct and indirect taxes. These points give a frame.

  • Equity Direct taxes are more progressive
  • Efficiency Indirect taxes are broad and easy to collect
  • Balance Widen the direct tax base, simplify indirect taxes

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Distinguish between direct and indirect taxes and discuss the balance between them in the Indian tax system.”

How to Answer

  1. Define Incidence and shifting.
  2. Compare Equity, efficiency, evasion.
  3. Data Share of direct taxes.
  4. Conclude Broaden the base.

GS Relevance

Prelims: meaning of tax, direct versus indirect tax, incidence, taxation powers in the Constitution. GS Paper 3: government budgeting, resource mobilisation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between direct and indirect tax?

A direct tax is paid to the government by the person on whom it is levied, and the burden cannot be shifted, as with income tax. An indirect tax is collected by a seller but borne by the consumer through a higher price, as with GST and customs duty.

What is tax incidence?

Tax incidence is the final resting place of a tax, that is, the person or group who bears the burden out of their own income after prices adjust. It differs from the legal impact, which is the person who must pay the tax to the government.

What is the formula for the buyer share of a tax?

The buyer share of an indirect tax is Es divided by the sum of Es and the absolute value of Ed, where Es is the elasticity of supply and Ed is the elasticity of demand. If Es is 1.5 and Ed is 0.5, buyers bear 75 per cent of the tax.

Is STT a direct or an indirect tax?

Securities Transaction Tax is treated as a direct tax in India. Although it is charged on each transaction in listed securities, it is levied on the investor and forms a part of taxes on income and capital, so it is not shifted like GST.

Which is bigger in India, direct or indirect taxes?

Direct taxes are bigger. In Budget 2026-27 they are estimated at about Rs 26.97 lakh crore, which is 61.2 per cent of gross tax revenue of Rs 44.04 lakh crore. Indirect taxes are the remaining 38.8 per cent. These are budget estimates, not final collections.

Which Article of the Constitution says no tax can be levied without law?

Article 265 of the Constitution says that no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law. It means the executive cannot impose a tax by itself, and every tax must rest on an Act of Parliament or a state legislature.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 In a direct tax, the impact and incidence fall on the same person.
True

That is the classical test of a direct tax.

2 Securities Transaction Tax is an indirect tax.
False

It is treated as a direct tax in India.

3 Article 265 prohibits the levy of tax without authority of law.
True

A tax must have the backing of a law.

4 Agricultural income can be taxed by the Union under the Union List.
False

Tax on agricultural income is a State List subject.

Share: