Fiscal Health Index: role in assessing states’ fiscal performance; ways it encourages prudent fiscal policy
Indian Economy › Public Finance: Budget, Deficits and Fiscal Policy · Topic 9.25
The Fiscal Health Index (FHI) is an annual scorecard from NITI Aayog that ranks Indian states on the quality of their public finances using Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) verified data. It scores five sub-indices, namely quality of expenditure, revenue mobilisation, fiscal prudence, the debt index and debt sustainability, and sorts states into Achievers, Front-Runners, Performers and Aspirational groups. The first edition (January 2025, 2022-23 data) put Odisha first with 67.8 points; the second edition (March 2026, 2023-24 data) kept Odisha first with 73.1 and added ten North-Eastern and Himalayan states. It rewards prudence through peer benchmarking, not through money.
8 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Public Finance: Budget, Deficits and Fiscal Policy
At a Glance
- Issuer NITI Aayog, annual index using CAG verified data
- First edition 24 January 2025; 18 major states; 2022-23 data; Odisha 67.8, Chhattisgarh 55.2, Goa 53.6
- Second edition March 2026; 18 major plus 10 North-Eastern and Himalayan states; 2023-24 data
- Top of 2026 list Odisha 73.1, Goa 54.7, Jharkhand 50.5, as reported
- Bottom of 2026 list Kerala 15th, West Bengal 16th, Andhra Pradesh 17th, Punjab 18th
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Public Finance: Budget, Deficits and Fiscal Policy
Where Does It Fit?
This Mains topic applies the ideas in Government Deficits: Revenue Deficit, Fiscal Deficit, Primary Deficit, Effective Revenue Deficit; General Analysis of Deficits and FRBM Act 2003 (FRBMA): Medium-Term Fiscal Policy Statement, Fiscal Policy Strategy Statement, Macroeconomic Framework Statement, Fiscal Targets, Escape Clause; FRBM (Amendment) 2012; Statement of Revenue Foregone; N.K. Singh Committee (2017) and Debt-to-GDP Shift to the states, and uses the receipts and spending categories in Classification of Receipts: Revenue Receipts (Tax and Non-Tax) and Capital Receipts (Loans, Sale of Government Assets, Disinvestment) and Classification of Expenditure: Plan and Non-Plan (Revenue and Capital); Revenue and Capital Expenditure; Capital Expenditure Quality. It prepares the next topic on how the Centre divides its taxes among the states in 16th Finance Commission: redefined horizontal devolution (formula). Previous topic: Government borrowings: components of Government’s debt and liabilities; factors contributing to increased public debt in India. Next topic: 16th Finance Commission: redefined horizontal devolution (formula).
How Does the Fiscal Health Index Judge a State?
| Sub-index | What it measures and what a good score shows |
|---|---|
| Quality of expenditure | Compares developmental spending with non-developmental spending, capital outlay as a share of gross state domestic product (GSDP) and the share of committed expenditure on salaries, pensions and interest. A high score means more money goes into roads, schools and health than into fixed bills |
| Revenue mobilisation | Looks at own tax revenue, state GST collections and non-tax revenue as a share of total receipts. A high score means a state can pay for its needs without leaning on Union transfers |
| Fiscal prudence | Tracks the fiscal deficit, the revenue deficit and compliance with FRBM limits, as in FRBM Act 2003 (FRBMA): Medium-Term Fiscal Policy Statement, Fiscal Policy Strategy Statement, Macroeconomic Framework Statement, Fiscal Targets, Escape Clause; FRBM (Amendment) 2012; Statement of Revenue Foregone; N.K. Singh Committee (2017) and Debt-to-GDP Shift. A high score means borrowing stays close to the 3 per cent of GSDP norm |
| Debt index | Compares outstanding liabilities and interest payments with the size of the state economy. A high score means a light debt burden |
| Debt sustainability | Compares the growth of GSDP with the interest rate on debt. If GSDP grows faster than interest cost, debt stays manageable; if not, debt compounds |
| Data and method | Scores come from CAG verified finance accounts so that the ranking cannot be disputed on numbers. The 2026 edition, as reported, uses a decade of data from 2014-15 to 2023-24 and ranks the 10 North-Eastern and Himalayan states in a separate list |
| Categories | Achievers, Front-Runners, Performers and Aspirational. In 2026 the Achievers among major states were Odisha, Goa and Jharkhand, and the Aspirational group was West Bengal, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh and Punjab |
What Do the Two Editions Show About State Finances?
| Finding | Evidence, as of Nov 2026 |
|---|---|
| Odisha leads twice | Odisha scored 67.8 in the 2025 edition and 73.1 in the 2026 edition, helped by mining linked non-tax revenue, a low debt burden and controlled deficits |
| Achievers share a profile | As reported for 2026, Achiever states have own tax shares above 60 per cent of revenue, capital outlay near 4 to 5 per cent of GSDP, fiscal deficit below 3 per cent and debt under 25 per cent of GSDP |
| Aspirational states carry a debt trap | Aspirational major states hold debt of about 35 to 45 per cent of GSDP, with committed expenditure of about 50 to 60 per cent of revenue receipts, as reported. In Punjab, salaries, pensions and interest took about 80 per cent of revenue receipts in 2023-24 |
| Capital spending gap | The 2025 edition found that Madhya Pradesh, Odisha, Goa, Karnataka and Uttar Pradesh gave about 27 per cent of spending to capital, against about 10 per cent in West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh, Punjab and Rajasthan, as reported |
| Movement across groups | Bihar moved from Aspirational to Performer, Karnataka and Telangana slipped from Front-Runner to Performer, and Tamil Nadu slipped from Performer to Aspirational, as reported |
| Special category states differ | In the separate list Arunachal Pradesh ranked first and Uttarakhand was also an Achiever, while Himachal Pradesh, Manipur and Nagaland were Aspirational, as reported |
| Deficit breaches | Andhra Pradesh’s fiscal deficit was reported at 4.35 per cent of GSDP, above the 4 per cent ceiling under its framework, and West Bengal spent over 20 per cent of revenue receipts on interest |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Why a ranking and not a rule: The FHI is not a legal limit like the FRBM Act. It works through public comparison, a form of competitive federalism in which states want to move up a published table, as in Fiscal federalism and Centre-state transfers
- How it encourages prudent policy: Each sub-index points to a lever: raise own tax revenue and GST compliance, curb committed expenditure, protect capital outlay, keep the deficit near 3 per cent of GSDP and avoid off-budget borrowing
- Link to borrowing space: The Centre ties its 50-year interest-free capital loans to states to reform conditions, so a clean fiscal profile helps a state make its case for fiscal space
- Link to markets: State development loans are priced by investors on credit quality. States with clean numbers can borrow longer at finer spreads, as discussed in Government Borrowings: Market Borrowings, Loans from Banks and FIs, External Debt, Small Savings and Provident Funds, State Development Loans, Securities Against Small Savings, Special Securities Issued to RBI, Other Liabilities; Ways and Means Advances; UDAY Bonds
- Early warning: Rising committed expenditure, interest above 15 to 20 per cent of revenue receipts and growing off-budget borrowing show stress before a crisis, so the index works as a dashboard for state finance departments
- NITI Aayog advice, as reported: Broaden the GST base, strengthen property tax, excise and stamp duty, rationalise subsidies including unconditional cash transfers, improve the composition of capital outlay and use multi-year fiscal frameworks
- Limits: A single score can hide context: hill states bear higher costs, poorer states have thin tax bases, and a low capital share may reflect a weak starting point. The index also uses past data, so it lags policy changes
- Risk of gaming: States may cut investment to improve the deficit number, or move borrowing to public sector companies. The index therefore watches the quality of expenditure and off-budget borrowing
- Fair verdict: A good transparency tool that complements, not replaces, the Finance Commission and FRBM framework. It would work better if scores were tied to a simple menu of incentives and adjusted for starting conditions
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Typical question: examine how the Fiscal Health Index assesses state finances and how it can encourage fiscal prudence
- Facts to quote: five sub-indices, CAG data, Odisha first in both editions, 18 states in 2025 and 28 in 2026
- Angle: index as a tool of competitive federalism and peer pressure rather than a legal limit
- Common errors: calling it a Finance Commission product, or listing Kerala among the top five
- Pair it with: FRBM, the 16th Finance Commission formula and the RBI state finances report
As an analytical point, a fiscal index can change behaviour only if the data is trusted and the ranking is read as a diagnosis, not a punishment. The FHI scores well on trust because of CAG data, and its next step is to link results to reform support.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Mains 2025 Listed as an exam theme
- Current Second edition in March 2026
- Federalism Peer pressure over central control
What Came Next?
The next topic explains how the 16th Finance Commission redrew the formula for sharing central taxes among states. Next topic: 16th Finance Commission: redefined horizontal devolution (formula).
Key People and Terms
- Committed expenditure Salaries, pensions and interest
- Capital outlay Spending that creates assets
- Own tax revenue Taxes raised by the state
- Debt sustainability Growth versus interest rate
- Off-budget borrowing Borrowing outside the budget
- Competitive federalism States compete on performance
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Five sub-indices: expenditure quality, revenue mobilisation, fiscal prudence, debt index, debt sustainability.
- Issuer: NITI Aayog, data: CAG verified.
- Odisha first in 2025 (67.8) and 2026 (73.1).
- 2026 edition: 28 states in two lists.
- A ranking, not a legal limit.
Do Not Confuse With
- Fiscal Health Index and Finance Commission award A ranking tool versus a formula that moves money
- FHI and FRBM Comparison tool versus a legal deficit rule
- Revenue deficit and committed expenditure A deficit measure versus the share of fixed bills in spending
Memory Hook
Spend on assets, earn your own, borrow within limits, and the table lifts you.
Mains Angle
Questions ask for design plus impact. Describe the five sub-indices briefly, then spend most words on how the index changes incentives and where it falls short.
- Design Five sub-indices and CAG data
- Findings Odisha, Goa, Punjab, Kerala
- Incentives Peer pressure and borrowing space
- Limits Context and lagging data
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Examine how the Fiscal Health Index assesses the fiscal performance of states, and discuss how it can encourage prudent fiscal policy.”
How to Answer
- Intro Define the Fiscal Health Index and note the March 2026 edition.
- Body 1 Five sub-indices and what each rewards.
- Body 2 Findings: Odisha, Goa, Jharkhand against Punjab, West Bengal, Kerala.
- Body 3 Incentive channels and limits.
- Conclusion What gets measured in public gets managed: a trusted index turns peer pressure into prudence.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Fiscal Health Index?
The Fiscal Health Index is an annual ranking of Indian states by NITI Aayog that scores public finances on five sub-indices using CAG verified data. The first edition came in January 2025 and the second in March 2026. It aims to guide state policy and promote healthy competition among states.
What are the five sub-indices of the Fiscal Health Index?
The five sub-indices are quality of expenditure, revenue mobilisation, fiscal prudence, debt index and debt sustainability. Together they judge how well a state spends, how much it earns, how closely it follows deficit norms, how heavy its debt is and whether growth can support the interest bill.
Which state is first in the Fiscal Health Index?
Odisha is first among major states in both editions, with 67.8 points in the 2025 edition and 73.1 in the 2026 edition, as reported. Its strengths are mining linked non-tax revenue, a low debt burden and a controlled deficit. Goa and Jharkhand were the other Achievers in 2026.
Which states are Aspirational in the Fiscal Health Index 2026?
Among the 18 major states, the Aspirational group in the 2026 edition is West Bengal, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh and Punjab, with Punjab ranked last, as reported. They face high debt, heavy committed expenditure and a large interest burden compared with revenue receipts.
How does the Fiscal Health Index encourage fiscal prudence?
It works through public comparison. Each state can see which sub-index pulls its rank down and which lever to use, such as raising own tax revenue, cutting committed expenditure or protecting capital outlay. Peer pressure, investor perception and borrowing space linked to reform give states a reason to improve.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The Fiscal Health Index is prepared by NITI Aayog.
It is an annual index using CAG verified state finance data.
2 The Fiscal Health Index has five sub-indices, one of which is debt sustainability.
The others are quality of expenditure, revenue mobilisation, fiscal prudence and the debt index.
3 Odisha ranked first among major states in the first edition of the index.
Odisha scored 67.8 in January 2025 and led again in 2026.
4 The Fiscal Health Index penalises a state with a legal fine for breaching deficit limits.
It is a ranking tool, not a penalty mechanism.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index