An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 9.15

Centre-State Fiscal Relations: Finance Commission (Article 280), Share of Central Taxes and Divisible Pool, Exclusions (Cess and Surcharge), Grants-in-Aid (Article 275)

Indian Economy › Public Finance: Budget, Deficits and Fiscal Policy · Topic 9.15

The Finance Commission is a constitutional body under Article 280 that the President sets up every five years to recommend how the net proceeds of Union taxes are shared between the Centre and the states and among the states, and which grants-in-aid the Centre should give under Article 275. The shareable amount is the divisible pool, which is gross tax revenue minus the cost of collection and minus cesses and surcharges, because these two are kept wholly by the Centre. The 16th Finance Commission, chaired by Arvind Panagariya, kept the states' share at 41 per cent for 2026-27 to 2030-31, the same as the 15th Finance Commission.

Share:
Centre-State Fiscal Relations: Finance Commission (Article 280), Share of Central Taxes and Divisible Pool, Exclusions (Cess and Surcharge), Grants-in-Aid (Article 275) - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Constitutional body Finance Commission, Article 280, every 5 years
  • 16th FC chair Arvind Panagariya
  • States’ share (2026-31) 41 per cent of divisible pool
  • Not in divisible pool Cess, surcharge, cost of collection
  • Grants-in-aid Article 275 (statutory), Article 282 (discretionary)
  • 2026-27 devolution Rs 15,26,255 crore (Budget estimate)
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Public Finance: Budget, Deficits and Fiscal Policy

Where Does It Fit?

This topic starts the federal finance section of the macro. The tax rates and the GST Council are explained in Goods and Services Tax (GST): Introduction, Dual GST Model, CGST, SGST, IGST, UTGST; Destination-Based Tax; Multiple Tax Levels; Input Tax Credit; Compliance and Reporting and GST Compensation Cess; Cess and Surcharge, and the money that actually reaches the states is traced in the next topic. Previous topic: Disinvestment in PSUs: DIPAM, Token Disinvestment, Strategic Disinvestment; National Investment Fund (NIF). Next topic: Funds Transfer from Union to State: Tax Devolution, Grants, Centrally Sponsored Schemes; Total Allocation, Utilisation, Fund Allocation, Centre-State Contribution Ratio.

How Does the Finance Commission Share Union Taxes with the States?

Term Meaning Rule or number
Finance Commission Body under Article 280 with a chairman and four members Appointed by the President at least every five years
Vertical devolution Share of the Centre and states in Union taxes 41 per cent to states in the 15th and 16th FC, 42 per cent in the 14th FC, 32 per cent in the 13th FC
Horizontal devolution Division of the states’ share among states Formula based on income distance, population, area, forests and other criteria
Divisible pool Net tax revenue that is shareable (Article 270) Gross tax revenue less cost of collection less cess and surcharge
Grants-in-aid Money given in addition to the tax share Article 275 for states in need, as Parliament decides, on the Commission’s advice
Period of the 16th FC Years covered 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2031, report tabled on 1 February 2026

Why Are Cess and Surcharge Kept Out of the Divisible Pool?

  • Constitutional basis: Article 270 shares the proceeds of Union taxes, but the proceeds of a cess or surcharge levied for specific purposes are excluded, with Article 271 allowing Parliament to levy a surcharge for Union purposes. So the Centre keeps them
  • What a cess is: a tax earmarked for a stated purpose, such as the Health and Education Cess and the road infrastructure cess on fuel
  • What a surcharge is: an extra percentage charged on income tax or corporation tax for high earners, and added on top of the tax. It is levied on the tax, not on income
  • Cost of collection: the Centre deducts the expenses of collecting the tax before the pool is arrived at
  • State complaint: As cesses and surcharges grow, the pool shrinks. Estimates of their share in gross tax revenue differ, from about 12.8 per cent to above 20 per cent in different years, as reported. The 16th FC said capping them or putting them into the pool is neither permissible nor desirable under the present constitutional scheme, as reported
  • Link with GST: The GST Compensation Cess funded compensation to states and its fate is covered in GST Compensation Cess; Cess and Surcharge

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Alternate names: The share is called tax devolution, shareable pool or net proceeds. Vertical devolution is also called vertical distribution and horizontal devolution is inter-se distribution among states
  • Article 275 and Article 282: Article 275 gives statutory grants-in-aid recommended by the Finance Commission to states needing assistance. Article 282 allows the Union or a state to make discretionary grants for any public purpose, which is how many scheme grants are given
  • Article 268, 269, 269A: Duties levied by the Union but collected and kept by states (Article 268, such as stamp duties), taxes on interstate sale (269) and the IGST on interstate trade (269A). They are outside the Article 270 pool
  • Worked example: effective share: For 2026-27 the gross tax revenue is estimated at Rs 44,04,086 crore and devolution to states at Rs 15,26,255 crore. The effective share is 15,26,255 / 44,04,086 = 0.3466, that is 34.7 per cent of gross taxes, not 41 per cent
  • Worked example: pool back-calculation: If devolution is 41 per cent of the pool, then pool = 15,26,255 / 0.41 = about Rs 37,22,573 crore. The amount kept out is 44,04,086 – 37,22,573 = about Rs 6,81,513 crore, or 15.5 per cent of gross tax revenue. This working treats collection costs, cess and surcharge as the only deductions, so it is indicative, not official
  • Worked example: simple pool: Take gross tax revenue of Rs 100. If cess, surcharge and collection cost are Rs 15, the pool is Rs 85 and the states get 41 per cent of 85 = Rs 34.85. Raising the excluded items to Rs 20 cuts the states’ amount to 0.41 x 80 = Rs 32.80
  • Horizontal formula of the 16th FC: Income distance 42.5 per cent, population (2011) 17.5, demographic performance 10, area 10, forest 10 and contribution to GDP 10, a new criterion. Tax and fiscal effort of 2.5 per cent in the 15th FC was dropped. In the 15th FC the weights were income distance 45, population 15, area 15, demographic performance 12.5, forest 10 and tax effort 2.5
  • State shares: Uttar Pradesh gets the largest share at 17.62 per cent and Sikkim the smallest at 0.34 per cent, as reported. On the 2026-27 amount, 17.62 per cent is about Rs 2,68,926 crore for Uttar Pradesh and 0.34 per cent is about Rs 5,189 crore for Sikkim, worked from the Budget figure
  • Grants of the 16th FC: Total grants of Rs 9,47,409 crore over five years, of which Rs 7,91,493 crore go to local bodies and Rs 1,55,916 crore is the Centre’s share for disaster management. Revenue deficit grants and sector-specific and state-specific grants were discontinued
  • Fiscal roadmap: The 16th FC advised a Centre fiscal deficit of 3.5 per cent of GDP by 2030-31 and a limit of 3 per cent of GSDP for states, and discontinuing off-budget borrowing by states
  • Terms of reference and role: The Commission also reviews the finance of local bodies, disaster funds and any matter the President refers. Its advice is recommendatory but the Centre has accepted the tax share in practice. The Finance Commission is distinct from the NITI Aayog and from the former Planning Commission

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Articles: 280 Finance Commission, 270 sharing of taxes, 275 statutory grants, 282 discretionary grants, 268 to 269A special duties
  2. Numbers: 41 per cent in the 15th and 16th, 42 in the 14th, 32 in the 13th
  3. Divisible pool: Excludes cess, surcharge and cost of collection
  4. New criterion: Contribution to GDP at 10 per cent in the 16th FC
  5. Common errors: Saying the Finance Commission is statutory, that the Planning Commission set shares, or that cess is shared with states

As an analytical point, the 41 per cent headline overstates what states receive, because the effective share of gross taxes is nearer 35 per cent. The federal bargain would be clearer if cess and surcharge were capped at a small share of gross tax revenue.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Articles Direct one-line MCQs
  • Pool Cess and surcharge exclusion
  • Numbers 14th, 15th and 16th shares

What Came Next?

The next topic follows the money from the Union to the states through devolution, grants and centrally sponsored schemes. Next topic: Funds Transfer from Union to State: Tax Devolution, Grants, Centrally Sponsored Schemes; Total Allocation, Utilisation, Fund Allocation, Centre-State Contribution Ratio.

Key People and Terms

  • Divisible pool Shareable net tax revenue
  • Vertical devolution Centre versus states
  • Horizontal devolution Among states
  • Cess Earmarked tax, not shared
  • Surcharge Extra tax on tax, not shared
  • Grants-in-aid Article 275 aid to states

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Article 280: Finance Commission every five years.
  • States’ share: 41 per cent (15th and 16th FC).
  • Pool excludes cess, surcharge, collection cost.
  • Statutory grants: Article 275.
  • New 16th FC criterion: contribution to GDP.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Article 275 and Article 282 Statutory grants on Commission advice versus discretionary grants
  • Vertical and horizontal devolution Centre-state split versus state-state split
  • Gross tax revenue and divisible pool Total taxes versus shareable net proceeds

Memory Hook

Gross tax, minus cess, surcharge and collection cost, makes the pool; the states take forty-one parts of a hundred.

Mains Angle

A Mains question may ask how fiscal federalism can be strengthened. These points give a frame and are developed in the Mains pages of this macro.

  • Design Vertical and horizontal formula
  • Concern Cess and surcharge
  • Way Cap cess, predictable transfers

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Explain how the Finance Commission shapes Centre-state fiscal relations and discuss the concerns of states over the divisible pool.”

How to Answer

  1. Define Article 280 body.
  2. Explain Pool, 41 per cent, grants.
  3. Assess Cess and surcharge.
  4. Conclude Cap and clarity.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Article 280, Article 270, Article 275, divisible pool, cess and surcharge, 14th, 15th and 16th Finance Commission shares. GS Paper 2 and 3: federalism, Centre-state finance.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Finance Commission of India?

The Finance Commission is a constitutional body under Article 280 that the President appoints at least every five years. It recommends how Union taxes are shared with the states, the principles for grants-in-aid under Article 275, and measures to support local bodies. The 16th Commission was chaired by Arvind Panagariya.

What is the divisible pool of taxes?

The divisible pool is the part of the Centre's gross tax revenue that is shared with the states. It is arrived at after deducting the cost of collection and the proceeds of cesses and surcharges, which the Centre keeps alone. The states receive a fixed percentage of this pool, now 41 per cent.

Why are cess and surcharge excluded from the divisible pool?

They are excluded because the Constitution lets the Centre keep the proceeds of cesses and surcharges levied for specific purposes. This means growth in these levies does not increase the states' share, which is why states want them capped. The 16th Finance Commission did not change this treatment.

What is the 16th Finance Commission share of states in central taxes?

The 16th Finance Commission recommended that the states receive 41 per cent of the divisible pool for 2026-27 to 2030-31, unchanged from the 15th Finance Commission. For 2026-27 the Budget estimates devolution at Rs 15,26,255 crore, which is about 34.7 per cent of gross tax revenue.

What is the difference between Article 275 and Article 282 grants?

Article 275 grants are statutory grants-in-aid to states in need, based on the Finance Commission recommendation and a law of Parliament. Article 282 grants are discretionary grants that the Union can give for any public purpose, and they fund most scheme transfers outside the Commission process.

What is the difference between vertical and horizontal devolution?

Vertical devolution decides the split of taxes between the Centre and all states together, which is 41 per cent for the states. Horizontal devolution divides the states' share among individual states using a formula of income distance, population, area, forests and contribution to GDP, among others.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Finance Commission is constituted under Article 280 of the Constitution.
True

The President appoints it every five years or earlier.

2 The divisible pool includes the proceeds of cesses and surcharges.
False

Cess and surcharge are kept by the Centre and are excluded.

3 The 16th Finance Commission recommended a states' share of 41 per cent of the divisible pool.
True

Unchanged from the 15th Finance Commission.

4 Grants-in-aid to needy states on the recommendation of the Finance Commission are given under Article 275.
True

These are statutory grants-in-aid.

5 Contribution to GDP was a criterion in the 15th Finance Commission formula.
False

It was introduced as a new criterion by the 16th Finance Commission.

Share: