An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 10.4

Statement and Inference – Distinguishing Inferences from Given Information

Reasoning › Statement-Assumption, Statement-Argument and Statement-Conclusion · Topic 10.4

An inference is a conclusion drawn from given facts, and in the five-grade format you classify it as definitely true, probably true, data inadequate, probably false or definitely false. Definitely true or false means the facts force the answer. Probably true or false means the facts make it likely but not certain. Data inadequate means the facts say nothing decisive about the inference.

Share:
Statement and Inference – Distinguishing Inferences from Given Information - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

An inference is a conclusion drawn from given facts, and in the five-grade format you classify it as definitely true, probably true, data inadequate, probably false or definitely false. Definitely true or false means the facts force the answer. Probably true or false means the facts make it likely but not certain. Data inadequate means the facts say nothing decisive about the inference.

At a Glance

  • Task Grade an inference against the given facts
  • Five grades Definitely true, probably true, data inadequate, probably false, definitely false
  • Definitely Forced by the facts, no doubt
  • Probably Likely on the facts but not certain
  • Data inadequate Facts do not settle it
  • Source of truth Only the passage, not general knowledge

Where Does It Fit?

The statement and inference format is the fourth topic of the Statement-Assumption, Statement-Argument and Statement-Conclusion macro, and the inference from data it tests is graded on five levels. It extends the yes or no judgment of Statement and Conclusion – Determining Logically Valid Conclusions into five grades, and prepares for the longer material in Passage-Based Conclusion and Inference Problems. The line between an inference and an assumption is drawn in Distinguishing Between an Assumption and an Inference.

What Are the Five Grades of an Inference?

In short: the grades measure how strongly the facts support the inference, from certain truth to certain falsity.

Grade Meaning Quick test
Definitely true Follows with no exception from the facts The facts force it
Probably true Facts make it likely, not certain Supported, but an exception is possible
Data inadequate Facts give no decisive support either way Cannot decide from the facts
Probably false Facts make it unlikely, not impossible Opposed, but an exception is possible
Definitely false Contradicts the facts Facts make it impossible

Suppose the facts are: “In a town, 90 per cent of the households own a television.” The inference “most households in the town own a television” is definitely true. The inference “the household next door owns one” is probably true. The inference “all households own a television” is definitely false, since 10 per cent do not. The inference “the town has 50,000 households” is data inadequate.

How Do You Grade an Inference Step by Step?

In short: check for certainty first, then for likelihood, and use data inadequate when the facts are silent.

  1. Read the facts and list every number, quantity word and condition.
  2. Check whether the inference is directly stated or mathematically forced. If yes, mark definitely true.
  3. Check whether the inference contradicts the facts. If yes, mark definitely false.
  4. If the facts only lean toward the inference, mark probably true; if they lean against it, probably false.
  5. If the facts do not touch the subject at all, mark data inadequate.

Decision guide

  • Forced by facts: definitely true.
  • Impossible given facts: definitely false.
  • Leans toward or away from it: probably true or probably false.
  • Silent on it: data inadequate.

Words in the inference decide the grade. An inference with “all”, “never” or “always” is hard to prove, so it is often definitely false or data inadequate. An inference with “may”, “some” or “likely” is easier to support, so it is more likely to be probably or definitely true. For the matching method in yes or no form, see Statement and Conclusion – Determining Logically Valid Conclusions.

How Do Numbers and Causes Change the Grade?

In short: numbers can make an inference definitely true or false, while a cause-effect claim is usually only probable unless the passage states it.

Facts Inference Grade
A shop sold 400 shirts, of which 280 were blue More than half were blue Definitely true
A shop sold 400 shirts, of which 280 were blue Customers prefer blue Probably true
A shop sold 400 shirts, of which 280 were blue All shirts were blue Definitely false
A shop sold 400 shirts, of which 280 were blue The shop earned Rs 20,000 Data inadequate
Rain fell on 25 of 30 days It did not rain on a few days Definitely true
Rain fell on 25 of 30 days The next month will be rainy Data inadequate
  • Arithmetic is certain: 280 of 400 is 70 per cent, so the majority claim is definitely true.
  • Preference is probable: sales suggest a preference but other reasons may exist.
  • Future claims: without a stated trend, they are data inadequate.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Facts: “A city has 2,000 schools, of which 1,500 have a library.” Inference: Most schools in the city have a library.

  1. 1,500 out of 2,000 is 75 per cent, more than half.
  2. This follows by arithmetic alone.

Answer: Definitely true.

Example 2

Question: Facts: “A city has 2,000 schools, of which 1,500 have a library.” Inference: Every school in the city has a library.

  1. 500 schools have no library.
  2. The inference contradicts the facts.

Answer: Definitely false.

Example 3

Question: Facts: “A city has 2,000 schools, of which 1,500 have a library.” Inference: A school in the city picked at random will probably have a library.

  1. 75 per cent of schools have one, so a random pick is likely, not certain, to have one.

Answer: Probably true.

Example 4

Question: Facts: “A city has 2,000 schools, of which 1,500 have a library.” Inference: The library schools score higher in exams.

  1. The facts give no exam data.
  2. No support or opposition is found.

Answer: Data inadequate.

Example 5

Question: Facts: “In a survey of 200 people, 20 said they travel by metro daily.” Inference: A person picked at random from the surveyed group probably does not travel by metro daily.

  1. 20 of 200 is 10 per cent, so 90 per cent do not travel by metro daily.
  2. The facts lean toward the inference, but 20 people do travel by metro, so it is not forced.

Answer: Probably true.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Do the arithmetic first: percentages and fractions can settle an inference as definitely true or false.
  • Use probably only when the facts lean one way without forcing it.
  • Pick data inadequate when the inference introduces a topic the facts never mention.
  • Inferences with all, always, never and every are rarely better than definitely false or data inadequate.
  • Ignore real-world knowledge, even if it feels obvious.

Common Mistakes

  • Marking an inference definitely true because it agrees with common sense. The facts must force it.
  • Choosing probably false when the facts are silent. That is data inadequate.
  • Treating a cause-effect link as certain when only a correlation is stated.
  • Missing a contradiction hidden in a number or a quantity word.
  • Confusing probably true with definitely true after the facts show a clear trend.

Practice Questions

  1. Facts: “Of 50 students, 30 are girls.” Inference: More than half the students are girls. Grade?
  2. Facts: “Of 50 students, 30 are girls.” Inference: The class teacher is a woman. Grade?
  3. Facts: “Of 50 students, 30 are girls.” Inference: All students are boys. Grade?
  4. Facts: “A bus is late on 8 days out of 10.” Inference: The bus will probably be late tomorrow. Grade?
  5. Facts: “A village has 40 houses and 38 have electricity.” Inference: The village has a power plant. Grade?
  6. Facts: “A village has 40 houses and 38 have electricity.” Inference: More than 90 per cent of the houses have electricity. Grade?

Answers: 1) definitely true; 2) data inadequate; 3) definitely false; 4) probably true; 5) data inadequate; 6) definitely true (38 of 40 is 95 per cent).

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Format Five-grade inference questions appear in SSC, defence and banking papers.
  • Skill They sharpen the habit of separating certain, likely and unknown.
  • Link The skill supports Passage-Based Conclusion and Inference Problems and Distinguishing Between an Assumption and an Inference.
  • Everyday use It is the skill used in reading data in reports and surveys.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Passage-Based Conclusion and Inference Problems. It applies the same grading and conclusion skills to longer passages.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Inference A conclusion drawn from given facts
  • Definitely true Forced by the facts
  • Probably true Supported, but not certain
  • Data inadequate The facts do not decide it
  • Probably false Unlikely given the facts
  • Definitely false Contradicted by the facts

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Definite means forced by the facts; probable means likely only.
  • Silence in the facts means data inadequate.
  • Arithmetic can make an inference definitely true or false.
  • Never use outside knowledge to grade.
  • Absolute words in an inference are hard to prove.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Probably false vs data inadequate Probably false needs some evidence against it; data inadequate has no evidence either way.
  • Probably true vs definitely true Probably true leaves room for exceptions; definitely true leaves none.
  • Inference vs assumption An inference comes from the facts; an assumption sits behind them.
  • Inference vs opinion An inference rests on given facts; an opinion rests on belief.

Memory Hook

Forced is definite, leaning is probable, silent is inadequate.

GS Relevance

Used in SSC CGL, CDS, CAPF, bank and some state PCS reasoning papers as 'Inferences', where each inference from a passage is graded on the five-point scale.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an inference in logical reasoning?

An inference is a conclusion drawn from given facts or data. In the five-grade format, you grade each inference as definitely true, probably true, data inadequate, probably false or definitely false, depending on how strongly the facts support or oppose it.

How do you solve definitely true and probably true questions?

Check whether the facts force the inference, as with a direct statement or simple arithmetic. If so, it is definitely true. If the facts only lean towards it and an exception is possible, it is probably true. Use only the given facts.

When is the answer data inadequate?

Data inadequate is the answer when the given facts say nothing decisive about the inference, so it cannot be judged true or false even loosely. This usually happens when the inference brings in a new topic, a future event or a number that is not provided.

What is the difference between probably false and definitely false?

Definitely false means the inference contradicts the facts, so it is impossible given them. Probably false means the facts make the inference unlikely but do not rule it out, leaving a small chance that it is true.

Can common knowledge be used in inference questions?

No. The given facts are the only source. Real-world knowledge can mislead you, since an inference that is true in life may still be data inadequate on the facts. Grade strictly on what the passage provides and nothing more.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 An inference that contradicts the facts is definitely false.
True

A contradiction makes it impossible given the facts.

2 If the facts are silent on a topic, the inference is probably false.
False

Silence means data inadequate.

3 Percentages in the facts can make an inference definitely true.
True

Arithmetic can force an answer.

4 General knowledge can decide a grade even if the passage is silent.
False

Only the given facts count.

Share: