Statement and Course of Action – Determining Appropriate Follow-Up Action
Reasoning › Statement-Course of Action and Cause-Effect Reasoning · Topic 11.1
A course of action is a step or decision that should be taken to improve, solve or follow up a problem described in a statement. A course of action follows if it is practical, directly tackles the problem, is proportionate, and does not cause a bigger problem. Courses that are extreme, irrelevant, impractical, or that merely shift blame do not follow.
8 min read · Reasoning · Statement-Course of Action and Cause-Effect Reasoning
Quick Answer
A course of action is a step or decision that should be taken to improve, solve or follow up a problem described in a statement. A course of action follows if it is practical, directly tackles the problem, is proportionate, and does not cause a bigger problem. Courses that are extreme, irrelevant, impractical, or that merely shift blame do not follow.
At a Glance
- Task Decide which suggested actions should be pursued
- Valid action Practical, direct, proportionate, safe
- Invalid action Extreme, irrelevant, impractical, blame-shifting
- Statement type A problem, defect, shortage or danger
- Usual options Only I follows, only II, both, neither
- Outside facts Use common sense but not special data
Where Does It Fit?
This is the first topic of the Statement-Course of Action and Cause-Effect macro. It begins the decision-making strand that continues in Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems and Choosing Between an Immediate and a Long-Term Course of Action. It builds on the judgment skills of Argument Evaluation Based on Relevance and Strength Criteria, which applies relevance and strength criteria to arguments.
What Makes a Course of Action Valid?
In short: a valid course of action directly deals with the problem in the statement, can be carried out in practice, and does not go further than the problem needs.
| Test | Valid action | Invalid action |
|---|---|---|
| Relevance | Targets the problem named | Deals with a different problem |
| Practicality | Can be done with ordinary means | Needs an impossible or absurd step |
| Proportion | Matches the size of the problem | Too drastic or too trivial |
| Side effects | Does not create a bigger problem | Causes harm or injustice |
| Responsibility | Takes responsible steps | Only blames or waits |
If the statement says “A fire broke out in a building because the wiring was faulty”, then “The wiring of the other buildings should be inspected” is a valid course. “All buildings should be demolished” is extreme. “The fire should be forgotten” is irresponsible.
How Do You Solve Course of Action Questions?
In short: state the problem, imagine what a sensible authority would do, and test each suggestion against the five checks.
- Identify the problem in one line, such as “frequent power cuts”.
- For each course, ask whether it addresses that problem directly.
- Ask whether it can be done and whether it is in proportion.
- Ask whether it would create a worse problem.
- Choose the option that matches.
Quick rules
- Investigate, inspect, take corrective measures: usually valid.
- Ban, shut, punish all, dismiss everyone: usually extreme.
- Wait and see, ignore, blame others: usually invalid.
- Offer help, provide aid, set up a committee: valid if the problem is real and large.
Some questions ask which course of action should be followed after a cause is given. For these, see Cause and Effect Reasoning – Identifying Which Statement Is the Cause and Which Is the Effect, which separates cause from effect, and Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems, which compares decisions.
When Is a Course of Action Not Followed?
In short: an action is not followed when it is extreme, irrelevant, impractical, over-reactive, or avoids the problem.
| Statement | Course of action | Verdict | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Many students fail in maths | The school should arrange extra classes | Follows | Direct, practical, proportionate |
| Many students fail in maths | Maths should be removed from the syllabus | Does not follow | Extreme, it avoids the problem |
| The river is polluted by factories | Factories should treat waste before discharge | Follows | Targets the source |
| The river is polluted by factories | All factories should be closed immediately | Does not follow | Over-reaction |
| A bridge is damaged | The bridge should be repaired | Follows | Direct response |
- Too drastic: a total ban or closure is rarely the first step.
- Delay: “wait for a year” is usually not responsible for an urgent problem.
- Passing the buck: asking someone else to deal with it without any step of your own is weak.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Statement: “The municipality has received many complaints about uncollected garbage in the area.” Courses of action: I. The collection schedule should be reviewed and improved. II. All residents should be fined for the garbage.
- I targets the cause of the complaint directly and is practical. Follows.
- II punishes residents for a municipal failure and is disproportionate. Does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Example 2
Question: Statement: “Many road accidents occur at the city crossing due to poor visibility at night.” Courses of action: I. Street lights should be installed at the crossing. II. The crossing should be closed forever.
- I removes the cause named. Follows.
- II is extreme and impractical for a busy crossing. Does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Example 3
Question: Statement: “A large number of employees in the factory have complained of skin rashes.” Courses of action: I. The factory should find out the cause and take corrective steps. II. The employees should be asked to resign.
- I is a practical, direct response. Follows.
- II shifts the problem onto the employees and is unjust. Does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Example 4
Question: Statement: “The students of the college are not attending the morning classes regularly.” Courses of action: I. The college should look into the reasons for absence. II. The morning classes should be cancelled permanently.
- I seeks to understand the cause before acting. Follows.
- II removes the problem without solving it and is extreme. Does not follow.
Answer: Only I follows.
Example 5
Question: Statement: “A heavy storm has damaged crops in many villages.” Courses of action: I. The government should provide relief to the affected farmers. II. The government should survey the damage and plan help.
- I is a direct and proportionate response to the damage. Follows.
- II is a practical step that allows a targeted response. Follows.
Answer: Both follow.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- State the problem in your own words before you read the actions.
- Prefer actions that investigate, correct, improve or provide support.
- Reject actions with absolute verbs: ban, abolish, close forever, punish all.
- Reject actions that do nothing, delay indefinitely, or blame others.
- When two actions are both sensible and compatible, both can follow.
Common Mistakes
- Choosing a drastic action because the problem feels serious.
- Rejecting a sensible step because it is slow.
- Ignoring side effects such as harm to innocent people.
- Selecting an action that addresses a different problem from the one in the statement.
- Assuming only one course can follow.
Practice Questions
- Statement: “A bank has received complaints of long queues.” Action: The bank should add more counters. Follows?
- Statement: “A village has no drinking water.” Action: The villagers should be moved out forever. Follows?
- Statement: “Students are weak in English.” Action: Remedial English classes should be started. Follows?
- Statement: “A road has many potholes.” Action: The road should be closed for a decade. Follows?
- Statement: “The factory is releasing smoke.” Action: Install filters in the chimney. Follows?
- Statement: “Prices of vegetables are rising.” Action: Ban all vegetable sales. Follows?
Answers: 1) Yes; 2) No; 3) Yes; 4) No; 5) Yes; 6) No.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Exam frequency Course of action questions are a staple of CSAT, SSC and bank reasoning.
- Governance link The skill mirrors how administrators choose among responses.
- Ethics link It helps in GS 4 case studies, where practical, proportionate action is rewarded.
- Next step It leads to Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems and Choosing Between an Immediate and a Long-Term Course of Action.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Cause and Effect Reasoning – Identifying Which Statement Is the Cause and Which Is the Effect. It stops treating the statement as a problem to fix and asks which of two statements is the cause and which is the effect.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Course of action A step to follow up a problem
- Pursued Taken up and carried forward
- Proportionate In measure with the size of the problem
- Corrective measure A step that removes the cause of a problem
- Extreme Too drastic for the problem
- Impractical Not possible with ordinary means
Related Topics
- Cause and Effect Reasoning – Identifying Which Statement Is the Cause and Which Is the Effect
- Identifying Independent Causes vs Common Cause for Two Given Effects
- Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems
- Choosing Between an Immediate and a Long-Term Course of Action
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- A valid action is direct, practical and proportionate.
- Extreme actions such as ban or close forever rarely follow.
- Do nothing or blame others is weak.
- Investigation and correction are usually valid.
- More than one course can follow.
Do Not Confuse With
- Course of action vs conclusion A course of action is what should be done; a conclusion is what is true.
- Practical vs ideal Practical is possible now; ideal may not be achievable.
- Corrective vs punitive Corrective fixes the cause; punitive only punishes.
- Direct vs indirect A direct action targets the stated problem; an indirect one may not.
Memory Hook
Fix the problem, not the people; do enough, not too much.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a course of action in logical reasoning?
A course of action is a step or decision proposed to improve, solve or follow up a problem given in a statement. It follows if it is practical, directly addresses the problem, is proportionate in size, and does not cause a bigger problem than the one it tries to fix.
How do you solve statement and course of action questions?
State the problem, then test each suggested action for relevance, practicality, proportion and side effects. Choose actions that investigate, correct or support, and reject those that are extreme, irrelevant, impractical or that avoid or delay the problem. More than one action can follow.
Why are extreme actions rejected as courses of action?
Extreme actions such as banning, closing forever or punishing everyone are out of proportion to most problems and may cause greater harm. A sensible authority first investigates and corrects the cause, so drastic steps are usually not what a course of action question rewards.
Can both courses of action follow a statement?
Yes. If both actions are practical, relevant and proportionate, and they do not conflict, both follow. For example, surveying the damage and providing relief after a storm are compatible, so a question with those actions would have both following.
Is do nothing ever a valid course of action?
Seldom. Waiting or ignoring a real problem is usually treated as irresponsible, unless the statement says the problem is minor or already being handled. Most exams expect an active, practical step such as inquiry, correction or support from the authority concerned.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 An extreme step such as closing forever is usually a valid course of action.
It is out of proportion to most problems.
2 A course of action should address the problem in the statement directly.
Relevance is the first test.
3 Only one course of action can follow a statement.
Compatible actions can both follow.
4 Investigating the cause of a problem is usually a valid course of action.
It is practical and proportionate.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index