An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 11.2

Cause and Effect Reasoning – Identifying Which Statement Is the Cause and Which Is the Effect

Reasoning › Statement-Course of Action and Cause-Effect Reasoning · Topic 11.2

In a cause and effect question, two statements are given and you decide which one produces the other. The cause is the event or condition that happens first or brings the other about, and the effect is the result. Ask "if I remove this, does the other statement still happen?" and "does one explain the other?" The cause usually explains or precedes the effect, though time order alone does not prove a cause.

Share:
Cause and Effect Reasoning – Identifying Which Statement Is the Cause and Which Is the Effect - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

In a cause and effect question, two statements are given and you decide which one produces the other. The cause is the event or condition that happens first or brings the other about, and the effect is the result. Ask “if I remove this, does the other statement still happen?” and “does one explain the other?” The cause usually explains or precedes the effect, though time order alone does not prove a cause.

At a Glance

  • Task Decide cause and effect between two statements
  • Cause Brings about the other event
  • Effect Result of the cause
  • Key test Remove the cause: does the effect disappear?
  • Common options I cause II; II cause I; independent; common cause
  • Clue words Because, due to, as a result, therefore

Where Does It Fit?

This is the second topic of the Statement-Course of Action and Cause-Effect macro. It follows Statement and Course of Action – Determining Appropriate Follow-Up Action, which handles actions, and leads to Identifying Independent Causes vs Common Cause for Two Given Effects, which covers independent and common causes for two effects. The timing issues that can mislead you are discussed in Cause-Effect Problems Involving Simultaneous or Time-Correlated Events.

How Do You Identify the Cause and the Effect?

In short: the cause explains the effect, comes first or at the same time, and if removed, the effect is expected to fail. The effect is the result.

Test Cause Effect
Explains Gives the reason Needs the reason
Order Happens first or together Happens after or together
Removal test Without it, the effect is unlikely Without it, the cause still exists
Words Because, owing to, due to Hence, so, as a result

Statements: I. The factory was closed for a week. II. The factory workers were without wages for a week. The closure explains the lost wages, so I is the cause and II is the effect. The reverse does not work: loss of wages does not close a factory.

  • Removal test: if the factory had not closed, the workers would have been paid. So the closure is the cause.
  • Explanation test: ask “why did this happen?” The answer should be the other statement.

How Do You Choose Among the Standard Options?

In short: exams offer five or so standard relations. Decide which fits each pair.

Option Meaning Example pair
I is the cause and II is its effect I brings about II Heavy rain; roads flooded
II is the cause and I is its effect II brings about I Roads flooded; heavy rain (reverse of above)
Both are effects of independent causes Two separate causes Price of vegetables rose; a new metro line opened
Both are effects of a common cause One cause behind both Schools closed; offices shut (cause: curfew)
Neither is a cause or an effect No link A cricket match was held; a new road was inaugurated

Decision order

  • Step 1: Is there a direct link? If yes, find the direction.
  • Step 2: If no direct link, is there a common cause behind both?
  • Step 3: If neither, are they independent or unrelated?

The second and third steps are the subject of Identifying Independent Causes vs Common Cause for Two Given Effects. Use the removal test for the first step. Ask: if I had not happened, would II still have happened?

What Traps Confuse Cause and Effect?

In short: the commonest traps are reversing the direction, treating a coincidence as a cause, and mistaking the earlier event for the cause just because it came first.

  • Reversal: “The hospital is crowded” and “an epidemic spread” are not interchangeable. The epidemic is the cause.
  • Time order: the cause is not simply what came first. A rooster crows before sunrise but does not cause it.
  • Coincidence: two events in the same week may have nothing to do with each other.
  • Purpose versus cause: “The company hired more staff” and “the company wants to expand” are linked by purpose, but only the second explains the first.

The harder situations, where two events occur at the same time or close together, are handled in Cause-Effect Problems Involving Simultaneous or Time-Correlated Events.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: I. The supply of onions fell sharply this month. II. The price of onions rose sharply this month.

  1. Ask why the price rose. The fall in supply explains it.
  2. Remove the cause: if supply had not fallen, the price would likely not have risen.

Answer: I is the cause and II is its effect.

Example 2

Question: I. Many people in the town fell ill with fever. II. The municipality sprayed insecticide in the town.

  1. The spray was a response to illness, not its source.
  2. So fever (I) led to the spray (II).

Answer: I is the cause and II is its effect.

Example 3

Question: I. The school remained closed on Monday. II. A heavy rain with flooding hit the city on Monday.

  1. Flooding explains the school’s closure.
  2. So II is the cause and I is the effect.

Answer: II is the cause and I is its effect.

Example 4

Question: I. A new factory opened in the town. II. The cricket team of the town won the district cup.

  1. No link is visible. The factory did not make the team win, and the team did not open the factory.

Answer: Neither is a cause or an effect; they are independent events.

Example 5

Question: I. The company announced a bonus for all employees. II. The company made record profits this year.

  1. Record profits give a reason for a bonus.
  2. So II explains I.

Answer: II is the cause and I is its effect.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Ask “why did this happen?” for each statement and see whether the other answers it.
  • Use the removal test: delete the cause and see if the effect fails.
  • Watch for response words such as launched, sprayed, announced; they are often effects of a problem.
  • Do not decide by time order alone.
  • If no link is visible, check for common cause or independence before forcing a direction.

Common Mistakes

  • Choosing the earlier event as the cause without checking explanation.
  • Reversing cause and effect when the response is mistaken for the origin.
  • Treating two unrelated events as cause and effect.
  • Ignoring that an action may be a response, not a cause.
  • Using outside facts that the statements do not support.

Practice Questions

  1. I. Rainfall was low this year. II. The yield of rice fell. Which is the cause?
  2. I. The patient took the prescribed medicine. II. The patient recovered. Which is the effect?
  3. I. The road was closed. II. A tree fell on the road. Which is the cause?
  4. I. The shop offered a discount. II. A new movie was released. Cause and effect?
  5. I. The price of petrol rose. II. Fares of autos rose. Which is the effect?
  6. I. People wore woollen clothes. II. Temperatures dropped. Which is the cause?

Answers: 1) I; 2) II; 3) II; 4) Neither, unrelated events; 5) II; 6) II.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Fixed format Cause and effect questions appear in a set pattern in many reasoning papers.
  • Skill They train clean thinking about reasons and results.
  • Link The skill supports Identifying Independent Causes vs Common Cause for Two Given Effects and Cause-Effect Problems Involving Simultaneous or Time-Correlated Events.
  • Use It is used daily in reading news and reports.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Identifying Independent Causes vs Common Cause for Two Given Effects. It asks what to do when two effects are given and the cause may be shared or separate.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Cause The event or condition that brings about another
  • Effect The result of a cause
  • Removal test Remove the cause and see whether the effect fails
  • Response An action taken after a problem
  • Coincidence Events that occur together without a link
  • Direct link A cause-effect relation between two statements

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • The cause explains; the effect follows.
  • Use the removal test.
  • A response is an effect, not a cause.
  • Time order alone does not prove a cause.
  • Check for common cause before declaring independence.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Cause vs reason A cause produces the result; a reason may only justify an action.
  • Cause vs earlier event An earlier event is not always the cause.
  • Effect vs response A response is an action taken because of a problem.
  • Coincidence vs cause Events at the same time may be unrelated.

Memory Hook

Ask why; the answer is the cause.

GS Relevance

A fixed question type in SSC CGL, bank PO, CDS, CAPF and several state PCS reasoning papers: two statements I and II are given, and you decide which is the cause and which is the effect.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you identify cause and effect in reasoning?

Ask why each event happened and see whether the other statement answers it. The cause explains the effect and usually comes first or at the same time. Apply the removal test: if removing one event would stop the other, the removed event is the cause.

What is the removal test for cause and effect?

The removal test imagines that the suspected cause never happened and asks whether the effect would still occur. If the effect would likely not occur, the removed event is the cause. If the effect would occur anyway, the event is not a cause.

Does the earlier event always cause the later event?

No. Two events in sequence may be unrelated, or both may be results of something else. Time order is only a clue. A cause must also explain the later event, so check for an explanation, not only for order.

Is an action taken after a problem a cause or an effect?

An action taken after a problem is usually an effect, since the problem prompted it. For example, spraying insecticide after an outbreak of fever is a response to the fever, so the fever is the cause and the spraying is its effect.

What are the standard options in cause and effect questions?

The usual options are that I is the cause and II its effect, that II is the cause and I its effect, that both are effects of independent causes, that both are effects of a common cause, and that neither is related to the other.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The cause always happens before the effect, so the earlier event is the cause.
False

Order is only a clue; the cause must also explain the effect.

2 A response to a problem is usually an effect of that problem.
True

The problem prompts the response.

3 If removing an event would stop the other event, the removed event is the cause.
True

That is the removal test.

4 Two unrelated events can both be given without any cause-effect link.
True

Independence is a valid option.

Share: