Identifying Independent Causes vs Common Cause for Two Given Effects
Reasoning › Statement-Course of Action and Cause-Effect Reasoning · Topic 11.3
When two effects are given, they may come from independent causes or from one common cause. If a single event could explain both effects, the answer is common cause. If each effect has its own separate, unrelated explanation, the causes are independent. The test is to look for one event that, if removed, would stop both effects together.
7 min read · Reasoning · Statement-Course of Action and Cause-Effect Reasoning
Quick Answer
When two effects are given, they may come from independent causes or from one common cause. If a single event could explain both effects, the answer is common cause. If each effect has its own separate, unrelated explanation, the causes are independent. The test is to look for one event that, if removed, would stop both effects together.
At a Glance
- Situation Two effects given, causes unknown
- Common cause One event explains both
- Independent causes Each effect has its own cause
- Key test Is there one event that explains both?
- Typical signal Both effects are of the same type and time
- Option wording Both are effects of a common cause
Where Does It Fit?
This is the third topic of the Statement-Course of Action and Cause-Effect macro. It is the second half of the cause-effect idea introduced in Cause and Effect Reasoning – Identifying Which Statement Is the Cause and Which Is the Effect, where one statement was the cause of the other. Here both statements are effects. The follow-up topic Cause-Effect Problems Involving Simultaneous or Time-Correlated Events adds time-related complications.
What Is the Difference Between a Common Cause and Independent Causes?
In short: a common cause is one event behind both effects. Independent causes are two different events, each behind one effect.
| Feature | Common cause | Independent causes |
|---|---|---|
| Number of causes | One | Two or more |
| Link between effects | Related through the cause | No link |
| Test | One event explains both | Each needs its own explanation |
| Example | A strike: buses stopped, offices closed | Price of tomatoes rose; a cricket team lost a match |
Consider two effects: I. Schools were closed in the city. II. Many offices reported low attendance. A single event such as a severe storm warning or a curfew can explain both. That is a common cause.
Now consider: I. The price of tomatoes rose. II. The cricket team lost a match. There is no single event that explains both. The causes are independent, and probably the effects are also unrelated.
How Do You Apply the One-Event Test?
In short: try to name one event that explains both effects. If you can, it is a common cause. If not, the causes are independent.
- Write the cause of the first effect.
- Write the cause of the second effect.
- If both causes are the same event, it is a common cause.
- If the two causes are different, they are independent.
Decision hints
- Same time, same place, same type: suspect a common cause.
- Different fields, different places: suspect independent causes.
- If one statement explains the other, use the cause and effect options from Cause and Effect Reasoning – Identifying Which Statement Is the Cause and Which Is the Effect first.
Do not stretch to find a common cause. A far-fetched shared cause is not acceptable. The common cause must be natural and strongly connected with both effects.
What Can Go Wrong With Common Cause Reasoning?
In short: mistakes arise when students force a common cause or ignore a direct link between the effects.
- Forced common cause: inventing “the economy” or “the weather” to link unrelated events.
- Missing direct link: if one effect explains the other, it is not a case for common cause; it is cause and effect.
- Same type, not same cause: two price rises can have two different causes.
- Time overlap: two effects in the same week may still be independent.
| Pair of effects | Verdict | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Crop yield fell; farm incomes fell | Not common cause, one is the cause of the other | Lower yield explains lower income |
| Crop yield fell; river levels dropped | Common cause | Drought explains both |
| The stock market fell; a film was a hit | Independent | No shared explanation |
Practical decisions based on these causes are discussed in Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Effects: I. Many people in the colony fell ill with stomach infection. II. The water supply in the colony was found to be dirty. Is there a common cause?
- II is a natural cause of I. Dirty water leads to infection.
- So this is cause and effect, not common cause.
Answer: II is the cause and I is its effect.
Example 2
Question: Effects: I. Roads in the city were waterlogged. II. Trains were running late. Is the cause common or independent?
- Heavy rain can waterlog roads and delay trains. One event explains both.
Answer: Both are effects of a common cause (heavy rain).
Example 3
Question: Effects: I. The price of gold rose. II. A newspaper increased its price. Is the cause common or independent?
- No single event explains both a gold price rise and a newspaper price rise.
- Each would have its own reason.
Answer: Both are effects of independent causes.
Example 4
Question: Effects: I. Many offices remained closed. II. Public transport was off the roads. Is the cause common or independent?
- A general strike or curfew explains both.
Answer: Both are effects of a common cause (a strike or curfew).
Example 5
Question: Effects: I. Sales of umbrellas increased. II. Sales of raincoats increased. Is the cause common or independent?
- Both are explained by the arrival of the rainy season.
Answer: Both are effects of a common cause (the rainy season).
Shortcuts and Tricks
- First check whether one statement explains the other; if so it is cause and effect.
- Try to name one event for both; if it is natural and strong, choose common cause.
- If the effects belong to unrelated fields, choose independent causes.
- Do not choose common cause on the basis of time alone.
- Reject far-fetched common causes such as the government or the economy unless the statements support them.
Common Mistakes
- Using common cause when one effect is actually the cause of the other.
- Labelling two similar events as common cause without a shared explanation.
- Choosing independent causes when an obvious shared event exists.
- Using outside knowledge about events not in the statements.
- Forgetting that the options may include neither.
Practice Questions
- Effects: I. Schools closed. II. Offices closed. Both after a cyclone warning. Common or independent cause?
- Effects: I. Wheat prices rose. II. A new bus service started. Common or independent?
- Effects: I. Roads were empty. II. Shops were shut. Both on the day of a bandh. Common or independent?
- Effects: I. Many farmers lost crops. II. Prices of vegetables rose. Is it common cause?
- Effects: I. Many people used sunscreen. II. Cold drinks sales rose. Common or independent?
- Effects: I. A library opened. II. A mobile company reduced tariffs. Common or independent?
Answers: 1) common cause; 2) independent causes; 3) common cause; 4) not common cause; I is the cause of II; 5) common cause (summer heat); 6) independent causes.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Option coverage This option appears often among the standard cause-effect options.
- Skill It trains you to look for hidden shared drivers behind events.
- Link It prepares for Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems and Cause-Effect Problems Involving Simultaneous or Time-Correlated Events.
- Real use Used in analysing news events and economic trends.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems. It moves from explaining events to making decisions between competing options.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Common cause One event behind two effects
- Independent causes Separate causes for separate effects
- One-event test Look for a single event that explains both effects
- Effect A result of some cause
- Shared driver The hidden event common to both effects
- Unrelated Without any link
Related Topics
- Cause and Effect Reasoning – Identifying Which Statement Is the Cause and Which Is the Effect
- Decision-Making Based Reasoning Problems
- Statement and Course of Action – Determining Appropriate Follow-Up Action
- Choosing Between an Immediate and a Long-Term Course of Action
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Common cause means one event explains both effects.
- Independent causes mean each effect has its own cause.
- Check cause and effect between the two before common cause.
- Do not force a far-fetched common cause.
- Neither related is also a valid option.
Do Not Confuse With
- Common cause vs cause-effect In cause-effect one statement explains the other; in common cause an outside event explains both.
- Independent vs unrelated Independent means separate causes; unrelated means no link at all.
- Similar vs common Two similar events need not share a cause.
- Timing vs cause Occurring together is not the same as having one cause.
Memory Hook
One event for two effects means common; two events for two effects means independent.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a common cause in reasoning questions?
A common cause is a single event or condition that explains both of the given effects. For example, a cyclone warning can explain why schools closed and why offices reported low attendance. If one natural event explains both statements, choose both are effects of a common cause.
How do you tell independent causes from a common cause?
Try to name one event that explains both effects. If a natural, strongly connected event does exist, the effects share a common cause. If each effect needs its own different explanation and no single event covers both, the causes are independent.
Can two similar effects have independent causes?
Yes. Two price rises or two closures may look alike but arise from different events, such as a tax change in one case and a shortage in the other. Similarity of type alone is not enough to choose a common cause.
What if one effect explains the other?
If one statement directly explains the other, the relation is cause and effect and not common cause. Always check for a direct link between the two statements first, and then consider whether a common outside cause or independent causes fit better.
Why should far-fetched common causes be avoided?
Almost any two events could be linked by something general such as the economy or the weather. Exams expect a natural, specific and strongly connected cause. If you need to invent a vague link, the better answer is independent causes.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 A common cause is one event that explains both effects.
That is the definition.
2 If one statement explains the other, the pair is a case of common cause.
That is cause and effect.
3 Two effects of the same type always share a cause.
Similar effects can arise independently.
4 A far-fetched shared cause is acceptable if the effects occur together.
The cause must be natural and strongly connected.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index