An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 7.7

Ranking Problems with Multiple Parameters Compared Simultaneously (Height and Weight)

Reasoning › Ranking, Order and Sequence · Topic 7.7

Ranking with multiple parameters means ordering the same persons on two scales at once, such as height and weight. Write one ranking line for each parameter, then answer combined questions by taking the intersection of the two sets, for example persons who are taller than X and heavier than X.

Share:
Ranking Problems with Multiple Parameters Compared Simultaneously (Height and Weight) - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Ranking with multiple parameters means ordering the same persons on two scales at once, such as height and weight. Write one ranking line for each parameter, then answer combined questions by taking the intersection of the two sets, for example persons who are taller than X and heavier than X.

At a Glance

  • Method One ranking line per parameter
  • Combined question Take the common names from both lists
  • Taller but lighter than X Taller list intersect lighter list
  • Overall rank Add the two ranks, smaller sum is better
  • Missing link Parameters do not predict each other
  • Common mistake Assuming tall means heavy

Where Does It Fit?

This topic doubles the single-parameter chain of Ranking Based on Height, Weight, Age, Marks or Performance. Large groups are handled in Comparative Ranking Requiring Ordering Multiple Individuals Simultaneously, and the next topic, Ranking Based on Interview, Examination or Event Sequence Order, ranks events and interviews in time order.

How Do You Handle Two Parameters at the Same Time?

In short: never mix the two parameters in one chain. Draw a separate line for height and a separate line for weight, using the same persons, then read each question from both lines.

Rank Height (tallest first) Weight (heaviest first)
1 A C
2 C D
3 B A
4 E B
5 D E
  • Same person, two positions: A is 1st in height and 3rd in weight.
  • No link between lines: a person’s position in one line gives no information about the other line.
  • Clue handling: sort clues about height into one line and clues about weight into the other, as in Ranking Based on Height, Weight, Age, Marks or Performance.

How Do You Answer Combined Questions?

In short: list the names that satisfy each condition separately, then pick the names that appear in both lists.

Question Height list Weight list Answer
Taller and heavier than B A, C C, D, A A, C (2 persons)
Taller and lighter than D A, C, B, E A, B, E A, B, E (3 persons)
Shorter and heavier than A C, B, E, D C, D C, D

Set method

  • Persons satisfying both conditions = Persons satisfying condition 1, common with persons satisfying condition 2.
  • If no name is common, the answer is none.

Count carefully when the question says taller than, because the person named in the question is not counted as taller than himself.

How Do You Find an Overall Best or Worst Person?

In short: when a question asks for an overall rank without a stated weighting, add the two ranks. The smaller total is better.

  • Rank sums: with the table above, A = 1 + 3 = 4, B = 3 + 4 = 7, C = 2 + 1 = 3, D = 5 + 2 = 7, E = 4 + 5 = 9, so C is the best and E is the worst.
  • Tie in sums: B and D both have a total of 7, so they tie and the ideas of Ranking Problems Involving Ties or Equal Positions apply.
  • Stated weighting: if a question gives different weights to the parameters, multiply first and then add.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Heights from tallest: A, C, B, E, D. Weights from heaviest: C, D, A, B, E. How many persons are both taller and heavier than B?

  1. Taller than B: A and C.
  2. Heavier than B: C, D and A.
  3. Common: A and C.

Answer: 2 persons.

Example 2

Question: Using the same lists, how many persons are taller than D but lighter than D?

  1. Taller than D: A, C, B, E (D is the shortest).
  2. Lighter than D: A, B, E (C is heavier, D is second heaviest).
  3. Common: A, B and E.

Answer: 3 persons.

Example 3

Question: Using the same lists, who is the second tallest, and what is that person’s rank in weight?

  1. Second tallest = C.
  2. C is the heaviest, so weight rank 1.

Answer: C, who is 1st in weight.

Example 4

Question: Using the same lists, which person has the lowest sum of the two ranks?

  1. A = 1 + 3 = 4, B = 3 + 4 = 7, C = 2 + 1 = 3, D = 5 + 2 = 7, E = 4 + 5 = 9.
  2. C has the smallest sum of 3.

Answer: C.

Example 5

Question: P is taller than Q but lighter. R is taller than P and heavier than Q. S is shorter than Q but heavier than P. Who is the tallest? Is R the heaviest?

  1. Height clues: P > Q, R > P, Q > S. Chain: R > P > Q > S. R is the tallest.
  2. Weight clues: Q > P, R > Q, S > P. So R > Q > P and S > P.
  3. S and R are not compared, and S and Q are not compared.

Answer: R is the tallest. Whether R is the heaviest cannot be determined.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Make two separate lines before reading any question.
  • Convert each condition into a short list of names, then intersect the lists.
  • Never use the person asked about when counting persons taller or heavier than him.
  • For overall rank, add the two ranks and choose the smallest sum.
  • Do not assume that the tallest is the heaviest unless the clues say so.

Common Mistakes

  • Mixing height and weight in a single chain.
  • Assuming a taller person is also a heavier person.
  • Including the reference person in the lists.
  • Forgetting that “lighter than” reverses the weight line.
  • Adding ranks when the question asks about a single parameter.

Practice Questions

  1. Using the heights A, C, B, E, D and weights C, D, A, B, E: who is shorter and heavier than C?
  2. Same lists: how many persons are taller than E and lighter than E?
  3. Same lists: what is the weight rank of the tallest person?
  4. Same lists: what is the height rank of the heaviest person?
  5. Same lists: how many persons are shorter than A and lighter than A?
  6. Same lists: who has the highest sum of the two ranks?

Answers: 1) none; 2) 0; 3) 3rd; 4) 2nd; 5) 2; 6) E.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Real scale Real groups are compared on several scales at once.
  • Logic skill Keeping two lines apart builds careful reading.
  • Exam use Banking sets often use height and weight puzzles.
  • Link The set-intersection idea is used again in Venn-based syllogisms.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Ranking Based on Interview, Examination or Event Sequence Order. It orders persons by the sequence in which they are interviewed or examined.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Parameter A quantity used to compare persons, such as weight
  • Intersection Names common to two lists
  • Rank sum Sum of ranks on two parameters
  • Combined question A question using two conditions together
  • Reference person The person named in the question
  • Line A separate order for each parameter

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • One line for each parameter.
  • Combined conditions need common names from both lists.
  • The reference person is never counted.
  • Height does not predict weight.
  • Smaller rank sum means a better overall position.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Taller vs heavier They use two different lines.
  • Rank in one vs rank in both A rank is always for a single parameter.
  • Sum vs product Rank sums are added, not multiplied.
  • Equal sums vs equal ranks Equal sums form a tie, but ranks may differ.

Memory Hook

Two parameters, two lines, and the answer lives in the overlap.

GS Relevance

Two-parameter ranking appears in banking and SSC reasoning sets, where the same group is compared on height, weight, age or marks together.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you rank people by height and weight together?

Draw one ranking line for height and another for weight, using the same people. A person can have different positions in the two lines. Answer each combined question by listing the names that satisfy each condition, then choosing the names that appear in both lists.

How do you find who is taller and heavier than a person?

List everyone taller than the person from the height line and everyone heavier from the weight line. The names common to both lists are the answer. The named person is never counted. If no name is common to both lists, the answer is none.

Can a taller person be lighter than a shorter person?

Yes, height and weight are separate parameters, so a taller person can be lighter than a shorter one. Never assume the two lines match unless a clue says so. This is why each parameter needs its own separate ranking line in the puzzle.

How do you find the overall best person from two ranks?

Add each person's two ranks. The person with the smallest sum has the best overall position. If two persons have equal sums, they tie. If the question assigns different weights to the parameters, multiply each rank by its weight before adding.

What is the most common mistake in two-parameter ranking?

The most common mistake is mixing height and weight in one chain, or assuming that the tallest person is the heaviest. Keep two separate lines, read each question from both, and use only the names that appear in the lists for both conditions.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The tallest person is always the heaviest person.
False

Height and weight are separate parameters and need separate lines.

2 Persons who are both taller and heavier than X are found by taking the names common to both lists.
True

The set intersection gives persons satisfying both conditions.

3 In the lists with heights A, C, B, E, D and weights C, D, A, B, E, three persons are taller and lighter than D.
True

They are A, B and E.

4 In a two-parameter ranking, the person with the largest rank sum has the best overall position.
False

The smallest rank sum is the best.

Share: