Comparative Ranking Requiring Ordering Multiple Individuals Simultaneously
Reasoning › Ranking, Order and Sequence · Topic 7.4
Comparative ranking with many individuals means ordering five to eight people at once from several overlapping clues. Write each clue as a link in a chain, join the links on common names, and test whether the final chain is a single line (a unique order) or has branches (data insufficient for some questions).
7 min read · Reasoning · Ranking, Order and Sequence
Quick Answer
Comparative ranking with many individuals means ordering five to eight people at once from several overlapping clues. Write each clue as a link in a chain, join the links on common names, and test whether the final chain is a single line (a unique order) or has branches (data insufficient for some questions).
At a Glance
- Step 1 Write each clue as a link
- Step 2 Merge links on shared names
- Step 3 Check that the chain is a single line
- Gap clue n places above = rank minus n
- Branch Two unlinked names mean no fixed order
- Race order First means earliest finisher
Where Does It Fit?
This topic scales the chain method of Ranking Based on Height, Weight, Age, Marks or Performance to larger groups and mixes comparison clues with numerical gaps. The next topic, Ranking Problems Involving Ties or Equal Positions, shows what happens when two persons share the same rank.
How Do You Order Many Persons From Overlapping Clues?
In short: convert every sentence into a short chain, then join chains that share a name until one long chain remains.
| Clue type | Written as | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Comparison | X > Y | A is taller than B gives A > B |
| Between | X > Y > Z | B is between A and C, with A the tallest, gives A > B > C |
| Immediately above | X Y adjacent | A is immediately above B means no one is between them |
| n places above | Rank of X = Rank of Y – n | A is 2 places above C gives rank of A = rank of C – 2 |
| Not the topper | At least one person above | Used to remove the top position |
- List all persons.
- Write the clue that links the most names first.
- Insert the other clues into the chain one by one.
- Check the final order against every clue.
When Is the Order Unique and When Is the Data Insufficient?
In short: the order is unique only when each neighbour pair in the final chain is directly linked by a clue. If two persons sit on separate branches, their relative order is unknown.
Branch test
- Clues A > B, C > B and B > D give A and C above B, but no clue compares A and C.
- So the order is (A, C) > B > D with A and C interchangeable, and any question that depends on A against C is data insufficient.
- Unique order: every question has one answer.
- Partial order: some questions, such as who is last, still have one answer, because the bottom of the chain is fixed.
- Extra checks: always test whether the question depends on the unknown pair.
Problems that start from a numerical gap are common in race questions, and the same method is used for position problems with ties in Ranking Problems Involving Ties or Equal Positions.
How Do You Solve Race and Gap Problems?
In short: a race order is a ranking from the first finisher, so “A finished 2 places ahead of B” means B’s rank is A’s rank + 2.
- Places ahead: add the gap to the leader’s rank to get the follower’s rank.
- Immediately after: a gap of one place.
- From the end: use the master formula of Ranking from the Top and Bottom in a List/Row to convert between top and bottom ranks.
- Several clues: find the one clue that fixes an actual rank number, then place the others relative to it.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: A is taller than B but shorter than F. C is shorter than B but taller than D. E is shorter than D. Who is the second shortest?
- Clues: F > A, A > B, B > C, C > D, D > E.
- Chain: F > A > B > C > D > E.
- The shortest is E and the second shortest is D.
Answer: D.
Example 2
Question: A finished 2 places ahead of B, and B finished 3 places ahead of C. C finished 6th. In which position did A finish?
- B’s rank = 6 – 3 = 3.
- A’s rank = 3 – 2 = 1.
Answer: A finished 1st.
Example 3
Question: In a race of five, E finished before D but after A. B finished after D. C finished before A. Who finished third?
- Clues: A > E, E > D, D > B, C > A in finishing order (earlier is higher).
- Chain: C, A, E, D, B.
- Third place is E.
Answer: E.
Example 4
Question: A is taller than B, C is taller than B, and B is taller than D. Is A taller than C?
- A and C are both above B.
- No clue compares A and C.
Answer: Cannot be determined.
Example 5
Question: In a group of 8, P is 3rd from the top. Q is 2 places below P. R is 2 places above the last person. Who ranks higher, Q or R?
- Q’s rank = 3 + 2 = 5.
- The last is 8th, so R is 8 – 2 = 6th.
- 5 is a higher rank than 6.
Answer: Q ranks higher.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Start from the clue with the most names.
- Convert gap clues into rank numbers as soon as one rank is known.
- If a clue conflicts with your chain, you have probably reversed a direction.
- After building the chain, re-read every clue once to check.
- Mark branches with brackets, such as (A, C), so that unknown pairs are visible.
Common Mistakes
- Treating “ahead” as a larger rank number.
- Fixing the order of two branch persons by guessing.
- Counting a gap of 2 places as 1 person between.
- Skipping the final check against every clue.
- Using the left-to-right order of the story rather than the real chain.
Practice Questions
- A > B, C > A, D < B. Who is second from the top?
- In a race, P beat Q, Q beat R, S beat P, and T finished after R. Who finished third?
- In a list of 8 persons, B is 3rd from the bottom and A is 2 places above B. What is A’s rank from the top?
- A is heavier than B, C is lighter than B, D is heavier than A, E is lighter than C. Who is in the middle?
- In a list of 10, A is 4th from the top and B is 3 places below A. What is B’s rank from the bottom?
- P is taller than Q and R is taller than Q. Who is the tallest of the three?
Answers: 1) A; 2) Q; 3) 4th; 4) B; 5) 4th; 6) cannot be determined.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Larger puzzles Six and seven-person puzzles are the standard level in banking and CSAT sets.
- Skill You learn to detect incomplete data quickly.
- Base for arrangement The same chain thinking is used for seating puzzles.
- Speed A chain drawn once answers every question that follows.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Ranking Problems Involving Ties or Equal Positions. It explains how ranks are written when two or more persons have equal marks.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Chain A line of persons ordered by clues
- Branch Two persons both linked to one person but not to each other
- Gap The number of places between two persons
- Immediately above Next higher rank with nobody between
- Unique order One arrangement fits all clues
- Insufficient data More than one order fits the clues
Related Topics
- Ranking Based on Height, Weight, Age, Marks or Performance
- Ranking Problems Involving Ties or Equal Positions
- Ranking from the Top and Bottom in a List/Row
- Finding Total Number of People Given Relative Ranks
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Merge short chains on common names.
- A gap of n places adds or subtracts n from a rank.
- A branch stops you from comparing the two branch persons.
- The top and bottom may be fixed even if the middle is not.
- Always verify the final order against all clues.
Do Not Confuse With
- Places ahead vs persons between 2 places ahead means 1 person between.
- Before vs after In a race, before means a smaller rank number.
- Top fixed vs order fixed A fixed topper does not fix the other ranks.
- Chain vs list A chain may have brackets for unknown order.
Memory Hook
Build the chain, bracket the branches, then answer only what the chain proves.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you solve ranking questions with many persons?
Convert every clue into a short inequality chain, then merge chains on common names until one long chain remains. Verify that the chain satisfies every clue. If two persons are not linked, bracket them, because any question that depends on their order has insufficient data.
How do you solve race finishing order puzzles?
Treat the finishing order as a ranking from the first finisher. A clue that says A finished 2 places ahead of B means B's rank is A's rank plus 2. Find one clue that fixes an actual rank, then place the remaining persons around it.
When is the data insufficient in a ranking puzzle?
The data is insufficient when two persons sit on different branches of the chain and no clue compares them. For example, A taller than B and C taller than B does not decide whether A or C is taller, so that question cannot be answered.
What is the difference between places ahead and persons between?
If A finished 2 places ahead of B, the rank of B is A's rank plus 2, and there is exactly 1 person between them. In general, persons between equals places apart minus one, which prevents the common off-by-one error.
How can I check my final ranking order?
Read each clue once more and tick it off against the final chain. If any clue is violated, one comparison was probably written in the wrong direction. Rewrite the chain from the clue that links the most names and test again.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 If A is taller than B and C is taller than B, A is necessarily taller than C.
A and C are both above B, but no clue compares them.
2 If A finished 2 places ahead of B and B finished 3 places ahead of C, A finished 5 places ahead of C.
The gaps add: 2 + 3 = 5.
3 In a chain F > A > B > C > D > E, the second shortest person is D.
E is shortest and D is next.
4 If A is 2 places ahead of B, there are 2 persons between them.
There is exactly 1 person between them.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index