An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 7.3

Ranking Based on Height, Weight, Age, Marks or Performance

Reasoning › Ranking, Order and Sequence · Topic 7.3

Ranking based on height, weight, age, marks or performance means arranging people in order from comparison clues such as taller than, heavier than, older than or scored more than. Turn each clue into an inequality, join them into one chain, and read off the tallest, youngest, highest or any required position.

Share:
Ranking Based on Height, Weight, Age, Marks or Performance - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Ranking based on height, weight, age, marks or performance means arranging people in order from comparison clues such as taller than, heavier than, older than or scored more than. Turn each clue into an inequality, join them into one chain, and read off the tallest, youngest, highest or any required position.

At a Glance

  • Core method Convert each clue into an inequality chain
  • Chain symbol A > B means A is greater than B
  • Tallest Left end of a height chain
  • Youngest Right end of an age chain
  • Number of persons greater than X Rank of X – 1
  • Insufficient data Two persons not linked in the chain cannot be compared

Where Does It Fit?

This topic applies the position ideas of Ranking from the Top and Bottom in a List/Row to comparison words. The next topic, Comparative Ranking Requiring Ordering Multiple Individuals Simultaneously, extends the method to many persons and conditions, and Ranking Problems with Multiple Parameters Compared Simultaneously (Height and Weight) compares two parameters such as height and weight at once.

How Do You Convert Comparison Clues Into a Ranking?

In short: write each clue as an inequality using the same symbol throughout, then link the clues that share a person into one chain.

Clue Written as Meaning
A is taller than B A > B A comes before B in a tallest-first list
C is lighter than D D > C Rewrite so the larger quantity is on the left
E scored more than F E > F E ranks above F
G is younger than H H > G H is older, so H is on the left
J is not taller than K K >= J K is taller or equal, and equality needs a separate clue
  • One direction: pick one direction, for example tallest first, and rewrite every clue that way.
  • Join on common persons: if A > B and B > C, then A > B > C.
  • Read the chain: the person at the left end of the chain is the tallest, oldest or highest scorer, and the right end is the shortest, youngest or lowest.

How Do You Answer Who Is Tallest, Second or Middle?

In short: once the chain is complete, the position of each person is read directly. If the chain has gaps, only the relations that are in the chain can be stated.

Question Chain used Reading
Who is the tallest? P > Q > R > S P
Who is third from the top? P > Q > R > S R
Who is the middle in 5? Third in a chain of 5 The person at position 3
How many are taller than R? P > Q > R > S 2, since rank of R is 3

Complete or incomplete chain

  • A chain with all persons in a single line gives a unique order.
  • If a person has two unlinked neighbours, such as A > B and A > C with no clue joining B and C, the order of B and C cannot be fixed.

Missing links are the main trap in this topic. If a question asks about two persons who are not joined by any chain of clues, the correct answer is that the data is insufficient. More advanced multi-person conditions are practised in Comparative Ranking Requiring Ordering Multiple Individuals Simultaneously.

What Are the Typical Variations in Marks and Age Problems?

In short: marks, age, weight and height problems all use the same chain, but the wording may change from more and less to older and younger or better and worse.

  • Equal quantities: a clue such as “A and B have the same height” puts both persons at one level, and ties are handled in Ranking Problems Involving Ties or Equal Positions.
  • Numerical clues: when numbers are given, such as marks 82, 75 and 90, simply sort the numbers.
  • Difference clues: when a clue says A is 4 years older than B and B is 3 years older than C, then A is 7 years older than C.
  • Negative questions: a question that asks who is not the tallest has several correct answers unless the chain makes it unique.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: P is taller than Q. Q is taller than S. R is shorter than S. Who is the tallest and who is the shortest?

  1. Write the clues: P > Q, Q > S, S > R.
  2. Join the chain: P > Q > S > R.
  3. The left end is P and the right end is R.

Answer: P is the tallest and R is the shortest.

Example 2

Question: Anil scored more than Bina but less than Chetan. Dev scored less than Bina. Who is second in the order of marks?

  1. Clues: Chetan > Anil, Anil > Bina, Bina > Dev.
  2. Chain: Chetan > Anil > Bina > Dev.
  3. The second position is Anil.

Answer: Anil.

Example 3

Question: A is older than B. C is younger than B. D is older than A. E is younger than C. Who is the oldest, and what is E’s position from the oldest?

  1. Clues: A > B, B > C, D > A, C > E.
  2. Chain: D > A > B > C > E.
  3. D is the oldest, and E is 5th from the oldest.

Answer: D is the oldest, and E is 5th from the oldest.

Example 4

Question: In a group of five friends, A is heavier than B and C. D is lighter than B but heavier than E. C is heavier than D. Who is the lightest?

  1. Clues: A > B, A > C, B > D, D > E, C > D.
  2. A is at the top. B and C are both above D, but B and C are not compared with each other.
  3. D is above E, and nobody is below E.
  4. So the order is A > (B, C in either order) > D > E.

Answer: E is the lightest.

Example 5

Question: X is 4 years older than Y. Y is 3 years older than Z. If Z is 20 years old, what is X’s age?

  1. Y = 20 + 3 = 23 years.
  2. X = 23 + 4 = 27 years.

Answer: 27 years.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Rewrite every clue in the same direction before drawing the chain.
  • Start the chain from the person who appears in two clues, not from the first sentence.
  • If two persons are linked only through a third person on the same side, their order is undecided.
  • For numerical marks, sort the numbers and ignore the story.
  • When the question asks for position from the other end, count from that end after the chain is complete.

Common Mistakes

  • Mixing directions, such as writing “taller than” and “lighter than” clues with the same arrow without converting.
  • Assuming an order between two persons who have no connecting clue.
  • Reading “not the tallest” as meaning “the shortest”.
  • Reading “older than” as “younger than” in a negative clue.
  • Forgetting that an inequality chain must include every person before naming the middle person.

Practice Questions

  1. A > B and C > B and A > C. Who is highest, and who is lowest?
  2. R is shorter than S. T is taller than S. U is shorter than R. Who is the tallest?
  3. Marks: P 62, Q 78, R 54, S 78.5. Who scored second highest?
  4. P is older than Q, R is older than P, S is younger than Q. Who is the second oldest?
  5. X is 2 years older than Y, and Y is 5 years older than Z. How much older is X than Z?
  6. A is taller than B, and C is taller than D. Is A taller than C?

Answers: 1) A is highest and B is lowest; 2) T; 3) Q; 4) P; 5) 7 years; 6) cannot be determined.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Core skill Chain building is the basis of almost every ordering puzzle.
  • Exam use Comparison ranking appears in UPSC CSAT and SSC reasoning sets.
  • Accuracy The method forces you to show which clues are missing.
  • Link The same chain is used in seating and arrangement puzzles later on.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Comparative Ranking Requiring Ordering Multiple Individuals Simultaneously. It uses the same chain method for several people at once and with more complex clues.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Inequality chain A line of persons joined by greater-than signs
  • Insufficient data A situation where the clues cannot fix an order
  • Ascending order From smallest to largest
  • Descending order From largest to smallest
  • Parameter The quantity being compared, such as height
  • Link A clue that connects two persons in the chain

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Write every clue as an inequality in one direction.
  • Join clues on common persons to form a chain.
  • The left end is the greatest and the right end is the least.
  • Persons with no link cannot be compared.
  • Marks, age, weight and height use identical methods.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Taller vs heavier Different parameters need different chains, as shown in Ranking Problems with Multiple Parameters Compared Simultaneously (Height and Weight).
  • Older vs younger Older means more years; reversing this reverses the whole chain.
  • Not tallest vs shortest A person who is not tallest may be anywhere below the top.
  • Equal vs greater Equal quantities sit at the same rank, not one above the other.

Memory Hook

Clue to inequality, inequality to chain, chain to answer.

GS Relevance

Comparison-based ordering appears in UPSC CSAT, SSC CGL, banking and CAPF reasoning, usually with three to six persons and a who-is-second question.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you rank people based on height or weight clues?

Convert each clue into an inequality such as A > B, using one direction for all clues. Join clues that share a person into a single chain. The person at the left end of the chain is the tallest or heaviest, and the person at the right end is the shortest or lightest.

How do you solve age comparison reasoning questions?

Write each statement as older or younger using the same arrow direction, then link statements through common persons to form one chain. The leftmost person is oldest. If a numerical difference is given, add or subtract it along the chain to get the actual ages.

What do you do when two persons cannot be compared?

If two persons are not joined by any chain of clues, their order cannot be fixed, so the correct answer is data insufficient. For example, A taller than B and C taller than D give no relation between A and C.

How do you find the second tallest person from clues?

Build the complete chain from tallest to shortest, then read the second name from the left. If any person lies on a branch that is not linked, check whether the second position is still fixed, otherwise the data is insufficient.

Does the method change for marks instead of height?

No, the method is identical for height, weight, age and marks. Only the words change, such as scored more than or less than. Write each clue as an inequality and join them in a chain, or sort the numbers directly when marks are given.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 If A is taller than B and B is taller than C, then A is taller than C.
True

Inequalities pass along a chain: A > B > C.

2 If A is taller than B and A is taller than C, B must be taller than C.
False

B and C are not linked, so their order cannot be decided.

3 If P scored more than Q and R scored less than Q, P has the highest of the three marks.
True

The chain is P > Q > R, so P is highest.

4 If X is older than Y, then Y is older than X.
False

The two statements contradict each other.

Share: