Replacement Problems (Repeated Removal and Replacement of a Portion of a Mixture)
Quantitative Aptitude › Average and Mixture/Alligation · Topic 8.6
In a replacement problem, a fixed quantity is drawn out of a vessel and replaced with another liquid, and this is repeated. After n replacements, the original liquid left is the initial quantity multiplied by (1 minus the fraction replaced) raised to the power n.
5 min read · Quantitative Aptitude · Average and Mixture/Alligation
Quick Answer
In a replacement problem, a fixed quantity is drawn out of a vessel and replaced with another liquid, and this is repeated. After n replacements, the original liquid left is the initial quantity multiplied by (1 minus the fraction replaced) raised to the power n.
At a Glance
- Formula Left = V × (1 – x/V)n
- V Initial quantity of pure liquid
- x Quantity removed each time
- n Number of replacements
- Fraction replaced x/V
- After one step Left = V – x
Where Does It Fit?
This topic builds on Mixture and Alligation Rule (Rule of Alligation) and Mixing Two or More Ingredients of Different Prices/Concentrations. It is the multi-step version of mixing, and it is paired with Alligation Problems Involving More Than Two Mixtures/Components in harder problems.
What Is a Replacement Problem?
In short: a vessel holds a liquid. A part is taken out and replaced by water or another liquid. The mixture is then stirred and the process repeats.
Replacement formula
- Pure liquid left after n replacements = V × (1 – x/V)n
- Fraction of original left = (1 – x/V)n
- The mixture is assumed to be uniform before each removal.
Each time, the portion removed carries away the original liquid in the same proportion as it is present, so the original liquid is multiplied by the same factor every step.
How Does the Formula Work Step by Step?
| Step | Pure milk left (V = 64, x = 16) |
|---|---|
| Start | 64 litres |
| After 1st replacement | 64 × 48/64 = 48 litres |
| After 2nd replacement | 48 × 48/64 = 36 litres |
The pure milk is 36 litres and water is 64 – 36 = 28 litres, so the ratio milk to water is 9 : 7. This agrees with the formula V × (1 – x/V)2 = 64 × (3/4)2 = 36.
What Variations Appear in Exams?
- Find the quantity replaced: if 80 litres of milk becomes 60 litres of milk after one replacement, x satisfies 80(1 – x/80) = 60, so x = 20.
- Fraction removed each time: if one third is removed each time for two times, the fraction of the original left is (2/3)2 = 4/9. For 27 litres this is 12 litres.
- Ratio after replacements: if one fifth is replaced twice, the original is (4/5)2 = 16/25, so original : added = 16 : 9.
- Link to alligation: single-step replacement can also be solved as a mixture using Mixture and Alligation Rule (Rule of Alligation).
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: A vessel has 64 litres of pure milk. 16 litres are removed and replaced by water, and this is done again. How much pure milk is left?
- V = 64, x = 16, n = 2.
- Left = 64 × (1 – 16/64)2 = 64 × (3/4)2.
- 64 × 9/16 = 36.
Answer: 36 litres
Example 2
Question: A vessel has 80 litres of milk. After one replacement by water it contains 60 litres of milk. How much was replaced?
- 80(1 – x/80) = 60.
- 1 – x/80 = 3/4, so x/80 = 1/4.
- x = 20.
Answer: 20 litres
Example 3
Question: A vessel has 30 litres of spirit. 6 litres are replaced by water, and this is done three times. How much spirit is left?
- Fraction left each time = 24/30 = 0.8.
- Left = 30 × 0.83 = 30 × 0.512.
- 30 × 0.512 = 15.36.
Answer: 15.36 litres
Example 4
Question: One third of a 27-litre mixture of pure milk is replaced by water twice. How much pure milk is left?
- Fraction left each time = 2/3.
- Left = 27 × (2/3)2 = 27 × 4/9.
- 27 × 4/9 = 12.
Answer: 12 litres
Example 5
Question: One fifth of a vessel of pure milk is replaced by water twice. Find the ratio of milk to water.
- Milk fraction = (4/5)2 = 16/25.
- Water fraction = 1 – 16/25 = 9/25.
- Ratio = 16 : 9.
Answer: 16 : 9
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Convert the removed quantity into a fraction of the vessel before applying the power.
- The fraction left each time is the same, so use a repeated multiplier.
- For one replacement, just subtract: left = V – x.
- For the ratio of original to added, use fractions of the vessel.
- Check by listing the quantity after each step for small n.
Common Mistakes
- Subtracting x each time without reducing it for the water already removed.
- Using x as a fraction of the original but not the current mixture quantity.
- Forgetting that the vessel size stays constant after each replacement.
- Squaring the wrong factor, such as (x/V)n instead of (1 – x/V)n.
- Reading the answer as water when pure liquid is asked.
Practice Questions
- A vessel holds 50 litres of milk. 10 litres are replaced by water twice. How much milk is left?
- A vessel holds 100 litres of milk. 20 litres are replaced by water once. How much milk is left?
- What fraction of the original is left after removing one quarter three times?
- A vessel of 200 litres has 40 litres replaced twice. How much of the original remains?
- One fifth of a mixture is replaced by water twice. What is the ratio of original to water?
Answers: 1) 32 litres; 2) 80 litres; 3) 27/64; 4) 128 litres; 5) 16 : 9.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Common pattern Replacement appears in many mixture questions.
- Formula use One formula covers all repeats.
- Link It is a stepping stone to Alligation Problems Involving More Than Two Mixtures/Components.
- Reasoning It teaches repeated multiplicative change.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Average Speed Problems Linked to Alligation, which uses alligation to connect average speed with the time spent at each speed.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Replacement Removing a portion and adding another liquid
- Fraction replaced Removed quantity divided by vessel capacity
- Pure liquid The original liquid in the mixture
- Uniform mixture Liquid mixed evenly before each removal
- Vessel capacity Total volume of the container
- Power n Number of replacements
Related Topics
- Mixing Two or More Ingredients of Different Prices/Concentrations
- Average Speed Problems Linked to Alligation
- Average of Numbers, Ages, Weights and Scores
- Weighted Average Calculation
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Left = V × (1 – x/V) raised to n.
- The vessel size stays constant.
- Mixture is uniform before each removal.
- For one step, left = V – x.
- Water fraction = 1 – original fraction.
Do Not Confuse With
- Quantity removed vs fraction removed The formula uses the fraction.
- Pure milk vs mixture Only the pure milk is multiplied.
- One step vs n steps One step subtracts; n steps multiply the factor.
- Left vs added Left is the original liquid; added is the replacement liquid.
Memory Hook
Each replacement multiplies the original by the same fraction.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the formula for repeated replacement in mixtures?
The formula for repeated replacement states that the quantity of the original liquid left after n replacements equals the initial quantity multiplied by (1 minus the fraction replaced) raised to the power n. For 64 litres with 16 litres replaced twice, 64 multiplied by (3/4) squared gives 36 litres.
How do you find pure milk left after replacement with water?
Pure milk left after replacement is found by multiplying the initial milk by the fraction left in each step, repeated for each replacement. If one quarter is removed and replaced with water three times, the fraction left is (3/4) cubed, which is 27/64 of the original milk.
What is the ratio of milk to water after replacement?
After replacement, the ratio of milk to water is the fraction of milk left to the fraction of water that has entered. If one fifth is replaced twice, milk is (4/5) squared, which is 16/25, and water is 9/25, so the ratio of milk to water is 16 to 9.
Does the vessel size change after each replacement?
The vessel size stays the same in replacement problems because the quantity removed is replaced by an equal quantity of water. The total volume remains the initial volume, but the share of the original liquid falls with each step because the removed portion also carries some water.
How do you find the quantity replaced each time?
The quantity replaced each time is found from the given amount of original liquid left after one replacement. If 80 litres of milk becomes 60 litres, solve 80 multiplied by (1 minus x/80) equal to 60, which gives x equal to 20 litres removed and replaced.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 After n replacements the original liquid left is V × (1 - x/V)n.
Each replacement multiplies it by the same fraction.
2 A vessel of 64 litres of milk with 16 litres replaced twice by water holds 32 litres of milk.
64 × (3/4)2 = 36 litres.
3 The volume of the mixture changes after each replacement.
The removed quantity is replaced, so the volume stays constant.
4 If one fifth is replaced twice, milk to water is 16 : 9.
Milk = 16/25 and water = 9/25.
Related Topics
Browse the full Quantitative Aptitude index