An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 8.9

Alligation Problems Involving More Than Two Mixtures/Components

Quantitative Aptitude › Average and Mixture/Alligation · Topic 8.9

Alligation with more than two components finds the quantities of three or more ingredients that give a required mean. The ingredients are split into those below the mean and those above it, and each cheaper ingredient is paired with a dearer one.

Share:
Alligation Problems Involving More Than Two Mixtures/Components - Quantitative Aptitude - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Alligation with more than two components finds the quantities of three or more ingredients that give a required mean. The ingredients are split into those below the mean and those above it, and each cheaper ingredient is paired with a dearer one.

At a Glance

  • Method Pair each cheaper with a dearer ingredient
  • Needs At least one below and one above the mean
  • Answer Not unique unless the pairs are fixed
  • Check Total cost / total quantity = mean
  • Ingredient equal to the mean Any quantity can be added
  • Two-step method Mix two first, then mix with the third

Where Does It Fit?

This topic extends Mixture and Alligation Rule (Rule of Alligation) and Mixing Two or More Ingredients of Different Prices/Concentrations from two ingredients to more. It uses the same differences, applied to pairs.

How Does the Pairing Method Work?

In short: list the ingredients below the mean and above the mean. Pair one cheaper with one dearer ingredient, apply alligation to each pair, and add up the quantities of each ingredient.

Pairing steps

  • For each pair (c, d): cheaper : dearer = (d – m) : (m – c).
  • Combine the pairs so that every ingredient appears once.
  • Verify with total cost / total quantity = mean.

The answer is not unique when there are more than two ingredients, because the pairs can be taken in different proportions. Exam questions usually give a fixed pairing or a ratio to find.

How Do You Solve a Three-Ingredient Problem?

Pair Ratio (cheaper : dearer)
Rs 20 with Rs 50 for mean 35 (50 – 35) : (35 – 20) = 15 : 15 = 1 : 1
Rs 30 with Rs 50 for mean 35 (50 – 35) : (35 – 30) = 15 : 5 = 3 : 1

Taking one unit from the first pair and one unit from the second pair gives quantities Rs 20 : Rs 30 : Rs 50 = 1 : 3 : 2 (the Rs 50 part is 1 + 1 = 2). Check: (20 + 90 + 100)/6 = 210/6 = Rs 35.

What Special Cases Should You Know?

  • Ingredient equal to the mean: it may be added in any quantity, because it does not change the mean.
  • All on one side: if every ingredient is below the mean, the mean cannot be reached.
  • Two-step method: mix two ingredients first to get an intermediate, then mix that intermediate with the third using alligation. For Rs 20 and Rs 40 mixed equally to Rs 30, then mixed with Rs 60 to reach Rs 40, the final ratio is 1 : 1 : 1.
  • Four ingredients: take two cheaper and two dearer, pair them, and add the quantities. For a mean of Rs 15 from Rs 8, 12, 20 and 24, the ratio 5 : 3 : 7 : 1 works.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Rice at Rs 20, Rs 30 and Rs 50 per kg is to be mixed to give Rs 35 per kg. Find a suitable ratio.

  1. Pair Rs 20 with Rs 50: ratio (50 – 35) : (35 – 20) = 1 : 1.
  2. Pair Rs 30 with Rs 50: ratio (50 – 35) : (35 – 30) = 3 : 1.
  3. Take 1 of Rs 20, 3 of Rs 30, and 1 + 1 = 2 of Rs 50.
  4. Check: (20 + 90 + 100)/6 = 35.

Answer: 1 : 3 : 2

Example 2

Question: Four grades at Rs 8, 12, 20 and 24 are mixed in the ratio 5 : 3 : 7 : 1. Find the mean price.

  1. Total cost = 40 + 36 + 140 + 24 = 240.
  2. Total quantity = 16.
  3. Mean = 240/16 = 15.

Answer: Rs 15

Example 3

Question: Solutions of 20 per cent, 40 per cent and 70 per cent are mixed to get 45 per cent. Find a suitable ratio.

  1. Pair 20 and 70: (70 – 45) : (45 – 20) = 25 : 25 = 1 : 1.
  2. Pair 40 and 70: (70 – 45) : (45 – 40) = 25 : 5 = 5 : 1.
  3. Quantities: 20 per cent: 1, 40 per cent: 5, 70 per cent: 1 + 1 = 2.
  4. Check: (20 + 200 + 140)/8 = 45.

Answer: 1 : 5 : 2

Example 4

Question: Three grades at Rs 40, Rs 50 and Rs 60 are mixed in the ratio 2 : 3 : 5. Find the mean price.

  1. Total cost = 80 + 150 + 300 = 530.
  2. Total quantity = 10.
  3. Mean = 530/10 = 53.

Answer: Rs 53

Example 5

Question: Rs 20 and Rs 40 grades are mixed equally. This mixture is then mixed with Rs 60 grade to give Rs 40. Find the final ratio of the three grades.

  1. Equal mix of Rs 20 and Rs 40 has a mean of Rs 30.
  2. Mixing Rs 30 and Rs 60 for a mean of Rs 40 gives (60 – 40) : (40 – 30) = 2 : 1.
  3. So 2 parts of the intermediate mixture and 1 part of Rs 60.
  4. The intermediate has 1 part each of Rs 20 and Rs 40, so the final ratio is 1 : 1 : 1.
  5. Check: (20 + 40 + 60)/3 = 40.

Answer: 1 : 1 : 1

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Split the ingredients into those below and above the mean before pairing.
  • Choose the simplest pairs to make the numbers small.
  • Use the total-cost check at the end of every answer.
  • If an ingredient equals the mean, treat it as a free addition.
  • For many ingredients, mix two at a time using alligation, then combine the results.

Common Mistakes

  • Pairing two ingredients that are both below the mean.
  • Combining pair ratios without matching the common ingredient.
  • Assuming the answer is unique when several ratios are possible.
  • Forgetting to verify with total cost.
  • Using cost prices and selling prices together.

Practice Questions

  1. Grades of Rs 20, 30 and 40 are mixed in the ratio 3 : 2 : 5. Find the mean price.
  2. In what ratio should Rs 10 and Rs 40 grades be mixed to get Rs 25?
  3. 1 kg each of Rs 20, Rs 40 and Rs 60 grades are mixed. Find the mean price.
  4. Solutions of 20, 40 and 70 per cent are mixed in the ratio 1 : 5 : 2. Find the strength.
  5. Is a mean of Rs 70 possible from Rs 30, 40 and 60 grades?

Answers: 1) Rs 32; 2) 1 : 1; 3) Rs 40; 4) 45 per cent; 5) No, because every grade is below Rs 70.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Harder sets Three-ingredient problems separate strong candidates.
  • Method Pairing reduces them to two-ingredient problems.
  • Check habit Verifying with totals prevents errors.
  • Link It follows from Mixture and Alligation Rule (Rule of Alligation).

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Average of Consecutive Numbers, Consecutive Even Numbers and Consecutive Odd Numbers, which turns to averages of consecutive numbers.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Pairing Matching a cheaper and a dearer ingredient
  • Mean Required price or strength of the mixture
  • Intermediate mixture Mixture of two ingredients used in a later step
  • Component One ingredient in a mixture
  • Total cost check Verification by cost over quantity
  • Concentration Strength of a solution

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Pair a cheaper ingredient with a dearer one.
  • At least one ingredient must be below and one above the mean.
  • The answer is not unique for more than two ingredients.
  • An ingredient equal to the mean can be added freely.
  • Verify with total cost / total quantity.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Pair ratio vs final ratio The final ratio combines the pairs.
  • Mean vs average of prices The mean is weighted by quantities.
  • Possible vs unique Several correct ratios may exist.
  • Two-step vs pairing Both reach the same mean by different routes.

Memory Hook

Pair low with high, add the parts, then check the cost.

GS Relevance

Three-ingredient mixing questions appear in SSC CGL and CAT mixture sets.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is alligation used with more than two ingredients?

Alligation with more than two ingredients uses the pairing method. Ingredients below the mean are paired with ingredients above it, alligation gives the ratio for each pair, and the quantities are added up. The result is checked by dividing total cost by total quantity, which must equal the mean.

Is the answer unique with three ingredients?

The answer is not unique with three or more ingredients because the pairs can be combined in different proportions and still produce the same mean. Exam questions therefore fix the pairing or give a ratio to find. Any correct combination can be confirmed using total cost divided by total quantity.

What if one ingredient equals the mean price?

An ingredient priced exactly at the mean can be added in any quantity without changing the mean price of the mixture. It contributes no extra value above or below the mean, so it acts as a free addition when the other ingredients already balance around the mean.

How does the two-step method work?

The two-step method mixes two ingredients first to obtain an intermediate mixture, then mixes that intermediate with the third ingredient using alligation. For Rs 20 and Rs 40 mixed equally to Rs 30, then mixed with Rs 60 to give Rs 40, the final ratio is 1 to 1 to 1.

When is a mean impossible to reach?

A mean is impossible to reach when all ingredients lie on one side of it. For example, a mean of Rs 70 cannot be made from grades priced at Rs 30, Rs 40 and Rs 60, because every mixture of them costs no more than the dearest grade of Rs 60.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 A mean price above the dearest ingredient can be obtained by mixing.
False

A mixture cannot cost more than its dearest part.

2 With three ingredients, the mixing ratio for a given mean is always unique.
False

Different pairings can give the same mean.

3 Grades of Rs 40, Rs 50 and Rs 60 mixed in the ratio 2 : 3 : 5 have a mean of Rs 53.
True

(80 + 150 + 300)/10 = 53.

4 An ingredient equal to the mean price can be added in any quantity.
True

It does not shift the mean.

Share: