Consumption-Price Trade-off Problems (Expenditure Held Constant)
Quantitative Aptitude › Percentage · Topic 4.9
When expenditure is held constant, price and consumption are inversely related: if the price rises by x%, consumption must fall by 100x/(100 + x) per cent, and if the price falls by x%, consumption can rise by 100x/(100 - x) per cent.
5 min read · Quantitative Aptitude · Percentage
Quick Answer
When expenditure is held constant, price and consumption are inversely related: if the price rises by x%, consumption must fall by 100x/(100 + x) per cent, and if the price falls by x%, consumption can rise by 100x/(100 – x) per cent.
At a Glance
- Rule Price × Consumption = Expenditure
- Price up x% Consumption down 100x/(100 + x) %
- Price down x% Consumption up 100x/(100 – x) %
- Price +25% Consumption -20%
- Price -20% Consumption +25%
Where Does It Fit?
This is the constant-product case of Percentage Change in the Product of Two Interdependent Quantities. It reuses the restoring percentages seen in Percentage Increase and Percentage Decrease Calculations, and it is the idea behind many problems in Combined Percentage and Profit-Loss Problems and Cost Price, Selling Price and Marked Price Relationships.
What Is the Rule When Expenditure Is Held Constant?
In short: expenditure is price multiplied by quantity, so if expenditure must not change, the new quantity is the old quantity divided by the price multiplier.
Formulas
- Expenditure = Price per unit × Quantity consumed
- New consumption = Old consumption × 100/(100 + x), when price rises by x%
- New consumption = Old consumption × 100/(100 – x), when price falls by x%
| Price change | Price multiplier | Consumption multiplier | Change in consumption |
|---|---|---|---|
| +25% | 5/4 | 4/5 | -20% |
| +20% | 6/5 | 5/6 | -16.67% |
| +50% | 3/2 | 2/3 | -33.33% |
| +100% | 2 | 1/2 | -50% |
| -20% | 4/5 | 5/4 | +25% |
| -25% | 3/4 | 4/3 | +33.33% |
| -50% | 1/2 | 2 | +100% |
How Do You Use the Rule in Word Problems?
In short: find the price multiplier, invert it, and read off the consumption change.
- Price rises 20%: the multiplier is 6/5, so consumption becomes 5/6, a fall of 1/6 or 16.67%.
- With numbers: Rs 240 buys 12 kg at Rs 20 per kg. After a 20% price rise the price is Rs 24, so Rs 240 buys 10 kg, which is 2 kg less, or 16.67%.
- Percentage cut vs price rise: the fall in consumption is always smaller than the rise in price, because it is measured on a larger base.
What If Consumption Is Reduced by a Different Amount?
In short: if consumption changes by a different percentage from the one needed, expenditure changes, and the product formula of Percentage Change in the Product of Two Interdependent Quantities gives the change.
- Example: price rises 10% and consumption falls 5%. The multiplier is 1.1 × 0.95 = 1.045, so expenditure rises 4.5%.
- Break-even: consumption must fall 9.09% to offset a 10% price rise, since 100 × 10/110 = 9.09.
- Increase in spending: if consumption falls less than needed, spending rises. If it falls more, spending falls.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: The price of a commodity rises by 25%. By what percentage must consumption fall to keep expenditure the same?
- Price multiplier = 5/4.
- Consumption multiplier = 4/5.
- Fall = 1 – 4/5 = 1/5 = 20%.
Answer: 20%
Example 2
Question: The price of sugar falls by 20%. By what percentage can consumption rise for the same expenditure?
- Price multiplier = 4/5.
- Consumption multiplier = 5/4.
- Rise = 5/4 – 1 = 1/4 = 25%.
Answer: 25%
Example 3
Question: Rs 240 buys 12 kg of rice. The price rises by 20%. How much rice does the same money buy now?
- Old price = 240/12 = Rs 20 per kg.
- New price = 20 × 1.2 = Rs 24 per kg.
- New quantity = 240/24 = 10 kg.
Answer: 10 kg, which is 16.67% less
Example 4
Question: The price of fuel rises by 10% and a driver cuts use by 5%. Find the change in expenditure.
- Multipliers: 1.1 and 0.95.
- 1.1 × 0.95 = 1.045.
Answer: Expenditure rises by 4.5%
Example 5
Question: The price falls by 16 2/3 %. By what percentage can consumption rise at constant expenditure?
- 16 2/3 % = 1/6, so the price multiplier is 5/6.
- Consumption multiplier = 6/5.
- Rise = 1/5 = 20%.
Answer: 20%
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Use fractions: a price rise of 1/n needs a fall of 1/(n + 1) in consumption.
- A price fall of 1/n allows a rise of 1/(n – 1) in consumption.
- Remember the pairs: 25% and 20%, 20% and 16.67%, 50% and 33.33%, 100% and 50%.
- Pick a price of Rs 100 and quantity 100 to see the change clearly.
- If the percentages are not exactly offsetting, use the product formula to find the change in expenditure.
Common Mistakes
- Assuming a 25% price rise needs a 25% fall in consumption.
- Using the new price as the base for the price change.
- Reversing the rule: a price fall allows consumption to rise by 100x/(100 – x), not 100x/(100 + x).
- Forgetting that the question holds expenditure, not quantity, constant.
- Rounding 16.67% to 17% in multi-step problems.
Practice Questions
- The price rises 50%. By what percentage must consumption fall?
- The price falls 25%. By what percentage can consumption rise?
- The price doubles. By what percentage must consumption fall?
- The price rises 12.5%. By what percentage must consumption fall?
- Rs 600 buys 15 units. The price falls 20%. How many units does Rs 600 buy now?
- The price rises 20% and consumption falls 10%. Find the change in expenditure.
Answers: 1) 33.33%; 2) 33.33%; 3) 50%; 4) 11.11%; 5) 18.75; 6) an 8% rise.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Frequent It is a regular type in arithmetic papers.
- Link to products It is the constant case of Percentage Change in the Product of Two Interdependent Quantities.
- Link to prices It underlies discount questions in Successive Discount Problems.
- Speed Fraction pairs make answers instant.
What Comes Next?
The next topic, Percentage Error in Measurement of Area/Volume, uses percentage change on measurement errors in length, area and volume.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Expenditure Price multiplied by quantity
- Consumption Quantity used or bought
- Inverse relation When one quantity rises, the other falls
- Restoring percentage The change that offsets another change
- Price multiplier The factor by which price is multiplied
Related Topics
- Percentage Points vs Percentage Change Distinction Problems
- Percentage Error in Measurement of Area/Volume
- Percentage to Fraction and Fraction to Percentage Conversion
- Percentage Increase and Percentage Decrease Calculations
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Expenditure = price × consumption.
- Price +25% means consumption -20%.
- Price -20% means consumption +25%.
- Fall in consumption = 100x/(100 + x) for a price rise of x%.
- Use fractions to answer quickly.
Do Not Confuse With
- Price up vs consumption up They move in opposite directions at constant expenditure.
- Constant expenditure vs constant quantity Here the money spent is fixed, and the quantity changes.
- Fall of 20% vs rise of 20% They are not offsetting: 0.8 × 1.2 = 0.96.
Memory Hook
Price up, buy less; the cut is smaller than the rise.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you find the change in consumption when price changes?
When expenditure stays constant, new consumption equals old consumption divided by the price multiplier. If the price rises by 25 per cent, the multiplier is 5 over 4, so consumption becomes 4 over 5 of the old amount, a fall of 20 per cent.
What is the formula for reduction in consumption?
If the price rises by x per cent, consumption must fall by 100x divided by 100 plus x per cent to keep expenditure unchanged. For a 25 per cent price rise the formula gives 2500 divided by 125, which is a 20 per cent fall.
If the price falls by 20 per cent, how much more can be bought?
If the price falls by 20 per cent and expenditure is held constant, consumption can rise by 25 per cent. The price multiplier is 4 over 5, so the consumption multiplier is 5 over 4, which is an increase of one-quarter.
Why is the fall in consumption smaller than the price rise?
The fall in consumption is smaller than the price rise because it is measured on a larger base. A price rise of 25 per cent takes the price to 125, and the consumption must fall by 25 out of 125, which is only 20 per cent.
What happens to expenditure if consumption falls by less than needed?
If consumption falls by less than needed, expenditure rises. A price rise of 10 per cent with a consumption fall of 5 per cent gives a multiplier of 1.1 times 0.95, which is 1.045, so expenditure rises by 4.5 per cent.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 If the price rises 25%, consumption must fall 20% to keep expenditure the same.
4/5 of the old quantity is a fall of 20 per cent.
2 If the price rises 20%, consumption must fall 20% to keep expenditure the same.
It must fall 16.67 per cent.
3 If the price falls 20%, consumption can rise 25% at constant expenditure.
5/4 of the old quantity is a rise of 25 per cent.
4 If the price rises 50%, consumption must fall 50%.
It must fall 33.33 per cent.
Related Topics
Browse the full Quantitative Aptitude index