Railways: issues and challenges (NITI Aayog India@75), steps taken, way forward; role of PPP in station redevelopment; DFCs
Indian Economy › Infrastructure and Investment Models · Topic 16.22
Indian Railways faces issues of finance, safety, capacity and freight share even as it modernises. Its operating ratio was estimated at 98.8 per cent in 2025-26 (revised) and 98.4 per cent in 2026-27 (budget), meaning almost every rupee earned goes to working expenses, and passenger services depend on freight revenue, which has contributed about 68 per cent of internal revenue on average. The National Rail Plan aims for a 45 per cent rail share of freight by 2030. Steps taken include 99.6 per cent electrification, two Dedicated Freight Corridors totalling 2,843 km, Kavach safety systems, Amrit Bharat stations and Public-Private Partnership in stations, wagons and locomotive factories.
7 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Infrastructure and Investment Models
At a Glance
- Operating ratio 98.8 per cent (2025-26 revised), 98.4 per cent (2026-27 budget)
- Freight loading 1,670 million tonnes in 2025-26
- Freight share in internal revenue About 68 per cent on average
- Electrification 99.6 per cent (March 2026)
- Dedicated Freight Corridors 2,843 km commissioned
- Rail freight share goal 45 per cent by 2030
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Infrastructure and Investment Models
Where Does It Fit?
This is the Mains companion to Railways Sector: Recent Initiatives by the Railways; DFCs; Station Redevelopment through PPP and links to Industrial Corridors and Dedicated Freight Corridors (DFC); Corridor Development and Implementation Trust; Nodal Ministry (DPIIT) and Implementing Agency on DFCs and Logistics sector: issues and challenges; way forward on logistics. The PPP models are in PPP Models: Contracting, Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT), DBFO, Concessions, EPC, Swiss Challenge, Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM), Annuity. Previous topic: Roads: Budget 2026-27 highlights, significance, issues, measures, way forward; PM GatiShakti; RRTS. Next topic: Ports and waterways: Inland Water Transport, National Waterways, significance, issues, steps, way forward.
What Are the Issues and Challenges of Indian Railways?
| Issue | Evidence | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Weak finances | Operating ratio of 98.8 per cent in 2025-26 (revised) and 98.4 per cent budgeted for 2026-27 | Little surplus remains for capital works, so capital spending depends on budgetary support |
| Cross-subsidy | Freight has contributed about 68 per cent of internal revenue on average between 2017-18 and 2026-27, and passenger services have not met their operating costs | Freight tariffs stay high to support passengers, which pushes some cargo to roads |
| Freight share | The National Rail Plan aims to raise rail’s freight share to 45 per cent by 2030 | Rail is cheaper and cleaner than road for bulk cargo |
| Capacity constraints | Dense routes carry both passenger and freight trains on shared lines | Delays and low speeds, which the Dedicated Freight Corridors address |
| Safety | Automatic train protection is being rolled out. Kavach covers 3,103 route km, with 24,427 km under way | Safety is a basic requirement and needs long-term funding |
| Station and service quality | Only 208 of 1,338 identified stations had been redeveloped by June 2026 | Passenger amenities lag the pace of network growth |
| Institutional | Regulation, accounting and private participation have developed slowly. A Railway Development Authority was set up in 2017 as an independent regulator | Reforms need clear tariff, access and performance rules |
What Steps Have Been Taken and How Do PPP and DFCs Help?
| Step | Facts |
|---|---|
| Budget support | Budgetary support rose from about Rs 32,000 crore in 2014-15 to Rs 2.78 lakh crore in 2026-27 |
| Electrification | 99.6 per cent of the network, 69,873 route km, by March 2026 |
| Dedicated Freight Corridors | Eastern DFC from Ludhiana to Sonnagar (1,337 km) and Western DFC from JNPT to Dadri (1,506 km) are commissioned, with about 443 trains a day. Budget 2026-27 proposes a new Dankuni to Surat DFC |
| Freight growth | Loading rose from 1,098 million tonnes in 2014-15 to 1,670 million tonnes in 2025-26, a rise of about 52 per cent |
| Gati Shakti Cargo Terminals | 142 terminals commissioned with 224 million tonnes a year of capacity, drawing about Rs 10,000 crore of private investment |
| PPP in station redevelopment | In July 2018 Railways listed 13 stations such as Charbagh in Lucknow, Ernakulam Junction, Habibganj, Surat and Tirupati for redevelopment through PPP, with private developers chosen by open bidding and station land used commercially to fund improvements |
| PPP in manufacturing and projects | Railways PPP projects follow the 2012 PPP Policy. 18 projects worth Rs 16,686 crore are complete and 7 worth Rs 16,362 crore are under way. PPP locomotive factories are at Madhepura and Marhowra in Bihar |
| Amrit Bharat Station Scheme | Launched in 2023 to redevelop 1,338 stations as city centres, with 208 completed by June 2026 |
What Else Should You Remember?
- NITI Aayog view: NITI Aayog’s Strategy for New India at 75 stressed raising capacity, safety and freight share, greater private participation and independent regulation of the sector, which the current reforms and the National Rail Plan follow
- Why railways matter: Railways carry bulk freight such as coal, cement and food grains at lower cost and lower emissions than road, and they are the main long-distance passenger mode, so efficiency affects logistics cost and climate goals
- Role of PPP: PPP brings capital, expertise and commercial use of land and trains, but station projects have faced slow bidding and low interest, so risk allocation and revenue models matter, as in Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Definition, Need, Prerequisites, Advantages
- DFC impact: The corridors free the existing lines for passenger trains and allow longer, heavier and faster freight trains, and the Eastern DFC has cut wagon turnaround from 15-16 days to 2-3 days
- Link to ports and highways: Port connectivity and first-mile terminals are needed so that cargo can move to rail, as in Ports and waterways: Inland Water Transport, National Waterways, significance, issues, steps, way forward and Roads: Budget 2026-27 highlights, significance, issues, measures, way forward; PM GatiShakti; RRTS
- Way forward: Rationalise freight and passenger pricing, speed up Kavach, complete DFC feeder links, scale terminals, use performance-based PPP and strengthen independent regulation
- Fiscal angle: A high operating ratio and rising pension and wage costs limit own funds, so asset monetisation and private capital are needed alongside budget support
- Current angle: Record freight loading of 1,670 million tonnes in 2025-26, 99.6 per cent electrification and the planned Dankuni to Surat DFC are the freshest facts
- Model answer tip: Frame the answer as finance, capacity, safety and service, give two facts for each, and end with a line on rail-led logistics
- Common errors: Thinking DFCs carry passengers. They carry goods only
- Another common error: Treating Amrit Bharat Station Scheme and PPP station redevelopment as the same. They are separate programmes
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Operating ratio: 98.8 per cent in 2025-26 (revised), 98.4 per cent in 2026-27 (budget)
- DFCs: Eastern 1,337 km and Western 1,506 km, total 2,843 km
- Freight loading: 1,670 million tonnes in 2025-26
- National Rail Plan: 45 per cent freight share by 2030
- PPP stations: 13 stations listed in July 2018
As an analytical point, the railway challenge is to fund expansion while holding down costs. With an operating ratio near 98 per cent, the system cannot self-fund its capital plans. Raising freight share, adding capacity through DFCs and bringing in private capital through well-designed PPPs are linked answers to the same problem.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Issues Finance, capacity, safety, share
- Steps Electrification, DFCs, Kavach
- PPP Stations, wagons, locomotives
What Came Next?
The next topic covers ports and waterways: inland water transport, National Waterways, significance, issues, steps and way forward. Next topic: Ports and waterways: Inland Water Transport, National Waterways, significance, issues, steps, way forward.
Key People and Terms
- Operating ratio Working expenses per Rs 100 of earnings
- DFC Dedicated Freight Corridor
- Kavach Automatic train protection
- ABSS Amrit Bharat Station Scheme
- NRP National Rail Plan
- RDA Railway Development Authority
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Operating ratio: 98.8 per cent (2025-26 revised).
- DFCs: 2,843 km.
- Freight loading: 1,670 million tonnes.
- National Rail Plan: 45 per cent by 2030.
- Amrit Bharat: 208 of 1,338 stations (June 2026).
Do Not Confuse With
- Operating ratio and profit Expense per Rs 100 earned versus surplus
- DFC and passenger lines Goods-only corridor versus shared network
- Amrit Bharat Station Scheme and PPP stations Government-led redevelopment versus private developer model
Memory Hook
Ninety-eight to earn a hundred, so freight, DFCs and PPP must fill the gap.
Mains Angle
Questions ask for issues, steps and the way forward. These points give a frame.
- Issues Finance, capacity, safety
- Steps Electrification, DFCs, PPP
- Way forward Pricing, safety, regulation
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Examine the issues and challenges facing Indian Railways and evaluate the role of Dedicated Freight Corridors and PPP in station redevelopment.”
How to Answer
- Intro Operating ratio near 98 per cent.
- Issues Finance, capacity, safety, share.
- Steps DFCs, Kavach, PPP, Amrit Bharat.
- Conclude Freight share and finance must rise together.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main challenges facing Indian Railways?
The main challenges are a very high operating ratio of 98.8 per cent in 2025-26, dependence on freight revenue to support passenger services, capacity limits on dense routes, safety investment needs, a falling rail share of freight and slow station and service improvement.
What is the operating ratio of Indian Railways?
The operating ratio is the working expenses spent to earn Rs 100. It was estimated at 98.8 per cent for 2025-26 (revised) and 98.4 per cent for 2026-27 (budget), meaning almost all earnings go to expenses and little is left for capital works.
What are the Dedicated Freight Corridors?
The two Dedicated Freight Corridors are goods-only railway lines: the Eastern DFC from Ludhiana to Sonnagar of 1,337 km and the Western DFC from JNPT to Dadri of 1,506 km, together 2,843 km. They free existing lines for passenger trains and speed up freight.
How is PPP used in railway station redevelopment?
In July 2018 Railways listed 13 stations, such as Charbagh in Lucknow, Ernakulam Junction and Surat, for redevelopment through PPP, with private developers chosen by open bidding and station land used commercially. Railways PPP projects follow the 2012 PPP Policy.
What is the National Rail Plan goal for freight?
The National Rail Plan aims to raise the rail share of freight transport to 45 per cent by 2030. Freight loading rose from 1,098 million tonnes in 2014-15 to 1,670 million tonnes in 2025-26, which makes India the second largest freight railway in the world.
What safety measures has Railways taken?
Railways is rolling out Kavach, the indigenous automatic train protection system, which has been deployed on 3,103 route km with 24,427 km under way. Kavach applies brakes if the loco pilot fails, and Version 4.0 has been commissioned on major routes.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The operating ratio of Indian Railways was estimated at 98.8 per cent in 2025-26 (revised).
It measures expenses per Rs 100 earned.
2 Dedicated Freight Corridors carry passenger trains.
They are goods-only lines.
3 The National Rail Plan aims for a 45 per cent rail share of freight by 2030.
The aim is to raise rail's freight share.
4 In July 2018 Railways listed 13 stations for redevelopment through PPP.
They included Charbagh in Lucknow and Surat.
5 The Western DFC runs from Ludhiana to Sonnagar.
That is the Eastern DFC. The Western DFC runs from JNPT to Dadri.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index