An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 16.16

PPP Models: Contracting, Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT), DBFO, Concessions, EPC, Swiss Challenge, Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM), Annuity

Indian Economy › Infrastructure and Investment Models · Topic 16.16

PPP models are the contract structures that decide who finances, builds, operates and bears risk in a Public-Private Partnership. The main ones are contracting (service and management contracts), Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT), Design-Build-Finance-Operate (DBFO), concessions, Engineering Procurement and Construction (EPC), the Swiss Challenge method of bidding, the annuity model and the Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM). Under HAM, approved for national highways in January 2016, the government pays 40 per cent of the project cost in five instalments during construction and the developer funds the other 60 per cent, recovering it through fixed annuity payments, while toll revenue goes to the authority. This topic was asked in UPSC Mains 2020.

Share:
PPP Models: Contracting, Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT), DBFO, Concessions, EPC, Swiss Challenge, Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM), Annuity - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • BOT Developer builds, operates and collects user charges, then transfers
  • Annuity Authority pays fixed amounts, developer bears no traffic risk
  • HAM 40 per cent from government, 60 per cent from developer
  • HAM approval Cabinet, January 2016, for national highways
  • EPC Government funds fully, contractor builds
  • Swiss Challenge Original proponent can match a better rival bid
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Infrastructure and Investment Models

Where Does It Fit?

This topic follows the meaning and need of PPPs in Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Definition, Need, Prerequisites, Advantages and the models overview in Investment Models: Public Sector-Led and Private Sector-Led Investment Models. The problems with PPPs are discussed in PPP: advantages; concession agreement; types; problems with PPP projects; Vijay Kelkar Committee on revisiting PPP; PPP and intergenerational equity; FDI and FII in investment model and highway use in Road Transport: National Highways, Road Sector Initiatives, RRTS. Previous topic: Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Definition, Need, Prerequisites, Advantages. Next topic: Infrastructure Investment; NIIF; India Infrastructure Project Development Fund (IIPDF).

How Do the Main PPP Models Compare?

Model Who funds and builds Who bears traffic or revenue risk How the private party is paid
Service or management contract Government owns and funds, private party manages for a short term Government Fixed fee for services
Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) toll Developer funds, builds and operates, then hands over Developer Tolls or user charges collected by the developer
BOT annuity Developer funds and builds, then operates Authority Fixed annuity payments from the authority, with tolls going to the authority
Design-Build-Finance-Operate (DBFO) Private party designs, builds, finances and operates Depends on the contract User charges or availability payments over the concession
Concession Private party gets the right to build and operate for a fixed period Usually the concessionaire User charges, under the concession agreement
Engineering Procurement and Construction (EPC) Government funds fully, contractor builds Government Contract payments for construction only
Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM) Government 40 per cent, developer 60 per cent Authority, since it collects tolls 40 per cent as construction support in five instalments and the rest through annuities
Swiss Challenge A bidding method, not a funding structure Not applicable Original proponent can match the best rival offer

What Are the Features of HAM and the Swiss Challenge?

Element Facts
HAM split The authority pays 40 per cent of the project cost in five instalments linked to construction milestones, and the developer arranges the remaining 60 per cent. Worked example: for a Rs 1,000 crore project, the authority pays Rs 400 crore and the developer arranges Rs 600 crore
HAM risk allocation The developer bears construction and maintenance risk and the authority bears revenue risk, since toll collection is by the National Highways Authority of India and not by the developer
HAM payment The developer receives annuity payments over the operating period, with an interest component on the unpaid amount
Why HAM was introduced Pure BOT toll projects had stalled because developers were wary of traffic risk and lenders were reluctant, so HAM shared the burden between the authority and the developer
Annuity model Developer builds with its own funds and the authority pays equal annual or semi-annual payments, so the developer has no traffic risk. It carries a heavy fiscal commitment for the authority
Swiss Challenge A method in which an unsolicited proposal from a private party is published, other parties are invited to give better offers and the original proponent gets a chance to match the best offer. It is a procurement method and not a funding model
DBFO Design-Build-Finance-Operate gives the private party control of design as well as financing and operation, which suits projects needing innovation

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Also called: Contracting is also called outsourcing. BOT is called toll road concession in highway projects. HAM means Hybrid Annuity Model. DBFO is also written DBFOT when the asset is transferred back
  • Variants of BOT: Build-Own-Operate-Transfer (BOOT) leaves ownership with the developer during the concession. Build-Own-Operate (BOO) leaves the asset with the developer permanently. Toll-Operate-Transfer (TOT) hands over an existing asset to a private operator for a fixed period
  • Concession agreement: The central contract of a PPP. It sets the term, tariff, performance standards, termination payments and the rights and duties of the authority and the concessionaire, as covered in PPP: advantages; concession agreement; types; problems with PPP projects; Vijay Kelkar Committee on revisiting PPP; PPP and intergenerational equity; FDI and FII in investment model
  • Contracting types: Service contracts hire private firms for specific tasks. Management contracts hand over operation for a fixed fee. Lease contracts let the private party operate for a rent and bear operating risk
  • EPC and risk: Under EPC the contractor bears construction risk but the government bears financing and operating risk. Government funds the project fully, so it is a public-led model, as in Investment Models: Public Sector-Led and Private Sector-Led Investment Models
  • Why models differ: The choice depends on whether the project earns user revenue and on how much traffic risk the developer is willing to take
  • Fiscal impact: HAM and annuity models create future payment obligations for the authority, which are contingent or committed liabilities
  • Exam hint: Remember that in HAM the authority collects the toll and in BOT toll the developer does
  • UPSC link: This topic was asked in UPSC Mains 2020, and the answer needs a comparison of models with risk allocation and the logic of HAM
  • Common errors: Writing that Swiss Challenge is a funding model. It is a bidding method
  • Another common error: Stating that in HAM the developer collects the toll. The authority does

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. HAM: 40 per cent government, 60 per cent developer, toll with authority, approved January 2016
  2. BOT toll: Developer collects user charges and bears traffic risk
  3. Annuity: Authority pays fixed amounts, developer has no revenue risk
  4. Swiss Challenge: Bidding method with a right to match
  5. EPC: Fully government-funded construction contract

As an analytical point, the evolution of road models from BOT toll to annuity to HAM tracks how risk was shifted. When developers could not carry traffic risk, the authority took it back, and HAM split funding so that both sides had a stake. Each model solved one problem but created another, mainly in fiscal liabilities and renegotiation.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Models BOT, DBFO, EPC, HAM, annuity
  • Risk Who bears revenue risk
  • Method Swiss Challenge

What Came Next?

The next topic covers infrastructure investment, the National Investment and Infrastructure Fund and the India Infrastructure Project Development Fund. Next topic: Infrastructure Investment; NIIF; India Infrastructure Project Development Fund (IIPDF).

Key People and Terms

  • BOT Build-Operate-Transfer
  • DBFO Design-Build-Finance-Operate
  • HAM Hybrid Annuity Model
  • EPC Engineering Procurement and Construction
  • Annuity Fixed periodic payment
  • Swiss Challenge Right to match a rival bid

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • HAM: 40:60; five instalments; authority collects tolls.
  • BOT toll: developer bears traffic risk.
  • Annuity: authority bears revenue risk.
  • EPC: government funds fully.
  • Swiss Challenge: bidding method.

Do Not Confuse With

  • BOT toll and BOT annuity Developer takes traffic risk versus authority takes it
  • HAM and annuity model Part funding by authority versus full funding by developer
  • Swiss Challenge and open bidding Right to match versus plain competitive bidding

Memory Hook

BOT the user pays, annuity the state pays later, HAM they split forty-sixty.

Mains Angle

Questions ask for a comparison of models and their risk allocation. These points give a frame.

  • Models BOT, annuity, HAM, EPC
  • Risk Traffic and construction
  • Fiscal Annuity commitments

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Explain the Hybrid Annuity Model and compare it with other PPP models in infrastructure, in terms of risk allocation and fiscal impact.”

How to Answer

  1. Intro Models allocate risk differently.
  2. HAM 40:60, toll with authority.
  3. Compare BOT toll, annuity, EPC.
  4. Conclude Fiscal liabilities and contract quality.

GS Relevance

Prelims: BOT, DBFO, concession, EPC, Swiss Challenge, Hybrid Annuity Model, annuity model. GS Paper 3: infrastructure, PPP models, highways.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Hybrid Annuity Model?

The Hybrid Annuity Model is a PPP model for infrastructure in which the government pays 40 per cent of the project cost in five instalments during construction and the developer funds the remaining 60 per cent, recovering it through annuity payments, while the authority collects the toll and bears revenue risk.

What is the Build-Operate-Transfer model?

In the Build-Operate-Transfer model a private developer finances and builds an asset, operates it for a fixed concession period, recovers its investment through user charges such as tolls, and then transfers the asset to the government. The developer bears the traffic risk in a BOT toll project.

What is the Swiss Challenge method?

The Swiss Challenge is a bidding method in which an unsolicited proposal from a private party is published, other parties are invited to give better offers, and the original proponent can match the best offer to win the project. It is a procurement method and not a funding model.

What is the difference between EPC and HAM?

Under Engineering Procurement and Construction the government funds the project fully and the contractor only builds it. Under HAM the government pays 40 per cent and the developer arranges 60 per cent, and the developer is also responsible for maintenance and receives annuity payments.

What is DBFO in a PPP?

Design-Build-Finance-Operate is a PPP model in which a private party designs, builds, finances and operates the asset for the concession period, usually paid by user charges or availability payments, giving it control over design as well as operation and a strong incentive for lifecycle efficiency.

Why was HAM introduced for highways?

HAM was approved in January 2016 because pure BOT toll projects had stalled as developers were wary of traffic risk and lenders were reluctant. By sharing funding and leaving revenue risk with the authority, HAM made projects more bankable.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 In the Hybrid Annuity Model, the authority pays 40 per cent of the project cost during construction.
True

The payment is in five instalments linked to milestones.

2 In HAM the developer collects the toll.
False

The authority collects the toll and bears revenue risk.

3 The Swiss Challenge is a method of bidding.
True

The original proponent can match the best rival offer.

4 Under BOT toll the developer bears the traffic risk.
True

It recovers its investment from user charges.

5 EPC contracts are privately funded.
False

The government funds EPC projects fully.

Share: