An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 3.19

Planning in India: issues related to planning; Bombay Plan, People’s Plan, Mahalanobis Plan, Wage-Good Model, Gandhian Plan; Mobilisation of Resources

Indian Economy › Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms · Topic 3.19

Planning in India is the state-led process of setting national goals and allocating scarce resources among sectors over a fixed period, begun with the Planning Commission in March 1950 and the First Five Year Plan of 1951-56. Its intellectual roots lie in the Bombay Plan, People's Plan, Gandhian Plan, the Mahalanobis Plan of the Second Plan and the Wage-Good Model. The main issues were top-down design, a heavy public sector, regional imbalance and weak implementation. Resources were mobilised through taxes, public sector surpluses, borrowing, deficit financing, domestic savings and foreign capital. The twelfth and last Five Year Plan ended in March 2017.

Share:
Planning in India: issues related to planning; Bombay Plan, People’s Plan, Mahalanobis Plan, Wage-Good Model, Gandhian Plan; Mobilisation of Resources - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Planning Commission set up 15 March 1950, by executive resolution
  • First Five Year Plan 1951-56, Harrod-Domar based, agriculture led
  • Second Plan model Mahalanobis, heavy industry, 1956-61
  • Last Five Year Plan 12th Plan, 2012-17
  • Resource sources Taxes, public sector surplus, borrowing, savings, foreign capital
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms

Where Does It Fit?

This Mains topic draws on the Prelims descriptions of planning strategies and the history of the Planning Commission. It asks the analytical question: what went right and wrong with planning, and how were the resources found. The next topics compare the Planning Commission with NITI Aayog. Previous topic: Types of Economic Systems (Capitalist, Socialist, Mixed). Next topic: What is economic planning; Planning Commission vs NITI Aayog; key functions of NITI Aayog; vision, strategy and action; criticisms of NITI Aayog; way forward.

What Were the Main Plans and Models Behind Indian Planning?

Plan or model Core idea, with the era and what it contributed
Bombay Plan, 1944 Drawn up by eight leading industrialists, including J.R.D. Tata and G.D. Birla. It proposed to double per capita income in 15 years, with heavy state role in basic industry and infrastructure. It showed that Indian big business accepted planning
People’s Plan, 1945 Prepared by M.N. Roy and the Indian Federation of Labour. It was left-leaning, gave priority to agriculture and consumer goods, and favoured nationalisation of key sectors and land redistribution
Gandhian Plan, 1944 Put forward by S.N. Agarwal. It stressed village self-sufficiency, cottage and small industries, decentralisation and agriculture over heavy industry
Mahalanobis Plan, 1956 P.C. Mahalanobis used a four-sector model for the Second Plan with a high share of investment in capital goods, to build an industrial base and raise future growth. It shaped the public sector led strategy
Wage-Good Model Proposed by C.N. Vakil and P.R. Brahmananda. It argued that the bottleneck to growth was a shortage of wage goods, mainly food and basic consumer goods, so that investment should favour agriculture and labour-intensive industry
Harrod-Domar logic The First Plan treated savings and investment as the engine of growth, so the growth rate equals the saving rate divided by the capital output ratio. A 12 per cent saving rate with a capital output ratio of 4 gives growth of 3 per cent
Sarvodaya and Visvesvaraya plans Earlier proposals, as in Pre-Independence Plans: Visvesvaraya Plan, Gandhian Plan, FICCI Proposal, Congress Plan, People’s Plan, Sarvodaya Plan, Bombay Plan, which set the vocabulary of planning

What Were the Issues in Indian Planning, and How Were Resources Mobilised?

Issue or source of resources Explanation and assessment
Top-down design and one size fits all Targets and sector allocations were fixed at the centre and handed to states, with little regard to local conditions. Centrally sponsored schemes grew in number and rigidity
Heavy public sector and licensing The public sector dominated investment, and the licence permit regime delayed capacity creation, raised costs and blunted efficiency
Regional imbalance Plan funds, industry and infrastructure did not reach all states equally, and gaps between states persisted
Weak implementation and leakages Delays, cost overruns and corruption reduced the benefit of outlays. Poverty alleviation programmes had low targeting accuracy
Under-achievement of targets Growth stayed near 3.5 per cent a year from 1950 to 1980, often called the Hindu rate of growth, before rising in the 1980s
Taxes and public sector surplus Direct and indirect taxes, plus profits of public enterprises, were the first source of plan resources. Public enterprise surplus fell short of expectation
Domestic savings Gross domestic savings rose from under 10 per cent of GDP in the early 1950s to near 30 per cent of GDP in recent years, and they fund most investment
Borrowing and deficit financing Market and external borrowing, plus deficit financing by printing money in the early plans, funded the gap. Deficit financing raised inflation and was curbed after the 1990s
Foreign capital and aid Foreign aid and loans were used in the early plans, followed by foreign direct investment, portfolio flows and external commercial borrowings after 1991

What Else Should You Remember?

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Pre-independence plans: know the authors and the central idea of the Bombay, People’s and Gandhian plans
  2. Models: Mahalanobis is heavy industry, Wage-Good is food and consumer goods, Harrod-Domar is savings and capital output ratio
  3. Institution: Planning Commission was created in 1950 by an executive resolution, not by the Constitution
  4. Resources: taxes, public sector surplus, borrowing, deficit financing, domestic savings and foreign capital
  5. Common errors: calling the Planning Commission a statutory body, or placing the Wage-Good Model in the Second Plan

As an analytical point, planning in India succeeded in building institutions, an industrial base and a savings habit, but failed to deliver speed and efficiency because it relied on control rather than incentives. The shift to indicative planning and then to NITI Aayog follows from that lesson.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Asked Planning and resources, GS 3
  • Framework Models and issues
  • Link NITI Aayog next

What Came Next?

The next topic compares the Planning Commission with NITI Aayog and examines the criticisms of both. Next topic: What is economic planning; Planning Commission vs NITI Aayog; key functions of NITI Aayog; vision, strategy and action; criticisms of NITI Aayog; way forward.

Key People and Terms

  • Five Year Plan Medium-term national plan
  • Bombay Plan Industrialists plan of 1944
  • Wage-Good Model Food and consumer goods focus
  • Mahalanobis model Heavy industry strategy
  • Plan holiday 1966-69 annual plans
  • Deficit financing Money creation to fund gap

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Planning Commission: 1950, executive resolution.
  • Bombay Plan: 1944, industrialists.
  • People’s Plan: M.N. Roy, 1945.
  • Gandhian Plan: S.N. Agarwal.
  • Last Five Year Plan: 12th, ended March 2017.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Mahalanobis Plan and Wage-Good Model Capital goods first versus wage goods first
  • Bombay Plan and People’s Plan Industrialists plan versus left-leaning labour plan
  • Plan holiday and rolling plan 1966-69 gap versus year-wise revision of plan

Memory Hook

Plans on paper, resources from pockets: tax, savings, borrowing, aid.

Mains Angle

Questions ask you to evaluate planning and to name how resources were raised. This outline gives both.

  • Introduction Planning began in 1950, drawing on earlier plans
  • Body 1 Models: Bombay, People’s, Gandhian, Mahalanobis, Wage-Good
  • Body 2 Issues: top-down, public sector, regional imbalance, implementation
  • Body 3 Mobilisation of resources: taxes, savings, borrowing, foreign capital
  • Conclusion Planning gave a base, markets gave speed

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Examine the main issues in Indian planning and discuss how resources were mobilised for plan expenditure.”

How to Answer

  1. Intro 1950 and plan roots.
  2. Models Five plans in brief.
  3. Issues Control, imbalance, leakage.
  4. Way Savings and markets.

GS Relevance

GS Paper 3: Indian economy and issues relating to planning, mobilisation of resources, growth, development and employment. A staple theme of UPSC Mains, tested through planning models and resource mobilisation questions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is economic planning in India?

Economic planning in India is the process of setting national goals and allocating resources among sectors over a fixed period. It began with the Planning Commission in 1950 and the First Five Year Plan of 1951-56. The twelfth plan ended in March 2017, and NITI Aayog replaced the Commission in 2015.

What was the Bombay Plan of 1944?

The Bombay Plan was a 1944 proposal by eight leading Indian industrialists, including J.R.D. Tata and G.D. Birla, to double per capita income in 15 years. It called for a strong state role in basic industry and infrastructure, and it influenced the public sector led strategy after independence.

What is the difference between the Mahalanobis Plan and the Wage-Good Model?

The Mahalanobis Plan of the Second Plan gave priority to capital goods and heavy industry to build a base for later growth. The Wage-Good Model of Vakil and Brahmananda argued that growth was limited by a shortage of food and consumer goods, so investment should favour agriculture and labour-intensive industry.

What were the main issues in Indian planning?

The main issues were top-down design with one size fits all schemes, a dominant public sector and licensing, regional imbalance, weak implementation, leakages and low growth near 3.5 per cent a year until 1980. These weaknesses led to the reforms of 1991 and later to NITI Aayog.

How were resources mobilised for Five Year Plans?

Plan resources came from taxes, public sector surpluses, domestic savings, market borrowing, deficit financing and foreign aid, later joined by foreign direct investment after 1991. Deficit financing raised inflation, so it was curbed, and domestic savings became the main funding source of investment.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Planning Commission was created by an Act of Parliament.
False

It was set up by an executive resolution in 1950.

2 The Wage-Good Model emphasised food and consumer goods.
True

It was proposed by Vakil and Brahmananda.

3 The People's Plan was prepared by M.N. Roy.
True

It was a left-leaning plan of 1945.

4 The plan versus non-plan split was abolished from the Union Budget 2017-18.
True

It was replaced by revenue and capital expenditure.

Share: