Impact of liberalisation on Indian-owned companies: positive impacts and challenges in competing with MNCs
Indian Economy › Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms · Topic 3.22
The impact of liberalisation on Indian-owned companies is mixed: after 1991 removed licensing and opened imports and foreign direct investment, firms gained cheaper technology, capital and export markets, and some became multinationals themselves, such as Tata, Infosys and Sun Pharma. But they also faced fiercer competition from multinational corporations with scale, brands and research budgets, and several were sold or lost share, as when Parle sold its soft drink brands to Coca-Cola in 1993. Competitiveness, not protection, became the test of survival. India's policy answer combines competition law, production linked incentives, trade agreements and support for MSMEs.
7 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms
At a Glance
- Turning point New Industrial Policy, July 1991
- Competition law Competition Act 2002 replaced the MRTP Act
- Notable overseas deals Tata Steel-Corus 2007, Tata Motors-Jaguar Land Rover 2008
- Notable sell-off Parle drinks to Coca-Cola, 1993
- Current support PLI schemes, about Rs 36,754 crore paid by June 2026
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms
Where Does It Fit?
This Mains topic applies the reforms listed in Liberalisation in 1991: Industrial Sector Reforms, Financial Sector Reforms (Pre-1991 Financial Sector Regulation), Tax Reforms (Reduction in Income and Corporate Taxes; Indirect Tax Reforms; GST), Foreign Exchange Reforms, Trade and Investment Policy Reforms (Dismantling Pre-Reform Policies) to the question of who gained at the firm level. It is closely tied to Globalisation: Trade Barriers, Tariff Hikes, Outsourcing; Effect on Power Loom Industry. Previous topic: New Industrial Policy 1991 and persistent challenges of LPG reforms; next generation of reforms. Next topic: PLFS 2023-24) Manufacturing…">Reasons for India’s leap from agriculture to services; can India become developed without a strong industrial base?.
What Were the Positive Impacts of Liberalisation on Indian-Owned Companies?
| Positive impact | How it helped, with examples |
|---|---|
| End of licensing and entry barriers | Firms could expand capacity and enter new fields without a licence from the government. Capacity in cement, steel, autos and consumer goods grew quickly |
| Access to technology and capital | Foreign technology agreements became automatic, and foreign direct investment brought machinery, know-how and finance. Joint ventures in autos and electronics helped technology transfer |
| Competition raised efficiency | Imports and new entrants forced firms to cut costs, improve quality and invest in design. The Competition Act 2002 replaced the MRTP Act to protect competition rather than restrict size |
| Access to global markets | Lower tariffs and a convertible current account helped exports. Services exports, led by information technology, were about $387 billion in 2024-25 |
| Rise of Indian multinationals | Outward foreign direct investment and mergers and acquisitions grew. Tata Steel bought Corus in 2007, Tata Motors bought Jaguar Land Rover in 2008, and Hindalco bought Novelis in 2007 |
| Cheaper finance and capital markets | Financial sector reform, a stronger stock market and foreign portfolio flows reduced the cost of capital for large firms |
| New sectors and entrepreneurs | Telecom, private banking, airlines, pharmaceuticals, information technology and later start-ups opened to private and new firms |
What Challenges Did Indian Firms Face in Competing With Multinationals?
| Challenge | Why it hurts, with examples and policy response |
|---|---|
| Scale and economies of scale | Multinational corporations have large production volumes and lower unit costs. Many Indian firms are small. Response: cluster policies, mergers, MSME credit |
| Brands, distribution and marketing | Global brands and supply chains outspend local firms. Response: build Indian brands and use digital commerce |
| Research, design and technology gaps | Research spending is below 1 per cent of GDP, which keeps firms dependent on foreign technology. Response: the Rs 1 lakh crore Research Development and Innovation scheme |
| Cost of capital and logistics | Interest rates, power and logistics costs are higher than in many Asian peers. Response: PM Gati Shakti, the National Logistics Policy and bond market reform |
| Takeovers and exit | Some firms sold out. Parle sold Thums Up, Limca and Gold Spot to Coca-Cola in 1993, and Ranbaxy was taken over by Daiichi Sankyo in 2008 |
| Import competition | Cheap imports, notably from China in electronics and chemicals, hurt small producers. Response: safeguard and anti-dumping duties, quality control orders, and production linked incentives, which had paid about Rs 36,754 crore by 30 June 2026 |
| Compliance burden | Many inspections and criminal penalties raised costs. Response: Jan Vishwas Act 2026, which amended 79 Acts |
| Unequal playing field in trade deals | Free trade agreements open Indian markets to rivals, though they also give Indian exporters access. The India-UK pact took effect in July 2026 and the India-EU deal was concluded in January 2026 |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Pre-1991 protection: before 1991 Indian firms enjoyed protection through high tariffs, licensing and reserved sectors, so many had little pressure to improve
- Net assessment: the strongest firms became global players, while weaker, small and old-technology firms struggled. Overall, competition raised productivity
- Fears at the time: critics feared that multinational corporations would crowd out domestic firms, a concern behind the Swadeshi Jagran Manch and trade union protests in the 1990s
- Foreign direct investment rules: caps and approval routes still apply in sensitive sectors such as defence, insurance and multi-brand retail, while most sectors are on the automatic route
- Sector patterns: domestic firms dominate in pharmaceuticals, information technology services and two-wheelers, whereas multinationals hold strong positions in consumer packaged goods, passenger cars and electronics
- Concentration concerns: large business groups have grown bigger, and critics point to market concentration, which is why competition regulation by the Competition Commission of India matters
- MSME link: micro, small and medium enterprises supply many large firms, so their credit and technology support decides how widely liberalisation gains spread
- Policy mix since 2014: Make in India, production linked incentives, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code and Atmanirbhar Bharat try to build domestic capacity without returning to closed markets
- Evaluation lens: a balanced answer weighs consumer gains and productivity against displaced firms and concentration
- Global lessons: East Asian economies shielded and nurtured firms with performance conditions, so India uses incentives tied to output and exports instead of blanket protection
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Positive impacts: technology, capital, exports, efficiency, rise of Indian multinationals
- Challenges: scale, brands, research gaps, cost of capital, takeovers, import competition
- Examples: Tata-Corus 2007, Tata-JLR 2008, Parle-Coca-Cola 1993, Ranbaxy-Daiichi 2008
- Policy response: Competition Act 2002, production linked incentives, MSME support, trade pacts, Jan Vishwas Act
- Common errors: listing only benefits or only harm, or naming the MRTP Act as the current competition law
As an analytical point, liberalisation did not defeat Indian business, but it ended its comfort. Firms that invested in scale and technology gained, while those that relied on protection lost, so policy should reward performance, not shelter weakness.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Asked Mains 2013
- Balance Gains and losses
- Current PLI and FTAs
What Came Next?
The next topic asks why India moved from agriculture to services and whether it can develop without a strong industrial base. Next topic: Reasons for India’s leap from agriculture to services; can India become developed without a strong industrial base?.
Key People and Terms
- Liberalisation Removal of controls
- MNC Multinational corporation
- Outward FDI Indian firms investing abroad
- Competition Act 2002 Law replacing MRTP
- M&A Mergers and acquisitions
- PLI Production linked incentive
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Parle drinks to Coca-Cola: 1993.
- Tata Steel bought Corus: 2007.
- Tata Motors bought JLR: 2008.
- Competition Act: 2002.
- Challenges: scale, brand, research.
Do Not Confuse With
- MRTP Act and Competition Act 2002 Curbing size versus protecting competition
- Inward FDI and outward FDI Foreign money coming in versus Indian firms investing abroad
- Liberalisation and privatisation Freeing markets versus selling state assets
Memory Hook
Protection fell, competition rose, and Indian firms either scaled up or sold out.
Mains Angle
The Mains question wanted both gains and difficulty in competing with multinationals. Use this two-part structure.
- Introduction Liberalisation after 1991 opened markets
- Body 1 Positive impacts: technology, exports, Indian multinationals
- Body 2 Challenges: scale, brands, research, takeovers, imports
- Body 3 Policy response: competition law, PLI, MSME support
- Conclusion Reward performance, not protection
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“How has liberalisation impacted Indian-owned companies? Discuss the positive impacts and the challenges they face in competing with multinational corporations.”
How to Answer
- Intro 1991 opening.
- Gains Tech, capital, markets.
- Pains Scale, brand, takeovers.
- Way Competition and capacity.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How did liberalisation affect Indian companies?
Liberalisation after 1991 removed licensing and opened imports and foreign investment. It gave Indian firms access to technology, capital and export markets and raised efficiency, and some became global players. But it also exposed them to stronger multinational competitors, and some were taken over or lost market share.
What are the positive impacts of liberalisation on Indian firms?
The positive impacts include freedom to expand without licences, easier access to foreign technology and capital, higher efficiency from competition, export growth, and the rise of Indian multinationals such as Tata through acquisitions like Corus in 2007 and Jaguar Land Rover in 2008.
Why do Indian companies find it hard to compete with MNCs?
Multinational corporations have larger scale, strong brands and distribution, bigger research budgets and cheaper finance. Indian firms face higher logistics and capital costs, lower research spending of about 0.7 per cent of GDP, and import competition. These gaps explain takeovers such as Parle drinks in 1993.
What is the Competition Act 2002?
The Competition Act 2002 replaced the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act and aims to prevent practices that harm competition, such as cartels and abuse of dominance. It set up the Competition Commission of India, so that large and foreign firms alike compete fairly in Indian markets.
How is the government helping Indian companies compete?
The government uses production linked incentives, which had paid about Rs 36,754 crore by 30 June 2026, plus MSME credit, logistics reform, the Jan Vishwas Act to cut compliance, and trade agreements for market access. The focus is on scale and technology, not protection.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 Parle sold its soft drink brands to Coca-Cola in 1993.
Thums Up, Limca and Gold Spot were sold.
2 The Competition Act 2002 replaced the MRTP Act.
It set up the Competition Commission of India.
3 Tata Motors acquired Jaguar Land Rover in 2008.
A prominent outward acquisition.
4 Outward FDI means foreign firms investing in India.
It means Indian firms investing abroad.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index